AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 49 read with Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as “the MRTP Act”)
  • Section 45 of the said Act read with Section 89(4) of the Maharashtra Municipalities Act, 1965
  • [Deleted by Maharashtra Act 6 of 1976]
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966
  • LA Act, 1894
  • Section 126, Section 127 of the MRTP Act
  • (3) On receipt of a purchase notice, the State Government shall forthwith call from the Planning Authority and the appropriate authority such report or records or both, as may be necessary,
  • Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 49 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 127 of the MRTP Act (as it existed prior to amendment in 2009)
  • Section 126 read with Section 127 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 44 of the MRTP Act
  • (4) On receiving such records or reports, if the State Government is satisfied that the conditions specified in sub-section (1) are fulfilled,
  • MRTP Act, 1966 (Section 127)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 49 read with Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as “the MRTP Act”)
  • Section 45 of the said Act read with Section 89(4) of the Maharashtra Municipalities Act, 1965
  • [Deleted by Maharashtra Act 6 of 1976]
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966
  • LA Act, 1894
  • Section 126, Section 127 of the MRTP Act
  • (3) On receipt of a purchase notice, the State Government shall forthwith call from the Planning Authority and the appropriate authority such report or records or both, as may be necessary,
  • Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 49 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 127 of the MRTP Act (as it existed prior to amendment in 2009)
  • Section 126 read with Section 127 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 44 of the MRTP Act
  • (4) On receiving such records or reports, if the State Government is satisfied that the conditions specified in sub-section (1) are fulfilled,
  • MRTP Act, 1966 (Section 127)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Hasmukhrai Vanmalidas Mehta, owns land in Survey No. 16 (Hissa 3) and Survey No. 18 (Hissa 4) in Village Sheel, Taluka Khopoli, District Raigad, Maharashtra. In 1990 he received permission and a commencement certificate to develop the land for residential purposes under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (MRTP Act). Although the sanctioned Development Plan of 1977 placed the land in a residential zone, a fresh scheme prepared in 1999 reserved it for an Agricultural Produce Market Committee (APMC) yard and truck terminal.

After learning of the new reservation, the appellant served a purchase notice under Section 49 of the MRTP Act on 17 August 2000. The Director of Town Planning advised commencement of acquisition proceedings within one year, but no concrete steps were taken by either the Khopoli Municipal Council or the APMC. Repeated reminders between 2001 and 2003 produced no action. The appellant therefore filed Writ Petition No. 2266 of 2004 before the Bombay High Court seeking either acquisition of or release from reservation of his land.

On 17 July 2007 the High Court dismissed the petition, reasoning that (i) the purchase notice was premature because the Development Scheme was not finalised, and (ii) the ten-year period under Section 127 had not expired from the date the plan was finalised (March 2003). The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reservation of the appellant’s land for an APMC yard and truck terminal lapsed under Sections 49 and 127 of the MRTP Act because the authorities failed to take timely steps for acquisition.
  2. Whether the appellant is entitled to have the land released from reservation and permitted to develop it for residential use.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The State cannot keep private land in limbo indefinitely; it must either acquire the land within the time-frames prescribed in Sections 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act or release it.
  • The purchase notice served in 2000 and the authorities’ inaction for over twenty years entitle the appellant to automatic release of the land from reservation.

State’s Arguments

  • A purchase notice under Section 49 can be served only after ten years from the coming into force of the Development Plan; therefore the appellant’s 2000 notice was ineffective.
  • Because the ten-year period had not expired when the notice was served, the respondents were under no obligation to act on it.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T. Vijayalakshmi v. Town Planning Member (2006) 8 SCC 502 Right to construct in a residential area is valuable; such right can be regulated but not indefinitely withheld. Doctrine of legitimate expectation applies. Used to emphasise that the appellant cannot be deprived of use of his property for an indefinite period without lawful acquisition.
Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 7 SCC 555 Sections 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act require expeditious acquisition; failure to take substantive steps within prescribed periods causes reservation to lapse. Relied upon as the primary authority to conclude that the reservation lapsed because no genuine steps toward acquisition were taken within the statutory periods.
Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay v. Hakimwadi Tenants Assn. 1988 Supp SCC 55 Legislative intent of Sections 126 and 127 is to prevent indefinite reservation by mandating acquisition within set time-frames. Cited (via Girnar Traders) to reinforce the requirement that authorities cannot perpetually delay acquisition merely by procedural steps.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first reproduced the full text of Sections 49 and 127 (pre-2009) of the MRTP Act to frame the statutory context. It observed that:

  • No action had been taken for acquisition or purchase of the land for more than twenty years despite repeated reminders from the Khopoli Municipal Council and the Town Planning authorities.
  • The APMC, the intended beneficiary of the reservation, failed even to contest the appeal, underscoring its inaction.
  • Under Section 49(7), once a purchase notice is confirmed and the appropriate authority does not apply for acquisition within one year, the reservation “shall be deemed to have lapsed.”
  • Under Section 127, if land is not acquired within ten years of the Development Plan coming into force, and acquisition is not initiated within six months of notice by the owner, the reservation automatically lapses.
  • The precedents in T. Vijayalakshmi and Girnar Traders affirm that the statutory scheme prevents authorities from indefinitely restricting an owner’s property rights without acquiring the land.

Applying these principles, the Court held that the authorities’ prolonged inactivity—despite statutory notices and ample time—meant that no valid “steps toward acquisition” had been taken. Consequently, the reservation lapsed and the appellant’s land must be released.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court order set aside. The appellant’s land stands released from reservation under Section 127 of the MRTP Act.

Implications: The decision frees the appellant to develop the land in accordance with regulations applicable to adjacent residential land. While the Court applied existing precedent rather than creating new doctrine, it reinforces that planning authorities must act within statutory deadlines or lose the power to reserve private land indefinitely.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Hasmukhrai V. Mehta v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

    Prafulla C. Pant, J.— This appeal is directed against the order dated 17-7-2007 WP No. 2266 of 2004 whereby the High Court of Judicature of Bombay has discussed Writ Petition No. 2266 of 2004, seeking direction either to release the appellant's land situated in Village Sheel, District Raigad in terms of Section 49 read with Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as “the MRTP Act”), from reservation and allow the appellant to develop the property for residential use, or, in the alternative, to declare that the appellant's land stood acquired for the purposes of Agricultural Produce Market Committee (for short “APMC”) and truck terminal (for which it was reserved).

    2. In brief, the factual matrix of the case is that the appellant Hasmukhrai Vanmalidas Mehta owns land in Survey No. 16, Hissa No. 3 and Survey No. 18, Hissa No. 4, situated in Village Sheel, Taluka Khopoli, District Raigad in the State of Maharashtra. On 14-2-1990, he applied to the Planning Authority seeking permission to carry out development of land with necessary documents as required under Section 44 of the MRTP Act. The appellant was granted permission and issued commencement certificate dated 3-4-1990 by Respondent 4 (Chief Officer, Khopoli Municipal Council) under Section 45 of the said Act read with Section 89(4) of the Maharashtra Municipalities Act, 1965. The Development Plan of Khopoli Municipal Council was sanctioned by the Government, vide Order No. TPS/1476/32/UD-5 dated 17-12-1976. It is pleaded on behalf of the appellant that the land in question, belonging to the appellant, was included in the residential zone in the sanctioned plan of 15-1-1977. It is further pleaded that on 15-7-1991, the Chief Town Planning Officer granted “no-objection certificate” for utilisation of the land for non-agricultural purpose. From the communication dated 15-7-1991, made by Respondent 4 it is revealed that the Development Plan for residential purpose was sanctioned, and commencement certificate was issued by him on 19-6-1992 for construction. Development charges amounting Rs 1,92,490 were also recovered from the appellant by getting served notice dated 31-7-1998, for use of land for residential purpose.

    3. However, on 14-1-1999 the appellant was informed by Respondent 4 that a fresh development scheme of Khopoli Town has been prepared which includes the appellant's Surveys Nos. 16/3 and 18/4 as a part of land reserved for Agriculture Produce Market Yard (for short “APM Yard”) and for truck terminal. Reacting to it, on 17-8-2000 the appellant served a purchase notice under Section 49 of the MRTP Act as the land in question was already in the sanctioned plan left in 1977 for residential purposes. In reply to this, Director, Town Planning, vide his communication dated 16-3-2001, though confirmed receiving of the purchase notice, but directed the appellant to contact APMC, Khopoli. The Director, Town Planning wrote a separate letter to the Chief Officer of Municipal Council of Khopoli that the proceedings of land acquisition for APM Yard be initiated within one year from 16-3-2001 failing which it would amount to release of the land from the reservation for APM Yard.

    4. Consequently, Khopoli Municipal Council wrote a letter on 23-4-2001 to APMC to immediately initiate acquisition proceedings and to act on purchase notice served by the appellant. The appellant himself wrote a letter to Respondent 5 (APMC) requesting for initiation of acquisition proceedings. Another letter was sent on 6-7-2001 by Respondent 4 to Respondent 5 calling upon it to take necessary steps for acquisition of the appellant's land. However, no steps were taken for one year i.e by 15-3-2001. Respondent 4 again reminded Respondent 5 between September 2001 to March 2002 to complete the acquisition proceedings. When nothing was done, the appellant again on 5-7-2002 sought revalidation of the permission for construction earlier allowed to him. After running from pillar to post, the appellant made a representation dated 13-2-2003 to the Secretary, Urban Development, Government of Maharashtra, on the above issue, but to no avail. Ultimately, the appellant filed a writ petition in February 2004 complaining that the respondents are neither acquiring the land belonging to the appellant nor releasing the same from reservation for APM Yard, and sought necessary directions from the High Court.

    5. By the impugned order WP No. 2266 of 2004, the High Court by its two paragraph order, dismissed the writ petition by observing that notice dated 17-8-2000 given by the writ petitioner (present appellant) invoking the provisions of Section 49 of the MRTP Act is of no help as the Development Scheme by then was not finalised. It is further observed by the High Court that Section 127 of the MRTP Act contemplates that the land be acquired by the Planning Authority within a period of 10 years after reservation, but in the present case, plan was finalised in March 2003, as such before the expiry of ten years elapsed, no benefit can be given to him.

    6. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the papers on record.

    7. Before further discussion, we think it just and proper to quote the relevant provisions of law applicable to this case. Section 49 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 reads as under:

    “49. Obligation to acquire land on refusal of permission or on grant of permission in certain cases.—(1) Where—
    (a) any land is designated by a plan as subject to compulsory acquisition, or
    (b) any land is allotted by a plan for the purpose of any functions of a Government or local authority or statutory body, or is land designated in such plan as a site proposed to be developed for the purposes of any functions of any such Government, authority or body, or
    (c) any land is indicated in any plan as land on which a highway is proposed to be constructed or included, or
    (d) any land for the development of which permission is refused or is granted subject to conditions, and any owner of land referred to in clauses (a), (b), (c) or (d) claims—
    (i) that the land has become incapable of reasonably beneficial use in its existing state, or
    (ii) (where planning permission is given subject to conditions) that the land cannot be rendered capable of reasonably beneficial use by the carrying out of the permitted development in accordance with the conditions; or
    (e) the owner of the land because of its designation or allocation in any plan claims that he is unable to sell it except at a lower price than that at which he might reasonably have been expected to sell if it were not so designated or allocated,
    the owner or person affected may serve on the State Government within such time and in such manner, as is prescribed by regulations, a notice (hereinafter referred to as ‘the purchase notice’) requiring the appropriate authority to purchase the interest in the land in accordance with the provisions of this Act.
    (2) The purchase notice shall be accompanied by a copy of any application made by the applicant to the Planning Authority, and of any order or decision of that Authority and of the State Government, if any, in respect of which the notice is given.
    (3) On receipt of a purchase notice, the State Government shall forthwith call from the Planning Authority and the appropriate authority such report or records or both, as may be necessary, which those authorities shall forward to the State Government as soon as possible but not later than thirty days from the date of their requisition.
    (4) On receiving such records or reports, if the State Government is satisfied that the conditions specified in sub-section (1) are fulfilled, and that order or decision for permission was not duly made on the ground that the applicant did not comply with any of the provisions of this Act or rules or regulations, it may confirm the purchase notice, or direct that planning permission be granted without condition or subject to such conditions as will make the land capable of reasonably beneficial use. In any other case, it may refuse to confirm the purchase notice, but in that case, it shall give the applicant a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
    (5) If within a period of six months from the date on which a purchase notice is served the State Government does not pass any final order thereon, the notice shall be deemed to have been confirmed at the expiration of that period.
    (6) [Deleted by Maharashtra Act 6 of 1976]
    (7) If within one year from the date of confirmation of the notice, the appropriate authority fails to make an application to acquire the land in respect of which the purchase notice has been confirmed as required under Section 126, the reservation, designation, allotment, indication or restriction on development of the land shall be deemed to have lapsed; and thereupon, the land shall be deemed to be released from the reservation, designation, or, as the case may be, allotment, indication or restriction and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land, under the relevant plan.”

    8. Another relevant provision i.e Section 127 of the MRTP Act (as it existed prior to amendment in 2009) is reproduced as under:

    “127. Lapsing of reservations.—If any land reserved, allotted or designated for any purpose specified in any plan under this Act is not acquired by agreement within ten years from the date on which a final regional plan, or final development plan comes into force or if proceedings for the acquisition of such land under this Act or under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (1 of 1894), are not commenced within such period, the owner or any person interested in the land may serve notice on the Planning Authority, Development Authority or as the case may be, appropriate authority to that effect; and if within six months from the date of the service of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps as aforesaid are commenced for its acquisition, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed, and thereupon the land shall be deemed to be released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise, permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.”

    9. The learned counsel for the appellant argued that the High Court has erred in law in dismissing the writ petition in which the appellant had fairly sought direction either to acquire the land or to release the same. It is further submitted that the land cannot be held up for indefinite period, and the State is bound either to acquire the land within the period provided under Section 126 read with Section 127 of the MRTP Act, or to release the same.

    10. In reply to this, on behalf of the State, it is contended that notice could have been served by the appellant-writ petitioner only after expiry of ten years of the Development Plan, and the respondents were not required to take note of the purchase notice given by the appellant within the period of ten years.

    11*. The above reply, in our opinion does not answer as to why steps have not been taken for acquisition for the last twenty years.

    12. We think it pertinent to mention here that APMC, Respondent 5, even after service of notice, has not cared to contest this appeal. Also, we think it relevant to mention that till date no steps appear to have been taken for acquisition of the land in question or to release the same. The land of the appellant, in our opinion, cannot be held up, without any authority of law, as neither the same is purchased till date by the respondent authorities, nor acquired under any law, nor the appellant is being allowed to use the land for the last more than twenty years.

    13. In T. Vijayalakshmi v. Town Planning Member (2006) 8 SCC 502, this Court, in paras 13 and 15, has observed as under:

    “13. Town Planning legislations are regulatory in nature. The right to property of a person would include a right to construct a building. Such a right, however, can be restricted by reason of a legislation. In terms of the provisions of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, a comprehensive development plan was prepared. It indisputably is still in force. Whether the amendments to the said comprehensive development plan as proposed by the Authority would ultimately be accepted by the State or not is uncertain. It is yet to apply its mind. Amendments to a development plan must conform to the provisions of the Act. As noticed hereinbefore, the State has called for objection from the citizens. Ecological balance no doubt is required to be maintained and the courts while interpreting a statute should bestow serious consideration in this behalf, but ecological aspects, it is trite, are ordinarily a part of the town planning legislation. If in the legislation itself or in the statute governing the field, ecological aspects have not been taken into consideration keeping in view the future need, the State and the Authority must take the blame therefor. We must assume that these aspects of the matter were taken into consideration by the Authority and the State. But the rights of the parties cannot be intermeddled with so long as an appropriate amendment in the legislation is not brought into force.
    ***
    15. The law in this behalf is explicit. Right of a person to construct residential houses in the residential area is a valuable right. The said right can only be regulated in terms of a regulatory statute but unless there exists a clear provision the same cannot be taken away. It is also a trite law that the building plans are required to be dealt with in terms of the existing law. Determination of such a question cannot be postponed far less taken away. Doctrine of legitimate expectation in a case of this nature would have a role to play.”

    14. In Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 7 SCC 555, this Court, per majority, in paras 32, 54 and 56 has held as under:( & 586-87)

    “32. If no proceedings as provided under Section 127 are taken and as a result thereof the reservation of the land lapses, the land shall be released from reservation, allotment or designation and shall be available to the owner for the purpose of development. The availability of the land to the owner for the development would only be for the purpose which is permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan. Thus, even after the release, the owner cannot utilise the land in whatever manner he deems fit and proper, but its utilisation has to be in conformity with the relevant plan for which the adjacent lands are permitted to be utilised.
    ***
    54. When we conjointly read Sections 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act, it is apparent that the legislative intent is to expeditiously acquire the land reserved under the Town Planning Scheme and, therefore, various periods have been prescribed for acquisition of the owner's property. The intent and purpose of the provisions of Sections 126 and 127 has been well explained in Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay v. Hakimwadi Tenants Assn. 1988 Supp SCC 55 If the acquisition is left for time immemorial in the hands of the authority concerned by simply making an application to the State Government for acquiring such land under the LA Act, 1894, then the authority will simply move such an application and if no such notification is issued by the State Government for one year of the publication of the draft regional plan under Section 126(2) read with Section 6 of the LA Act, wait for the notification to be issued by the State Government by exercising suo motu power under sub-section (4) of Section 126; and till then no declaration could be made under Section 127 as regards lapsing of reservation and contemplated declaration of land being released and available for the landowner for his utilisation as permitted under Section 127. Section 127 permitted inaction on the part of the acquisition authorities for a period of 10 years for dereservation of the land. Not only that, it gives a further time for either to acquire the land or to take steps for acquisition of the land within a period of six months from the date of service of notice by the landowner for dereservation. The steps towards commencement of the acquisition in such a situation would necessarily be the steps for acquisition and not a step which may not result into acquisition and merely for the purpose of seeking time so that Section 127 does not come into operation.
    ***
    56. The underlying principle envisaged in Section 127 of the MRTP Act is either to utilise the land for the purpose it is reserved in the plan in a given time or let the owner utilise the land for the purpose it is permissible under the town planning scheme. The step taken under the section within the time stipulated should be towards acquisition of land. It is a step of acquisition of land and not step for acquisition of land. It is trite that failure of authorities to take steps which result in actual commencement of acquisition of land cannot be permitted to defeat the purpose and object of the scheme of acquisition under the MRTP Act by merely moving an application requesting the Government to acquire the land, which Government may or may not accept. Any step which may or may not culminate in the step for acquisition cannot be said to be a step towards acquisition.”

    15. In view of the principle of law laid down by this Court, as above, we are of the view that in the present case since neither have steps been taken by the authorities concerned for acquisition of the land, nor is the land of the appellant purchased under purchase notice, nor is he allowed to use the land for the last more than twenty years, the land will have to be released as the appellant cannot be deprived from utilising his property for an indefinite period.

    16. Inaction on the part of APMC and bona fide act of the appellant are apparent from the documents on record. In this connection, we think it relevant that from the copy of letter dated 15-7-1991 (Annexure P-2) it is clear that Khopoli Municipal Council granted permission for demarcation of Survey No. 16, Hissa No. 3 and Survey No. 18, Hissa No. 4 of Village Sheel, and allowed that the plot be used by the appellant for residential purpose, subject to other conditions mentioned in the letter. Another document on record, is copy of letter dated 23-4-2001 (Annexure P-8) sent by the Chief Officer of Khopoli Municipal Council to the Chairman, Agriculture Produce Market Committee, wherein at the end of the letter, it is expressly mentioned that if action of acquisition of land was not started within the time-limit mentioned under the MRTP Act, 1966, the Committee (APMC) would be responsible for lapse of reservation of the land. Also, Report dated 21-4-2003 (Annexure P-14) of the Town Planning and Valuation Department addressed to the Principal Secretary of the Urban Development Department of the State of Maharashtra shows that the Committee (APMC) and the State Government were reminded of the fact regarding the requirement of acquisition proceedings and the fact that it is yet not known that any action for land acquisition was taken till the report was submitted or not. Necessity of early action was reiterated in the letter. However, it appears that no one bothered on the issue to take steps for acquisition.

    17. In the above circumstances, having considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and after going through the documents on record and further considering the law laid down by this Court, as discussed above, we find that the High Court has erred in law in dismissing the writ petition.

    18. Accordingly, we allow the appeal and set aside the impugned order WP No. 2266 of 2004 passed by the High Court. Since no steps appear to have been taken till date for the last more than twenty years either for acquisition or for purchase of the land under the MRTP Act, 1966 by the authorities concerned, as such, the land in question stands released from reservation under Section 127 of the MRTP Act.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hasmukhrai V. Mehta v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
    (Dec 3, 2014)