AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2008 INSC 57
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Secondary School Code
  • Secondary Education Code
  • Section of the Education Code (no specific section mentioned)
  • Master plan (no specific act/article title mentioned, but referred to as 'required by' a judgment)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2008 INSC 57
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Secondary School Code
  • Secondary Education Code
  • Section of the Education Code (no specific section mentioned)
  • Master plan (no specific act/article title mentioned, but referred to as 'required by' a judgment)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Maharashtra regulates the establishment of new primary, secondary, and higher-secondary schools through various Education Codes. In 2000, the Bombay High Court in Gramvikas Shikshan Prasarak Mandal v. State of Maharashtra directed the State to formulate a master plan (2000–2010) before granting permissions for new Marathi-medium schools. English-medium, other non-Marathi medium, and minority institutions were expressly excluded from that requirement.

Because the master plan was delayed, the Aurangabad Bench later allowed the State to grant permissions on a “permanent unaided” basis for academic years 2004-2005 and 2005-2006. Acting on more than 3,000 applications, the Government issued an order dated 16-5-2006 permitting 1,495 new higher-secondary classes/schools on a “permanent no-grant” basis subject to strict conditions regarding infrastructure, fees, and financial self-sufficiency.

The fourth respondent (Maharashtra Rajya Shikshan Sansthan Mahamandal) filed Public Interest Litigation (PIL) No. 2897 of 2006 before the Nagpur Bench, asserting that the 16-5-2006 order violated the Gramvikas decision because the master plan was still pending. Without impleading any of the 1,495 schools, the High Court quashed the Government Order at the admission stage on 7-7-2006. The affected institutions appealed to the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government could grant permission to 1,495 new higher-secondary schools without a finalised master plan in light of the Bombay High Court’s decision in Gramvikas Shikshan Prasarak Mandal.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in quashing the permissions without giving the newly approved schools an opportunity to be heard.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (Permitted Schools) & State of Maharashtra

  • The Secondary Education Code governs new school permissions; District and State Level Committees had verified compliance with all Code requirements.
  • The Gramvikas judgment required a master plan only for Marathi-medium schools, not for English-medium, other non-Marathi medium, or minority-run schools included in the 1,495 permissions.
  • The Aurangabad Bench had already allowed permissions on a permanent unaided basis for 2004-2005 and 2005-2006 despite the absence of a master plan.
  • Quashing the permissions without notice or impleadment of the affected schools violated principles of natural justice.

PIL Petitioner (Maharashtra Rajya Shikshan Sansthan Mahamandal)

  • Contended that granting permissions before finalising the master plan contravened the directive in Gramvikas, rendering the State’s 16-5-2006 order illegal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gramvikas Shikshan Prasarak Mandal v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 2000 Bom 437 Directed the State to formulate a master plan for granting permissions to new Marathi-medium schools during 2000-2010. The Supreme Court held that Gramvikas did not bar interim permissions, nor did it apply to English-medium, other non-Marathi medium, or minority schools; hence the High Court’s reliance on it to quash all 1,495 permissions was misplaced.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that:

  • The 16-5-2006 permissions were issued only after rigorous scrutiny by District and State Level Committees, considering location, existing school density, enrolment statistics, infrastructure, and financial viability.
  • Gramvikas mandated a master plan exclusively for Marathi-medium schools; therefore, the High Court overlooked the fact that many of the 1,495 schools were outside its scope (English, non-Marathi, or minority institutions).
  • Even assuming the master plan requirement applied, the delay in preparing it could not justify denying educational access, particularly when prior High Court orders had allowed similar permissions for earlier years.
  • Natural justice was violated because none of the 1,495 schools were impleaded or heard before their permissions were annulled.
  • The State bears a constitutional duty to facilitate access to education, and permitting privately funded, no-grant schools helps discharge that obligation without imposing financial liability on the exchequer.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court judgment set aside. The Government Order dated 16-5-2006 continues in force, preserving the permissions of all 1,495 schools.

Implications: The decision reinstates operational authority to the newly permitted schools, ensuring continued educational access for students. The Court clarified that interim permissions need not await a master plan where exclusions apply, and emphasized adherence to natural justice when challenging such permissions. No new precedent was set beyond these clarifications.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Superstar Education Society v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

    Order

    The Order of the Court was delivered by

    K.G Balakrishnan, C.J— Leave granted. Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned counsel for the State of Maharashtra (Respondents 1, 2 and 3).

    2. In the State of Maharashtra, there are three categories of schools — Marathi medium schools, English medium schools, other non-Marathi medium schools. Some schools in all three categories are established by religious or linguistic minority groups. Establishment of new primary, secondary and higher secondary schools are governed by the respective Education Codes.

    3. In the year 2000 a public interest litigation was filed in the Bombay High Court complaining that a large number of schools were being started in the State without following any norms. A Division Bench of the Bombay High Court considered the matter in Gramvikas Shikshan Prasarak Mandal v. State of Maharashtra AIR 2000 Bom 437. By judgment dated 11-4-2000, the High Court directed the State Government to prepare a master plan, for granting permission to the primary, secondary and higher secondary schools during 2000-2010, by reviewing and updating the existing State policies and schemes and by incorporating the guidelines suggested by the High Court in its judgment. The decision clarified that the master plan will be only for Marathi medium schools. As regards English medium schools and other non-Marathi medium schools, no directions were issued. It was also stated that schools established by religious or linguistic minorities will not be governed by the proposed master plan.

    4. Due to several reasons, there was delay in finalising the master plan. On considering the reasons assigned by the State Government, the Aurangabad Bench permitted sanctioning of all types of schools including Marathi medium schools for 2004-2005 and 2005-2006 on permanent unaided basis even though the master plan was not ready.

    5. In regard to the year 2005-2006, the State Government considered more than 3000 applications and the proposals/recommendations by the District Level Committees in regard to such applications, and granted permission for 1495 new higher secondary classes/schools by Order dated 16-5-2006 on “no-grant basis”. Such permission was granted subject to the following conditions:

    (i) No financial assistance would be provided to any of the newly approved higher secondary classes even in future.
    (ii) The higher secondary schools should scrupulously follow the orders issued by the Government from time to time, as also the provisions of the Secondary School Code and the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977 and the 1981 Rules framed thereunder.
    (iii) The school administrations should not charge any fee from students in excess of the fees approved by the Government.
    (iv) The school administrations should maintain adequate and sufficient financial position.
    (v) The schools should display prominently a board stating “Higher Secondary School with permission on permanent no-grant basis” and also state in their letterheads “School on permanent no-grant basis”.
    (vi) The societies running the schools should furnish affidavits confirming that they are ready to run the higher secondary classes on permanent no-grant basis and such affidavits shall be permanently maintained.

    In pursuance of such permission, the higher secondary classes were commenced and were being conducted.

    6. When matters stood thus, the fourth respondent (Maharashtra Rajya Shikshan Sansthan Mahamandal) filed a public interest litigation (WP No. 2897 of 2006) before the Nagpur Bench challenging the Order dated 16-5-2006 on the ground that grant of permission to 1495 schools violated the direction issued by the High Court in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437 for preparation of a master plan. None of the 1495 schools which were granted permission, were impleaded as parties to the writ petition. It was contended that the decision rendered in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437 required finalisation of a master plan before granting permission for starting new schools and in the absence of a master plan, grant of permission to start new schools was illegal. The High Court by its judgment dated 7-7-2006, allowed the said writ petition at the stage of admission itself, and quashed the Government Order dated 16-5-2006, on the ground that grant of permission for new schools by the State Government, without preparing the master plan and without fixing any year wise quota for new schools, was in breach of the procedure prescribed in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437, and therefore, illegal. Aggrieved by the order of the Division Bench, several institutions which had been granted permission under the Order dated 16-5-2006 have filed these appeals by special leave.

    7. Though notice was issued to the respondents and served, the writ petitioner in the PIL (Maharashtra Rajya Shikshan Sansthan Mahamandal) has not entered appearance. Though the State and its authorities did not challenge the order of the High Court, they supported the appellants and contended before us that the Order dated 16-5-2006 was validly made. It was submitted that the Secondary Education Code governed the starting of secondary and higher secondary schools; and that permission was granted to 1495 schools by Order dated 16-5-2006, only after the District Level Committees recommended grant of permission to those schools, after verifying that the applicants fulfilled the requirements of the Education Code; that all permissions were on “permanent no-grant basis” without any financial assistance and appropriate conditions were imposed to ensure that the schools were properly run; that the decision in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437 required the master plan to be prepared only for Marathi medium schools and not for English medium or other non-Marathi medium schools and schools run by religious and linguistic minorities; that the High Court had set aside the Order dated 16-5-2006 in regard to all 1495 schools, even though it related to a large number of schools which were not required to be covered by the master plan; and that the High Court had ignored the fact that its Aurangabad Bench had permitted the State Government to sanction schools on permanent unaided basis, even without the master plan, for the years 2004-2005 and 2005-2006. It was also contended that the High Court could not have quashed the permission granted to the 1495 schools, without hearing them and without impleading them as parties to the writ petition.

    8. The objects of regulating permissions for new private schools are: (i) to ensure that they have the requisite infrastructure, (ii) to avoid unhealthy competition among educational institutions; (iii) to subject the private institutions seeking entry in the field of education to such restrictions and regulatory requirements, so as to maintain standards of education; (iv) to promote and safeguard the interests of students, teachers and education; and (v) to provide access to basic education to all sections of society, in particular the poorer and weaker sections; and (vi) to avoid concentration of schools only in certain areas and to ensure that they are evenly spread so as to cater to the requirements of different areas and regions and to all sections of society.

    9. While the decision of the Bombay High Court in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437 directed the formulation of a master plan by incorporating the suggestions made by the Court, it does not bar the grant of permission to schools before the master plan was finalised. At all events, the proposed master plan is not intended to apply to English medium schools, non-Marathi schools and schools run by religious and linguistic minorities. We are also informed that the State Government has already constituted a committee under the chairmanship of Director of Education (Secondary & Higher Secondary), Maharashtra on 24-7-2006 for preparing a master plan.

    10. A perusal of the Order dated 16-5-2006 shows that the permission has been granted only after the proposals/applications were evaluated by the District Level Committees/State Level Committee and necessary recommen-dations were made by such committees. It is evident from the counter-affidavit filed by the State of Maharashtra that these committees evaluate the proposals for schools by taking note of all the relevant aspects including: place (situation) of the proposed school—whether urban, rural, tribal, non-tribal, etc.; population at the place of proposed school; number of primary/secondary schools within a radius of 5 km from the proposed school, and their distance to the proposed school; the enrolment figures relating to 7th and 8th standards within a 5 km area; distance from the similar existing schools within a 5 km radius; the built-up area of school; availability of facilities like sports ground; separate toilets for boys and girls, infrastructure like furniture (benches and tables); library; educational study material; financial position of the proposed school, etc. It is also seen that for 2004-2005 and 2005-2006 the Aurangabad Bench of the High Court permitted the State Government to grant permission to schools on permanent unaided basis.

    11. It is the duty of the State Government to provide access to education. Unless new schools in the private sector are permitted it will not be possible for the State to discharge its constitutional obligation. Permission has been granted to 1495 new schools under the Order dated 16-5-2006 on permanent no-grant basis without any financial commitment or liability on the part of the State Government, even in future, and at the same time ensuring that the schools follow the parameters and conditions prescribed by the Education Code, reserving liberty to the authorities to take appropriate action, should there be any violation. The said Order does not contravene any provision of law. It was not even the case of the writ petitioner that the schools permitted did not fulfil the conditions and requirements relating to such schools.

    12. The High Court has quashed the Order dated 16-5-2006 without even noticing that many of the schools which have been permitted under the said Order, were English medium schools or non-Marathi schools or schools run by religious and linguistic minorities, which were not intended to be covered by the proposed master plan. It also failed to notice that any delay in drafting or finalising the master plan cannot be a bar for new schools being permitted, particularly in view of the subsequent orders of the Aurangabad Bench. When the permission had been accorded and schools had started functioning on that basis, the High Court ought not to have quashed the permission granted to those 1495 schools, without impleading the schools or without hearing them. On the facts and circumstances, the assumption that the Order dated 16-5-2006 violated the order in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437 does not appear to be sound. Even if the High Court wanted implementation of the decision in Gramvikas Mandal AIR 2000 Bom 437, it ought to have directed that the master plan should be prepared within a time-bound schedule rather than quashing the permission granted to 1495 schools thereby denying access to a large number of students aspiring for higher secondary education.

    13. We therefore allow these appeals, set aside the judgment of the High Court. The Government Order dated 16-5-2006 permitting new schools will, therefore, continue to be in force. We however make it clear that if any school is found to have flouted or not fulfilled the parameters prescribed by the Education Code or the conditions stipulated by the State Government in the Order dated 16-5-2006, the authorities of the State Government concerned will be at liberty to take appropriate action against the defaulting schools, including cancellation of the permission. The appeals are disposed of accordingly. Parties to bear their respective costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Superstar Education Society v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
    (Jan 16, 2008)