Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 19th October 2000, SK Upadhyaya, Vice Principal CTC-1 C.R.P.F. Neemuch, lodged a complaint alleging withdrawal of money from a bank draft through forged signatures. Following this, a police investigation was initiated under Sections 420, 467, 468, and 471 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The investigation revealed that one Yuddhveer Singh, in conspiracy with co-accused Parvinder Singh and the applicant Kaushalyabai, had withdrawn money by forging signatures and transferred the money to her father. Charges under Sections 419, 420, 467, 468, and 471/34 IPC were framed against the applicant by the learned Judicial Magistrate, Class I Neemuch, in Criminal Case No. 1187/01. The applicant challenged the framing of charges through this Criminal Revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there is sufficient prima facie material to frame charges against the applicant under Sections 419, 420, 467, 468, and 471/34 IPC?
  2. Whether the trial court erred in framing charges based on the prosecution's material, including statements under Section 27 of the Evidence Act and co-accused statements?
  3. Whether the identity of the applicant as wife of co-accused Parvinder Singh is established for the purpose of framing charges?

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant is not the wife of co-accused Parvinder Singh but of Vijendrasingh Rathi, supported by a certificate from Deputy Commandant, CRPF Neemuch.
  • The only evidence against the applicant is a memorandum under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, which did not lead to any recovery.
  • Even accepting the prosecution's material at face value, no prima facie case exists to warrant framing of charges.
  • Relied on the judgment in Sushil Kumar Sharma v. State of M.P. to support the contention.

State's Arguments

  • At the stage of framing charges, the scope for interference is limited.
  • There is ample material against the applicant to justify framing the charges.
  • No illegality or irregularity was committed by the trial court in framing the charges.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sushil Kumar Sharma v. State of M.P., 1995 (1) MPWN 248 Support for the principle that prima facie material must exist before framing charges. Relied upon by the applicant to argue lack of prima facie case against her.
State of Karnataka v. L. Muniswamy, AIR 1977 SC 1489 At the charge framing stage, prosecution evidence must be substantial enough to connect accused with the crime; weak bits of evidence are insufficient. Cited by the court to highlight that the prosecution's material was inadequate to frame charges.
Niranjan Singh Karam Singh v. Jitendra Bhimraj, AIR 1990 SC 1962 At the framing of charge stage, the court may sift evidence to determine if facts at face value disclose the offence; not all prosecution claims must be accepted without question. Applied by the court to evaluate the prosecution's material and conclude absence of prima facie case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the factual matrix and the prosecution's evidence at the framing stage. It noted the discrepancy regarding the applicant's marital status, as the charge-sheet consistently identified her husband as Vijendra Singh, not co-accused Parvinder Singh. The certificate submitted by the applicant supported this fact, and the prosecution's documents did not contradict it. The court found the statement recorded under Section 27 of the Evidence Act unhelpful as it did not lead to any recovery or disclose relevant facts. Further, the statement of co-accused Parvinder Singh mentioning the applicant was insufficient to establish her involvement in the alleged offence.

The court applied the principles from the cited Supreme Court judgments, emphasizing the limited scope of interference at the charge framing stage but also the necessity for prima facie material to connect the accused to the offence. The court held that accepting the prosecution's case at face value still failed to disclose a prima facie case against the applicant. Proceeding with trial would amount to an abuse of process, causing unnecessary harassment to the applicant and loss to the public exchequer.

Holding and Implications

The revision is allowed and the order of framing charges against the applicant is set aside.

This decision results in the applicant not being put on trial for the offences charged, as the court found no prima facie case. The ruling does not establish new legal precedent but enforces the principle that charges cannot be framed without sufficient prima facie evidence, protecting accused persons from unwarranted legal harassment and preserving judicial resources.

    Kaushalya Devi v. State Of M.P.

    Cases referred:

    1. Sushil Kumar Sharma v. State of M.P., 1995 (1) MPWN 248. (Para 5)

    2. State of Karnataka v. L. Muni-swamy, AIR 1977 SC 1489. (Para 8)

    3. Niranjan Singh Karam Singh v. Jitendra Bhimraj, AIR 1990 SC 1962. (Para 8)

    Order

    S.L. Kochar, J.— This Criminal Revision, has been preferred on behalf of the applicant against the order dated 24-2-2003 passed in Criminal Case No. 1187/01 by learned Judicial Magistrate, Class I Neemuch, thereby framing the charge for the offence punishable under Sections 419, 420, 467, 468 and 471/34 IPC against applicant.

    2. The facts of the case, in brief, are that on 19th October, 2000, compl-ainant, SK Upadhyaya, Vice Principal CTC-1 C.R.P.F. Neemuch lodged a written complaint to the effect that by making forged signature, the amount of draft was withdrawn from the Bank.

    On the basis of the aforesaid report, Police registered offence punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 I.P.C. against applicant and stepped into investigation.

    3. On investigation, it is found that one named K. Vishwambharan was Ex. Cook in CRPF in whose favour, bank draft was issued but on the basis of handwriting expert, one Vikramsingh has withdrawn money by making forged signatures from the bank. The Investi-gating Agency, on the report of hand writing expert, found one Yuddhveer Singh s/o Dharam Pal Singh obtained money by making forged signature in the name of Vikram Singh hatching conspiracy with co-accused Parvindar Singh S/o Harcharan Singh and fur-ther, said Parvindar Singh entered into conspiracy with his wife, present applicant Kaushalyabai, who has trans-ferred money to her father for purcha-sing tractor. As such offences have been registered against present applicant and charge-sheet has been filed.

    4. Learned trial Court, after hea-ring both parties, framed charges under Sections 419, 420, 467, 468 and 471/34 IPC by the impugned order, which is under challenge.

    5. Mr. Uberai, learned Sr. Coun-sel appearing for the applicant sub-mitted that applicant Kaushalya Devi is not wife of co-accused Parvinder Singh and this fact is borne out from the charge-sheet filed by the prosecution under Section 173 Cr.P.C. The applicant is the wife of Vijendrasingh Rathi. The counsel has filed certificate Annexure “C” duly issued by Deputy Comandant, CRPF Neemuch. He also putforth that only evidence against the applicant is memorandum under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, in pursuance whereof there is absolutely no recovery. According to him, even if complete material available in the charge-sheet on its face value without any rebuttal by the applicant, is accepted, no prima case is made out worth for taking cognizance much less for framing charge for the aforesaid offences. To bolster his submission, the counsel placed reliance on the judgment passed by Principal Bench of this Court in the case of Sushil Kumar Sharma v. State of M.P.1.

    6. In oppugnation, Mr. Girish Desai, learned Deputy Advocate General appearing for the State, has submitted that at the stage of framing of charge, there is very limited scope to interfere in revision and there is ample material against the applicant for framing the charge, as such no illegality, irregularity or impropriety committed by the trial Court.

    7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after perusing the entire record carefully, this Court is of the opinion that contention of learned counsel for applicant finds strong support on factual and legal position. Every where in the charge-sheet, name of husband of the applicant is men-tioned as Vijendra Singh. In the memo of arrest, in the seizure-memo and in the charge-sheet there is nothing revealing the fact that applicant is the wife of Parvinder Singh, as such even if ignoring the certificate filed by the applicant, Annexure “C” by the prose-cution’s own showing applicant is the wife of Vijendra Singh. Apart from this controversy of the name of the husband, in pursuance of the statement recorded under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, there is no recovery of bank draft. As such this statement is not helpful to the prosecution. It is merely a piece of paper. No relevant facts have been discovered in pursuance thereof.

    8. The next evidence is statement of co-accused Parvinder Singh, who has stated that on 9th August 2000, co-accused Yuddhveer Singh has presented one draft in the said State Bank of Indore and obtained Rs. 100000/-. The said sum of the draft was given by him to the present applicant and Parvinder Singh got the draft prepared through the applicant in the name of Dan Singh Rathi. No such document has been recovered from the bank showing the fact that present applicant got the draft prepared. Therefore, merely appearance of the name of the present applicant in the statement of co-accused Parvinder Singh, is not sufficient to take cogni-zance and to frame charge for putting the applicant on trial. Against the order of framing of charge, an interference in Revision or under inherent powers, further reference can be made to Supreme Court Judgment in the Case of State of Karnataka v. L. Muniswamy2 and in the case of Niranjan Singh Karam Singh v. Jitendra Bhimraj3.

    9. In the case of State of Karnataka (Supra) it has been held that:

    "A few bits here and a few bits there on which the prosecution proposes to rely are woefully in-adequate for connecting the res-pondents with the crime, however skilfully one may attempt to weave those bits into a presentable whole."

    10. In the case of Niranjan Singh (Supra) the Apex Court has held as under :

    "It seems will settled that at the Sections 227, 227 stage i.e., stage of framing of charge the Court is required to evaluate the material and documents on record with a view to finding out if the facts emerging therefrom taken at their face value disclose the existence of all the ingredients constituting the alleged offence. The Court may for this limited purpose sift the evidence as it cannot be expected even at that initial stage to accept all that the prosecution states as gospel truth even if it is opposed to common sense or the broad probabilities of the case."

    11. The Apex Court has consis-tently held that if there is no legal evi-dence then framing of charge would be groundless, and compelling the accused for facing the trial is nothing but contrary to the procedure prescribed by law which is offending Article 21 of the Constitution of India. For this purpose, the Court has limited powers to look into and sift the evidence upto

    some extent. (See AIR 1990 SC 1962). Applying the tests as laid down by the Apex Court, this Court is of the opinion that even if complete prosecution case is accepted, there is absolutely no material to make out prima facie case against the applicant. Therefore, it would be nothing but an abuse process of court of law to direct and compel the appli-cant to face the trial for which there is no certainty how much time the same will take. It is not only harassment or personal loss to the applicant but great loss to public exchequor.

    12. Consequently, this revision is allowed. The order of framing of charge passed by the trial Court is hereby set-aside.

    Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kaushalya Devi v. State Of M.P.
    (Mar 20, 2003)