AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2008 INSC 617
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Letters Patent Act (no specific section/subsection/year mentioned)
  • Section not specified, Statutory benefits (no specific act/article title mentioned)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2008 INSC 617
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Letters Patent Act (no specific section/subsection/year mentioned)
  • Section not specified, Statutory benefits (no specific act/article title mentioned)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The litigation concerns the quantum of compensation payable for 185 kanals 13 marlas of land acquired from Villages Ratgal, Sunderpur and Palwal, abutting Kurukshetra town, for establishing a Government Ayurvedic College and Pharmacy. The chronology is as follows:

  • Section 4 notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 issued on 08-02-1983; Section 6 notification published on 11-05-1983.
  • Collector’s award dated 30-03-1984 fixed compensation at Rs 40,000 per acre for “Chahi” land and Rs 25,000 per acre for “ghair mumkin” land.
  • On reference under Section 18, the Additional District Judge (27-02-1985) assessed the market value at Rs 15 per sq. yd. (≈ Rs 72,600 per acre) and also granted 25 % severance charges to some owners.
  • The landowners appealed; a Single Judge of the Punjab & Haryana High Court (26-05-1988) enhanced the rate to Rs 20.59 per sq. yd. (≈ Rs 99,668 per acre).
  • Five Letters Patent Appeals were filed. The Division Bench (05-11-1998) considered two 1981 sale deeds and marginally increased the rate to Rs 1,25,000 per acre, maintaining all statutory benefits.
  • The State of Haryana (Civil Appeals Nos. 2461-65 of 2000) and the landowners (Civil Appeals Nos. 2466-70 of 2000) approached the Supreme Court challenging the Division Bench judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Division Bench of the High Court was justified in enhancing compensation from Rs 99,668 to Rs 1,25,000 per acre on the basis of two 1981 sale deeds.
  2. Whether the Division Bench erred in refusing to rely on additional evidence (earlier awards/ judgments—Annexures A-1 and A-2) that suggested a higher market value for comparable land.
  3. What directions, if any, should the Supreme Court issue regarding reassessment of market value.

Arguments of the Parties

State of Haryana (Appellant in C.A. Nos. 2461-65/2000)

  • Contended that the Division Bench had wrongly increased compensation beyond the Single Judge’s figure of Rs 99,668 per acre.

Landowners (Appellants in C.A. Nos. 2466-70/2000)

  • Claimed the land had far greater potential because it abutted Kurukshetra town and lay close to the judicial complex and official residences of senior district officers.
  • Relied on two earlier awards/judgments (Annexures A-1 and A-2) admitted under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, showing substantially higher compensation for nearby acquisitions (1973 and 1981) for urban development projects.
  • Argued that the Division Bench ignored these comparable transactions without adequate reasons, leading to under-valuation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Vasudev Chandrashankar (1997) 11 SCC 218 Earlier awards (within ≈ eight years) in respect of the same village and similar land provide a reasonable base for determining market value. Used to emphasise that the High Court should have treated Annexures A-1 and A-2 (earlier awards) as reliable comparables instead of rejecting them summarily.
Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh (2005) 12 SCC 564 Lands in adjoining villages forming a single developmental unit can be valued uniformly where there is little to differentiate their potential. Cited to support the proposition that the acquired lands, being contiguous to Kurukshetra town, should be valued on par with lands in the earlier awards.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

A. Appeals by the State of Haryana

  • The State had accepted the Single Judge’s rate and never appealed it; its challenge was only to the marginal increase ordered by the Division Bench.
  • The Division Bench merely added 12 % per annum for two years (to cover the 1981-83 gap) based on two unchallenged 1981 sale deeds and evidence of rising prices. The Supreme Court found “nothing wrong” with this cautious approach.
  • Accordingly, the State’s appeals were dismissed.

B. Appeals by the Landowners

  • The Division Bench had allowed the landowners’ application under Order 41 Rule 27 and admitted Annexures A-1 and A-2 but then rejected them with “vague” observations about distance and stagnant prices.
  • The Supreme Court held that, in light of Vasudev Chandrashankar and Harinder Pal Singh, earlier comparable awards for adjacent urbanising land should have been analysed seriously.
  • The Division Bench’s casual treatment of the additional evidence constituted an error requiring reconsideration.

Holding and Implications

State’s Appeals (C.A. Nos. 2461-65 of 2000): DISMISSED.

Landowners’ Appeals (C.A. Nos. 2466-70 of 2000): ALLOWED; MATTER REMANDED.

Consequences:

  • The High Court’s fixation of Rs 1,25,000 per acre stands as the minimum payable; on remand the Division Bench may only revise the market value upward, after reconsidering Annexures A-1 and A-2 alongside other evidence.
  • The Punjab & Haryana High Court Division Bench is directed to decide the remanded matter afresh, preferably within nine months of presentation.
  • No costs were awarded by the Supreme Court.
  • No new precedent was established, but the decision reinforces principles governing reliance on earlier awards and comparable transactions in land-acquisition valuation.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Haryana v. Gurbax Singh (Dead) By Lrs. And Another

    V.S Sirpurkar, J.— This judgment will dispose of Civil Appeals Nos. 2461-65 of 2000 filed by the State of Haryana as also the other civil appeals being Civil Appeals Nos. 2466-70 of 2000 which have been filed by the private parties against the State of Haryana complaining against the impugned judgment dated 5-11-1998 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana.

    2. The subject-matter in all the appeals is common i.e quantum of compensation payable for the lands acquired from Villages Ratgal, Sunderpur and Palwal. The total land which was acquired was 185 kanals 13 marlas. The appellants in Civil Appeals Nos. 2466-70 of 2000 are the landowners. The land was acquired for the public purpose of establishing Government Ayurvedic College and Pharmacy at Kurukshetra. Section 4 notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) was issued on 8-2-1983 while notification under Section 6 was published on 11-5-1983. The award was announced by the Collector on 30-3-1984 who assessed the compensation at the rate of Rs 40,000 per acre in respect of “Chahi” land and Rs 25,000 per acre with regard to “ghair mumkin” land. The landowners applied for a reference under Section 18 of the Act. The reference was accordingly placed before the Additional District Judge who passed his award on 27-2-1985 and held that the market value should have been at the rate of Rs 15 per square yard. Thus the compensation at the rate of Rs 72,600 per acre was awarded by the Additional District Judge besides the statutory benefits. Some of the landowners were given additional compensation at the rate of 25% in respect of their unacquired land on account of severance caused by acquisition. Not satisfied with the award, the landowners filed appeals before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh.

    3. The learned Single Judge vide his judgment dated 26-5-1988 found that the value of the land was Rs 20.59 per square yard and accordingly fixed the market value at Rs 99,668 per acre. Further appeals were filed before the Division Bench by the landowners.

    4. In all five letters patent appeals came to be filed before the Division Bench. Three landowners preferred applications (in the judgment in RFA No. 7 of 1982) for permission to enhance the claim as also to produce additional evidence and the award given by the District Judge in Land Acquisition Case No. 22/4 of 1990. These documents were produced along with applications as Annexures A-1 and A-2. The Division Bench considered both the documents, however, it did not find any justification for the claim made on behalf of the landowners. It, however, considered the two sale deeds executed in January and March 1981, which were on record. It was noted that there was no evidence to suggest that the market value of the land was less than the one evidenced in the two sale deeds. Therefore, the Division Bench ordered an increase of 12% per annum for a period of two years and rounded off the market value of the land at Rs 1,25,000 per acre. The other benefits granted by the learned Single Judge were also maintained.

    5. Now the Government of Haryana as also the private appellants have come up before us by way of the present appeals.

    6. We must first consider the appeals filed by the Government of Haryana but before that we must note that though the learned Single Judge has enhanced the compensation payable to the landowners from Rs 72,600 per acre to Rs 99,668 per acre, the Government of Haryana had accepted that judgment and did not file any letters patent appeal against the same.

    7. The learned Single Judge had noted and taken into consideration Exhibits P-8 to P-16 being the sale deeds, Exhibit P-17 which was an advertisement issued by huda regarding allotment of plots, Exhibits P-28, P-29, R-1, R-2 and R-3 which were the mutations in respect of different pieces of lands in the three villages as also Exhibit P-30 which was the award dated 8-8-1984 given by the Additional District Judge, Kurukshetra in respect of the land which was acquired vide Notification dated 24-11-1978. Thus it has to be said that the Government of Haryana did not have any objection regarding the market value awarded by the learned Single Judge at Rs 99,668 per acre.

    8. The Division Bench has only marginally increased the compensation from Rs 99,668 per acre to Rs 1,25,000 per acre. The Division Bench has merely given the benefit of the two sale deeds being Exhibits P-8 and P-9 in a very limited manner by ordering the enhancement at the rate of 12% per annum for two years since the acquisition in this case had taken place in the year 1983 whereas those sale deeds were of January and March 1981. We do not find anything wrong in this approach. The Division Bench has also justified this increase by observing that there was continuous rise in the prices of land. It has further justified that though the two transactions were in respect of the small pieces of lands, however, the State had not challenged the action of the learned Single Judge in accepting those sales as a valid basis. It has also further observed that there was no evidence that the market value of the land was lesser than the one mentioned in the two sale deeds. All that the Division Bench, however, did was to marginally increase the quantum of compensation by adding 12% per annum for a period of two years and doing so, the Division Bench rounded off the market value for the year 1983 at Rs 1,25,000. We do not find anything wrong in this and, therefore, the appeals filed by the Government of Haryana (Civil Appeals Nos. 2461-65 of 2000) against this marginal increase would have to be dismissed. They are accordingly dismissed. However, the matters do not stop here.

    9. The appellant landowners have, however, filed the appeals as they are not satisfied with the marginal increase ordered by the Division Bench. In fact it is suggested in the judgment that in LPAs Nos. 1213, 1311 and 1312 of 1988 i.e the LPAs filed by the landowners, an application was filed for permission to enhance the claim and to produce additional documents consisting of the judgment in RFA No. 7 of 1992 and the award given by the District Judge in Land Acquisition Case No. 22/4 of 1990. The two documents were filed as Annexures A-1 and A-2 with an application. Relying on those judgments it was pointed out that the land concerned was close to the judicial complex and the official residence of the Deputy Commissioner and the Senior Superintendent of Police.

    10. A look at the judgment suggests that higher compensation was awarded in the two orders, the copies of which were produced by way of additional evidence. It appears that the said application which was under the provisions of Order 41 Rule 27 seems to have been allowed since the Division Bench has specifically referred to those two documents in its judgment. It was seen from those judgments that the land therein was acquired for establishment of an urban estate and was abutting the Pipli-Kurukshetra route. The Division Bench also noted that it was on this land that part of the town of Kurukshetra was established. The acquisition process with regard to this land was completed in 1973, much earlier than the present land acquisition proceedings. So also the land which was the subject-matter of award being Annexure A-2 was acquired in the year 1981. This acquisition was for the development of a city centre.

    11. The Division Bench has merely vaguely mentioned that the present lands are situated at some distance from the lands covered in the above judgments. It is only on this basis that the Division Bench went on to hold that it would not be safe to say that the compensation awarded by the court would be the correct measure for assessing the market value of the land in the present proceedings. Again a statement seems to have been made that despite the acquisition of lands vide Notifications dated 29-6-1973 and 11-3-1981 and the fact that the city of Kurukshetra was developing, the price of land in the three villages had not shown any upward trend. It is on these grounds that the claims made on behalf of the appellants were rejected holding that the said documents could not be made the basis for deciding the correct market value of the land in question. In our opinion this is not the right approach. The Division Bench having allowed the application under Order 41 Rule 27 and having considered the documents in question should not have written the vague finding regarding the distance of the land covered in the judgments and the land covered by the present proceedings. Further, the Division Bench should not have casually observed that the prices of lands in the three villages had not showed any upward trend. We do not wish to comment on these aspects as, in our opinion, it would be better for the Division Bench to apply its mind to the facts and figures covered in the aforementioned judgments.

    12. It has been held by this Court in Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Vasudev Chandrashankar (1997) 11 SCC 218 that the earlier awards which were passed prior to about 8 years would provide a reasonable base for arriving at the correct market value. In the reported decision in the earlier award Rs 2100 per acre was held to be the proper market value, while in the subsequent award in question, the market value was increased to Rs 2500 per acre. This Court approved of the increase by observing that the lands in question were situated in the same village, though on different survey numbers. Some of the claimants are the claimants in the earlier acquisition as well. The Court observed:

    “5. … It is now settled legal position that the award of the reference court relating to the same village of the similar land possessed of same quality of land and potential offers a comparable base for determination of the compensation. The reference court also noted in Paras 18 and 19 the similarities of the lands under acquisition and that they were covered by Ext. 43. No doubt, the lands under acquisition are situated at the outskirts of the village. In the absence of any tangible material brought on record, as regards the distinctive features of differentiation between the quality of the lands situated, the land, subject-matter of Ext. 43 and the lands under acquisition Ext. 48, it is difficult to find out whether the reference court has applied any wrong principle of law in determination of the compensation.”

    13. In another decision of this Court in Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh (2005) 12 SCC 564 where one of us (Altamas Kabir, J.) was a party. This Court while confirming the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Court observed:

    “15. … From the sketch plan of the area in question, it appears to us that while the lands in question are situated in five different villages, they can be consolidated into one single unit with little to choose between one stretch of land and another. The entire area is in a stage of development and the different villages are capable of being developed in the same manner as the lands comprised in Kala Ghanu Pur where the market value of the acquired lands was fixed at a uniform rate of Rs 40,000 per acre.”

    This Court in para 13 of the above judgment took note of the contentions raised on behalf of the claimants that all the lands involved in the acquisition proceedings had similar potential for commercial exploitation and could be consolidated into a single unit where the process of development and improvement had already commenced. It was also noted that there were several mills and factories along with the residential accommodation which had come up in the area and there was little to differentiate between the lands comprised in either Village Kathania or Village Hamidpur and those comprised in the adjacent village of Kala Ghanu Pur, they were equally well-connected by arterial roads. The Court, therefore, declined to interfere with the award.

    14. In our opinion, the abovesaid consideration could practically be applied to the lands in question. The lands are abutting the Kurukshetra town and can easily be said to be a part and parcel of the Kurukshetra town, having a great potential. In our opinion, the Division Bench should have taken into consideration both Annexures A-1 and A-2 and then should have decided the question of market price. Looking at the judgment of the Division Bench we get the impression that the matter has been approached rather casually.

    15. Learned counsel took us through the above two annexures but we are deliberately not making any comments thereupon as, in our opinion, it would be better for the Division Bench to reconsider the matter in the light of what has been stated above.

    16. In the above backdrop we allow Civil Appeals Nos. 2466-70 of 2000 filed by the private appellants and direct remand of the matters to the Division Bench to reconsider the matter in the light of the observations made above. Needless to mention that since we have accepted the first part of the judgment of the Division Bench marginally enhancing the market price to Rs 1,25,000 per acre, that portion will remain untouched in the sense that if so considered appropriate in law, there may be only upward revision in the market price. We accordingly set aside the judgment to the extent that we have indicated above and remand the matter for fresh consideration to the Division Bench. Since the matter has become very old, it would be desirable if the matter is decided as early as possible, preferably within nine months from the date the petitions are presented before the Division Bench.

    17. In the result Civil Appeals Nos. 2461-65 of 2000 filed by the State of Haryana are dismissed and Civil Appeals Nos. 2466-70 of 2000 are allowed and remanded back to the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court for fresh consideration. Under the circumstances we desist from ordering any costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Haryana v. Gurbax Singh (Dead) By Lrs. And Another
    (May 8, 2008)