The petitioners assail the proceedings dated 19.04.2010 issued by the
Commissioner, Endowments Department, Andhra Pradesh, to various Registration
Authorities in Chittoor District indicating the particulars of immovable
properties allegedly belonging to Sri Hathi Ramji Math, Tirupati and Sri Bugga
Math, Tirupati and requesting the Registration Authorities to desist from
entertaining registration of documents in connection with these properties.
This communication was ostensibly issued under Section 22-A (1)(c) of the
Registration Act, 1908 (for short 'the Act of 1908').
2. It is the complaint of the petitioners that basing on this communication,
the Joint Sub-Registrar-I, Tirupati, refused to receive the documents presented
by them in respect of their lands in Survey No.242/B of Tirupati Village,
Tirupati Urban Mandal, Chittoor District, as the said lands were indicated in
the list appended to the proceedings dated 19.04.2010 as properties of Sri Hathi
Ramji Math, Tirupati.
3. Despite service of notice through the learned counsel for the petitioners,
there is no representation on behalf of Sri Hathi Ramji Math, Tirupati, the
second respondent in the writ petition.
4. In his counter, the Joint Sub-Registrar-I, Tirupati, stated that the
subject lands were classified as properties belonging to the Endowments
Department as per the proceedings dated 19.04.2010 received from the
Commissioner of the Endowments Department. He opined that registration of
documents pertaining to the subject lands was prohibited under Section 22-
A(1)(c) of the Act of 1908. He further stated that as long as the lands were
included in the list of Endowment properties, he had no option except to refuse
registration of the documents pertaining thereto.
5. Section 22-A of the Act of 1908, to the extent relevant, reads as under:
"22-A. Prohibition of registration of certain documents:
(1) The following classes of documents shall be prohibited from
registration, namely:-
(a) .. . . . . . . .
(b) . . . . . . . .
(c) documents relating to transfer of property by way of sale,
agreement of sale, gift, exchange or lease exceeding (ten) 10
years in respect of immovable property, owned by Religious and Charitable
Endowments falling under the purview of the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu
Religious Institutions and Endowments Act, 1987 or by Wakfs falling under the
Wakfs Act, 1995 executed by persons other than those statutorily empowered to do
so;
(d) . . . . . . .
(e) any documents or class of documents pertaining to the properties the State
Government may, by notification prohibit the registration in which avowed or
accrued interests of Central and State Governments, local bodies, educational,
cultural, Religious and Charitable Institutions, those attached by Civil,
Criminal Revenue Courts and Direct and Indirect Tax Laws and other which are
likely to adversely affect these interests.
(2) For the purpose of clause (e) of sub-section (1), the State Government
shall publish a notification after obtaining reasons for and full description of
properties furnished by the District Collectors concerned in the manner as may
be prescribed."
6. A bare reading of the above provision makes it clear that the prohibition
contemplated by clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 22-A of the Act of 1908
relates to the status of the executant of the document relating to properties
owned by Religious/Charitable/Endowment/Wakf institutions. Registration of
documents executed by other than those statutorily empowered to do so in respect
of such properties is prohibited thereunder. The said provision pre-supposes
the title of the institution over the land and merely prohibits registration of
documents executed by those without authority. Therefore, the only list that
could be communicated under this provision would be a the list of those
designated persons who have power and authority to execute documents on behalf
of the Religious/Charitable/Endoment/Wakf institutions and not a list of the
properties belonging to such institutions.
7. The communication dated 19.04.2010 addressed by the Commissioner of the
Endowments Department of the State therefore proceeds on a complete
misconception and misunderstanding of the scope of the above provision. In the
event the Religious/Charitable/Endowment/Wakf institution seeks to assert any
right over a property, prohibition as to registration of documents relating to
such property can operate only if a notification is issued under Section 22-A
(2) of the Act of 1908 in connection with Section 22-A(1)(e) thereof.
8. In the absence of a notification under section 22-a (2), it is not open to
the Endowments Department to communicate a list of properties allegedly owned by
religious institutions by way of a letter and trace the power to do so to
Section 22-A(1)(c) of the Act of 1908.
9. The communication dated 19.04.2010 addressed by the Commissioner of
Endowments, Andhra Pradesh, to various Registration Authorities in Chittoor
District is therefore without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained. The same is
accordingly set aside and the Joint Sub-Registrar-I, Tirupati, is directed to
receive and process the documents presented by the petitioners in respect of
their lands in Survey No.242/B of Tirupati Village, Tirupati Urban Mandal,
Chittoor District, without reference to the said communication. In the event
the documents presented are found to fulfil the requirements of the Registration
Act, 1908 and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, the Joint Sub-Registrar-I, Tirupati,
shall complete the registration formalities and release the documents in
accordance with the due procedure.
10. The writ petition is accordingly allowed. W.P.M.P. No.12521 of 2013 shall
stand closed in the light of this final order. No costs.
___________________
SANJAY KUMAR, J.
Date: June 03, 2013