AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure as the provisions of rule 3 of Order XVII
  • rule 8 of Order IX read with rule 2 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • provisions of rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX of the Code,
  • rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • rule 2 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rule 13 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Procedure.
  • section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 12, rule 3 or Order 17, rule 2
  • rule 6 or rule 8 of Order
  • rule 2 of Order XVII
  • rule 3 of Order XVII
  • rule 9 of Order IX
  • rule 3, Order XVII
  • Order XVII, rule 3
  • rule 3 of Order
  • rule 9 of Order
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure as the provisions of rule 3 of Order XVII
  • rule 8 of Order IX read with rule 2 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • provisions of rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX of the Code,
  • rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • rule 2 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rule 13 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Procedure.
  • section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 12, rule 3 or Order 17, rule 2
  • rule 6 or rule 8 of Order
  • rule 2 of Order XVII
  • rule 3 of Order XVII
  • rule 9 of Order IX
  • rule 3, Order XVII
  • Order XVII, rule 3
  • rule 3 of Order
  • rule 9 of Order
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Civil Revision under Section 115 CPC)

Factual and Procedural Background

The non-applicant (plaintiff) filed a civil suit on 24-3-1955 seeking specific performance of a motor-car sale contract or, alternatively, damages of Rs. 3,564-4-0. An ex parte decree was entered against the defendants on 18-6-1955 but was set aside on 19-12-1957, and notices were issued for further proceedings. At the date fixed for the plaintiff's evidence (20-2-1959) the plaintiff and his witnesses were absent and the trial Court dismissed the suit for want of prosecution. On appeal the Additional District Judge, Alirajpur, by order dated 22-10-1959 set aside that dismissal and remanded the case to the trial Court. When the trial Court re-fixed the matter for 9-12-1959 and directed the plaintiff to be present with witnesses, neither the plaintiff nor his witnesses appeared; the plaintiff sent a telegram seeking an adjournment, which was refused, and the trial Court dismissed the suit with costs under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure and drew a decree.

The plaintiff applied to set aside the dismissal treating it as if dismissed under rule 8 of Order IX read with rule 2 of Order XVII by filing an application under rule 9 of Order IX; that application was refused as incompetent because the dismissal was held to be under rule 3 of Order XVII. The plaintiff appealed to the Additional District Judge, who by order dated 30-12-1960 set aside the dismissal on payment of Rs. 50 as adjournment costs and remanded the case for recording evidence. The defendants (applicants) challenged that appellate order by filing the present civil revision under section 115 CPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dismissal of the suit by the trial Court—expressly made under rule 3 of Order XVII—should be treated as a dismissal under rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX, thereby rendering an application under rule 9 of Order IX competent.
  2. What is the proper forum or remedy where a trial Court has expressly purported to act under a specific provision (here, rule 3 of Order XVII) but the defendant/plaintiff contends that the provision was not in fact attracted?

Arguments of the Parties

Non-applicant (Plaintiff)'s Arguments

  • The trial Court, although it purported to act under rule 3 of Order XVII, in fact should be deemed to have acted under rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX because the conditions necessary to attract rule 3 were not fulfilled.
  • Consequently, an application under rule 9 of Order IX to set aside the dismissal should have been competent and properly entertained.

Applicants (Defendants)' Arguments

  • The defendants challenged the appellate order (which set aside the trial Court's dismissal) as wrong and illegal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhoorilal and others v. Kanhaiyalal and others, AIR 1933 Nag. 234 Support for proposition that rule 3 of Order XVII is not attracted when the Court adjourns the hearing on its own motion generally without reference to anything specific to be done by a party. Used to show that an adjournment by the Court of its own motion does not generally invoke rule 3 of Order XVII.
Rukmanse v. Shankarguda, ILR 1941 Bom. 83 Similar authority regarding when rule 3 of Order XVII operates. Cited as part of authorities supporting the proposition about adjournments by Court and inapplicability of rule 3 in such cases.
Enatulla v. Jiban Mohan, AIR 1914 Cal. 360 Authority relevant to circumstances in which rule 3 of Order XVII applies. Relied upon to support the proposition concerning adjournments and rule 3's applicability.
Ryall v. Sherman, ILR 1 Mad. 287 Another case cited on the same proposition about adjournments and rule 3. Used as supporting authority for the limits of rule 3's application.
Soonderlal v. Qoor-prasad, ILR 23 Bom. 414 Authority for the proposition that the mere physical presence of a pleader (counsel) is not equivalent to the party's presence in Court under the rules. Applied to show that the counsel's presence could not be construed as the plaintiff's appearance and that counsel's mere physical presence does not amount to conducting the case for the client.
Nasirkhan v. Itwar, AIR 1924 All. 144 = ILR 46 All. 669 Principle that the right of appeal depends on what the Court actually did, not on what it ought to have done; if the Court passes a decree under a specific provision, the remedy is by appeal under that provision. Quoted and relied upon to support the proposition that the remedy must follow the provision under which the lower Court actually acted.
Shri Kishan v. Radhakishen, AIR 1952 All. 652 Principle that where a Court expressly passes an order under a particular rule (Order 12, r.3 or Order 17, r.2), the order must be treated as such and the proper remedy is by appeal, not by restoration application, when the Court expressly refers to one rule. Adopted to support that an express order under a specific rule must be challenged by the remedy provided for that rule (appeal/revision) rather than by an alternative route.
Faiyazkhan v. Mithan, AIR 1954 All. 222 Affirmed that a decree passed expressly under rule 3 of Order XVII must be challenged by the remedy provided for that rule; appellate relief under rule 13 of Order IX was held unavailable for setting aside such decrees. Preferred by the Court and treated as more consonant with general principles; used as authoritative support for the view that remedy must follow the specific provision invoked by the trial Court.
Raja Singh v. Mannasingh, AIR 1940 All. 217 Decision mentioned in context of earlier conflicting authorities about the appropriate remedy. Mentioned as part of the jurisprudential background; the Court indicated that decisions like Raja Singh were not followed in Faiyazkhan.
Rafiq Ahmad v. Mohammad, ILR 1949 All. 759 = AIR 1949 All. 423 Another decision in the batch of earlier authorities on available remedies. Not followed in Faiyazkhan; cited as part of the contrastive jurisprudence.
Lalchand v. Kaka Bam, AIR 1927 Lab. 562 Support for the principle that where a decree is passed expressly under a specific provision, the remedy is as provided by that provision (appeal or revision). Quoted among authorities reinforcing the Court's approach to remedies based on the provision actually invoked.
Syed Baker Hussain v. Mirya Hussain Mirza, AIR 1923 Pat. 223 Authority cited in the same connection about remedy following the specific provision used by the Court. Relied upon for the general proposition about jurisdiction and remedy being determined by what the Court actually did.
Balbahadar Singh v. Walaiti Ram, AIR 1954 Fepsu 55 Another authority cited for similar principles concerning the remedy to challenge decrees passed under specific Code provisions. Included among authorities supporting the Court's approach to jurisdiction and remedy.
Sitalprasad v. Sukya, 1948 NLJ 443 = AIR 1948 Nag. 310 = ILR 1948 Nag. 462 Held that when a decree is passed under Order XVII, rule 3, the appropriate remedy is appeal; the decree cannot be set aside in a restoration application or by revision against refusal to restore. Cited as consistent authority; the Court noted that although Sitalprasad was overruled on another point by Motilal Joshi, the particular observations relied upon are still considered good law.
Motilal Joshi v. Mohammad Shaft, AIR 1956 Nag. 179 (reference to later treatment) Noted as having overruled Sitalprasad on another point. Cited to acknowledge that Sitalprasad had been overruled on another point, but the Court nevertheless regarded the specific observations relied upon as still good law for present purposes.
Pratap Singh v. Moolchand, 1961 J L J Note No. 211.42 A case brought to the Court's notice by the plaintiff. The Court held this case inapplicable because in Pratap Singh no decree was actually passed and the lower Court did not proceed specifically under rule 3 of Order XVII.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a sequence of legal analysis, grounded in the facts and in precedent:

  1. The Court first identified the narrow statutory question: whether a dismissal expressly made under rule 3 of Order XVII should be treated as one under rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX so as to permit a rule 9 of Order IX application.
  2. The Court examined the conditions for rule 3 of Order XVII to operate (as summarized from Mulla's CPC): (1) adjournment on application of a party, (2) adjournment on application of the party who later defaults, (3) adjournment granted to enable production of evidence or attendance of witnesses or other act necessary for progress, and (4) the party fails to perform the act within the time allowed. The opinion reproduced these conditions verbatim.
  3. Applying those conditions to the facts, the Court observed that the adjournment in the present case was by the Court of its own motion rather than on the plaintiff's application; further, the plaintiff's counsel being present was not the same as the plaintiff's personal appearance and, in any event, the counsel was not called upon to act on the plaintiff's behalf. On these bases the Court acknowledged that rule 2 of Order XVII might have been the more appropriate provision for the trial Court to have invoked.
  4. Despite that, the Court emphasised a fundamental principle: the rights of the parties are to be regulated by what the Court actually did (i.e., by the express provision invoked in the order), not by what it ought to have done. The Court relied on prior authority (Nasirkhan, Shri Kishan, Faiyazkhan and others) for the proposition that when a Court expressly passes an order under a specific provision of law, the remedy must be the one provided by that provision (normally an appeal or revision), and a litigant cannot recast the order as having been made under a different provision to invoke an alternative remedy.
  5. The Court noted a limited exception: where a specific provision is not mentioned in the order and surrounding circumstances point clearly to a different construction, a court may, in some cases, construe the judgment in the light most favourable to its validity. But that doctrine was not available here because the trial Court had expressly stated that it was acting under rule 3 of Order XVII.
  6. The Court considered and rejected the plaintiff's reliance on Pratap Singh as inapplicable because, in that case, no decree was actually passed and the lower Court had not proceeded specifically under rule 3 of Order XVII.
  7. On that basis of analysis and applying the cited authorities, the Court concluded that the appellate order (which treated the dismissal as one that could be set aside under rule 9 of Order IX) was erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The civil revision is allowed. The order of the lower appellate Court (which had set aside the trial Court's dismissal) is set aside and the order of the trial Court is restored. The plaintiff's application for setting aside the dismissal of the suit and the decree passed thereon under Order IX CPC is dismissed with costs throughout. The Court awarded counsel's fee of Rs. 25, if certified. The petition is allowed (final line of the opinion: "Petition allowed.").

Implications:

  • The direct legal effect is that the trial Court's dismissal of the plaintiff's suit (made expressly under rule 3 of Order XVII) stands restored; the appellate order vacating that dismissal is quashed.
  • The plaintiff's attempt to treat the dismissal as one under rule 2 of Order XVII and to invoke rule 9 of Order IX was held to be incompetent because the trial Court had expressly acted under rule 3; thus the proper remedy was by appeal/revision under the provision actually invoked by the trial Court.
  • The decision reaffirms the principle, supported by precedent cited in the opinion, that the remedy available to a litigant depends on the specific provision under which the trial Court actually acted, not on what the trial Court arguably ought to have done. The opinion applied existing case law rather than announcing a new principle of law.

Costs and fee: dismissal with costs throughout; counsel's fee Rs. 25 if certified (as awarded by the Court).

    Govardhan Badrilal Mahajan And Another v. Ganesh Balkrishwa Deshmukh

    This is a civil revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the appellate order of the Second Additional District Judge, Alirajpur, allowing the appeal of the non-applicant (Plaintiff) and setting aside the order of the Civil Judge, Class II, Alirajpur, dismissing the suit of the plaintiff under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    2. The facts, so far as relevant for our present purpose, are as follows:

    The non-applicant-plaintiff, on 24-3-1955, filed a civil suit against the applicants-defendants claiming specific performance of a contract of sale of a motor-car or, in the alternative, damages amounting to Rs. 3,564-4-0. On 18-6-1955, the suit was decreed against the defendants ex parts. The ex parte decree was, however, set aside on 19-12-1957; and the trial Court directed the issue of notices to the parties for their appearance £or proceeding further with the suit. The parties appeared; and when the case was fixed for evidence of the parties, the non-applicant-plaintiff absented himself from the hearing on 20-2-1959, on which date he had to lead his evidence. The trial Court, therefore, dismissed the suit on the ground that the plaintiff and his witnesses were absent. The Additional District Judge Alirajpur, on appeal, by his order dated 22-10-1959 set aside the order of the trial Court dated 20-2-1959 dismissing the suit and remanded the case to it for disposal according to law. On 28-10-1959, when the case was received back by the trial Court on remand, it directed issue of notices to the parties for their appearance on 9-12-1959. It further directed that the plaintiff should be present with his witnesses, whom he might summon for that date, if necessary. On 9-12-1959, neither the plaintiff nor his witnesses were present, though the counsel for the parties were present. The plaintiff had sent a telegram praying for an adjournment. The prayer for adjournment was rejected the case was dismissed with costs under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Procedure. A decree was also accordingly drawn up.

    The plaintiff, treating this dismissal as a dismissal under rule 8 of Order IX read with rule 2 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, applied for its being set aside under rule 9 of Order IX. The prayer, being refused on the ground that as the dismissal of the suit was under rule 3 of Order XVII, an application under rule 9 of Order IX was incompetent, he went up in appeal to the Court of the Additional District Judge, Alirajpur, who by his order dated 30-12-1960 set aside the order of dismissal on payment of Rs. 50 as adjournment costs and remanded the case to the trial Court for the recording of evidence and, thereafter, for its disposal according to law.

    3. The applicants (defendants) challenge this order as wrong and illegal.

    4. The question for consideration is whether the dismissal of the suit by the trial Court, which was expressly done by it under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, should be deemed to be one made under rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX of the Code, so that an application for setting aside the said dismissal filed by the plaintiff under rule 9 of Order IX should be held to be competent.

    5. The contention of the learned counsel for the non-applicant (plaintiff) is that notwithstanding the fact that the trial Court had purported to act under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, it should be deemed not to have so acted but to have acted under rule 2 of Order XVII read with rule 8 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure as the provisions of rule 3 of Order XVII were not in fact attracted.

    6. It is true that the provisions of rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure do not apply unless-

    "(1) the hearing is adjourned on the application of a party to the suit, as distinguished from an adjournment by Court of its own motion;

    (2) the hearing in adjourned on the application of the party who subsequently makes the default;

    (3) the adjournment is granted to enable the party to produce his evidence, or to cause the attendance of his witnesses, or to perform any other act necessary to the further progress of the suit; and

    (4) the party fails to perform any of the act a for which the adjournment was granted within the time allowed by the Court": (see Mulla's Civil Procedure Code, 12th Edn., p. 713).

    and in this case the adjournment was not on the application of the plaintiff who was subsequently found to have committed the default but an adjournment by the Court of its own motion; and there is ample authority for the proposition that where the Court itself adjourns the case for production of evidence by the parties quite generally without reference to anything in particular to be done by any one of the parties to the action, the adjournment does not bring into operat­ion rule 3 of Order XVII: [see Bhoorilal and others v. Kanhaiyalal and others AIR 1933 Nag. 234, Rukmanse v. Shankarguda A I R 1941 Bom. 83, Enatulla v. Jiban Mohan A I R 1914 Cal. 360 and Ryall v. Sherman I L R 1 Mad. 287. It is also true that on the date of bearing the counsel for the plaintiff was present but his physical presence alone could not be construed as his presence in Court on behalf of the plaintiff within the meaning of rule 1 of Order III. As pointed out by the Bombay High Court in Soonderlal v. Qoor-prasad I L R 23 Bom. 414. If a pleader does not conduct the case on behalf of his principal, his presence in Court is not an appearance in suit within the meaning of rule 6 or rule 8 of Order IX. It is also significant that the presence of the counsel was practically ignored by the Court as neither any question was put to him nor was he ever called upon to appear, apply and act on behalf of his client. Under these circumstances, it may be that rule 2 of Order XVII would have been the more appropriate provision under which the trial Court should have acted and not rule 3 of Order XVII under which it actually purported to act.

    7. But, even so, the fact remains that, rightly or wrongly, the trial Court chose to exercise its jurisdiction under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the rights of the parties shall have to be regulated by what it actually did than by what it ought to have done. In Nasirkhan v. Itwar AIR 1924 All. 144= ILR 46 All. 669, declining in somewhat similar circumstances to consider whether the lower Court which had made a decree in favour of the plaintiff under rule 3, Order XVII was justified in doing so, the learned Judge said:

    "The right of appeal does not depend on what the Court ought to have done but on what it actually did was to pass a decree on merits. Against such a decree the law allows an appeal. When the appeal comes up for decision, the appellate Court has then to decide whether the order passed was a proper order and one which the Court below had juris­diction to pass. If it decides this question in the negative, it will set the order aside."

    In Shri Kishan v. Radhakishen A I R 1952 All. 652, Agarwala J., speaking for the Division Bench, said:

    "The question whether an application for restoration is maintainable must be decided upon an interpretation of the order which the Court passes. If there is any doubt about the intention of the Court passing the order as to whether it intended to proceed under Order 12, rule 3 or Order 17, rule 2 in that case we can say that the order should be con­strued as one which 'ought' to have been passed. But this cannot be done when the Court expressly passes an order under one of the two rules. In that case, the aggrieved party should file an appeal against the order which is in fact a decree and not apply for restoration."

    Both these cases were cited with approval in Faiyazkhan v. Mithan A I R 1954 All. 222, where the Division Bench repelled the contention that a decree passed by the trial Court under rule 3 of Order XVII could be set aside by an appellate Court under rule 13 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure and the decisions reported in Raja Singh v. Mannasingh AIR 1940 All. 217 and Rafiq Ahmad v. Mohammad, Shaft I L R 1949 All. 759=A I R 1949 All. 423, were not followed. In my opinion the view of law enunciated in Faiyazkhan v. Mithan A I R 1954 All. 222 is more in consonance with the general principles of law and has to be preferred.

    8. It is trite that a Court has jurisdiction to decide rightly as well as wrongly, and that the appellate Court or the revisional Court to which it is sub­ordinate looks to its decision to find out if it is right or wrong. If it has purport­ed to act under any specific provision of law, the decision has to be judged with reference to that provision, and the forum which examines the correctness of the decision has also to be determined with reference to that provision. It is what a Court actually does which determines the forum and gives jurisdiction to the appellate or revisional Court and not what it ought to have done. If it were otherwise a great deal of uncertainty would be introduced into this class of litigation which could never be the intention of the law. As matter of judicial consideration also, when a specific provision is mentioned (unless it be a clerical or typing error), it would not be open to anybody to contend that the judicial intent was something different than what the plain and unambiguous language of the judgment warranted as the language of the judgment was the best indi­cation of the Court's intent. Consequently, where a decree has been passed expressly under a specific provision of the Code of Civil Procedure, however erroneously, the remedy is as provided by that provision, viz., by an appeal or revision: [See Faiyaz Khan v. Mithan AIR 1954 All. 222, Lalchand v. Kaka Bam AIR 1927 Lab. 562, Syed Baker Hussain v. Mirya Hussain Mirza AIR 1923 Pat. 223 and Balbahadar Singh v. Walaiti Ram AIR 1954 Fepsu 55.

    9. The matter may, however, be different where the specific section is not mentioned and we are left to refer from the surrounding circumstances what the section under which the Court had acted could have been. Regard being had to the presumption that a judgment is presumed to be correct till the contrary is shown, we may as a matter of judicial consideration, give to the judgment the best possible meaning and may presume every fact that would make it legal and valid rather than illegal or without jurisdiction, So that, in such oases, if we find that a particular judgment would be a valid one if passed under rule 2 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure and an invalid one if the Court had purported to act under rule 3 of Order XVII, we may well presume that which would make it legal and with jurisdiction.

    10. That this has been the view of this Court can also be gathered from the decision of Padhje J., in Sitalprasad v. Sukya 1948 N L J 443=A I R 1948 Nag. 310=ILR1948 Nag. 462 at p. 464:

    "It cannot be denied in this case that the lower Court did proceed under Order XVII, rule 3 and decided the case on merits. It has also passed a decree dismissing the plaintiff's suit. It is immaterial whether this decree is right or wrong because if it was wrong it could be set aside in appeal preferred there from and not in any other way. At any event the Court passing such a decree has no jurisdiction to set aside the decree passed by it in a proceeding started on an application for restoration of a suit to file and this Court cannot also do it in revision against an order refusing to restore the suit to file. The decree passed by the lower Court would therefore stand apart from the fact whether it was right or wrong because the proper remedy for having it set aside was not followed by the plaintiff."

    This case was, no doubt, overruled on another point by Rao and Tambe JJ. in Motilal Joshi v. Mohammad Shaft 1966 N L J m = AIR 1956 Nag, 179; but so far as the aforesaid observations are concerned, they are, in my opinion, still good law.

    11. The learned counsel for the non-applicant brought to my notice a case reported in Pratap Singh v. Moolchand 1961 J L J Note No. 211. 42; but that case has no application to the facts of this pase, because in that case neither was a decree passed in fact, nor did the lower Court proceed to decide the suit on merits specifically under rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    12. The application for revision is, therefore, allowed. The order of the lower appellate Court is hereby set aside and that of the first Court restored. The application of the plaintiff for setting aside the dismissal of the suit and the decree passed thereon under Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure is hereby dismissed with costs throughout. Counsel's fee Us. 25, if certified.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Govardhan Badrilal Mahajan And Another v. Ganesh Balkrishwa Deshmukh
    (Sep 29, 1961)