Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2014 INSC 329
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2014 INSC 329
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The prosecution alleged that on 21-10-1995 the appellants (A-1 and A-2) and two others forcibly took a young girl to a secluded agricultural field where she was raped. During the same transaction A-1 strangulated the victim, and the group disposed of her body in the field. The body was discovered the following day by the victim’s brother. The post-mortem confirmed homicidal death by strangulation and injuries consistent with sexual assault.

The initial investigation yielded no eyewitnesses or named suspects. Approximately 35 days later A-1 made an extra-judicial confession to PW-10, the Village Administrative Officer of Kadhili, which was recorded in writing and attested by PW-11. Pursuant to that confession certain recoveries, including the victim’s diary, were made. The next day A-2 confessed before PW-13, another Village Administrative Officer, in the presence of PW-14.

The trial court convicted both appellants under Sections 376(2)(g), 302 and 201 IPC, sentencing each to life imprisonment for murder, ten years’ rigorous imprisonment (RI) for gang rape, and three years’ RI for causing disappearance of evidence. On appeal, the High Court of Madras (Criminal Appeal No. 9 of 2005) acquitted A-2 of murder but otherwise affirmed the convictions. The present appeal by special leave challenges that High Court judgment before the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the death of the victim was homicidal and whether rape was committed upon her.
  2. Whether the appellants’ guilt could be established solely or primarily on the basis of their separate extra-judicial confessions, particularly when attesting witnesses had turned hostile in part.
  3. Consequent to the above, whether the convictions and sentences imposed by the High Court should be upheld or set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The High Court judgment was contrary to law, evidence and probabilities; it rested on surmises and conjectures.
  • Conviction could not legally rest on extra-judicial confessions because the witnesses present at the time of recording those confessions (PW-11 and PW-14) turned hostile.

State’s Arguments

  • The extra-judicial confessions were voluntary, true, and corroborated by independent evidence such as the post-mortem findings and recovery memos.
  • Even partial hostility of witnesses did not undermine the confessions, which were further supported by the scientific and circumstantial evidence.
  • A-1 strangulated the victim to silence her after the rape, while A-2’s role was confined to rape; hence the differential treatment by the High Court was justified.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reviewed the post-mortem report, which confirmed strangulation and signs of forcible sexual intercourse. This medical evidence matched the narrative contained in the appellants’ confessions, providing strong corroboration.

Addressing the hostile stance of PW-11 and PW-14, the Court observed that their partial hostility did not destroy the core fact that they witnessed the recording of the confessions and attested the documents. The Court found it significant that these witnesses did not deny their signatures or presence, thereby lending credibility to the Village Administrative Officers (PW-10 and PW-13) who deposed to the voluntary nature of the confessions.

The Court reiterated the settled principle that an extra-judicial confession, if voluntary and corroborated by independent evidence, can form the sole basis of conviction. It rejected the argument that such confessions are inherently weak evidence, emphasizing that their probative value is case-specific.

On factual analysis, the Court accepted the High Court’s differentiation between the two appellants: A-1 both raped and strangulated the victim, whereas A-2 participated in the rape but questioned A-1’s act of strangulation and did not share the intention to kill. Consequently, A-2’s acquittal on the murder charge was considered proper while his conviction for gang rape remained justified.

Overall, the Court found no infirmity in the concurrent findings of fact by the courts below. It concluded that the evidentiary chain—comprised of the confessions, medical evidence, recovery of incriminating articles, and corroborative testimony—proved the appellants’ guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The convictions and sentences affirmed by the High Court stand. The appellants’ bail bonds are cancelled, and they are to be taken into custody to serve the remaining portions of their sentences.

Implications: The decision reinforces that a voluntary and corroborated extra-judicial confession can sustain a conviction even when some attesting witnesses turn hostile, provided the remaining evidence establishes reliability. No new legal precedent is announced, but the ruling underscores the evidentiary weight such confessions may carry in similar criminal prosecutions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Baskaran And Another v. State Of Tamil Nadu .

    Gyan Sudha Misra, J.— This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 9-11-2006 Criminal Appeal No. 9 of 2005 passed by the High Court of Madras affirming the conviction and sentence of the first appellant under Sections 376(2)(g), 302 and 201 IPC awarding sentence of life imprisonment along with Rs 5000 fine, 10 years' RI, along with Rs 5000 fine and 3 years' RI, with a fine of Rs 2000, respectively. The trial court had awarded identical sentences to Appellant 2, who on appeal in the High Court, was acquitted of the offence of murder under Section 302 IPC but his conviction and sentence under Section 376 IPC was maintained.

    2. The case of prosecution which led to the conviction and sentence of the appellants summarily stated are as follows: the appellants A-1 and A-2 along with two others had forcibly taken the deceased girl to a secluded place on 21-10-1995 at about 7.00 p.m, when she was raped and then in the course of the same transaction, A-1 had strangulated her to death. Further, with a view to screen the offence, all of them threw the dead body to a secluded place in an agricultural field. The body was then discovered by the elder brother of the deceased girl, the next day. Investigation of the case was thereafter conducted which included the post-mortem report of the body of the deceased, wherein the doctor had opined death due to strangulation, injuries on the body, bleeding vaginal rupture. However, the vaginal smear did not reveal any traces of semen. The initial investigation did not reveal the names of the appellants and even the witnesses examined did not offer any clue in this regard. Thus, there were no eyewitnesses to the incident in support of the prosecution case.

    3. After about 35 days, on 25-11-1995, Appellant 1 approached PW 10, the Village Administrative Officer of Kadhili Village, whereby, he confessed that he along with Appellant 2 and two others murdered the deceased after raping her and offered to surrender. This confession was reduced into writing in the presence of PW 11 who was there and who signed the same. In pursuance of the confessional statement, the IO took him to the scene of crime where some earth sample was taken and then they went to A-1's home, where a diary belonging to the deceased was recovered. The next day, on 26-11-1995, A-2 approached PW 13, the Village Administrative Officer of Sunderam Palli Village and confessed about the crime, in the presence of PW 14, who had attested the written confession given to PW 13. The appellant-accused were then committed to trial and convicted on the basis of the extra-judicial confession. While A-1 had identified A-4, A-2 had identified A-3 and thus, they too were arrested. However, later the trial court had acquitted A-3 and A-4 and the State did not challenge the same.

    4. The High Court had to deal with the following two issues:

    (i) The nature of death of the deceased and whether rape was committed upon her;
    (ii) The guilt of the appellants with regard to the crime on the basis of their extra-judicial confessions, which were given separately to PW 10 and PW 13 by A-1 and A-2 respectively.

    5. The High Court found on the basis of the post-mortem report that the death was caused due to strangulation and that the girl's body exhibited all other symptoms of rape except the presence of semen in the vaginal swab.

    6. The High Court was informed by the counsel for the appellants that both the extra-judicial confessions (Ext. 7 by A-1 and Ext. 11 by A- 2) had striking similarity in their expression used thereunder although they were made by two different people/accused at two different places; but the Court found it an accidental coincidence as the sequence of events disclosed, was described in words that were commonly used.

    7. However, the defence that was taken was that the two witnesses PW 11 and PW 14 for A-1 and A-2's confessions had turned hostile as to the recovery of the diary from A-1's house and a certain letter from the house of A-2, due to which their evidence was challenged as not credible. However, the High Court rejected the same on the ground that in case these witnesses were “obliging witnesses” to the prosecution, they could have supported the entire prosecution case blindly and not turned hostile with reference to a particular portion. The High Court therefore relied upon the witnesses' statements with regard to the confessions that they made.

    8. The High Court, however, granted some relief to Appellant 2 by acquitting him from the charge of murder, on the basis of his confessional statement, wherein he had asked Appellant 1, at the time of strangulation as to why was he doing it and hence the High Court held that he had not participated in the murder and the deceased was strangulated by A-1 alone, all of a sudden, which led to her death.

    9. We have taken note of the prosecution evidence and perused the judgments of the courts below and also heard the learned counsel at length. The issue before us is whether the appellants can be convicted solely on the basis of these two extra-judicial confessions, which was witnessed by PW 11 and PW 14 who have turned hostile with regard to some portions of the prosecution evidence.

    10. The High Court, however, granted some relief to Appellant 2 by acquitting him of the charge of murder on the basis of his confessional statement wherein he had asked Appellant 1 as to why he was committing the act of strangulation and thus, the High Court inferred that he had not participated in the act of throttling the victim even though the deceased was killed and was held to have been strangulated by A-1 alone, all of a sudden, and hence was pleased to acquit A-2 of the charge of murder.

    11. We have carefully perused the evidence led by the prosecution as also the reasonings assigned in the judgment and order of the courts below and heard the learned counsel for the parties at length who in substance had submitted that the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 9 of 2005 is contrary to law, weight of evidence, probabilities and circumstances of the case and the material on record. According to the submission of the learned counsel for the accused, the judgment is based on mere surmises and conjectures and is, therefore, unsustainable in law and liable to be set aside. The counsel for the appellant further submitted that the conviction could not have been based on the confessional statement of the accused as the witnesses who were stated to be present at the time of recording of the confessional statement had turned hostile.

    12. However, on a scrutiny of the background and circumstance of the matter, we have taken note of the fact and find substance in the plea of the prosecution that the accused A-1 and A-2 committed rape on the victim one after the other and A-1 thought that if the victim is allowed to go alive, she may expose all of them and, therefore, A-1 throttled the neck of the deceased with his hands resulting in her death and on noticing this, A-2 questioned him as to why he did like that. Thus, even though A-2 had committed rape on the victim, his acquittal under Section 302 IPC but conviction under Section 376 IPC was rightly sustained.

    13. Insofar as A-1 is concerned, the background of the prosecution story cannot be given a go-by as the case of the prosecution is that the first petitioner/A-1 was insulted by the deceased when he attempted to develop intimacy with her and on being insulted by her, A-1 got angry and conspired with his friend and committed not only rape on her, but also murdered the deceased. Although, there is no eyewitness to this incident, the confessional statements of the appellant-accused fully corroborate the circumstantial evidence as the post-mortem report revealed that the deceased had died of strangulation which matched with the confessional statements of the appellant-accused.

    14. The sexual assault of rape is also established from the post-mortem report which establishes that the death of victim Janaki is homicidal and she was forcibly subjected to rape at the instance of several persons.

    15. The evidence of PW 10 and PW 13, the then Village Administrative Officers before whom the first and second accused gave their extra-judicial confessions, clearly unveils the case of the prosecution and this evidence was further corroborated. From the evidence of PW 11 (Radha Krishnan) and PW 14 (Selva Kumar) even though they were treated as hostile, they have not been able to establish the fact that the extra-judicial confessions had not been recorded in their presence. In addition, the recovery memos from the first accused and the second accused-appellants herein, clearly establish the charges levelled against them.

    16. It further cannot be overlooked that PW 10, the then Village Administrative Officer of Kadhili Village speaks about the extra-judicial confession of the first accused Baskaran and in this regard his evidence was corroborated by PW 11 (Radha Krishnan) who is an independent person and had no prior enmity with the first accused. Thus, even though this witness had turned hostile in the chief-examination itself, he spoke about the confession made by the first accused before the Village Administrative Officer and his presence there and putting his signature on the document regarding extra-judicial confession vide Ext. P-7 cannot be discarded, especially when this extra-judicial confession led to the surrender of the accused who were then arrested and tried. PW 14 (Selvakumar) although turned hostile, the same was confined only about the fact of recording confessional statement and he could not resile from the same.

    17. It is no doubt true that this Court time and again has held that an extra-judicial confession can be relied upon only if the same is voluntary and true and made in a fit state of mind. The value of the evidence as to the confession like any other evidence depends upon the veracity of the witness to whom it has been made. The value of the evidence as to the confession depends on the reliability of the witness who gives the evidence. But it is not open to any court to start with the presumption that extra-judicial confession is insufficient to convict the accused even though it is supported by the other circumstantial evidence and corroborated by independent witness, which is the position in the instant case. The courts cannot be unmindful of the legal position that if the evidence relating to extra-judicial confession is found credible after being tested on the touchstone of credibility and acceptability, it can solely form the basis of conviction.

    18. Having examined the instant case based on the aforesaid principle, we are not prepared to accept the plea that merely because one of the witnesses to the confessional statement did not support the confession in its entirety, the entire confession should be brushed aside as unreliable even though independent witness like the Village Administrative Officer had supported the recording of conviction. However, we have further taken note of the fact that the conviction of the appellants is not based merely on the confessional statements but also on other substantial evidence relied upon by the prosecution viz. recovery of the body, post-mortem report matching with confessional statements, evidence of other independent witnesses who corroborated the recording of confessional statement in their presence and thus do not create doubt about the credibility of the prosecution case so as to discard the same.

    19. We thus do not find any infirmity in the judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 9 of 2005 of the High Court holding the appellants guilty and sentencing them appropriately. Consequently, the appeal fails and is dismissed. The appellants are on bail. Their bail bonds are cancelled and they be taken into custody forthwith for serving out the remaining part of the sentence.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Baskaran And Another v. State Of Tamil Nadu .
    (Apr 25, 2014)