AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • 'Places of Worship (Special Provision) Act, 1991'
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • 'Places of Worship (Special Provision) Act, 1991'
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was instituted by Shri Mohd. Aslam alias Bhure, who approached the Supreme Court of India seeking urgent intervention for the preservation and protection of four places of worship: (1) Gyanvapi Masjid and Vishwanath Temple at Varanasi, and (2) Krishna Temple and Idgah at Mathura. The petition set out six specific prayers, ranging from heightened security measures to governmental takeover of these sites and action against certain political and religious organisations alleged to be threatening their status. The Court heard the petitioner’s senior counsel, the Attorney General for the Union of India, and senior counsel for the State of Uttar Pradesh. District Magistrates of Mathura and Varanasi as well as the State Home Secretary were present during the hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court should issue mandamus directing the Union and State Governments to safeguard the named religious sites (Prayer (i)).
  2. Whether specific security, crowd-control, and law-enforcement directions were warranted (Prayers (ii) and (iii)).
  3. Whether the Court could compel the Governments to prosecute violations of the Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991 (Prayer (v)).
  4. Whether the judiciary could order the Central Government to take over management of the sites or restrain specified organisations for alleged political motives (Prayers (iv) and (vi)).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Imminent threat exists to the integrity and continued existence of the four religious sites.
  • The State is constitutionally obliged to prevent damage or conversion of places of worship under the Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991.
  • Judicial intervention is necessary to ensure executive compliance and to prevent large gatherings that could endanger the sites.

Union of India’s Arguments (via Attorney General)

  • Since the events of 6 December 1992, the Central and State Governments remain “keenly alive” to the need for heightened security at sensitive religious places.
  • Comprehensive security measures have already been devised and are operational; public disclosure of specifics would be counter-productive to security interests.

State of Uttar Pradesh’s Arguments

  • Confirmed, on instructions from the District Magistrates and Home Secretary, that safeguarding these sites is a matter of “deep, anxious and committed concern.”
  • Asserted that all necessary precautions and safety measures are already in place.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed each prayer individually:

  • Prayers (iv) & (vi): Ordering governmental takeover of the sites and imposing restraints on political/religious organisations were deemed non-justiciable on the present pleadings. The issues required executive evaluation and lacked “judicially manageable standards.” Accordingly, no notice was issued on these prayers.
  • Prayer (v): Enforcement of the Places of Worship Act, 1991 is already a statutory obligation of the State. Issuing directions on a hypothetical future violation would be redundant; the Court declined further orders.
  • Prayers (ii) & (iii): Both Union and State counsel affirmed that robust security and crowd-control measures were already operational. Accepting these submissions, the Court found no necessity for additional directions.
  • Prayer (i): The Court accepted that safeguarding the specified religious sites falls squarely within the State’s duty and, while noting existing measures, formally directed both Governments to “take all necessary steps” to protect the sites.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF: The writ petition was disposed of with a direction to the Union and State Governments “to take all necessary steps for safeguarding the religious places” identified in Prayer (i). The accompanying impleadment applications were dismissed.

Implications: The order reinforces the executive’s primary responsibility to protect sensitive religious sites while signalling judicial reluctance to enter domains lacking clear legal standards or adequate factual foundations. No new legal precedent was set, but the directive underscores the continuing obligation of governments to ensure security and uphold the Places of Worship Act, 1991.

    Mohd. Aslam Alias Bhure v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    1. Shri Mohd. Aslam alias Bhure seeks the intervention of the Court in what is urged as a serious and urgent matter of public concern with regard to the preservation of certain places of worship in the country.

    2. The prayers sought in this petition are:

    “(i) directing the respondents to take steps for safeguarding of religious places i.e Gyanvapi Masjid and Vishwanath temple at Varanasi and Krishna temple and Idgah at Mathura;
    (ii) to take steps to provide appropriate security of these places for restraining any person from causing any mischief to these places;
    (iii) to regulate the entry of devotees to these places so that mob of large number of persons should not assemble near these places for causing any damage;
    (iv) to take over/manage the Gyanvapi Masjid and Vishwanath temple and Krishna temple and Idgah at Mathura in public interest by Central Government;
    (v) to register cases as per provisions of ‘Places of Worship (Special Provision) Act, 1991’ against any person who violates the Act by causing damage or converting these places from their existing religion to religion of other denomination;
    (vi) direct the Central Government to take steps against BJP, VHP, Bajrang Dal, RSS by restraining them from converting Idgah at Mathura and Gyanvapi Masjid at Varanasi to Hindu temple for their political benefits and in violation of the ‘Places of Worship (Special Provision) Act, 1991’.

    3. The prayers at (iv) and (vi), in our opinion, are not matters which can be dealt with by the Court on the state of the present pleadings. These prayers are not susceptible of an adjudication on the material placed before the Court. The matter is eminently one for appropriate evaluation and action by the Executive, and may not have an adjudicative disposition or judicially manageable standards as the pleadings now stand. We find no justification to issue notice to the respondents on these prayers at (iv) and (vi).

    4. So far as prayer (v) is concerned, it is the statutory obligation of the State to enforce the provisions of the Act. It does not need reiteration that that duty is a fortiori in matters of such serious public concern. In view of the plain obligations of the State to enforce the law, any direction on the hypothetical possibility of violation, amounts to no more than recanting the provisions of the statute itself.

    5. What remain to be considered are the prayers at (i), (ii) and (iii). We have heard Shri O.P Sharma, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner; Shri Milon K. Banerjee, learned Attorney General for the Union of India and Shri A.K Ganguly, learned Senior Counsel for the State of Uttar Pradesh and its officers.

    6. The District Magistrates of Mathura and Varanasi and the Home Secretary to the State Government of Uttar Pradesh are present in Court. Learned Attorney General submitted that after the events of December 6, 1992, both the Central and the State Governments are keenly alive to the need for an appropriate heightened security environment respecting places of worship referred to, and that the Governments are straining every nerve and resource to ensure such safety. Learned Attorney General submitted that adequate security measures for safeguarding these places of worship have been evolved and are in operation. He also submitted that it would not be appropriate in public interest to make a public disclosure of the details of the security preparations.

    7. Shri A.K Ganguly, upon instructions from the District Magistrates and the Home Secretary, submits that the prayers sought for by the petitioner are, indeed, the subject-matter of deep, anxious and committed concern of the Government and all precautions and safety measures have been evolved and are in operation in respect of these places of worship.

    8. In view of these submissions, no specific directions on the prayers at (ii) and (iii) are necessary as the Governments — States and Union — say that they are keenly alive to the problem and have taken adequate steps and that these measures are already in operation.

    9. We accordingly dispose of this writ petition by directing the State and Union Governments to take all necessary steps for safeguarding the religious places as prayed for in prayer (i).

    10. The impleadment applications are dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohd. Aslam Alias Bhure v. Union Of India And Others
    (Sep 24, 1993)