AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • subject-matter.12. Order 33, Rule 2
  • bonafides.11. Order 33 Rule 5
  • pleadings.13. Order 33, Rule 1
  • Order 33, Rule 1 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • subject-matter.12. Order 33, Rule 2
  • bonafides.11. Order 33 Rule 5
  • pleadings.13. Order 33, Rule 1
  • Order 33, Rule 1 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Legal Opinion Summary: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (Order 33, Rule 1 CPC)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges an order under Order 33, Rule 1 C.P.C. dismissing the petition for permission to sue in forma pauperis. The petitioner (plaintiff) sought (1) a declaration that he is the Mutawalli of a Dargha located at Yennunnarva, (2) possession of the Dargha, and (3) recovery of Rs. 60,000 as income realised by the defendant in 1964–1965.

The plaint alleges that the petitioner and his ancestors were hereditary Khazi and Mutawallis of the Dargha (a sanad alleged to have been granted during the reign of Emperor Aurangzeb), that government supervision was imposed after a complaint by one Sufi Azam Ali and that the Dargha remained under government supervision without proper enquiry. The petitioner alleges the defendant obtained possession in November 1964 by a fraudulent compromise with the Wakf Board.

The defendant filed a written statement denying the petitioner's title and asserting that the defendant and his ancestors were the Sajjada and Mutawallis; he relied on prior Government and other records and prior litigation (including O.S. No. 7 of 1955 and an application I.A. 84/1964 in those proceedings, which was dismissed on 25-11-1964). The defendant also raised several procedural and substantive objections, including non-joinder of necessary parties, limitation, and that the plaintiff was not a pauper.

The learned District Judge dismissed the petition to sue as pauper on two grounds: (1) the petitioner's claim is barred by limitation; and (2) the petitioner failed to disclose his entire property in the schedule attached to the petition, indicating lack of bonafides.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner may be permitted to sue in forma pauperis when he sues in a representative capacity as Mutawalli, i.e., whether his personal means should be excluded and the question of pauperism determined with reference to the means he possesses in that representative capacity.
  2. Whether the suit, on the face of the plaint and associated allegations, appears to be barred by limitation such that the petition to sue as pauper can be rejected under Order 33, Rule 5(d)(i).
  3. Whether the petition must be rejected because the petitioner failed to disclose in the schedule attached to the petition all movable and immovable property (Order 33, Rule 2 and Rule 5 provisions), thereby affecting bonafides.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioner's) Contentions

  • The petitioner and his ancestors were hereditary Mutawallis/Khazis of the Dargha and a sanad was allegedly granted in their favour; they had managed the Dargha for generations and appointed Mujawars and servants.
  • The Government took over supervision of the Dargha (following a complaint) and failed to make enquiries or dispose of claims; subsequently the defendant obtained possession by compromise with the Wakf Board in November 1964.
  • The suit was filed in his capacity as Mutawalli (a representative capacity), and therefore the assessment of his capacity to pay court-fee should be determined with reference to means possessed in that representative capacity rather than his personal assets.
  • He contends he is already the Mutawalli and seeks a declaration only because the defendant denies that status; thus he is suing in a representative capacity, not seeking appointment.

Respondent's (Defendant's) Contentions

  • The defendant denies the plaint's allegations as to the sanad and hereditary possession by the petitioner's family, asserting that he and his ancestors were the Sajjada and Mutawallis and that prior records and proceedings support that position.
  • The defendant relied on prior litigation outcomes (including O.S. 7/1955 and related proceedings) in which the defendant was recognized as Mutawalli (including a Minister's declaration in 1344 Fasli) and pointed out the petitioner's prior unsuccessful attempt to be impleaded as a supplemental defendant (I.A. 84/1964 dismissed).
  • Procedural objections: non-joinder of necessary parties (Endowment Department, State, Muslim Wakf Board, and another named person); absence of cause of action; limitation bar (the cause of action, if any, arose long ago); and the suit requires prior sanction of the Wakf Board under applicable provisions.
  • On pauperism, the defendant alleged the petitioner is not a pauper — he receives fees as Khazi for many villages, earns more than Rs. 200 per month, owns a house in Faruknagar valued at Rs. 4,000 and other properties; the schedule of properties filed with the petition is said to be incorrect.
  • Counsel for the respondent argued that because the petitioner seeks a declaration that he is the Mutawalli, the suit is not one brought in a representative capacity and therefore personal means should be considered for pauperism.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Mabia Khatum v. Sheikh Satkari Where a plaintiff sues in a representative character (e.g., Mutawali, Trustee or Shebait), the plaintiff may be allowed to sue as a pauper unless it is shown that he has in his possession property belonging to the wakf/estate for whom he sues sufficient to pay the court fee; the capacity of the representative is distinct from personal capacity. The court relied on this principle to hold that the petitioner, suing as Mutawalli (a representative), should not be assessed for pauperism by reference to his personal property; his capacity should be determined with reference to means in his representative capacity.
U.M. Usman v. Mayor Simon When the plaintiff sues in a representative capacity he is entitled to sue in forma pauperis if he is not in possession of properties or funds belonging to the real plaintiff (the institution/group) sufficient to pay the necessary court fee; the personal means of the plaintiff suing in representative capacity are immaterial. The court invoked this authority to reinforce that the petitioner's personal assets need not be considered in determining his entitlement to sue as pauper when he sues as Mutawalli; the appellate court declined to treat the petition as defective on that ground.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began with a combined reading of the relevant provisions of Order 33, Rules 1, 2 and 5 C.P.C. It noted that a suit may be instituted in forma pauperis when the plaintiff is not possessed of sufficient means to pay the court-fee and has annexed the required schedule of movable and immovable property, provided the suit does not appear to be barred by law. Rule 2 requires a schedule of any property belonging to the applicant; Rule 5 lists grounds for rejection (including absence of pauperism, disposal of property to enable a pauper application, absence of cause of action, and apparent bar by law such as limitation).

The lower court had found that the petitioner failed to disclose at least one item of property in the schedule and concluded the petition was barred by limitation. The appellate court examined whether those findings were sustainable in light of the plaintiff's pleaded capacity.

The appellate court analysed the character in which the petitioner sued. It concluded that the suit was filed in the petitioner's representative capacity as Mutawalli (not in his purely personal capacity). Explanation (iii) to Order 33, Rule 1 provides that where the plaintiff sues in a representative capacity, the question of pauperism is to be determined with reference to means possessed by him in that capacity. Applying that provision, the court held the petitioner need not disclose personal properties in the schedule when those properties are not held in his representative capacity.

The court rejected the respondent's argument (advanced by counsel) that because the petitioner sought a declaration that he is Mutawalli, it was not a representative suit; the court observed that the petitioner asserts he is already Mutawalli and seeks a declaratory relief to vindicate that status, so he is suing as Mutawalli (representatively).

On the limitation point the court described the question as a mixed question of law and fact; on a mere perusal of the allegations it was not possible to conclude definitively that the suit was barred by limitation. The appellate court therefore considered it improper, at the stage of deciding the pauper petition, to embark upon a detailed enquiry into the prior evidence and decide the limitation issue against the petitioner.

Having regard to the authorities cited (which support excluding the plaintiff's personal assets when he sues in a representative capacity) and the lack of a clear, decisive showing that the suit was barred by limitation on the face of the plaint, the appellate court concluded that the two grounds relied on by the lower court for rejecting the pauper petition were not sound.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed; the petitioner is permitted to sue as a pauper.

Direct consequences for the parties: the petitioner (appellant) is allowed to proceed in forma pauperis; the petition and appeal were allowed and there is no order as to costs. The decision removes the lower court's refusal to grant permission to sue as a pauper on the grounds of alleged non-disclosure of personal property and apparent limitation, enabling the suit to proceed to be adjudicated on its merits.

Prepared exclusively from the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the text have been introduced.

    Syed Mohd. Ibrahim Ali (Petitioner) v. Syed Akram Ali ().

    Ramachandra Raju, J.:— This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is directed against an order passed under Order 33, Rule 1 C.P.C whereby the petition filed to sue in forma pauperis was dismissed.

    2. The reliefs prayed for in the plaint are (1) to declare that the plaintiff (petitioner) is the Mutwalli of the Dargha, (2) that the defendant (respondent) be directed to handover possession of the Dargha to the plaintiff (petitioner) and (3) to recover a sum of Rs. 60,000/- from the defendant being the income realised by him during the years 1964 and 1965. The following are the allegations made in the plaint:

    “The plaintiff's father and his ancestors were hereditary Mutawallies of the Dargha. The plaintiff has also been the hereditary Mutawalli. The Dargha is situate at Yennunnarva, a village in Shadnagar taluk.

    3. During the period of the reign of the Emperor Awarangjib, the plaintiff's ancestors were appointed Khazi and Mutawali for the Dargha and a sanad was granted in their favour. They ware in management of the Dargha. They used to appoint servants and Mujawars. The plaintiff's ancestors were the Khazies for the area in which they were residing and they were also Mutawallies for the said Dargha. Therefore they appointed the defendant's father and other persons as Mujawars and servants of the Dargha to perform the services of Katiha and attend to the sweeping of Dargha etc., Thus, members of the plaintiff's family had been in possession and management of the Dargha for many generations. The defendant or any of his ancestors had no right to, or interest in, the Dargha. As stated above, the defendant's father and some other persons were appointed as servants and Mujawars for Dargha by the plaintiff's ancestors. They were not Sajjadas or Mutawalies for the Dargha at any time. About 50 years back, one Sufi Azam Ali made a complaint to the Ecclesiastical Dept., against then Mujawars of the Dargha alleging misconduct on their part in the matter of the management of the Dargha. He did so with the wrongful intention of taking possession of the Dargha. The Ecclesiastical Department entrusted the management of the Dargha to him without making any enqairy. Shortly, thereafter Government however dismissed him and took over the management of the Dargha, pending disposal of the case. The Dargha was taken over by the Government from the possession of the plaintiff's father and grand-father. They applied to the Ecclesiastical Department for possession of the Dargha but as there were other claimants also, the Nizam issued a firmana that, pending enquiry of the case, the Dargha need not be handed over to anybody. The Dargha thus remained under the supervision of the Government. No enquiry was made by the Government and no orders were passed regarding the management of the Dargha. The Government did not take any action inspite of several representations made by the Plaintiff's ancestors and also by the plaintiff. There was no justification for the failure of the Government to dispose of the plaintiff's petition or for continuance of the Government supervision and management of the Dargha. There was also no, justification for the Government to put the defendant in possession of the Dargha through the ??? Board. The defendant filed the suit for declaration of his right of management in respect of the Dargha and for its possession against the Government and Muslim Wakf Board. He also sued for recovery of the amount which was lying in deposit with the Government. He filed the suit in the District Court, Maha boobnagar. It was numbered as O.S 7 of 1955. He (Defendant) did not, however, implead the plaintiff herein as a party to the suit even though he was aware that he was the rightful claimant to the possession and management of the Dargha. After he came to know of the suit, he filed a petition for being brought on record as a supplemental defendant in the suit. But the District Court however dismissed the petition.

    4. In accordance with the ??? issued by H.E.H the Nizam, the Government took over the supervision of Dargha and as per the firman, the Government's supervision should be continued till the enquiry regarding the claims to the Dargha was completed. But the defendant colluded with the Wakf Board and entered into a compromise fraudulently and got possession of the Dargha and the amount in deposit, in November, 1964. The defendant by entering into a compromise with the Wakf Board and taking possession of the Dargha in November, 1964 denies the plaintiff's right of Mutawaliship for the Dargha. Hence the plaintiff is obliged to file this suit for above reliefs.

    5. The respondent (Defendant) filed a counter with the following allegations:—

    “That the plaintiff has no right to the Mutauwaliship of the Dargha and that the plaint allegations regarding the Sanad alleged to have been granted by emperor Aurangizib in favour of the plaintiff's ancestors are false. The other contentions in the written statement are follows, it is not true that the Dargha had been in possession and management of the members of the plaintiff's family for generations. It is not true that the defendant's father was appointed as a servant or as Mujawar for the Dargha. He was the Sajjada and Mutawali of the Dargha. The records available with the Government and the records and documents filed in prior proceedings prove that this defendant and his ancestors were the Mutawalies and Sajjadanashins of the Dargha. On a dispute raised by Sufi Azam Ali that he was the Mutawili of the Dargha against this defendant, the Ecclesiastical Department took over the management of the Dargha from Syed ???, the brother of this defendant. It is not true that the Government took over possession and management of the Dargha from the plaintiff's father and grandfather. In all the proceedings relating to the Dargha which were taken subsequent to the suit filed by Sufi Azam Ali, it was declared that the defendant and his ancestors were the Sajjadanashins and Mutawalies of the Dargha. In 1344 Fasli, the Minister declared this defendant as the Mutawali of the Dargha. The applications made by the plaintiff's ancestors and his father were all dismissed by the Authorities concerned on the ground that they had no right in respect of the Dargha. It is true that this defendant filed O.S 7/55 for declaration of his rights as Mutawali of the Dargha against the Government, in this Court. In 1958, evidence on behalf of the plaintiff and the Wakf Board was brought on record. The present plaintiff filed I.A 84/1964 praying to implead him as a supplemental defendant. In that I.A he made the same allegations as those which are now made in the present plaint. It was dismissed on 25-11-1964. The plaintiff has again come forward with this suit with false allegations and they are the same which were put forth by him I.A No. 84 of 1954. It is not true that the compromise entered into by the Wakf Board with this defendant in O.S 7/64 was the result of collusion between him and the Wakf board.

    6. This suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties namely Endowment Department, State of Andhra Pradesh, Muslim Wakf Board and Mohd. Burhan Mujawar. There is no cause of action for this suit. The cuase of action if at all arose in 1920 when the Dargha was taken overy by the Government under its supervision. No cause of action arose in favour of the plaintiff when the Wakf Board delivered possession of the Dargha to this 5-11-1964. The plaintiff was never in possession of the ??? its properties at any time. The fact that I.A 84/64 was dismissed does not give any fresh cause of action to him. He was not in possession of the Dargha within 12 years prior to this suit. He or any of his ancestors never took steps to get their rights in respect of the Dargha, if any declared in a Court of law. They functioned as Matawalis and they were never in possession of the Dargha or its properties as its Mutawalies at any time. Their claims if any were barred by limitation long ago. Their claims if any were barred by limitation long ago. The suit is not maintainable without prior sanction of the Wakf Board as per the provisions at the Muslims Wakf Board's Act. This defendant has been recognised as Mutawali of the Dargha.

    7. The valuation of the suit for purposes of Court fee is not correct. The Dargha is not a Trust or a Wakf. Section 27(a) of the Court fee is not therefore applicable.

    8. It is also not true that the plaintiff is a pauper. He is the Khazi for about 300 to 400 village. He gets an ??? than Rs. 200/- per month by way of tees which would be realised by him by performing marriages. He owns a house at Faruknagar which is worth Rs. 4000/-. He also owns ??? movable ??? mentioned ??? counter. The list of properties filed ??? with the plaint is not correct.

    9. The petition is liable to be rejected as there is no ??? cause of action for the suit and the suit is barred by limitation.

    10. The learned District Judge dismissed the petition one the grounds, namely (1) the claim of the petitioner must be deemed be barred by limitation and (2) that the petitioner failed to ??? his entire property, therefore lacking in bonafides.

    11. Order 33 Rule 5 is as follows:—

    “Or. 33 R. 5: The Court shall reject an application for permission to sue as a pauper;

    (a) Where it is not framed and presented ??? prescribed by rules 2 and 3, or

    (b) Where the applicant is not a pauper, or

    (c) Where he has, within two months next before the presentation of the application, deposed of any property fraudulently or in order to be able to apply for permission to sue as a pauper, or

    (d) Where his allegations do not show a cause of action, or

    (d)(i) Where the suit appears to be barred by any law, or

    (e) Where he has entered into any agreement with reference to the subject-matter of the proposed suit under which any other person has obtained an interest in such subject-matter”.

    12. Order 33, Rule 2 is as follows:

    “Or. 33 R. 2: Every application to sue as a pauper shall contain the particulars required in regard to plaints in suits, a schedule of any movable or immovable property belonging to the applicant, with the estimated value thereof, shall be annexed thereto, and it shall be signed and verified in the manner prescribed for signing and verification of pleadings”.

    13. Order 33, Rule 1 is as follows:

    “O. 33 R. 1:—Subject to the following provisions, any suit may be instituted by a pauper.

    14. Explanation (1)—A person is a pauper.

    (a) When he is not possessed of sufficient means to enable him to pay the fee prescribed by law for the plaint in such suit, or

    (b) Where no fee is prescribed when he is not entitled to property worth one hundred rupees other than his wearing apparel and the subject matter of the suit.

    Explanation:— (ii) Any part of the subject-matter of the suit which the opposite party relinquishes and places at the immediate disposal of the plaintiff shall be taken into account in considering the question of the possession of sufficient means by the plaintiff.

    Explanation:— (iii) Where the plaintiff sues in a representative capacity the question of pauperism shall be determined with reference to the means possessed by him in such capacity.

    In determining whether he is possessed of sufficient means the subject-matter of the suit shall be excluded”.

    15. So far as it concerns us in the present case by a combined reading of the above provisions it appears that a suit may be instituted in forma pauperis by a person when be is not possessed of sufficient means to enable him to pay court fee prescribed by law for the plaint in such a suit and he attaches a schedule of movable or immovable properly belonging to him with the estamated value thereof to show that he is not possessed of sufficient means to pay the Court fees and where the suit does not appear to be barred by any law; but when the plaintiff sued in a representative capacity, the question of incapacity to pay Court fee shall be determined only with reference to the means possessed by him in such a capacity and in cases where the plaintiff fails to show in the schedule of properties to be attached to the petition the entire movable and immovable property the court shall reject the application for permission to sue as a pauper.

    16. As found by the lower Court the petitioner failed to show in the schedule of properties at least one item of property which admittedly belongs to him. If the suit was filed in his individual capacity the petition is liable to be rejected on this ground ??? but the petitioner filed the suit in his capacity as Mutawali which is a representative capacity. If that is so, Explanation (iii) to rule 1 referred to above would come into play. It is not the case of the respondent that the petitioner is in possession of any other property belonging to the Dargha from which it can be said that he is in possession of sufficient means as Mutawali to enable him to pay the Court fee payable on the plaint. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent has argued before us that in the suit the petitioner has also prayed for a declaration that he is the Mutawali of the Dargha and therefore it cannot be said that the suit was filed by the petitioner in his representative capacity as Mutawalii. We fail to see any substance in this argument. It is not as if the petitioner is now seeking to be appointed as Mutawali. According to him he is already a Mutawali and he is seeking the declaration only because the respondent was denying that he is the Mutawali. The suit was filed by the petitioner as Mutawali only, and therefore it is a suit filed in a representative capacity. Therefore under these circumstances it cannot be said that he failed to disclose in the schedule any property of which he was in possession as Mutawali. As a matter of fact in our opinion the petitioner need not have to file any schedule ??? his personal properties. If that is so the second ground on which the lower Court dismissed the petition fails. It is nobody's case that the petitioner, Mutawali, was in possession of any property belonging to Dargha.

    17. If any authority is needed for the proposition that if the plaintiff is suing in a representative capacity his personal properties should not be taken into account to find his capacity to pay the Court-fee, the following cases may be noted.

    18. In the decision Smt. Mabia Khatum v. Sheikh Satkari 1 it was held that when the plaintiff sues in a representative character, such as Mutawali, Trustee or a Shebait, unless it is shown that the plaintiff has in his possession property belonging to the Wakf, estate or trust or the idol for whom he sues, sufficient to enable him to pay the requisite court fee prescribed by law he may be allowed to sue as a pauper even if it is shown that he has sufficient personal property of his own. The capacity of a person suing in a representative character must be kept distinct from his personal capacity.

    19. In the decision on U.M Usman v. Mayor Simon 2 it was held that when a plaintiff sues in a representative capacity he is entitled to sue in forma pauperis if he is not in possession of properties or funds belonging to the real plaintiff, i.e the institution or group of persons on whose behalf he files the suit, sufficient to enable him to pay the necessary court fee and in such Cases the question of the means of the plaintiff suing is immaterial. The next question to be considered is whether the suit appears to be barred by limitation. In a case like this the question of limitation is always a mixed question of law and fact. On a mere perusal of the allegations made we do not think it is possible to come to a definite conclusion that the suit is barred by limitation. The lower court discussed some evidence relating to some previous litigation in which the petitioner appears to have unsuccessfully attempted to become a party to come to the conclusion that the suit is barred by time. We do not think at this stage it is proper to go into those facts elaborately and embark on a roving enquiry to find out whether the suit is barred by limitations or not when it does not appear primarily on the allegations made that the suit is barred by limitation.

    20. Under these circumstsnces we consider that the two grounds on which the Lower Court dismissed the petition are not sound, Accordingly the appeal and the petition are allowed and the appellant is allowed to sue as pauper. In the circumstances there is no order as to costs.

    21. K.R.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Syed Mohd. Ibrahim Ali (Petitioner) v. Syed Akram Ali ().
    (Oct 1, 1969)