Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • (4) Section 10 (3) (a)
  • section 13 (1) (e)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • (4) Section 10 (3) (a)
  • section 13 (1) (e)
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition was filed by the tenant under the A.P. Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960. The landlord (landlady) had filed a petition for eviction of the tenant from premises bearing door no. 824 in ward no. 25 on the ground of bona fide requirement for residential purposes.

The tenant's plea was that the tenancy from its inception was for both residential and non-residential purposes (mixed or composite letting). The tenant asserted that door no. 824 was used exclusively as a clinic and another portion (door no. 806) was used for residence by the clinic compounder.

The Rent Controller found that the requirement for personal occupation by the landlord was not bona fide and that the premises bearing door no. 824 were non-residential; the Rent Controller therefore rejected the eviction petition. On appeal, the appellate authority (relying on a Supreme Court decision reported at AIR 1984 SC 121) held that the provisions of the rent control statute were applicable and that personal requirement for residence was maintainable even though the premises were non-residential-cum-residential, and it set aside the Rent Controller's order.

The tenant instituted this revision petition against the appellate authority's order. The tenancy agreement identified in the record is Ex. A-12, dated 25-11-1966, which the opinion treats as the foundational document for the tenancy relationship.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an eviction petition based on the landlord's bona fide personal requirement for residential occupation is maintainable under the rent control statute where the premises were let for mixed (residential and non-residential) purposes from the inception.
  2. Whether, in a composite letting (residential-cum-non-residential), the court may disintegrate the single tenancy contract and order eviction limited to the portion actually used for residential purposes.
  3. How to interpret the tenancy agreement (Ex. A-12), specifically whether the phrase "the tenant can reside and can have his dispensary" establishes a dominant residential purpose or indicates a mixed-purpose lease.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Tenant's) Arguments

  • The eviction petition based solely on bona fide requirement for residential purposes is not maintainable because the tenancy has been for both residential and non-residential purposes from the beginning.
  • The bona fide requirement for residential purposes does not arise in respect of premises that were let for mixed use; specifically, door no. 824 was used exclusively as a clinic.
  • Therefore, the petition for eviction on the ground of residential requirement should be dismissed.

Respondent's (Landlady's / Appellate Authority's) Arguments

  • The provisions of the rent control act do not prohibit seeking eviction for residential requirement even where premises are used for mixed purposes; there is no statutory lacuna barring such a petition.
  • The tenancy agreement language "the tenant can reside" should be viewed as indicating a dominant residential purpose, with the dispensary being incidental or subsidiary.
  • The appellate authority relied on Supreme Court authority (AIR 1984 SC 121) to hold that personal requirement for residence is maintainable even when the premises are non-residential-cum-residential.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1984 SC 121 The appellate authority relied on this Supreme Court decision to hold that the provisions of the rent control act were applicable and that personal requirement for residence was maintainable even though the premises were non-residential-cum-residential. The appellate authority used this decision to justify setting aside the Rent Controller's order; the present court records that the appellate authority proceeded on that basis but ultimately disagrees with the appellate outcome in the specific factual and statutory context of a composite lease (see final order where appellate order is set aside).
Miss S. Samyal v. Gian Chand The Supreme Court held that where premises are let for composite purposes (residential and non-residential), the tenancy contract is single and indivisible; courts cannot disintegrate the contract and grant relief under a provision applicable only to premises "let for residential purposes." The court relied on this principle to hold that the contract of tenancy cannot be divided so as to permit eviction under the rent control provision applicable only to residential lettings; hence the landlord has no remedy under the rent control statute for composite leases.
Dr. Gopal Dass Verma v. Dr. Bhardwaj Held that when premises are let for residential purposes and subsequently used for commercial or professional purposes with the landlord's consent, the premises cease to be residential premises for the purposes of the eviction provision. The court cited this authority to illustrate that changes in user with landlord's consent alter the character of the premises; the decision is discussed as part of the jurisprudence that treats user and consent as determinative, but the court emphasizes that the present case involves a composite lease from inception rather than a subsequent change of user.
G. Ramachandra Rao v. K. Ramakrishna Rao Held (in context) that a building constructed for residence which is rented out as lodging (for customers on daily rent) could still retain the character of a residence rather than be treated as a business or non-residential premises, depending on facts. The opinion notes this decision was referred to by the respondent; the court observes that such decisions turn on the nature of the building and the facts and are not directed at the legal consequences of composite leasing as in the present case.
Smt. Kamala Bai v. Dr. A. K. Shah Held that the character of a building and the terms of the tenancy agreement are to be considered in determining whether premises are residential or non-residential; user without landlord's consent is not itself determinative. The court cited this decision (referred to by the respondent) to show that facts and the tenancy deed are crucial; again the court treats such authorities as fact-sensitive and distinguishes them from the present question of composite lease drafted in Ex. A-12.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in a stepwise fashion grounded in the tenancy agreement, statutory scheme and cited authorities:

  1. Identification of the parties' agreed purpose of letting: The court begins by emphasizing that the proper starting point is Ex. A-12 (agreement dated 25-11-1966). Clause 2 of the agreement expressly states: "the tenant can reside and can have his dispensary in the house" and allows specified alterations to locate the dispensary. The court interprets this language as placing residence and dispensary "on the same par" and therefore as a lease for mixed purposes from the inception.
  2. Statutory structure: The court then analyses Section 10(3)(a) of the Act (quoted in the opinion). It highlights that the statutory scheme treats residential and non-residential evictions separately and distinctly, with different ingredients of bona fide requirement and different grounds for eviction depending on the character of the building. The court reads a deliberate dichotomy in the statute between residential and non-residential premises.
  3. Application of precedents: The court relies on Supreme Court authority (Miss S. Samyal v. Gian Chand and related jurisprudence) that a tenancy contract is single and indivisible and that, absent statutory provision, a court cannot split a composite letting into separate contracts for residential and non-residential parts for the purpose of applying a provision confined to residential lettings. The court also notes decisions (e.g., Dr. Gopal Dass Verma; G. Ramachandra Rao; Kamala Bai v. Dr. A. K. Shah) which are fact-sensitive and concern the character of the building and changes of user, but finds those authorities distinguishable because they do not address the legal consequences of a composite lease established from the inception.
  4. Conclusion as to applicability of Section 10(3)(a): Given the express mixed-purpose wording of Ex. A-12 and the statutory dichotomy, the court reasons that the statutory eviction remedy for bona fide personal requirement is not available in respect of premises let out for mixed purposes. The court finds no provision in the rent control statute enabling eviction in respect of a composite lease. The effect of this interpretive conclusion is that the statute's eviction provisions apply when premises are either residential or non-residential, but not where a composite lease exists from the start.
  5. On the contention of "dominant purpose": The court considered the respondent's submission that the initial clause "the tenant can reside" should be treated as the dominant purpose. The court rejects that approach, noting that the clause places residence and dispensary on equal footing and expressly permits alterations to accommodate the dispensary; therefore the lease must be read as mixed.
  6. On appellate reliance on AIR 1984 SC 121: Although the appellate authority relied on that Supreme Court decision to hold the rent control provisions applicable, the court revisits the statutory text and the agreement and concludes that, in the presence of a composite lease, the eviction remedy under the rent control statute is unavailable. Consequently the appellate authority's order is set aside.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court set aside the order of the appellate authority and restored the decretal order of the Rent Controller. The revision petition is allowed (C.R.P. Allowed). No costs were awarded.

Direct implications for the parties:

  • The eviction petition filed by the landlord for bona fide personal requirement for residential occupation (in respect of premises bearing door no. 824) cannot succeed under the rent control statute because the tenancy was a composite lease for both residential and non-residential purposes from inception; the Rent Controller's finding that the premises were non-residential and that the personal requirement was not bona fide is restored.
  • The appellate authority's contrary view (which had set aside the Rent Controller's order) is reversed; consequently the landlord does not obtain the statutory eviction remedy in this forum and the tenant's position is preserved under the Rent Controller's decree.

Broader legal implication as stated in the opinion:

The court explains that the rent control statute, by distinguishing residential and non-residential evictions and providing separate criteria for each, contains no provision for eviction where the premises are let for mixed purposes from the outset. Therefore, where a composite lease exists, the landlord is deprived of the expeditious remedy under the rent control act and must pursue a remedy by a civil suit. The opinion notes this creates a statutory "vacuum" for composite leases and that the court will not read into the statute an additional eviction provision absent legislative language.

Disposition: Revision petition allowed; appellate order set aside; Rent Controller's decretal order restored; C.R.P. allowed; no costs.

    Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli v. Lambu Indira Bai .

    (1) This revision petition at the instance of the tenant is under the provisions of the a. P. Buildings (lease, rent and eviction) control act, 1960. The landlord filed the petition for eviction of the tenant from premises bearing door no. 824 in ward no. 25 on the ground of bana fide requirement for residential purpose. The plea of the tenant is that the tenancy from the inception is for residential as well as non - residential purposes and the petition for bona fide requirement for residential purposes/only is not maintainable and the bona fide requirement does not arise. The plea of the tenant is amplified by stating that the house bearing door no. 824 is exclusively used for clinic and the other portion bearing door no. 806 is used by the com - pounder in the clinic for residence. The rent controller held that the requirement for personal occupation by the landlord is not bona fide and the provisions of rent control act are not applicable and further the premises bearing door no. 824 for which eviction is sought is a non - residential one. On appeal at the instance of the landlady the appellate authority held that the provisions of rent control act are applicable in view of the decision of the supreme court in air 1984 sc 121 and the personal requirement for residence is maintainable even though the premises let out is non - residentiai - cum - residential and in this view set aside the order of the rent controller.

    (2) The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that where the premises it residential - cum - non - residential the petition for eviction for the purpose of residence alone is not maintainable and hence the petition should be dismissed on this ground. The learned counsel for the respondent seeking the sustain the judgment of the appellate court contended that the provisions of rent control act do not prohibit the petition for eviction of a non - residential - cum - residential purposes on the ground of requirement of residential purpose and such lacuna cannot be deduced and in any event the let out premises is residential only.

    (3) The initial exercise is to identify the purpose for which the building is let out and the understanding between the parties as to use of the premises. The rent controller held that premises bearing door no. 824 is let out for non - residential purpose and the finding is not disturbed by the appellate court. It must be stated that the appellate court proceeded upon the facting that the premises is non - residential cum - residential. Ex. A - 12 is the agreement of tenancy, dated 25 - 11 - 1966 and it is not in dispute that this agreement constitutes the foundation for tenancy relationship. Clause 2 with reference to the purpose of letting out is as follows : " (2) the tenant can reside and can have his dispensary in the house. In the first instance the tenant can carry on small alterations for the convenience of locating the dispensary within a sum not exceeding rs. 2,000/ - (two thousand only). On this amount interest shall be charged at 9% p. A. This amount will be advanced by the tenant". This clause does not admit of any doubt as to mixed purpose of dispensary and clinic and the equitable alterations for having dispensary are provided. The land - lady did not adduce any evidence to the effect that this deed is not acted upon. The learned counsel for the respondent contends that the initial portion in clause 2, 'the tenant can reside" should be considered as dominant purpose and the location of dispensary is optional and too subsidiary to be given any importance. I am unable to appreciate this approach. The expression "the tenant can reside and can have dispensary" clearly discloses that the residence and dispensary are put on the same par and the lease is for both the purposes and the domination of preceding purpose cannot be as spelt out. The lease is evidently for mixed purpose of residence as well as non - residential.

    (4) Section 10 (3) (a) which controls eviction for personal requirement to the extent relevant is as follows :

    " (3) (a) a landlord may, subject to the provisions of clause (d) , apply to the controller for an order directing the tenant to put the landlord in possession of the building (i) in case it is a residential building (a) if the landlord is not occupying a residential building of his own in the city, town or village concerned and he requires it for his own occupation; (b) if the landlord who has more buildings than one in the city, town or village concerned is in occupation of one such building and he bona fide requires another building instead for his own occupation; (ii) in case it is a non - residential building which is used for the purpose of keeping a vehicle or adopted for such use, if the landlord requires it for his own use and if he is not occupying any such building in the city, town or village concerned which is his or the possession of which he is entitled whether under this act or otherwise : (iii) in case it is any other non - residential building, if the landlord is not occupying a non - residential building in the city, town or village concerned which is his own or to the possession of which he is entitled whether under this act or otherwise (a) for the purpose of business which he is carrying on, on the date of the application, or (b) for the purpose of a business which in the opinion of the controller, the landlord bona fide proposes to commence"
    . The lay out of the provision reveals that the considerations for eviction of residential and non - residential premises are different and they are given separate treatment. The ingredients of bona fide requirement are distinct. This dichotomy between residential and non - residential is kept up and continued in the event of eviction for the purpose of additional accommodation also as provided under clause (c).

    (5) The learned counsel for the petitioner invited to the decision reported in miss s. Samyal vs. Gian chand #1 wherein the tetant has been occupying the premises a part of which is used for girls school and the rest for residential purposes. The petition for ejectment was filed by the landlord on the ground of requirement of the house bona fide for his residence. The trial court dismissed the suit and on appeal the subordinate judge, delhi dismissed appeal holding that the house being ist out for purposes of non - residential as well as residential a decree for ejectment could not be granted under section 13 (1) (e) of the delhi and ajmer rent control act, 1952. The high court off punjab in the revision petition held that on the basis of the findings by the appellate court a decree for ejectment of the portion used for residential purposes can be passed and remanded the case to the trial court for demarcating those portions which were being used for residence and to pass a decree for ejectment to those specified portions of the house. While considering this aspect the supreme court held as follows : "in the present case the first appellate court held that the house was "let out for running a school and for residence". The high court held that where there is a composite letting it is open to the court to disintegrate the contract of tenancy and if the landlord proves his case of bona fide requirement for his own occupation to pass a decree in ejectment limited to that part which is being used" by the tenant for residential purposes. In so holding in our judgment, the high court erred. The jurisdiction of the court may be exercised under sec. 13 (1) (e) of the act only when the premises are let for residential purposes and not when the premises being let for composite purposes are used in specific portions for purposes residential and non - residential. The contract of tenancy is a single and indivisible contract, and in the absence of any statutory provision to that effect it is not open to the court to divide it into two contracts - one of letting for residential purposes, and the other for non - residential purposes, and the other for non - residential purposes and to grant relief under sec. 13 (1) (e) of the act limited to the portion of the demised property which "is being used" for residential purposes". In dr. Gopal dass verma vs. Dr. Bhardwaj #2 the supreme court held that when premises are let for residential purposes and subsequently they are used by the tenant for commercial, professional or other purposes with the consent of the landlord the landlord is not entitled to object the tenant for requirement for residence as the premises have by their need ceased to be promises 1st for residential purposes alone.

    (6) The learned counsel for the respondent referred to the decision in g. Ramachandra rao vs. K ramakrishna rao #3 wherein the tenant took the premises on lease for the purpose of running lodging hotel and in the context of considering the maintainability of the application by the landlord for eviction on the ground of personal requirement for residence, obul reddy, j. Held that the building was constructed for the purpose of residence and it has been put to use as residence or dwelling place for customers of the tenant i. E. , by dividing the building into several rooms and renting them out on dialy rent and this will not however make the house a business premises or in other words non - residential building. In smt. Kamala bai vs. Dr. A. K. Sham #4 the building was originally 1st out in favour of dr. Kamala towards his residence and doctor was using the premises for his general practice as a medical practitioner and afterwards one dr. A. K. Shah became the tenant and he was residing in the upstair portion of the house and was using the ground floor as a nursing home. The landlord sought the eviction on the ground that she bona fide requires the premises for her own occupation. In the context of considering whether the eviction petition can be filed for residential purpore ramachandraraju, j. Held that the user of the premises particularly without the consent of the landlord by the tenant is not determinative factor but the character of the building as such has to be taken into consideration and further the tenancy agreement has to be looked into.

    (7) Both the decisions referred to by the learned counsel for the respondent turned upon the facts as to the nature of the building and the intention as to user of the building and they are not concerned with the consequences of composite leasing. In the instant case it is patent from ex. A - 12 that the premises are let out for dual purpose and therefore it is composite lease comprising residence as well as non - residential. In view of dichotomy maintained under section 10 (3) (a) of the act between respective requirements and causes of action for filing a viction petition for residential and non - residential premises the requirement for residence cannot be availed of for eviction for non - residential premises and equally the requirement for non - residential purpose cannot be pre - passed into service for eviction from residential premises. There is no provision under the rent control act for eviction based upon bona fide personal requirement in respect of premises let out for mixed purpose of residential and non residential. The rent control act bearing a slant towards the protection of the tenants against un - reasona - ble evictions provided sufficient safeguards to the landlords for eviction and otherwise. The bona fide personal requirement is founded upon the legitimate necessity of the landlord and in the event of composite lease the landlord is deprived of the remedy under the rent control act. The rent control act is a self contained enactment be set with provisions broadly balancing the rights and obligations of the tenants and landlords and expeditious and offleatious remedies and the absence of any provision regarding the eviction of the premises having composite lease deprived the expeditious remedy under the rent control act and the landlord is obliged to seek remedy by a civil suit. The learned counsel for the respondent stressed that such interpretation leading to vaccum virtually should not be considered to have been intended by the provisions of the rent control act and the interpretation leaning towards furtherance of the purpose of the act should be adopted. It cannot be gain said that the rent control act took care of the interests of the landlords and provided for eviction in diverse contingencies but however there is absolutely no semblance of indication for eviction in composite leases. The rent control act having profusely provided for eviction in the case of residential or non - residential premises appears to have overlooked the provisions for eviction in respect of premises let out for mixed purpose. The ingredients for eviction for residential'and non - residential fare distinct and separate though there are certain similar features and in the absence of any provision for eviction in respect of premises bearing composite lease it is not possible to lead section 10 (3) (a) with a provision for eviction in respect of premises having composite lease and such interpretation is blessed by supreme court while considering the analogous provisions under the ajmer rent control act.

    (8) The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that in any event the dominant purpose of the lease is letting out for residence only and the incidential user does not alter the character of the building. I am unable to appreciate the contention ex. A - 12 the agreement of tenancy provides for tenancy for residence as well as for dispensary and this is reinforced by provision enabling the tenant to carry on small alterations for running the tenancy. The leasing out for residential purpose alone cannot be spelt out from ex. A - 2 and the composite lease is the logical outcome of ex. A - 2.

    (9) In the result the order of the appellate authority is set aside and the decretal order of the real coatroller is restored.

    (10) C. R. P. Allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Madhusudan Mahuli v. Lambu Indira Bai .
    (Apr 14, 1987)