Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a proprietary concern, was the highest bidder at a public auction conducted by the A.P. State Financial Corporation (the Corporation) under Section 29 of the State Financial Corporations Act, 1951. The auctioned assets — machinery, furniture, fixtures and stores of Koratla Textiles Private Limited (the loanee, a 100% Export Oriented Unit) — were transferred in the petitioner's name. The loanee had earlier availed of customs duty exemption for importing the machinery but failed to pay customs duty amounting to Rs. 52.34 lakhs and was potentially liable to penal action under Section 112 of the Customs Act. The loanee had executed a bond on 10-1-1994 for a five-year period which expired on 31-3-1998. Customs authorities prevented the petitioner from transporting the machinery on the ground that they had a charge over it. The petitioner sought a declaration that a purchaser in a sale under Section 29 is not liable for the loanee's dues to Customs and for a direction restraining respondents 3 and 4 from interfering with removal of the machinery.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in terms of Section 29(2) of the State Financial Corporations Act, properties transferred by the Financial Corporation in an auction sale would be subject to any charge under the Customs Act, 1962 (i.e., whether Customs can claim a continuing charge or lien on such transferred goods and thereby restrain the purchaser from removing the goods).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (appearing by Sri P. Sri Raghuram)

  • Section 29(2) of the State Financial Corporations Act means that no charge is created on the machinery in terms of the Customs Act when the Corporation transfers property under that provision.
  • Reliance on a Division Bench decision of the Court in Sitani Textiles and Fabrics (P) Limited v. Assistant Collector of Customs and Central Excise, 1998 (5) ALD 637.
  • The Customs authorities can enforce the bond only under Section 63 of the Customs Act so long as any lien subsists; reference was made to Sections 60 and the proviso to Section 61 of the Customs Act.
  • Since the liability of the loanee to Customs is not disputed and that liability was accepted by the Financial Corporation, there was no reason for respondents 3 and 4 to prevent the petitioner from lifting the machinery.

State Financial Corporation's Arguments (appearing by Sri Y.N. Lohita)

  • The Corporation supported the petitioner's contention and submitted that the Corporation does not have any liability because the bond had expired on 31-3-1998.

Respondents 3 and 4 (Customs Authorities) Arguments (appearing by Mr. L. Narasimha Reddy)

  • Because the loanee was a 100% Export Oriented Unit, the petitioner (as transferee) is liable to pay the dues to the Customs Department.
  • The goods are of a special nature under the EOU scheme; since the loanee had executed a bond for exemption from duty and the goods were confined to a warehouse, the goods would be deemed to be in the possession of the Customs authorities only.
  • Transfer of the properties under Section 29 does not wipe off the liability to pay customs duty nor extinguish the rights of the Customs Department; hence the Customs can continue to exercise a lien and prevent removal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sitani Textiles and Fabrics (P) Limited v. Assistant Collector of Customs and Central Excise, 1998 (5) ALD 637 Support for the proposition that the State Financial Corporations Act (a special enactment), particularly via Section 46-B, prevails over a general enactment like the Central Excise/Customs Acts; and that a transfer under Section 29(2) vests in the transferee all rights as if transfer made by the owner. The Court treated Sitani Textiles as a binding precedent to conclude that the State Financial Corporations Act prevails and that transfer under Section 29(2) vests full rights in the transferee, undermining the contention that Customs retains a charge sufficient to restrain lifting of the goods.
Isha Marbles v. Bihar State Electricity Board, JT 1995 (2) SC 626 Statement concerning the limits of enforcement against dishonest actors and a caution that inadequacy of law should not justify over-zealous actions ("No doubt, dishonest consumers cannot be allowed to play tyrant with the public property but inadequacy of the law can hardly be a substitute for overzealousness."). The Court invoked this observation to reject the submission that the loanee in collusion with the Corporation could defraud the Customs Department by effecting sale; the Court held that such a fear did not justify restraining transfer and lifting of the property in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner by first examining the relevant provisions of the Customs Act (Sections 59–63) and the provisions of the State Financial Corporations Act (notably Section 29 and Section 46-B).

  1. Analysis of the Customs Act: The Court set out Sections 59–63 (including subsections and provisos) and observed that the Customs Act "does not contain any provision that the exported machineries remain charged for the payment of the duties." The Court noted provisions regarding bonds for warehousing, the continuity of such bonds notwithstanding transfer (Section 59(3)), control over warehoused goods (Section 62), and related procedural provisions.
  2. Interpretation of Section 29 of the State Financial Corporations Act: The Court emphasized that Section 29(2) provides that any transfer made by the Financial Corporation "shall vest in the transferee all rights in or to the property transferred as if the transfer had been made by the owner of the property." The Court described the concept of ownership under Section 29 as limited to securing and realising loans, and that when action is taken under Section 29, ownership stands transferred free from all encumbrances. The Court also observed that Section 29 confers rights and prescribes procedures for enforcement.
  3. Effect of the non-obstante clause (Section 46-B): The Court relied on Section 46-B, which makes the provisions of the State Financial Corporations Act prevail "notwithstanding anything inconsistent ... in any other law." The Court characterized this non-obstante clause as having "wide amplitude."
  4. Application of precedents and rejection of Customs' contentions: The Court treated Sitani Textiles as a binding precedent establishing the primacy of the State Financial Corporations Act in this context. The Court also rejected the contention that the transfer would be a device to defraud Customs, invoking the Isha Marbles observation to say that fear of collusion did not justify denying the purchaser the right to lift the goods.
  5. Specific factual considerations: The Court noted that the sale had been widely advertised and that the sale confirmation letter from the Corporation contained a condition (Condition No. 7) indicating that the purchaser need not take responsibility for Central Excise dues because the Corporation would sort out the issue depending on a pending writ by the Central Excise Department. The Court mentioned that this condition was modified by a subsequent letter dated 22-3-2001.
  6. Narrow scope of determination: The Court explicitly declined to decide the question of liability between the loanee and the State Financial Corporation, stating that the issue did not arise for decision in the present case. Instead, the Court required the Corporation to give a written undertaking to pay any amount determined against the loanee in adjudication proceedings out of the sale proceeds.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The Court held that respondents 3 and 4 cannot restrain the petitioner from lifting the property sold by the State Financial Corporation under Section 29.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The petitioner (purchaser at the Section 29 sale) may lift the machinery; respondents 3 and 4 (Customs authorities) were not permitted to continue preventing removal on the basis of a claimed charge.
  • The Court directed that the State Financial Corporation shall give an undertaking in writing that if, in any adjudication proceedings, any amount is determined against the loanee, the Corporation will pay such amount out of the sale proceeds.
  • The Court expressly did not decide the question of liability between the loanee and the Corporation; that issue remains undetermined in this opinion.
  • No order as to costs was made.

The opinion applied existing precedents and statutory interpretation; it did not purport to establish a new legal principle beyond the application of the cited authorities and statutory provisions.

    Vijayalakshmi Enterprises v. Assistant General Manager, Andhra Pradesh Financial Corporation, Hyderabad And Others

    S.B Sinha, C.J:— In this writ petition, the petitioner herein which is a proprietary concern had sought for a declaration that a purchaser of goods in a sale under Section 29 of the State Financial Corporation Act, is not liable for the dues of the loanee payable to the Customs and Excise Authorities and for a direction upon the respondents 3 and 4 herein not to interfere with the removal of the machinery from the premises of the loanee and transport the same to the destination.

    2. The establishment of Koratla Textiles Private Limited, Lingojigud village, Choutuppal Mandal, Nalgonda District was a loanee of the A.P State Financial Corporation (hereinafter referred to as ‘the loanee’) machinery, furniture, fixtures and stores of the said company was put in public auction in terms of the provisions of Section 29 of the State Financial Corporations Act, 1951 (for short ‘the Act’). The petitioner being the highest bidder, the said machinery etc., were transferred in its name.

    3. The loanee is a 100% Export Oriented Unit having availed of certain benefits of exemption from paying the customs duty for importing the machinery. It failed to discharge an obligation to pay customs duty to the tune of Rs. 52-34 lakhs. The said failure to make payment, according to the customs authorities, would also attract penal action under Section 112 of the Customs Act for payment of penalty.

    4. It is not in dispute that the said loanee executed a bond on 10-1-1994 for a period of five years which period had already expired (31-3-1998). It is also not in dispute that the customs authorities had been preventing the petitioner herein from transporting the said machinery on the ground that it has a charge there over.

    5. The question which arises for consideration is as to whether in terms of Section 29(2) of the Act, the properties which were purchased in an auction sale under Section 29 of the Act would be subject to any charge under Customs Act, 1962.

    6. Sri P. Sri Raghuram, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted that having regard to the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 29 of the Act, no charge is created on the machinery in terms of the provisions of the Customs Act. In support of the said contention, reliance has been placed on a Division Bench decision of this Court in Sitani Textiles and Fabrics (P) Limited v. Assistant Collector of Customs and Central Excise, 1998 (5) ALD 637. The learned Counsel would contend that the customs authorities can enforce the bond only in terms of the provisions of Section 63 of the Customs Act so long as the lien subsists. Our attention in this connection has been drawn to the provisions of Section 60 of the Customs Act as also the proviso appended to Section 61 thereof. It was pointed out that the liability of the loanee to the customs authorities is not disputed and the said liability having been accepted by the Financial Corporation, there is absolutely no reason why the respondents 3 and 4 would prevent the petitioner from lifting the machinery.

    7. Sri Y.N Lohita, learned Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the State Financial Corporation supported the said contention and submitted that Corporation does not have any liability as the bond had expired on 31-3-1998.

    8. Mr. L. Narasimha Reddy, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents 3 and 4, however, would submit that having regard to the fact that the loanee had availed of the benefit under 100% EOU, the petitioner is liable to pay the dues to the Customs Department. The status of the goods being of special nature in terms of the said scheme and further having regard to the fact that the loanee had executed a bond for exemption from paying the duty and the goods having been confined to a warehouse the same would be deemed to be in possession of the customs authorities, only. It was contended that by transfer of the properties, in terms of Section 29 of the Act, the liability to pay the customs duty is not wiped off nor the right of the Customs Department is extinguished.

    9. Before adverting to the rival contentions of the parties, as noticed hereinbefore, the relevant provisions of the Customs Act may be noticed.

    10. Sections 59, 60, 61, 62, and 63 of Customs Act reads as under:

    59. Warehousing bond:—(1) The importer of any goods specified in clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 61, which have been entered for warehousing and assessed to duty under Section 17 or Section 18 shall execute a bond binding himself in a sum equal to twice the amount of the duty assessed on such goods—

    (a) to observe all the provisions of this Act and the rules and regulations in respect of such goods;

    (b) to pay on or before a date specified in a notice of demand,—

    (i) all duties, and interest, if any, payable under sub-section (2) of Section 61;

    (ii) rent and charges claimable on account of such goods under this Act, together with interest on the same from the date so specified at the rate of six per cent, per annum or such other rate as is for the time being fixed by the Board; and

    (c) to discharge all penalties incurred for violation of the provisions of this Act, and

    (2) For the purposes of sub-section (1), the Assistant Collector of Customs may permit an importer to enter into a general bond in such amount as the Assistant Collector of Customs may approve in respect of the warehousing of goods to be imported by him within a specified period.

    (3) A bond executed under this section by an importer in respect of any goods shall continue in force notwithstanding the transfer of the goods to any other person or the removal of the goods to another warehouse:

    Provided that where the whole of the goods or any part thereof are transferred to another person, the proper officer may accept a fresh bond from the transferee in a sum equal to twice the amount of duty assessed on the goods transferred and thereupon the bond executed by the transferor shall be enforceable only for a sum mentioned therein less the amount for which a fresh bond is accepted from the transferee.

    60. Permission for deposit of goods in a warehouse:—When the provisions of Section 59 have been complied within respect of any goods, the proper officer may make an order permitting the deposit of the goods in a warehouse.

    61. Period for which goods may remain warehouse—(1) Any warehoused goods may be left in the warehouse in which they are deposited or in any warehouse to which they may be removed—

    Provided that—

    (i) in the case of any goods which are likely to deteriorate, the aforesaid period of one year and thirty days, as the case may be, may be reduced by the Collector of Customs to such shorter period as the case may deem fit;

    (ii) in the case of any goods which are not likely to deteriorate, the aforesaid period of one year may, on sufficient cause being shown, be extended by the Collector of Customs for a period not exceeding six months and by the Board for such further period as it may deem fit;

    Provided further that when the licence for any private warehouse is cancelled, the owner of any goods warehoused therein shall, within seven days from the date on which notice of such cancellation is given or within such extended period as the proper officer may allow, remove the goods from such warehouse to another warehouse or clear them for home consumption or exportation.

    62. Control over warehoused goods:—(1) All warehoused goods shall be subject to the control of the proper officer.

    (2) No person shall enter a warehouse or remove any goods therefrom without the permission of the proper officer.

    (3) The proper officer may cause any warehouse to be locked with the lock of the Customs Department and no person shall remove or break such lock.

    (4) The proper officer may cause any warehouse to be locked with the lock of the Customs Department and no person shall remove or break such lock.

    11. Customs Act, therefore, does not contain any provision that the exported machineries remain charged for the payment of the duties.

    12. Section 29 of the State Financial Corporation Act reads thus:

    Rights of Financial Corporation in case of default:—(1) Where any industrial concern, which is under a liability to the Financial Corporation under an agreement, makes any default in repayment of any loan or advance or any instalment thereof or in meeting its obligation, in relation to any guarantee by the Corporation or otherwise fails to comply with the terms of its agreement with the Financial Corporation, the Financial Corporation shall have the right to take over the management or possession or both of the industrial concern as well as the right to transfer by way of lease or sale and realise the property pledged, mortgaged, hypothecated or assigned to the Financial Corporation.

    (2) Any transfer of property made by the Financial Corporation in exercise of its powers under sub-section (1) shall vest in the transferee all rights in or to the property transferred as if the transfer had been made by the owner of the property.

    (3) The Financial Corporation shall have the same rights and powers with respect to goods manufactured or produced wholly or partly from goods forming part of this security held by as it had with respect to the original goods.

    (4) Where any action has been taken against an industrial concern under provisions of sub-section (1), all costs, charges and expenses which in the opinion of the Financial Corporation have been properly incurred by it as incidental thereto shall be recoverable from the industrial concern and the money which is received by it shall in the absence of any contract to the contrary, be held by it in trust to be applied firstly, in payment of such costs, charges and expenses and, secondly, in discharge of the debt due to the Financial Corporation, and, the residue of the money to received shall be paid to the person entitled thereto.

    (5) Where the Financial Corporation has taken any action against an industrial concern under the provisions of sub-section (1), the Financial Corporation shall be deemed to be the owner of such concern, for the purposes of suits, by or against the concern, and shall sue and be sued in the name of the concern.

    13. Section 46-B of the Act which provides for a non-obstante clause read as follows:

    46-B: Effect of Act on other laws:—The provisions of this Act and of any rules or orders made thereunder shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any other law for the time being in force or in the memorandum or articles of association of an industrial concern or in any other instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act, but save as aforesaid, the provisions of this Act shall be in addition to, and not in derogation of any other law for the time being applicable to an industrial concern.

    14. The concept of ownership of debtor in terms of Section 29 of the Act is limited to the extent of securing and realising loan advanced by the Corporation. When an action is taken in terms of Section 29, the ownership stands transferred free from all encumbrances. It not only confers rights but also provides for a procedure as also enforcement thereof. In the instant case, the notification of sale had been widely published. At this stage, we may notice condition No. 7 mentioned in the sale confirmation letter dated 21-3-2001 addressed by the A.P State Financial Corporation to the petitioner which reads thus:

    15. However, the purchaser need not take responsibility for settlement of dues of Central Excise Department as the Corporation will sort out the issue with the said department depending upon the decision of the High Court in the writ petition filed by the Central Excise Department which is still pending.

    16. The said conditions were modified by letter dated 22-3-2001.

    17. The submission of Mr. Narasimha Reddy to the effect that the defaulting party in collusion with the State Financial Corporation may get the property sold with a view to defraud Customs Department cannot be accepted.

    18. In Isha Marbles v. Bihar State Electricity Board, JT 1995 (2) SC 626, it was observed:

    “No doubt, dishonest consumers cannot be allowed to play tyrant with the public property but inadequacy of the law can hardly be a substitute for overzealousness.”

    19. Whenever a loan is raised by a loanee, the properties are mortgaged. Once the mortgaged properties are taken over, the Corporation will become the absolute owner of the property and thereafter it can sell the same in any manner to any person. The provisions laid down in the Customs Act, as referred to hereinbefore, do not in any manner show that a statutory charge is created over the properties and as such we are of the opinion that the submission of Sri Narasimhareddy to the effect that the customs authorities can still exercise the right of lien is without any substance. Furthermore, the non-obstante clause contained in Section 46-B of the Act is of wide amplitude. In Sitani Textiles case (supra) this Court observed:

    20. In the present case, the State Financial Corporations Act, 1951 is a special enactment whereas the Central Excise and Salt Act is a general enactment. However, in view of Section 46-B, the State Financial Corporation Act prevails over the enactments.

    21. In view of the afore mentioned binding precedents, we are of the opinion that the respondents 3 and 4 cannot restrain the petitioner from lifting the property.

    22. We, however, do not want to go into the question as regards the liability of the loanee vis-a-vis the State Financial Corporation, as the said question does not arise for consideration in this case. However, having regard to the commitment made by the State Financial Corporation in the sale confirmation letter, it is directed that it shall give an undertaking in writing that in the event in any adjudication proceeding any amount is determined against the loanee, it shall, out of the sale proceeds, pay the same.

    23. The writ petition is accordingly allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vijayalakshmi Enterp... v. Assistant General Ma...
    (Apr 25, 2001)