Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 531
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 142, Constitution Bench quoted with approval the observations of Farwell, L.J in Latham v. R. Johnson & Nephew Ltd.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 531
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 142, Constitution Bench quoted with approval the observations of Farwell, L.J in Latham v. R. Johnson & Nephew Ltd.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

In 1998, the Welfare Department of the Government of Bihar decided to introduce two new trades—Electronics and Electrical Appliances Repairing—at the Kamla Nehru Social Service Institute for Handicapped and Rehabilitation Training Centre, Patna. Funds were sanctioned and, on 12-3-1999, a requisition was sent to the Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC) to fill the posts of Instructor and Assistant Instructor. No appointments were made in 1999 because BPSC did not issue recommendations. Although the scheme was later discontinued, BPSC advertised the vacancies on 30-12-2001.

The respondent, Mithilesh Kumar, applied, was interviewed on 9-11-2002, and was declared successful on 5-12-2002. Meanwhile, on 14-11-2002, the Empowered Committee decided to engage NGOs for training instead and asked BPSC to stop recommendations. Despite this, BPSC recommended the respondent for appointment.

After administrative silence, the respondent filed Writ Petition No. 543 of 2005. The Patna High Court directed the Director, Social Welfare, to decide his representation, which was rejected on 15-12-2005. The respondent then filed CWJC No. 447 of 2006, which was allowed; the State was ordered to appoint him. A State appeal (LPA No. 844 of 2007) was dismissed by a Division Bench on 18-7-2008. The State of Bihar filed the present special leave petition (SLP) before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State could refuse appointment to a candidate selected by BPSC after the selection process had begun but before appointment, on the ground that the recruitment policy had subsequently changed.
  2. Whether inclusion in a select list confers an indefeasible right to appointment when vacancies exist.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (State of Bihar)

  • BPSC should not have made any recommendation after the Empowered Committee asked for derequisition of the posts.
  • Placement on a select panel does not create an indefeasible right to appointment, citing Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India and All India Railway Recruitment Board v. K. Shyam Kumar.
  • The Court should not be swayed by sympathy, relying on observations in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) and Latham v. R. Johnson & Nephew Ltd.

Respondent (Mithilesh Kumar)

  • The selection process was completed under existing norms; a later policy change cannot nullify his selection.
  • Once vacancies were advertised and the respondent was duly selected, the State was bound to appoint him.
  • Changing recruitment norms mid-process is impermissible, relying on Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao, N.T. Devin Katti v. Karnataka PSC, and A.P. PSC v. B. Swapna.
  • The Director, Social Welfare, had even sought revalidation of BPSC’s recommendation, evidencing continuing vacancies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India, (1991) 3 SCC 47 Selection does not confer an indefeasible right to appointment. Cited by State to deny appointment; Court distinguished on facts because refusal was based on a post-selection policy change.
All India Railway Recruitment Board v. K. Shyam Kumar, (2010) 6 SCC 614 No indefeasible right even after successful selection. Court agreed with principle but held present case involved an unlawful mid-process policy shift.
Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao, (1983) 3 SCC 284 Vacancies occurring before rule change are governed by old rules. Relied upon to support respondent; Court accepted that pre-existing norms govern the vacancy.
N.T. Devin Katti v. Karnataka PSC, (1990) 3 SCC 157 Selection should be governed by rules prevailing when advertisement was issued; amendments are prospective. Accepted by Court to uphold High Court’s direction.
A.P. PSC v. B. Swapna, (2005) 4 SCC 154 Norms of selection cannot be altered after the process starts; amended rules are prospective. Supported Court’s conclusion that respondent’s selection stood unaffected.
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 Courts should not allow sympathy to override law in public employment. Cited by State; Court held sympathy was not the basis of its decision.
Latham v. R. Johnson & Nephew Ltd., (1913) 1 KB 398 Warning against deciding cases on sympathy. Quoted in Umadevi; Court noted but found it inapposite.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found no merit in the State’s challenge. It emphasized that:

  • The respondent had been duly selected in conformity with the recruitment norms existing when the advertisement was issued.
  • A subsequent administrative decision to engage NGOs could operate only prospectively; it could not defeat the legitimate expectation of a candidate already selected.
  • The line of authorities (Rangaiah, Devin Katti, B. Swapna) establishes that amended or altered recruitment rules do not retrospectively affect an ongoing selection process unless expressly stated.
  • The cases cited by the State regarding the absence of an indefeasible right to appointment were distinguished because, unlike in those cases, the respondent’s claim was rejected solely due to a later policy change, not due to non-availability of vacancies or other exigencies.
  • The principle against deciding on sympathy, reaffirmed in Umadevi, was acknowledged but found irrelevant as the decision rested on settled legal doctrine, not equity or compassion.

Holding and Implications

SLP DISMISSED; the judgments of the Patna High Court (Single Judge and Division Bench) directing appointment of the respondent are affirmed.

Implications: The State must appoint the respondent as Assistant Instructor (Electronics) in accordance with BPSC’s recommendation. The ruling reiterates the settled principle that recruitment norms existing at the commencement of a selection process govern that process, and later policy changes have only prospective effect. No new precedent is created, but the decision reinforces consistency in public employment jurisprudence.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Bihar And Others v. Mithilesh Kumar .

    Altamas Kabir, J.— In 1998, the Department of Welfare, Government of Bihar, decided to introduce two new trades (Electronic and Electrical Appliances Repairing) for vocational training in Kamla Nehru Social Service Institute for Handicapped and Rehabilitation Training Centre, Patna, for training of persons with disabilities. The said proposal was approved by the Empowered Committee constituted under the Bihar Public Service Commission under the chairmanship of the Development Commissioner and funds were also sanctioned for such training.

    2. In the light of the above decision on 12-3-1999, a requisition was sent by the Welfare Department, Government of Bihar, to the Bihar Public Service Commission (hereinafter referred to as “BPSC”) for appointment of Instructors and Assistant Instructors, but despite sanction of funds for the year 1998-1999, appointments were not made because the Commission failed to make recommendations for the said posts. Subsequently, the scheme was not extended by the Empowered Committee, but on 30-12-2001, pursuant to requisition made by the Welfare Department, BPSC advertised the posts for making appointments thereto.

    3. The respondent, Mithilesh Kumar, applied pursuant to the said advertisement and was called for and appeared at an interview on 9-11-2002, but immediately thereafter, on 14-11-2002, the Empowered Committee took a decision that from thenceforth the services of NGOs/institutions would be used for training persons with disabilities. The Assistant Director, Social Welfare, by his letter dated 14-11-2002, requested BPSC not to send any further recommendations as the scheme was no longer valid and the said Committee had decided to train students of the two trades through professionally established NGOs/institutions.

    4. On 5-12-2002, after the said communication was received from the Assistant Director, Social Welfare, the respondent was declared successful in the interview which had been held on 9-11-2002, and despite the request made by the Assistant Director, Social Welfare, BPSC recommended the name of the respondent to the said authority for appointment.

    5. The respondent, in his turn, made a representation seeking appointment pursuant to the results declared by the Commission. Not receiving any response, the respondent filed Writ Petition No. 543 of 2005 before the Patna High Court on 11-7-2005, for appropriate relief. The High Court disposed of the writ petition with a direction to the Director, Social Welfare, Government of Bihar, to dispose of the respondent's representation. On 15-12-2005, the Director, Social Welfare, considered the representation of the respondent and rejected the same.

    6. Aggrieved by the rejection of his representation, the respondent filed a fresh writ petition, being CWJC No. 447 of 2006, before the Patna High Court and the same was duly allowed. The order dated 15-12-2005, passed by the Director, Social Welfare, was quashed and the Secretary, Social Welfare, Government of Bihar and the Director, Social Welfare, were directed to appoint the respondent to the post of Assistant Instructor (Electronics) in Kamla Nehru Social Service Institute for Handicapped and Rehabilitation Training Centre, Patna, after obtaining a recommendation for validation by BPSC. A direction was given to issue the appointment letter in favour of the respondent within two weeks from the date of receipt/production of a copy of the High Court's order.

    7. The matter was taken to the Division Bench by the State of Bihar in LPA No. 844 of 2007. On 18-7-2008, the Division Bench of the Patna High Court dismissed the said appeal relying entirely on the judgment of the learned Single Judge, without giving any reasons of its own. The instant special leave petition has been filed against the said judgment of the Division Bench of the Patna High Court.

    8. Without denying the facts of the case, as narrated hereinabove, the learned counsel appearing for the State of Bihar submitted that once a request had been made by the Empowered Committee to derequisition the posts in question, BPSC ought not to have recommended the name of the respondent for appointment as Assistant Instructor (Electronics). Referring to the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India (1991) 3 SCC 47, (1991) 17 ATC 95, the learned counsel submitted that inclusion in the select panel did not vest the respondent with an indefeasible right to be appointed, even if a vacancy existed.

    9. Reference was also made to the decision of this Court in All India Railway Recruitment Board v. K. Shyam Kumar (2010) 6 SCC 614, wherein while considering the scope of judicial review, this Court had occasion to consider the aforesaid question also and it was reiterated that even after vacancies were notified for appointment and adequate number of candidates were found successful, they would not acquire any indefeasible right to be appointed against the existing vacancies.

    10. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent reiterated the fact that pursuant to the advertisement published by the Bihar Public Service Commission on 30-12-2001 for filling up the posts of Instructor/Assistant Instructor, the respondent had applied and admit card was issued to him in October 2002. Pursuant to the above, the respondent appeared in the selection process and the results were declared by the Commission on 5-12-2002 and after declaration of the results a direction was given by the Minister concerned to the Director, Social Welfare, Bihar, Patna, Petitioner 3, to appoint the respondent Mithilesh Kumar forthwith. Pursuant thereto, on 24-2-2004, the Director of Social Welfare asked the respondent to produce all his certificates before the Assistant Director on 22-2-2004, for verification but, thereafter, he was not favoured with an appointment letter. The learned counsel submitted that this compelled the respondent to file CWJC No. 543 of 2005 for issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus for his appointment to the post in question.

    11. The learned counsel submitted that on 5-3-2005, the Director wrote to the Deputy Secretary of the Commission to revalidate the recommendation which had been made by it and had expired during the pendency of the matter. On 3-5-2005, the recommendation was revalidated for a period of three months.

    12. Thereafter, on 11-7-2005, a learned Single Judge of the Patna High Court disposed of CWJC No. 543 of 2005 with a direction to the Director, Social Welfare, to dispose of the respondent's representation after seeking appropriate instruction from the State Government and to ensure disposal of the said representation on or before 3-8-2005.

    13. The learned counsel submitted that the respondent's representation was considered and rejected by the Director, Social Welfare, by his cryptic order dated 15-12-2005, which was, thereafter, affirmed by the Division Bench in LPA No. 844 of 2007 on 18-7-2008 in an even more cryptic fashion. The learned counsel urged that having been selected for appointment after a regular process of selection, the respondent's claim for appointment could not have been neutralised simply on the basis of a request subsequently made by the Assistant Director, Social Welfare, to BPSC not to send any further recommendations as a decision had been taken in the interregnum to train students in respect of the trades in question through professionally established NGOs/institutions.

    14. The learned counsel submitted that the conditions of the advertisement inviting applications for filling up the posts of Assistant Instructor (Electronics) in Kamla Nehru Social Service Institute for Handicapped and Rehabilitation Training Centre, Patna, could not have been altered to the prejudice of the respondent on account of a decision taken subsequently to have persons with disabilities trained by professionally established NGOs/institutions. Reliance was placed on the decision of this Court in Y.V Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao (1983) 3 SCC 284, where this Court in similar circumstances had held that when service rules are amended, vacancies which had occurred prior to the amended Rules would be governed by the old Rules and not by the amended Rules.

    15. Reference was also made by the learned counsel to the decision of this Court in N.T Devin Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission (1990) 3 SCC 157, (1990) 14 ATC 688, wherein it was reiterated that where selection process was initiated by issuing advertisement inviting applications, selection normally should be regulated by the rules and orders then prevailing. It was also emphasised that service jurisprudence provides that normally amendments effected during the pendency of a selection process operate prospectively, unless indicated to the contrary by express language or by necessary implication.

    16. The learned counsel lastly referred to the decision of this Court in A.P Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna (2005) 4 SCC 154, wherein while considering the norms for recruitment/selection for filling up vacancies which had been initially advertised, this Court was of the view that such norms of selection cannot be altered after commencement of the selection process and rules prescribing qualification, which were amended during the continuation of the selection process, have prospective operation unless something to the contrary is indicated expressly or by necessary implication.

    17. Replying to the submissions made on behalf of the respondent, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the respondent was not also entitled to any relief having regard to the decision of this Court in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1, where in paras 13 and 35, the Constitution Bench quoted with approval the observations of Farwell, L.J in Latham v. R. Johnson & Nephew Ltd. (1913) 1 KB 398, (1911-13) All ER Rep 117 (CA) to the effect that the Supreme Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 142 has to be very careful not to allow sympathy to affect its judgment.

    18. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties and we are not impressed with the stand taken by the petitioner State of Bihar, that the Bihar Public Service Commission ought not to have recommended the name of the respondent for appointment after the Assistant Director, Social Welfare had requested the Commission not to recommend any further names in view of the decision taken by the State to have disabled persons trained through professionally established NGOs/institutions in place of Instructors/Assistant Instructors for which advertisements had already been issued by the Commission.

    19. Both the learned Single Judge as also the Division Bench rightly held that the change in the norms of recruitment could be applied prospectively and could not affect those who had been selected for being recommended for appointment after following the norms as were in place at the time when the selection process was commenced. The respondent had been selected for recommendation to be appointed as Assistant Instructor in accordance with the existing norms. Before he could be appointed or even considered for appointment, the norms of recruitment were altered to the prejudice of the respondent. The question is whether those altered norms will apply to the respondent.

    20. The decisions which have been cited on behalf of the respondent have clearly explained the law with regard to the applicability of the rules which are amended and/or altered during the selection process. They all say in one voice that the norms or rules as existing on the date when the process of selection begins will control such selection and any alteration to such norms would not affect the continuing process, unless specifically the same were given retrospective effect.

    21. As far as the decision in Umadevi (3) case (2006) 4 SCC 1 is concerned, we share the sentiments as set out in para 35 of the judgment but we are only considering a situation where amendments are introduced to a recruitment process after the same has begun. The question of allowing sympathy to affect our judgment does not, therefore, arise in this case. Our focus is not on any individual, but on a legal principle which has been settled by this Court in various decisions, as referred to hereinbefore.

    22. There is no reason for us to have any disagreement with the decision of this Court in All India Railway Recruitment Board case (2010) 6 SCC 614 regarding the right to appointment even of selected candidates, but this is not a case of the respondent having acquired any indefeasible right which has to be cancelled on account of certain exigencies. On the other hand, this is a case where although selected for the purpose of appointment by BPSC, Patna, the case of the respondent was not even considered as there was a change in policy regarding recruitment in the meantime.

    23. While a person may not acquire an indefeasible right to appointment merely on the basis of selection, in the instant case the fact situation is different since the claim of the respondent to be appointed had been negated by a change in policy after the selection process had begun.

    24. In these circumstances, we do not see any reason to interfere with the impugned judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court dated 18-7-2008, in LPA No. 844 of 2007, affirming the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 31-7-2007, in CWJC No. 447 of 2006. The special leave petition is, therefore, dismissed, without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Bihar And Others v. Mithilesh Kumar .
    (Aug 19, 2010)