Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    District Collector v. Appikonda Rajendrakumar

    (1) The appellants herein are the defendants 1 and 2 in o. S. No. 133/1989 on the file of the district munsif, salur. Respondents 1 to 3, who are the children of the fourth respondent, filed the suit for declaration that they belong to 'konda kapu' community, which is notified as a schedule tribe in andhra pradesh, and for a consequential relief of mandatory injunction directing the second defendant (mandal revenue officer, ramabhadrapuram) to issue a certificate to the plaintiffs to that effect. They impleaded their father as the third defendant in the suit. The trial court decreed the suit. The defendants 1 and 2 filed an appeal a. S. No. 7/1991 on the file of the subordinate judge, bobbili, which was dismissed. Therefore, the defendants 1 and 2 filed this second appeal.

    (2) The plaintiffs' case in brief is as follows: - the plaintiffs' father (third defendant) , who belonged to kottakki village, which is near salur and which is now part of vizianagaram district in andhra pradesh, belongs to kapu community, but he was adopted by one appikonda lakshmunaidu, resident of hat - seshikhal village of rayaghad taluk in koraput district of orissa state, in the year 1949. The said appikonda lakshmunaidu belongs to kondakapu community. Therefore, by virtue of adoption by appikonda lakshmunaidu, the third defendant i. E. , the father of the plaintiffs, became a kondakapu by caste. Consequently, the plaintiffs, who are the children of the third defendant also belong to kondakapu caste, which is a scheduled tribe in andhra pradesh, and so they are entitled to the benefits as members of scheduled tribe.

    (3) Defendants 1 and 2 while denying the allegations of the plaintiffs contended that by mere adoption, the third defendant cannot claim that he belongs to kondakapu community and so, the plaintiffs are not entitled to the benefits as members of scheduled tribe. They further contended that since lakshmunaidu, was a resident of rayaghad taluk in orissa state where kondakapu community is not declared as scheduled tribe the third defendant cannot claim the benefits of scheduled tribe and in fact, he did not claim that benefit; and that the plaintiffs and the third defendant, who had their education in andhra pradesh, are not entitled to the said benefits. It is also contended that the suit is not maintainable for want of notice under section 80 of code of civil procedure.

    (4) The trial court as well as the appellate court accepted the adoption of third defendant by appikonda lakshmunaidu of hat - seshikhal village of rayaghad taluk in orissa, who belongs to kondakapu community and therefore, the 3rd defendant became a member of kondakapu caste and so, his children get the benefits of kondakapu caste and decreed the suit.

    (5) Since bom the trial court as well as the appellate court gave a concurrent finding regarding the adoption of third defendant by appikonda lakshmu naidu in 1949, that finding cannot be reconsidered in the second appeal. But the learned government pleader appearing for the appellants contended that since this adoption is prior to the hindu adoptions and maintenance act came into force, it was not permissible for a hindu to adopt a person of a different caste and, therefore, the adoption is invalid. The learned counsel for the respondents contended that the restriction was only among the four communities i. E. , brahmin, kshatriya, vysya and sudra and since the third defendant as well as his adoptive father belong to sudra community, there is no such bar. He relied upon the following passage in mayne's hindu law, 13th edition, revised by justice alladi kuppu swamy: -

    "in the second place, the adopted son must be of the same caste as his adopting father, that is, as brahman may not adopt a kshatriya, or vice versa. The rule in the saunaka smriti which is next to vasishtha the chief authority on the matter, expressly prohibits an adoption outside the caste, for it says that adoption in all classes must be made in their own classes only and not otherwise. The mitakshara is conclusive on the matter. Commenting on the text of manu, it says that the dattak son must be a savarna or of the same class. The adoption of a person belonging to a different primary caste is, therefore, invalid. But an adoption of a person from a sub - caste of the same primary caste is valid. So also a member of one religious sect may adopt a son from another religious sect."

    Therefore, i am unable to agree with the contention of the learned government pleader that the adoption is not valid.

    (6) The next question to be considered is, whether by virtue of the adoption, the third defendant and his children will get the benefits of members of scheduled tribe.

    (7) The learned government pleader contended that, even if the appellant's father became a kondakapu by caste by virtue of adoption and even if his children become members of the same caste as per the personal law applicable to the parties, i. E. , hindu law, still for the purpose of reservations they cannot be treated as members of the scheduled tribe.

    (8) Article 341 of the constitution of india reads:

    "scheduled castes - (1) the president (may with respect to any state of union territory) and where it is a state, after consultation with the governor thereof,) by public notification, specify the castes, races or tribes or parts of or groups within castes, races or tribes which shall for the purposes of this constitution be deemed to be scheduled castes in relation to that state (or union territory, as the case may be)"
    .

    (9) Article 342 of the constitution of india reads:

    "scheduled tribes - (1) the president (may with respect to any state (or union territory) and where it is a state, after consultation with the governor thereof,) by public notification, specify the tribes or tribal communities or parts of or groups within tribes or tribal communities which shall for the purposes of this constitution be deemed to be scheduled tribes in relation to that state (or union territory, as the case may be)"
    .

    Therefore, his contention is that, the notification of the scheduled castes or scheduled tribes under articles 341 and 342 of the constitution of india is for the purposes of giving the benefits under the constitution and so a person can claim those benefits only by birth and not by adoption or any other mode.

    (10) article 15 (4) of the constitution of india provides that:

    "nothing in this article or in clause (2) of article 29 shall prevent the state from making any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the scheduled castes and the scheduled tribes."

    (11) Article 16 (4) of the constitution of india provides that:

    "nothing in this article shall prevent the state from making any provision for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of any backward class of citizens which in the opinion of state, is not adequately represented in the services under the state."

    (12) Article 46 of the constitution of india provides that:

    "promotion of educational and economic interests of scheduled castes, scheduled tribes and other weaker sections - the state shall promote with special case the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections of the people, and in particular, of the scheduled castes and the scheduled tribes, and shall protect them from social injustice and all forms of exploitation."

    The learned government pleader contended that the rights under the personal law are different from the benefits granted under the constitution and therefore a person cannot claim the constitutional rights, merely by means of adoption or by any other mode. In support of his contention, he relied upon the decision in a. S. Sailaja vs. Principal, kurnool medical college. The facts of the case are that one girl by name sailaja, who was born in a brahmin family, claimed that she was adopted by a person of 'golla' (shephard) caste, which is a backward class and therefore claimed a seat in the seats reserved for the backward classes in the medical colleges. Justice k. Ramaswamy, as he then was, observed in paragraph - 42 of the judgment as follows: -

    "in the light of the above consideration, the necessary conclusion is that an adoption under the act (hindu adoption and maintenance act) is personal the purpose of sec. 12 is that he or she becomes completely a member of the adoptive family 'for all purposes' - be it for religious or secular purpose/ but for the purpose of the constitution under articles 14,15 (4) and 16 (4) , the adopted child must satisfy not only that he or she belongs to the particular homogeneous group or class or tribe but also must become a member of the homogeneous group or class or tribe, also had suffered or subjected to all the disadvantages or handicaps which the members of the homogeneous group, class or tribe, are subjected to or have undergone or is undergoing. In that context, recognition of such a person by the caste or community elders to which the adoptee has already been assimilated or seeks an entry is a relevant factory which has to be established as a fact. The purpose of adoption under sec. 12 is personal to the adoptee and is distinct and apart from the constitutional scheme under articles 14,15, (4) and 16 (4). The registration under sec. 16 furnishes only a rebuttable presumptive evidence that the adoption was made in compliance with the provisions of the act. Therefore, the presumption advances thus far and no further and is of little avail to the benefits under articles 15 (4) and 16 (4) of the constitution."

    (13) The writ appeal filed against the judgment - a. S. Sailaja vs. Principal, kurnool medical college was allowed by a division bench holding that the director passed the impugned order without notice and without any enquiry, and that the claim of sailaja, that she belongs to yadava community was rejected without bearing her.

    (14) The learned government pleader relied upon another decision in p. Vijaya lakshmi vs. Principal, sri venkateswara university college of engineering, tirupatht, wherein the question involved was whether a child born to a father belonging to besta (fisherman) caste, a backward class, and a mother belonging to bariki caste, which is a scheduled caste, can claim the status of scheduled tribe for the purpose of admission in the engineering college. In that case, the petitioner relied upon a government order to the effect that in the case of children born of inter - caste marriages, if either spouse happens to belong to scheduled caste, scheduled tribe or backward class, the caste of the child shall be deemed to be the lower caste of either of the parents and shall be eligible for reservation in the seats made for the caste. The learned judge, k. Ramaswamy. J, as he then was, referred to his decision in a. S. Sailaja vs. Principal, kurnool medical college (1 supra) , and held that a person entitled to be considered as a scheduled caste, must belong to one of the castes, races or tribes or parts or groups within castes, races or tribes specified by notification issued by the president under article 341 (1) of the constitution. "for the purposes of constitution", such persons are classified as a class who are subject to disabilities due to pangs of untouchability. By adoption or by marriage or any other devices unknown to law, a person cannot become the member of the scheduled caste within the meaning of article 366 (24) , "for the purposes of the constitution. " court cannot give such a declaration. For personal law, it may be a different question. The learned judge further held that, no person outside the fold of scheduled caste can claim such a status except by process under article 341. If a person is bom to parents of inter - caste, the mother belonging to scheduled caste, the child does not automatically become a scheduled caste. It is to be determined in the light of his/her up - bringing in the midst of scheduled castes with all attendant disadvantages, ignomy; his/her course of conduct in adopting the caste customs; treatment of his /her by members of the caste into which he/ she seeks to enter into and recognising him/her as scheduled caste. The learned judge also held that, since the government order runs counter to the constitutional scheme, it is ultra vires of the executive power and of the constitution.

    (15) In manikyamala vs. The principal, andhra medical college and others, a division bench of this court had considered the claim of the appellant therein, for admission to the medical college, on the ground that she belongs to kondakapu caste, scheduled tribe community. That appeal was preferred against the dismissal of the writ petition by a learned single judge. The appellant therein was actually admitted to mbbs course by the principal of the andhra medical college on the basis of a certificate of social status, enclosed to her application. But, however, on enquiry the second respondent held that she belongs to kapu (telaga) caste and not kondakapu caste, and hence she was not eligible for admission to the mbbs course against the seat reserved for a member of the scheduled tribe. The division bench allowed the writ appeal mainly on the ground that there is delay in conducting the enquiry and as the appellanthad completed the mbbs course by the time of enquiry she should not suffer for the faults committed by the first and second respondents.

    (16) A division bench of this court recently had an occasion to consider a similar question in w. A. Nos. 1161 and 1313 of 1992 smt. D. Neelima vs. Dean of p. G. Studies, a. P. The question involved in those two writ appeals was whether a lady who was born in a forward caste, on marriage to a person belonging to scheduled caste or scheduled tribe, becomes a member of the caste or tribe of her husband and whether acquisition of caste or tribe of the husband by virtue of marriage would cloth the wife with the right to reservation envisaged by article 15 (4) of the constitution of india. The division bench held that on marriage, the wife acquires the caste or tribe of her husband. But the division bench considered the constitutional aspect of the matter i. E. , whether acquisition of the caste or tribe of the husband would entail the wife to the reservation envisaged under article 15 (4) of the constitution. The division bench rejected the contention that consequent upon their entering into the caste or tribe of their respective husbands the wives would be entitled to the reservations envisaged by article 15 (4) of the constitution though neither of the two claimants in those cases underwent the stresses or strains or suffered the environmental disadvantages, the real backward class citizens faced, and on the other hand, they belonged to forward castes in hindu society before their marriage that took place after they completed their graduation and thus were not socially and educationally backward. The division bench further pointed out that by the device of marriage just before the time of applying for admission into the post - graduation courses, if they were to be permitted to invoke the benefit and protection available to the classes of persons, who really suffer from environmental disadvantages and incidental stresses and strains, it amounts to letting the purpose of reservation to whittle down, besides permitting entry of citizens better, if not, equally, placed as those constituting creamy layer.

    (17) The test laid down in the decisions referred to above is that though under the personal law a person on adoption or by marriage becomes member of the family of the adoptive father or the husband, as the case may be, and takes that caste, still he or she will not be entitled for the benefits of reservation under the constitution unless he or she suffers the disadvantages incidental to the particular caste in the social strata.

    (18) The learned government pleader has pointed out that the third defendant who is the father of the plaintiffs though was adopted by a person of kondakapu caste of hat - seshikhal village in koraput district of orissa state, he had migrated to andhra pradesh and had stayed here, married a lady of gajula kapu community and is employed in the state bank of india and so he had never lived as part of kondakapu cornmunity nor had he undergone the disadvantages of kondakapu cornmunity and in fact he had never claimed reservation as scheduled tribe on the basis that he is a kondakapu. Likewise, his children i. E. , plaintiffs have studied in college at visakhapatnam and the evidence of 1st plaintiff is that in the school records his caste in noted as 'kapu'. There is no evidence to show that they had suffered any social disadvantages as members of kondakapu community.

    (19) In the decision reported in miss y. Padma mythili vs. A. P. University of health sciences, a learned single judge of this court, ramanujul u naidu j. , held that kondakapus are sub - division of kapus, and the fact thai today most of the kondakapus are highly educated and well placed, does not debar mem from claiming such status and for their children, the incidental concessions and benefits conferred upon them for pursuing higher education and for seeking better employment.

    (20) The learned counsel for the respondents (plaintiffs) has, therefore, argued that it is nut necessary that a person should live in the very same backward conditions in order to claim the benefits of reservations. But, here is a case where the plaintiffs are claiming the benefits of scheduled tribe by virtue of the adoption of their father. No doubt, in the year 1949 when the third defendant was adopted, there might not have been any motive for the adoption i. E. , for claiming the benefits as members of scheduled tribe because the presidential order was issued after the constitution came into force in 1950. But, the evidence shows that neither the third defendant nor his children i. E. ;, plaintiffs have suffered any social disadvantage as members of kondakapu community. Therefore, i agree with the contention of the learned government pleader that though the third defendant was taken in adoption by a person belonging to kondakapu community, neither the third defendant nor his children i. E. , plaintiffs would be entitled to the benefits under the constitution as members of scheduled tribe.

    (21) The learned counsel for the plaintiffs/respondents contended that even prior to the presidential order was issued after the constitution came into force kondakapus were being treated as members of hill tribe and he had brought to my notice certain notifications issued by the madras public service commission in which kapus or visakhapatnam and godavari districts were shown in the list of hill and aboriginal tribes. The note appended to the notification reads that the list includes the tribes notified under the criminal tribes act. Though this is a second appeal and additional evidence is not permissible to be adduced in a second appeal and in fact, no such application for receiving the gazette notifications as additional evidence is filed, yet as the matter involves some importance regarding kondakapu community and they are the xerox copies of the said notification, i have gone through the same. The note that is appended to the list reads that the list includes tribes notified under criminal tribes act and as the criminal tribes act is no longer in force, no reliance can be placed upon such list. Now, the classification of persons either as scheduled castes or scheduled tribes is only done by virtue of the notifications issued under articles 341 and 342 of the constitution. Merely because kondakapu community was recognised as hill tribe prior to the constitution, that cannot be taken into account while considering the social status of the plaintiffs in claiming reservations as members of kondakapu community under article 342 of the constitution.

    (22) There is a factual error in the judgment of the lower court because the lower court proceeded on the assumption that the orissa state was formed on 1 - 11 - 1956 at the time of the reorganisation of states. That is not correct. It was formed on 1 - 4 - 1936 i. E. , long before the constitution came into force. Therefore, i am unable to agree with the contention of the learned counsel for the respondents that since koraput district was also part of visakhapatnam district till 1956 and as kapus of visakhapatnam district were enjoying the privileges as members of the hill tribe before the constitution came into force and so they continued to enjoy the same privileges even after the notification was issued under article 342 of the constitution.

    (23) Yet another contention taken by the learned government pleader is that people belonging to kondakapu community are declared as scheduled tribes in andhra pradesh but not in the state of orissa according to the presidential notification. Therefore, even if the third defendant belongs to kondakapu community by virtue of adoption by lakshmunaidu of hat - seshikhal village of koraput district in orissa state, he cannot be considered to be a member of the scheduled tribe, because in orissa state, kondakapu community is not treated as scheduled tribe. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs/ respondents contends that a citizen of india is entitled to migrate to any place in india and merely because me third defendant or his children have migrated from orissa to andhra pradesh, they do not cease to belong to kondakapu community and lose the privileges as members of that community. No doubt, a citizen of india is entitled to migrate to any part of the state and he continues to belong to the same religion or community to which he belongs notwithstanding the migration to another state, but here, we are concerned with the question whether a person belonging to kondakapu community is orissa state can be treated as member of a scheduled tribe. Article 342 of the constitution refers to the notification of the tribes as scheduled tribes 'in relation to that state or union territory'. The list of scheduled tribes is not uniform throughout the country but certain castes are declared as scheduled tribes in certain states. If the object of classifying the members of particular community as scheduled tribe anywhere in india, then there is no purpose in declaring that persons who belong to some castes in a particular state belong to scheduled tribe under the presidential notification; it can as well be said that kondakapus or any other caste will come under scheduled tribes anywhere in india. But that is not so according to the presidential order and the kondakapus in orissa state do not belong to scheduled tribe. If a person belonging to kondakapu community in orissa state does not belong to a scheduled tribe, he cannot acquire the status of scheduled tribe by migration to another state i. E. , andhra pradesh, where kondakapu community is declared as scheduled tribe.

    (24) My attention has been drawn to two decisions - one of the orissa high court and the another of the gujarat high court having a bearing on this question. In the decision reported in k. Apparao vs. Director p and t, it is pointed out that the phrase 'in relation to that state' occurring after the words 'scheduled castes' in article 341 (1) and the phrase 'in relation to that state' occurring after the words 'scheduled tribes' in article 342 (1) are not without significance. This shows that in order to get the benefit of being a member of the scheduled caste or scheduled tribe in the matter of public employment, the person claiming it should be a member of such caste or tribe in relation to a particular area or state where he is residing and where he seeks employment. It is further stated as follows:

    "it is therefore clear that the particular scheduled tribes specified in the various parts of the schedule to that order are recognised as of the scheduled to that order are recognised as the scheduled to that order are recognised as scheduled tribes only for the particular area included in those parts of the schedule and not anywhere else. So, any reference to scheduled tribes of scheduled castes must be intended to be scheduled castes or scheduled tribes in relation to the particular area or state as appearing in the schedule to that order."

    In that case, the petitioner, who is a resident of orissa, belongs to kondakapu community which is not a scheduled tribe in orissa state. He claimed that he belongs to scheduled tribe on the ground that that caste is mentioned in the list of scheduled tribes in andhra pradesh. It was held that the petitioner cannot, while residing in orissa stafe, cannot claim the benefit of being a member of a scheduled tribe in another state for the purpose of public employment.

    (25) In the decision reported in manjn singh vs. Dean, b. J. Medical college, the petitioner belonged to jatav caste, which is recognised as scheduled caste in uttar pradesh. Her father, who is a central government employee, was transferred to rajkot in gujarat. The petitioner applied for a seat in m. B. B. S. Course in gujarat claiming to belong to a scheduled caste in uttar pradesh. Since she was not given seat, she filed the writ petition. The contention of the respondents that the petitioner would be considered to belong to scheduled caste community in relation to state of uttar pradesh, and she could not be considered to be belonging to scheduled caste in so far as the state of gujarat is concerned. After referring to article 341 (1) , it was held thus -

    "therefore, particular caste may be specified to be scheduled caste only in relation to a particular area in a state but once a person belongs to such scheduled caste in that area, he would be a scheduled caste member not only for that ayea of the state but also for the entire state and other states of india. The phrase 'in relation to that state' in art. 341 (1) is used only to identify the castes, races or tribes or part of or groups within the castes, races of tribes of a particular state which are to be deemed to be or treated as scheduled castes for the purpose of the constitution. A caste which is socially and educationally backward in relation to a state or an area in the state, would not cease to be so outside the state or area of the state. If a scheduled caste specified under art. 341 is to be deemed to be a scheduled caste only within the state or area of the state in relation to which it is so specified, the very object of giving protection to such caste will be defeated. If the phrase 'in relation to' is to be understood in the narrow sense in which respondents want us to understand, it would mean that if a caste in a particular area of state is notified as scheduled caste under art. 341 (1) such caste would be scheduled caste only within that area of the state. As already pointed out above, scheduled caste is for the purpose of the constitution and not for a state or a particular area of state."

    (26) Therefore, the above decision lays down that if a person belongs to a scheduled caste tribes in a state even if he or she goes to another state, he or she does not cease to be a member of a scheduled caste or tribe. But, in the present case, though the third defendant was adopted by lakshmunaidu, belonging to kondakapu caste in orissa state, and became a member of that community he did not get benefit of scheduled tribe because kondakapu community is not notified as scheduled tribe in orissa. When the third defendant does not belong to scheduled tribe in orissa, by migration to andhra pradesh, he cannot claim the status of a person belonging to scheduled tribe and so the plaintiffs also cannot get the benefits of scheduled tribe.

    (27) I, therefore, agree with the contention of the learned government pleader that the plaintiffs cannot claim the benefits of scheduled tribe in andhra pradesh on both the grounds i. E. , that they have not suffered any social disadvantages as being members of a scheduled tribe and also on the ground that as kondakapu community is not a scheduled tribe in orissa they cannot claim the benefits of scheduled tribe in andhra pradesh.

    (28) Another contention taken by the learned government pleader is that notice under section 80 c. P. C was not given and so the suit is not maintainable. But, it is pointed out by the learned counsel for the respondents that the court granted permission under section 80 (2) c. P. C. Therefore, this contention of the government pleader is not sustainable.

    (29) In the result, the second appeal is allowed and the judgment and decree of the courts below are set aside and the suit filed by the plaintiffs is dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    District Collector v. Appikonda Rajendrakumar
    (Apr 9, 1993)