AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
009 INSC 1308
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 116 of the Evidence Act
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Order 43 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, amended from 1-2-1977
  • Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Section 3(iii) of the 1950 Act
  • Section 13 of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950
  • Section 3(iii) of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950
  • Section 13(1)(h)(i) of the 1950 Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
009 INSC 1308
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 116 of the Evidence Act
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Order 43 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, amended from 1-2-1977
  • Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Section 3(iii) of the 1950 Act
  • Section 13 of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950
  • Section 3(iii) of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950
  • Section 13(1)(h)(i) of the 1950 Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Bhavani Shankar, father of Respondents 1 and 2 (Subhash and Gopal Paliwal), owned several properties including the disputed shop room. After his death, Subhash and Gopal filed an eviction suit on 3 January 1998 against the present petitioners, asserting personal and bona fide need of Subhash’s son, Sandeep, for a painting business.

The petitioners, defendants in the suit, applied on 22 July 1998 under Order 11 Rules 12 & 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) for production of an alleged will dated 21 July 1989 by which Bhavani Shankar purportedly bequeathed the shop to Gopal alone. The trial court dismissed that application, and the petitioners filed their written statement on 8 December 1998 without pleading the will. On 2 August 2000 the trial court decreed eviction and recovery of rent in favour of the respondents.

The petitioners appealed on 28 August 2000. During the appeal, they sought (3 August 2002) to amend the written statement under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC to plead the will, but the Additional District Judge refused on 13 November 2002, noting their prior knowledge of the document. After procuring a certified copy of the will, the petitioners again applied (3 January 2003) under Order 6 Rule 17 and Order 41 Rule 27 CPC for amendment and additional evidence. On 20 May 2003, the first appellate court allowed both requests.

The respondents challenged that order. The High Court, by judgment dated 19 December 2005, allowed their civil miscellaneous appeal and rejected both applications of the petitioners. The petitioners then approached the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal lay to the High Court against the first appellate court’s order allowing amendment of pleadings and additional evidence, in light of Order 43 Rule 1(u) CPC.
  2. Whether the petitioners, having earlier admitted the landlord–tenant relationship, could belatedly amend their written statement and adduce the will to deny the respondents’ status as landlords.
  3. Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the first appellate court’s order permitting amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 and additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Subhash Paliwal did not qualify as “landlord” under Section 3(iii) of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950, because the will vested exclusive ownership in Gopal; therefore, the eviction suit was not maintainable under Section 13 of the Act.
  • The appellate court had wide power to admit additional evidence where parties, despite due diligence, could not earlier produce it, or where its admission was needed for proper adjudication.
  • The certified copy of the will went to the root of the dispute; refusal to permit its introduction caused grave prejudice.
  • Cited several Supreme Court decisions emphasising liberal allowance of amendments (e.g., Dondapati Narayana Reddy; Prem Bakshi; Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal; Andhra Bank).
  • Contended that an appeal against the first appellate court’s order was not maintainable under Order 43 Rule 1.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioners’ written statement (8 December 1998) admitted the respondents as landlords and acknowledged payment of rent; no reference to any will was made until long after the decree.
  • The first application for amendment came only on 3 September 2002—well after the decree—showing lack of bona fides.
  • By amended clause (u) of Order 43 Rule 1, an appeal against a remand order under Order 41 Rule 23-A is maintainable; hence the High Court’s jurisdiction was proper.
  • After rejection of discovery under Order 11 Rules 12 & 14 CPC, recourse to Order 41 Rule 27 for the same document was impermissible.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dondapati Narayana Reddy v. Duggireddy Venkatanarayana Reddy (2001) 8 SCC 115 Amendments should be liberally allowed unless they cause irreparable prejudice. Distinguished; Court held liberal principle inapplicable because petitioners had earlier admitted landlordship and delayed plea.
Prem Bakshi v. Dharam Dev (2002) 2 SCC 2 Amendments generally do not cause failure of justice; they alert the opposite side to new pleas. Distinguished on same ground of petitioners’ admissions and delay.
Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal v. K.K. Modi (2006) 4 SCC 385 “Real controversy” test—amendments necessary to resolve the dispute should be permitted. Held inapplicable; petitioners attempted to raise a “new story” only at appellate stage.
Andhra Bank v. ABN Amro Bank N.V. (2007) 6 SCC 167 Reiterated liberal approach to amendments. Not applied owing to petitioners’ prior knowledge and admissions.
Pandit Ishwardas v. State of M.P. (1979) 4 SCC 163 Appellate court may permit amendment if justified, subject to delay considerations. Court found delay and prior knowledge fatal to petitioners’ request.
Harcharan v. State of Haryana (1982) 3 SCC 408 Amendments on main controversy should not be refused on technical grounds. Court rejected applicability for same reasons as above.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Maintainability of the High Court appeal. The Supreme Court held that, because Rule 23-A was introduced into Order 43 Rule 1(u) CPC with effect from 1 February 1977, an appeal against a remand order is expressly maintainable. Hence the High Court had jurisdiction to entertain the respondents’ appeal.

2. Effect of petitioners’ admissions. In their original written statement the petitioners admitted that Subhash and Gopal were their landlords and that they paid rent to them. Under Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act, such admissions estopped them from later disputing the respondents’ title during the subsistence of tenancy.

3. Delay and knowledge regarding the will. The courts below found that the petitioners were aware of the alleged will from the outset. They neither pleaded it in the written statement nor sought amendment during trial. The attempt to introduce it two years into the appeal was viewed as an endeavour to “prolong the disposal” of the case.

4. Inapplicability of liberal amendment jurisprudence. While acknowledging precedents advocating a liberal approach, the Court concluded those authorities could not assist the petitioners because their conduct—admitting landlordship, delaying amendment, and trying to introduce a new defence—undermined bona fides.

5. Consequential finding. Given the estoppel and lack of bona fide, the will—even if produced—would make little difference; therefore, the High Court correctly set aside the first appellate court’s order allowing amendment and additional evidence.

Holding and Implications

The special leave petition is dismissed.

Consequently, the High Court’s order rejecting the petitioners’ applications for amendment and additional evidence stands affirmed. The eviction decree in favour of the respondents remains undisturbed. The Court made no order as to costs, and the decision sets no new precedent beyond applying established principles on admissions and amendment of pleadings.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Jaswant Kaur And Another v. Subhash Paliwal And Others

    Altamas Kabir, J.— One Bhavani Shankar, the father of Respondents 1 and 2, Subhash Paliwal and Gopal Paliwal, was the owner of several properties, including the disputed shop room. After his demise, on 3-1-1998, Subhash Paliwal and Gopal Paliwal filed a suit against the petitioners for their eviction from the shop room in question on the ground of personal necessity and bona fide necessity of Sandeep, son of Subhash Paliwal, for his painting business.

    2. On 22-7-1998, the petitioners filed an application under Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, for a direction upon the respondents to produce on record the will said to have been executed by their late father, Bhavani Shankar, on 21-7-1989, whereby he was alleged to have bequeathed the disputed shop room to his younger son, Gopal Paliwal, thereby asserting that Subhash Paliwal was not the owner of the suit shop room and the suit for eviction for the bona fide need of his son was not, therefore, maintainable.

    3. After hearing the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties, the learned Civil Judge dismissed the said application. Subsequently, the petitioners herein filed their written statement on 8-12-1998, denying the averments made in the plaint, but without making any averment with regard to the existence of the will said to have been executed by Bhavani Shankar. Ultimately, by judgment and decree dated 2-8-2000, the learned trial court decreed the suit for eviction and recovery of rent in favour of the respondents, against which the petitioners preferred first appeal on 28-8-2000.

    4. On 3-8-2002, the petitioners filed an application in the pending appeal under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure for amendment of the written statement to incorporate the submissions that in view of the will purportedly executed by Bhavani Shankar, Subhash Paliwal was not the owner of the suit property and could not, therefore, ask for eviction of the petitioners therefrom for the personal and bona fide requirement of his son.

    5. The learned Additional District Judge No. 2, Udaipur, by his order dated 13-11-2002, dismissed the application filed by the petitioners on the ground that despite having knowledge of the will in question even at the time of filing written statement, no such averment had been made. The revisional application filed by the petitioners before the High Court against the order dated 13-11-2002, has been lying defective and no steps have been taken to proceed with the same.

    6. According to the petitioners, on obtaining a certified copy of the will dated 21-7-1989, said to have been executed by Bhavani Shankar, the petitioners once again made an application under Order 6 Rule 17 and under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure for amendment of the written statement and for permission to bring on record additional evidence on the ground that the will in question was not in their possession prior to 18-11-2002, as a result whereof they were unable to make any reference thereto in the written statement.

    7. The first appellate court by a reasoned order dated 20-5-2003, allowed both the applications, against which the respondents filed a civil miscellaneous appeal before the High Court and the High Court by its impugned order dated 19-12-2005, allowed the appeal and rejected both the applications filed by the petitioners on 3-1-2003, under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC and Order 41 Rule 27 CPC.

    8. Appearing on behalf of the petitioners, Ms Shobha, learned advocate, submitted that the High Court had erred in interfering with the reasoned judgment of the first appellate court since Subhash Paliwal did not fall within the definition of “landlord” as defined in Section 3(iii) of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1950 Act”), under Section 13 whereof a suit for eviction could be brought by the landlord on the ground of bona fide necessity for the use or occupation for himself or his family. Ms Shobha submitted that neither the brother nor the brother's son of the exclusive owner would have any right to claim eviction after their rights were separated by the will executed by Bhavani Shankar on 21-7-1989.

    9. Ms Shobha submitted that the powers of the appellate court were sufficiently wide to allow the introduction of additional evidence if the courts below had wrongly declined to admit the evidence or if the parties seeking to bring the documents on record failed to produce the same despite due diligence, or if the appellate court thought it appropriate to have the said document on record for a proper adjudication of the lis.

    10. Ms Shobha urged that the High Court had failed to gauge the importance of bringing on record the certified copy of the will by way of additional evidence and had erred in disallowing the petitioners' prayer for amendment of the written statement on the basis thereof, as it went to the very root of the petitioners' case that Subhash Paliwal had no right to maintain the suit jointly with Gopal Paliwal for eviction of the petitioners from the suit shop room for the bona fide need of the nephew of the exclusive owner.

    11. Ms Shobha submitted that as was held by this Court in Dondapati Narayana Reddy v. Duggireddy Venkatanarayana Reddy (2001) 8 SCC 115 amendment of pleadings should be liberally allowed, unless it is established that the result would cause such injustice and prejudice against the opposite side as could not be compensated by costs or as would deprive him of a right accrued due to lapse of time.

    12. Reference was also made to a decision of this Court in Prem Bakshi v. Dharam Dev (2002) 2 SCC 2 in the context of an application for amendment filed under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC, wherein it was observed that it was almost inconceivable how mere amendments of pleadings could possibly cause failure of justice or irreparable injury to any party. It was observed that such amendments only serve advance notice to the other side as to the plea which a party might take up. Accordingly, a situation could not be envisaged where amendment of pleadings, whatever be the nature of such amendment, would even remotely cause failure of justice or irreparable loss to any party.

    13. Reference was also made to the decision of this Court in Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal v. K.K Modi (2006) 4 SCC 385 wherein the approach to be taken by the courts in considering whether to permit amendment fell for consideration and it was held that the courts should allow all amendments that may be necessary for determining the real question in controversy between the parties, provided it did not cause injustice or prejudice to the other side. It was observed that the real controversy test is the basic or cardinal test and it is the primary duty of the court to decide whether such an amendment is necessary to decide the real dispute between the parties. Similar views were also expressed in Andhra Bank v. ABN Amro Bank N.V (2007) 6 SCC 167

    14. Ms Shobha urged that although the will in question may have been within the knowledge of the petitioners, without obtaining a certified copy thereof, it was not possible to include the same in the pleadings while filing the written statement, particularly when the application filed by the petitioners under Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 for discovery of the said document had been rejected by the trial court.

    15. It was further submitted that the High Court should have appreciated the fact that there was no bar to the appellate court permitting amendment of pleadings to enable a party to raise a new plea, as was held by this Court in Pandit Ishwardas v. State of M.P (1979) 4 SCC 163 In fact, this Court observed that all that was necessary was that the appellate court should observe the well-known principles subject to which amendments of pleadings are usually granted. Naturally, one of the circumstances which would be taken into consideration before an amendment was granted is the delay in making the application seeking such amendment and, if made at the appellate stage, the reason why it was not sought in the trial court.

    16. Ms Shobha also referred to the decision of this Court in Harcharan v. State of Haryana (1982) 3 SCC 408 where it was observed that amendment of pleadings relating to the main controversy should not be refused on mere technical grounds.

    17. Ms Shobha then contended that the appeal in the High Court was not maintainable under Order 43 Rule 1 CPC against an order passed either under Order 6 Rule 17 or Order 41 Rule 27 CPC.

    18. Ms Shobha concluded on the note that since by virtue of the will executed by Bhavani Shankar, neither Subhash Paliwal nor his son had any ownership rights over the disputed shop room, the suit for eviction filed by Subhash Paliwal for the bona fide need of his son was not maintainable being hit by Section 13(1)(h)(i) of the 1950 Act. She urged that the High Court had exercised its jurisdiction erroneously in interfering with the order of the appellate court.

    19. Appearing for the respondents, Mr S.K Keshote, learned Senior Advocate, contended that the submissions made on behalf of the petitioners were misconceived, since even in their written statement filed on 8-12-1998, no reference had been made to the will and the petitioners admitted the respondents to be their landlords and had also contended that the rents for the suit premises were being paid to them.

    20. Mr Keshote submitted that the suit was ultimately decreed by the trial court in favour of the respondents on 3-8-2000, and an appeal was filed by the petitioners herein against the said judgment and decree on 28-8-2000. Thereafter, it was only on 3-9-2002, that an application was made for amendment of the written statement to incorporate the plea regarding the will. By its order dated 13-11-2002, the first appellate court dismissed the said application on the ground that though the fact regarding the execution of the will was within the knowledge of the petitioners even at the time of filing of the written statement, no such plea had been taken till the suit was decreed or even in the appeal when the same was filed.

    21. Mr Keshote submitted that no interference was, therefore, called for with the findings of the first appellate court regarding the lapse on the part of the petitioners herein to amend the written statement during the trial of the suit.

    22. On the question of maintainability of the appeal before the High Court in view of the provisions of Order 43 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Mr Keshote submitted that under the amended provisions of clause (u) of Rule 1 of Order 43, which was brought into effect from 1-2-1977, an appeal against an order of remand under Rule 23-A of Order 41 CPC, is maintainable.

    23. For the sake of reference, the provisions of Order 43 Rule 1(u) CPC are extracted hereinbelow:

    “1. Appeals from orders.—An appeal shall lie from the following orders under the provisions of Section 104, namely:
    (a)-(t)***
    (u) an order under Rule 23 or Rule 23-A of Order 41 remanding a case, where an appeal would lie from the decree of the appellate court;
    (w)***”

    24. Mr Keshote then submitted that having admitted the relationship of landlord and tenant in their written statement, the petitioners could not resile from their admissions and that too at the appellate stage. It was submitted that the application for amendment was not bona fide and had been correctly dismissed by the High Court. Mr Keshote urged that once the prayer made by the petitioners to get the certified copy of the will on record before the trial court under the provisions of Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC was rejected on 22-7-1998, the question of an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC for the same purpose, did not arise.

    25. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties and in view of the introduction of Rule 23-A in Order 43 Rule 1(u) CPC, it can no longer be argued, as has been done by Ms Shobha, that the appeal was not maintainable. We are, therefore, satisfied that the appeals before the High Court were maintainable and had been rightly entertained by the High Court.

    26. As far as Ms Shobha's second submission regarding the bona fide requirements of the son of Respondent 1, Subhash Paliwal, is concerned, we are unable to accept the same in view of the petitioners' own admission in their written statement that Subhash Paliwal and Gopal Paliwal were their landlords in respect of the suit shop room and that they had been paying rents to them till the filing of the suit. In fact, the petitioners would stand estopped from taking such objection under Section 116 of the Evidence Act.

    27. It is no doubt true, as has been submitted by Ms Shobha, that the power to allow amendment of pleadings is very wide and is to be applied liberally. However, in the context of the instant case, such an argument would not be available to the petitioners since, as found by the courts below, they were fully aware of the will in question, but had not even mentioned the same in their written statement and had only made an application under Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC for a direction upon the respondents to produce the same, which prayer had been rejected. It is only at the first appellate stage, and, that too, about two years after the appeal had been filed, that the two applications were made under Order 41 Rule 27 and Order 6 Rule 17 CPC for amendment of the plaint and for bringing on record the certified copy of the will. By virtue of the said two applications, the petitioners attempted to introduce a new story by way of defence in order to prolong the disposal of the appeal.

    28. In such circumstances, we are of the view that notwithstanding the new case attempted to be made out by the petitioners, the same is of little consequence in view of their admission that the respondents, Subhash Paliwal and Gopal Paliwal, were their landlords and that they were paying rents for the suit shop room to them.

    29. The various decisions cited by Ms Shobha quite unequivocally lay down the law relating to amendment of pleadings, but they cannot be applied to the facts of this case in view of the admissions made on behalf of the petitioners that they had been paying the rents for the suit shop room to the respondents.

    30. In view of such admission, little remains to be considered in the present proceedings, notwithstanding Ms Shobha's submission regarding the definition of “landlord” in Section 3(iii) of the 1950 Act in support of her submission that Subhash Paliwal did not fall within the description of “landlord” in the Act.

    31. The special leave petition is, accordingly, dismissed. There will, however, be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jaswant Kaur And Another v. Subhash Paliwal And Others
    (Dec 15, 2009)