Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 3 and of clauses (a) and (b) of sub - section (1) of section 5 and sub - sections (i) and (2) of section 6
  • sub - section (7) of section 2
  • sub - section (2) of section 9,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 3 and of clauses (a) and (b) of sub - section (1) of section 5 and sub - sections (i) and (2) of section 6
  • sub - section (7) of section 2
  • sub - section (2) of section 9,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a revision petition against the judgment and decree of the District and Sessions Judge, Secunderabad, which dismissed Small Cause Suit No. 148/1 of 1954. The lower court dismissed the suit on the ground that the plaintiff had not established that he was not a professional money-lender within the meaning of the Hyderabad Money-lenders Act. The revision first came before Manohar Pershad, J., where for the first time the respondent-defendant contended that the plaintiff had admitted in evidence that the loan was advanced to enable the defendant to bribe an officer to obtain a job for his son, and that the suit therefore involved an illegal purpose and should be dismissed. The matter was referred to a bench. Subba Rao, C.J., delivered the opinion on the revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent-defendant may raise, for the first time in revision, a plea that the loan was for an illegal purpose (i.e., to bribe an official) based on an alleged admission in the plaintiff's evidence.
  2. Whether the burden of proof under Section 9 of the Hyderabad Money-lenders Act lies upon the plaintiff to prove that he is not a professional money-lender, or upon the defendant to allege and prove that the plaintiff is a professional money-lender without a licence.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended (for the first time in revision) that the plaintiff admitted in his evidence that the money was advanced to the defendant to bribe an officer to secure a job for the defendant's son, and that this admission established that the loan was for an illegal purpose and the suit should be dismissed.
  • The respondent's earlier written statement (filed in the suit) had alleged different facts: illicit intimacy between the defendant and a close relative of the plaintiff, that the defendant had discarded her a year before the promissory note, and that the plaintiff and others forced the defendant to execute the promissory note; it also pleaded that the note was not supported by consideration.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the plaintiff's legal arguments in the proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court gave a twofold analysis.

  1. On the newly-raised plea of illegality: the court refused to allow the respondent to raise, for the first time in revision, a plea which could and should have been raised in the written statement and argued before the trial judge. The court observed that the new plea was inconsistent with the respondent's written statement. The court evaluated the evidence and found that it did not clearly and unambiguously establish that the money was borrowed to be given as a bribe; rather, the evidence showed that the defendant had told the plaintiff he required money for bribing an official. The court noted that even when directly questioned, learned counsel for the respondent would not admit that his client had borrowed money to bribe an official. Given these facts, the court held it was not justified in permitting the respondent to raise that plea at the revision stage.
  2. On the burden of proof under the Hyderabad Money-lenders Act (Section 9): the court examined Section 9, which requires courts in suits relating to loans to decide whether the plaintiff is a money-lender as defined in sub-section (7) of section 2 and whether statutory provisions (including licensing under section 3) have been complied with; it further provides that if it is proved that the plaintiff is a money-lender as so defined but does not hold a licence granted under section 3, the court shall dismiss his suit. The court reasoned that a plaintiff cannot be required to prove a negative (i.e., that he is not a professional money-lender). Therefore, where a defendant seeks to non-suit the plaintiff on the ground that the plaintiff is a professional money-lender without a licence, it is the defendant who must allege and prove that fact. The learned district judge erred by placing the burden upon the plaintiff to prove he was not a professional money-lender; that misplacement of burden vitiated the lower court's finding.

Holding and Implications

Revision allowed; the decree of the lower court is set aside and the plaintiff's suit is decreed.

Direct consequences for the parties: the plaintiff's suit is decreed and the plaintiff (petitioner) is awarded costs both in this court and in the court below.

No broader legal implications or new precedent are discussed in the opinion; the decision reverses the lower court's dismissal and resolves the case between the parties on the described bases.

    Munagala Yadgiri v. Pittala Veeriah .

    Subba Rao, C.J.:-

    (1) This is a revision against the judgment and decree of the learned district and sessions judge, secunderabad, dismissing the small cause suit no. 148/1 of 1954 on the ground that it had not been established by the plaintiff that he was not a professional money - lender. This revision came up in the first instance for disposal before our learned brother, manohar pershad, j. Before him, it was contended for the first time that the plaintiff admitted in his evidence that the amount was advanced to the defendant in order that he might bribe an officer to get a job for his son and, on that admission, the suit should be dismissed, as the loan was advanced for an illegal purpose. The learned judge has referred the case to a bench, presumably on the ground that the question raised is of some importance.

    (2) We do not think we are justified in allowing the respondent - defendant to raise for the first time in revision a plea which he could have, if he intended, raised in his written statement and argued before the learned district judge. Indeed, the plea now raised is inconsistent with the allegation he made in the written statement. In the written statement, it is alleged that he had illicit intimacy with a close relative of the plaintiff, that he discarded her a year prior to the execution of the promissory note, and that the plaintiff and others forced him to execute the promissory note in favour of the plaintiff and that it is not supported by consideration the present alleged admission, namely, that the money was required to bribe an official is certainly inconsistent with the said case. But it is said that when facts supporting the illegality of a contract are disclosed to or discovered by the court in the course of the proceedings, the court suo motu should dismiss the suit if the facts establish clearly the case of illegality. Be that as it may, we are not satisfied that, in the present case, the record discloses the facts, clearly and unambiguously, in the sense that we can accept them, to non - suit the plaintiff. What is stated in the evidence is not that money was borrowed to bribe an official, but that the defendant told the plaintiff that he required the money for bribing an official. The defendant's case was not that the money was borrowed to be given as a bribe to secure a job for his son. Even when we put a direct questions to the learned counsel for the respondent, he is not in a position, for obvious reasons, to admit that his client borrowed the money to bribe some official. In the circumstances, we cannot allow the respondent to raise that plea before us.

    (3) On the second question, the learned judge held that the burden of proof lies upon the plaintiff to prove that he is not a professional money - lender. Section 9 of the hyderabad money - lenders act (v of 1349 - f) reads : - notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force, in every suit relating to a loan : 1. The court shall frame and decide the issues whether the money - lender is a money - lender as defined in sub - section (7) of section 2 and whether he has complied with the provisions of section 3 and of clauses (a) and (b) of sub - section (1) of section 5 and sub - sections (i) and (2) of section 6 2. If it is proved that the plaintiff is a money - lender as defined in sub - section (7) of section 2 but does not hold a licence granted under section 3, the court shall dismiss his suit. "

    (4) Under this act, a professional money - lender, who has not obtained a licence, cannot maintain a suit in a civil court for recovery of the amount due to him. The court shall dismiss his suit. But a person who seeks to non - suit the plaintiff, should necessarily allege and establish that the plaintiff is a professional money - lender. Indeed , sub - section (2) of section 9, in clear terms, says that if it is proved that the plaintiff is a money - lender as defined in sub - section (7) of section 2 but does not hold a licence, the court shall dismiss his suit. Obviously, the plaintiff cannot prove the negative viz. , that he is not a professional money - lender. It is for the defendant to allege and prove that the plaintiff is a professional money - lender. It is, therefore, clear that the learned judge's finding is vitiated by the fact of his throwing the burden wrongly upon the plaintiff.

    (5) In the result, the decree of the lower court is set aside and the plaintiff's suit is decreed. The petitioner (plaintiff) will have his costs both here and in the court below. Revision allowed suit decreed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Munagala Yadgiri v. Pittala Veeriah .
    (Dec 18, 1957)