Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 9 (b) 37 (2) (c) of Protection oil Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (in short "Act 2005")
  • Section 20 and 22 of "Act 2005".
  • Section 2 of "Act 2005"
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 9 (b) 37 (2) (c) of Protection oil Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (in short "Act 2005")
  • Section 20 and 22 of "Act 2005".
  • Section 2 of "Act 2005"
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These are revisions against the order passed in Criminal Appeal No. 501/07 (Razzak Khan and 2 others v. Smt. Shahnaz Khan) and Criminal Appeal No. 595/07 (Smt. Shahnaz Khan v. Razzak Khan and 2 others) dated 19-12-2007 by the 6th Additional Sessions Judge, Jabalpur. The appeals arose from Complaint Case No. 23/2007 and an order dated 29-9-2007 by the JMFC, Jabalpur, in proceedings under Sections 9(b), 37(2)(c) of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 ("Act 2005").

Relevant factual points recorded in the opinion: - Ramzan Khan and Smt. Shahnaz Khan divorced on 3-5-2007 in the presence of witnesses. - Razzak Khan, Rehmail Khan and Ramzan Khan are real brothers. Smt. Shahnaz Khan is the daughter of the applicants' real sister; she had a prior marriage and a son, Shoaib (about 16 years old). She entered into a second marriage (nikah) with Ramzan Khan on 19-3-2003. - Prior to and after certain family events, parties lived in rented and ancestral homes; Ramzan returned to the ancestral house in February 2006 with his brothers and wife. - Smt. Shahnaz Khan filed a complaint under the Act seeking reliefs under Sections 18–20. The JMFC granted a number of reliefs on 29-9-2007 (expenses of delivery, non-interference with employment, monthly maintenance, protection from assault/abuse, medical expenses for newborn, delivery of stridhan). - On appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 595/07) the Sessions Judge modified reliefs and directed the Protection Officer to provide accommodation in the husband's ancestral house under Section 19(1)(f) and awarded Rs. 500/- per month maintenance for foster son Shoaib. - Revision and cross-revision applications followed: applicants challenged aspects of the appellate order; Smt. Shahnaz Khan sought enhancement of maintenance and compensation under Sections 20 and 22 of the Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellate court erred in directing the Protection Officer to provide accommodation in the husband's ancestral (shared) household under Section 19(1)(f) of the Act 2005, particularly where the marriage had been dissolved by divorce.
  2. Whether Smt. Shahnaz Khan and her children were entitled to the quantum of maintenance awarded by the courts below (including claims for enhancement and for maintenance to the foster son Shoaib).
  3. Whether the jurisdiction and protective provisions of the Act 2005 (including rights to reside in a shared household under Section 17(1)) apply to a woman who has been divorced by the husband.
  4. Whether, as an alternative to providing accommodation in the shared household, the husband should be directed to secure alternative accommodation or pay monthly rent to the aggrieved person under Section 19(1)(f).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants (Razzak Khan, Rehmail Khan and Ramzan Khan) — Arguments

  • The applicants argued that Smt. Shahnaz Khan is employed as a clerk in MPSRTC and lives comfortably in her parental house; she is in a better financial position than Ramzan Khan, who is a photocopy mechanic with irregular earnings and a heart problem.
  • It was contended that Ramzan Khan is hardly able to maintain himself and that it was improper to require him to provide accommodation in the ancestral house or to pay substantial maintenance.
  • Counsel argued that, since divorce had been given, jurisdiction under the Act 2005 (as to residence in the shared household) is not attracted to a divorced wife, and that directing accommodation in the husband's house to a divorcee would be improper.
  • It was also argued that the applicant Smt. Shahnaz Khan did not name her foster son Shoaib in the original application before the JMFC, so the Appellate Court had no cause to grant maintenance to Shoaib.
  • One of the applicants' counsel (Shri Usmani) conceded willingness to pay Rs. 500 per month to Smt. Shahnaz Khan and children (recorded as a concession during proceedings).

Respondent (Smt. Shahnaz Khan) — Arguments

  • Smt. Shahnaz Khan sought enhancement of maintenance: increase monthly maintenance for Gazi Khan from Rs. 1,000 to Rs. 2,000 and for foster son Shoaib Khan from Rs. 500 to Rs. 1,000, from the date of application.
  • She also sought adequate compensation under Sections 20 and 22 of the Act 2005, arguing that the reliefs granted were meagre in light of the price index.
  • Her counsel emphasized that the strict rule of pleadings is not rigidly applied in proceedings under the Act, addressing the contention regarding non-naming of Shoaib in the original complaint.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.R. Batra v. Smt. Tarun Batra, Civil Appeal No. 5837/06 (Supreme Court), decided 15-12-2006 Clarification that a claim for alternative accommodation under the Act can only be made against the husband; that the right to reside in a shared household refers to a house belonging to the husband or a joint family of which the husband is a member. The Court applied this precedent to hold that the claim for alternative accommodation could be directed against husband Ramzan Khan and interpreted the right to residence as concerning the husband's house or the joint family house of which he is a member. This supported directing the husband to secure alternative accommodation or pay rent under Section 19(1)(f).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by reference to the factual findings of the courts below and the statutory framework of the Act 2005. Key elements of the reasoning as recorded in the opinion are:

  • Fact-finding: The court accepted the admitted facts — notably, that divorce was given on 3-5-2007; that Smt. Shahnaz Khan is employed as a clerk in MPSRTC and lives in her parental house; and that Ramzan Khan has irregular earnings as a photocopy mechanic and suffers from a heart ailment. The courts below had assessed evidence and income, and the Sessions Judge had awarded monthly maintenance (aggregate noted as Rs. 2,500 per month to Smt. Shahnaz Khan and her children).
  • Statutory interpretation: The court reproduced and relied upon Section 17(1) of the Act 2005 — the right to reside in a shared household — and Section 2's definitions of "aggrieved person," "domestic relationship" and "shared household." The court emphasized that Section 17(1) confers a right to reside in a shared household on every woman in a domestic relationship, "notwithstanding anything contained in any other law," and that eviction/exclusion is only in accordance with the law's procedure.
  • Application to divorce: The court rejected the applicants' argument that a divorced wife has no right under the Act to reside in the husband's ancestral house or that such an arrangement would be improper (described in the opinion as "Haram"). The court found that the statutory text and definitions support the right to reside irrespective of other laws and that the argument therefore had no force.
  • Use of precedent: The court cited the Supreme Court decision in S.R. Batra to clarify that claims for alternative accommodation can be made against the husband and that the concept of a shared household includes a house belonging to the husband or the joint family of which he is a member. This reinforced that the remedy under Section 19(1)(f) could be directed at Ramzan Khan.
  • Remedial direction and alternative: The court applied Section 19(1)(f) and its interpretation to provide an alternative — directing Ramzan Khan to secure same-level alternative accommodation for Smt. Shahnaz Khan through the Protection Officer or, alternatively, to pay Rs. 900 per month as rent from the date of the Trial Court order (29-9-2007).
  • Assessment of maintenance: After reviewing the evidence and the findings of income rendered by the courts below, this Court found the monthly maintenance awarded by the Appellate Court (recorded as Rs. 2,500 per month for Smt. Shahnaz Khan and her children) to be justified and did not upset that determination.
  • Scope of interference: The court expressly stated it found no illegality, irregularity or perversity in the impugned orders sufficient to interfere with the revisions, except for the specific modification under Section 19(1)(f) noted above.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: With a modification under Section 19(1)(f) of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, both revision petitions were dismissed.

Direct consequences and implications as recorded in the opinion:

  • The Appellate Court's award of monthly maintenance (aggregate Rs. 2,500 per month to Smt. Shahnaz Khan and her children, as determined by the courts below) was held to be justified by this Court and left undisturbed.
  • On the question of residence/accommodation, the Court directed that, under Section 19(1)(f), Ramzan Khan must either secure for Smt. Shahnaz Khan alternate accommodation of the same standard as the shared household (with the assistance of the Protection Officer) or pay Rs. 900 per month as rent to Smt. Shahnaz Khan from the date of the Trial Court order (29-9-2007).
  • The Court rejected the argument that, because divorce had been granted, the jurisdiction and protections of the Act (including the right to reside in a shared household) do not apply to the divorced wife; the Court held that the statutory provisions support such rights and remedies.
  • No broader precedent beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and the cited Supreme Court authority (S.R. Batra) was claimed to be created by this decision; the Court limited its interference to the specific modification stated and dismissed the revisions otherwise.

Disposition recorded by the Court: With the modification in terms of Section 19(1)(f) (alternative accommodation or rent of Rs. 900/- per month from 29-9-2007), both revisions are dismissed.

    Razzak Khan And Others v. Shahnaz Khan

    These two revisions against the order passed in Criminal Appeal No. 501/07 (Razzak Khan and 2 others Vs. Smt. Shahnaz Khan) and Criminal Appeal No. 595/07 (Smt. Shahnaz Khan Vs. Razzak Khan and 2 others) dated] 19-12-2007, passed by 6th Additional Sessions Judge, Jabalpur arising out of the order passed in Complaint Case No. 23/2007 order dated 29-9-2007 by learned JMFC Jabalpur in proceeding under Section 9 (b) 37 (2) (c) of Protection oil Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (in short "Act 2005") whereby these revisions have been filed before this Court. 2. This is undisputed that Ramzan Khan and Smt. Shahnaz Khan had taken divorce on 3-5-2007 in presence of witnesses. Razzak Khan, Rehmail Khan and Ramzan Khan are real brothers and Smt. Shahnaz Khan is the daughtei of real sister of the applicants whose first marriage has been performed witM Musarraf Khan and out of first wedlock Master Shoaib was born who is present 16 years of age. After lapse of 12 years of the death of her first husband, Shahnaa Khan has performed Nikah with Ramzan Khan on 19-3-2003 and both of them were living in a rented house. Ramzan Khan after the death of his father Rasool Khan, on 7-2-2006 started living in ancestral house with his two brothers along with his wife Shahnaz Khan. 3. The Shahnaz Khan filed a complaint under section 9 (b) 37 (2) (c) of the "act 2005" for claiming relief under Section 18 to 20 before JMFC Jabalpur. The JMFC vide order dated 29-9-2007 granted following reliefs to] Smt. Shahnaz Khan. 1. Smt. Shahnaz Khan is entitled for sum of Rs. 16,439/- expense of delivery and medicines from Ramzan Khan. 2. Ramzan Khan shall not restrain Smt. Shahnaz Khan for going to service (work place) nor he will snatched salary. 3. Ramzan Khan shall give Rs. 2000/- per month toward the maintenance to Smt. Shahnaz Khan and son Gazi Khan. 4. Ramzan Khan shall not assault and abuse the applicant (Smt. Shahnaz Khan) 5. Shri Ramzan Khan shall pay necessary medical expenses in relation to newly born baby. 6. Protection Officer was directed to ensure the delivery of the Stridhan as per annexed to the complaint in his presence. 4. In Criminal Appeal No. 595/07, learned 6th Additional Sessions Judge modified relief to Smt. Shahnaz Khan and directed Protection Officer for providing accommodation in the ancestral house of husband under section 19 (1) (f) of the "act 2005" and further granted Rs. 500/- per month maintenance in favour of the foster son Shoaib Khan. 5. Learned Advocate of Shri Razzak Khan, Rahman Khan and Ramzan Khan argued in detailed that Smt. Shahnaz Khan is working as a Clerk in MPSRTC and comfortably living in her parental house with her sons. She is in a better financial position whereas Ramzan Khan is a photo copy mechanic and living with brothers and hardly able to maintain himself. However, Shri Usniani has conceded that even now he is prepared to pay 500/- per month to Smt. Shahnaz Khan and children. Learned Advocate has further argued that it will not be proper in view of the fact that Shahnaz Khan after divorce will live in the shared house with Ramzan Khan and she is living very comfortably in her ancestral house with her parents and brothers. 6. However, in Criminal Revision No. 112/2008, Smt. Shahnaz Khan has demanded enhancement of the quantum of maintenance regarding Gazi Khan from Rs. 1000/- to Rs. 2000/- and regarding foster son Shoaib Khan from Rs. 5007-to Rs. 1000/- per month from the date of application and also demanded adequate compensation in terms of Section 20 and 22 of "Act 2005". Shri Imtiaz Hussain learned Counsel for Smt. Shahnaz Khan has argued that looking to the price index meager relief is granted to her and children. Therefore, this amount should be enhanced. 7. Both the learned Counsels were heard at length. 8. It is admitted position that Ramzan Khan has given divorce to Smt. Shahnaz Khan on 3-5-2007. Smt. Shahnaz Khan is working as a clerk in the MPSTRC at Jabalpur and living in her parental house. 9. Learned Advocate of Razzak Khan and others Shri Ahdullaha Usmani argued that because Smt. Shahnaz Khan is working as a clerk, therefore, her financial position is much better than her husband who is casually working as a photo copy mechanic and suffering from heart problem. The learned Appellate Court after considering the evidence produced by both the parties held that Smt. Shahnaz Khan and her children are entitled for Rs. 2500/- per month relief. Shri Usmani, learned Counsel argued that applicant Smt. Shahnaz Khan did not refer name of her foster son Shoaib Khan in original application before JMFC therefore, learned Appellate Court without any cause granted Rs. 500/- maintenance to Gazi Khan. It is admitted position that Gazi Khan is foster son of Smt. Shahnaz Khan and Razzak Khan and strict rule of pleadings are not applicable in proceedings under the "Act 2005". Shri Imtiaz Hussain, learned Advocate of Shahnaz Khan has argued at length that looking to the present price index quantum of monthly maintenance of Rs. 1000/- to Gazi Khan and Rs. 500/- to Shoaib Khan should be enhanced and further adequate compensation be granted to Smt. Shahnaz Khan. 10. It is admitted position that Smt. Shahnaz Khan is working as a clerk in MPSRTC, Jabalpur whereas her husband Ramzan Khan is a photocopy mechanic and not getting regular salary, he is also suffering from heart ailment. In these circumstances, both the Courts below after appreciation of evidence has given findings of income, regarding financial status of the parties. This Courtt of the view that the monthly maintenance granted by learned Appellate Courti justified. 11. Shri Ahdullaha Usmani learned Advocate for Razzak Khan and others has vehemently argued that if divorcee wife Smt. Shahnaz Khan will stay' in the shared house with applicant then it will create many problems. Further Smt. Shahnaz Khan is living comfortably with her brother in her parental house and therefore, the Revisional Court has committed a grave mistake in ordering for providing accommodation to her in the house of husband and brothers. Hi has further argued that because Ramzan Khan has given divorce to Smt. Shahnaz Khan therefore, jurisdiction under "Act 2005" is not attracted. 12. It is clear that applicant and his two brother are staying in a three-1 storied house at Jabalpur. In this regard it will be proper to reproduce Section 17(1) of the Act of 2005. "17. (1) Right to reside in a shared household. Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, every woman in a domestic relationship shall have the right to reside in the shared house hold, whether or not she has any right, title or beneficial interest in the same." This Section lays down that irrespective of any contrary proviso in any other law, every woman in a domestic relationship shall have the right to reside in the shared household and the aggrieved person shall not be evicted or excluded from the shared household by the respondent except in accordance with the procedure established by law. Further Section 2 of "Act 2005" defines "aggrieved persons" and "domestic relationship" and "shared household" as given below :- "2. Definitions.— (a) "aggrieved person" means any woman who is, or has been, in a domestic relationship with the respondent and who alleges to have been subjected to any act of domestic violence by the respondent; (f) "domestic relationship " means a relationship between two persons who live or have, at any point of time, lived together in a shared household, when they are related by consanguinity, marriage, or through a relationship in the nature of marriage, adoption or are family members living together as a joint family; (s) "shared household" means a household where the person aggrieved lives or at any stage has lived in a domestic relationship either singly or along with the respondent and includes such a household whether owned or tenanted either jointly by the aggrieved person and the respondent, or owned or tenanted by either of them in respect of which either the aggrieved person or the respondent or both jointly or singly have any right, title, interest or equity and includes such a household which may belong to the joint family of which the respondent is a member, irrespective of whether the respondent or the aggrieved person has any right, title or interest in the shared household." 13. Thus, it is clear that every women in a domestic relationship shall have the right to reside in the shared house except in accordance with the procedure established by law therefore, this argument of applicant has no force that divorcee wife Shahnaz Khan has no right to reside in an ancestral house of husband or such living will amount to 'Haram'. 14. Further as held by Apex Court in S.R. Batra Vs. Smt. Tarun Batra, Civil Appeal No. 5837/06 (SC), decided on 15-12-2006, it is made clear that the claim for alternative accommodation can only be made against husband Ramzan Khan and she is entitled a right to residence in a shared house would only mean house belonging to husband Ramzan Khan or house which belongs to joint family of which husband is a member. 15. If circumstances required so, divorcee wife Shahnaz Khan in view of section 19 (1) (f) of the "act 2005" in the alternative husband Ramzan Khan is directed to secure same level of alternate accommodation for Shahnaz Khan as enjoyed by her in the shared house with the help of Protection Officer or he will pay Rs. 900/- per month rent to Smt. Shahnaz Khan from date of Trial Court order i.e., 29-9-2007. 16. Suffice it to say that the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Jabalpur, has not committed any error of law and fact in impugned Criminal Appeal No. 501/2007 and 595/2007, dated 19-12-2007. This Court does not find any such illegality, irregularity or perversity in the impugned order to interfere in these revision petitions except modification as provided in section 19 (1) (f) of the "act 2005". 17. With this modification, both revisions are dismissed. _____________

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Razzak Khan And Others v. Shahnaz Khan
    (Mar 25, 2008)