Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 591
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section [no section specified], of the [no act/article title specified]
  • Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Section 23(3) of the 1950 Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India, Section 33(2)(b) of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 4, Sub-section (4) of the Apprenticeship Act
  • Constitution Bench in MD, ECIL v. B. Karunakar
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 591
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section [no section specified], of the [no act/article title specified]
  • Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Section 23(3) of the 1950 Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India, Section 33(2)(b) of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 4, Sub-section (4) of the Apprenticeship Act
  • Constitution Bench in MD, ECIL v. B. Karunakar
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, employed as a helper at the Kumuli Depot of the appellant Corporation, was accused of stealing Rs 37,086.05 on 3 November 1985. Parallel criminal and departmental proceedings followed. While the respondent pleaded not guilty in both forums, the departmental enquiry found him guilty and he was dismissed after issuance of a show-cause notice.

The Corporation sought the Labour Court’s approval of the dismissal under Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Approval was refused because Clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders—which requires the employer to consider the employee’s past service record and other extenuating or aggravating circumstances—had not been complied with.

During the pendency of the approval application, the criminal court acquitted the respondent. The appellant’s writ petition against the Labour Court’s refusal succeeded before a Single Judge but was reversed by a Division Bench. The appellant then appealed to the Supreme Court under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether non-compliance with Clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders vitiates the employer’s decision to dismiss and bars approval under Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
  2. Whether Clause 17(5) is mandatory or merely directory, particularly in cases of alleged grave misconduct such as theft or misappropriation.
  3. What effect, if any, the respondent’s acquittal in the criminal proceedings should have on the disciplinary penalty.
  4. Whether the Supreme Court should exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Article 136 to interfere with the Division Bench judgment restoring the respondent to service.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Clause 17(5) is not imperative when the misconduct proved is grave; dismissal is the only appropriate penalty for theft/misappropriation, so past record is irrelevant.
  • The Labour Court, acting under Section 33(2)(b), cannot re-appraise evidence or review proportionality; its jurisdiction is confined to verifying procedural compliance.
  • An acquittal in a criminal case does not undermine findings of a domestic enquiry because the standards of proof differ.
  • Relied on decisions such as Janatha Bazar, A.T. Mane, Sapan Kumar Mitra and N. Selvaraj.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The Court should decline Article 136 relief; Clause 17(5) is mandatory and was admittedly ignored.
  • The respondent’s service record is blemish-free, and he has been continuously working since his reinstatement in 1989.
  • The criminal acquittal reinforces the need to set aside the dismissal and was rightly treated by the Division Bench as an additional factor.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Janatha Bazar (2000) 7 SCC 517 Dismissal is ordinarily appropriate for grave misconduct involving misappropriation. Cited by the appellant to justify dismissal without reference to past record.
Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. A.T. Mane (2005) 3 SCC 254 Same principle as Janatha Bazar. Relied on by the appellant.
South Bengal STC v. Sapan Kumar Mitra (2006) 2 SCC 584 Acquittal in a criminal case does not automatically vitiate departmental findings. Cited to argue that criminal acquittal is irrelevant in domestic enquiries.
N. Selvaraj v. Kumbakonam City Union Bank (2006) 9 SCC 172 Same proposition regarding acquittal and domestic enquiries. Relied on by the appellant.
U.P. SEB v. Shiv Mohan Singh (2004) 8 SCC 402 Interpretation of “shall” as mandatory or directory depends on context. Formed part of the Court’s discussion on Clause 17(5).
Sainik Motors v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1961 SC 1480 Cited in Shiv Mohan Singh on mandatory versus directory language. Quoted illustratively.
P.T. Rajan v. T.P.M. Sahir (2003) 8 SCC 498 Words “shall”/“may” are not conclusive for mandatory interpretation. Used to assess Clause 17(5).
Shiveshwar Prasad Sinha v. District Magistrate, Monghyr AIR 1966 Pat 144 (FB) Timelines in procedural statutes may be directory. Cited illustratively in mandatory/directory discourse.
Nomita Chowdhury v. State of W.B. (1999) 2 Cal LJ 21 Same as above. Referenced in the discussion.
Garbari Union Co-op. Credit Society v. Swapan Kumar Jana (1997) 1 CHN 189 Same point on directory provisions. Cited in passing.
Raza Buland Sugar Co. v. Municipal Board AIR 1965 SC 895 Procedural “shall” can be directory if no prejudice occurs. Quoted to show flexibility in procedural compliance.
State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma (1996) 3 SCC 364 Test of prejudice for procedural violations. Used to explain that deviation may be excused absent prejudice.
Venkataswamappa v. Special Dy. Commissioner (1997) 9 SCC 128 Procedural requirement directory when no prejudice. Cited illustratively.
Rai Vimal Krishna v. State of Bihar (2003) 6 SCC 401 Same as above. Cited illustratively.
Ashok Lanka v. Rishi Dixit (2005) 5 SCC 598 Interpretation of mandatory/directory language. Relied on in statutory construction discussion.
Harjit Singh v. State of Punjab (2007) 9 SCC 582 Executive agencies are bound by self-imposed standards. Referred to but ultimately distinguished given facts.
Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India (2007) 4 SCC 54 Natural justice compliance evaluated case-wise. Cited to support fact-specific approach.
State of Punjab v. Sukhwinder Singh 1999 SCC (L&S) 1234 “Gravest act” need not be expressly stated in the order. Used to relax technical wording requirements.
Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Gold Mines (1999) 3 SCC 679 Where facts and evidence are identical, criminal acquittal may bind departmental action. Cited while distinguishing differing lines of authority.
G.M. Tank v. State of Gujarat (2006) 5 SCC 446 Same line as Paul Anthony. Discussed to contrast with present facts.
Commissioner of Police v. Narender Singh (2006) 4 SCC 265 Acquittal not conclusive where standards of proof differ. Quoted as part of second line of cases.
Jasbir Singh v. Punjab & Sind Bank (2007) 1 SCC 566 Acquittal may not upset departmental punishment if additional misconduct is involved. Referenced in discussion on differing lines of authority.
Noida Entrepreneurs’ Assn. v. Noida (2007) 10 SCC 385 Same as above. Cited in the same context.
Narinder Mohan Arya v. United India Insurance Co. (2006) 4 SCC 713 Relationship between civil, criminal and disciplinary findings. Quoted for nuanced approach.
Karam Chand Ganga Prasad v. Union of India (1970) 3 SCC 694 Civil court findings may bind criminal proceedings. Mentioned within Narinder Mohan Arya excerpt.
Krishnakali Tea Estate v. Akhil Bharatiya Chah Mazdoor Sangh (2004) 8 SCC 200 Standard of proof differences between forums. Referenced illustratively.
Manager, RBI v. S. Mani (2005) 5 SCC 100 Same as above. Cited in support.
Delhi Cloth & General Mills v. Ganesh Dutt (1972) 4 SCC 834 Past record can be deemed considered if order so states. Quoted to illustrate factual evaluation of past record consideration.
Transmission Corpn. of A.P. v. Lanco Kondapalli Power (2006) 1 SCC 540 Supreme Court’s Article 136 jurisdiction is discretionary. Used to justify refusal to interfere.
Chandra Singh v. State of Rajasthan (2003) 6 SCC 545 Same principle of self-restraint under Article 136. Relied on for declining interference.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Clause 17(5) in light of general principles distinguishing mandatory from directory provisions. Although the clause employs the word “shall”, precedent shows that its application can be flexible, particularly where strict adherence would cause injustice or defeat the purpose of the disciplinary framework. The Court noted:

  • Procedural provisions—even couched in mandatory language—may be treated as directory if substantial compliance occurs or if deviation causes no prejudice (Shiv Mohan Singh, S.K. Sharma).
  • Grave misconduct cases may justify deviation from Clause 17(5), yet each case turns on its own facts.
  • The respondent had been honorably acquitted in the criminal case, a factor the Division Bench was entitled to treat as mitigating in addition to the unconsidered past record.
  • The respondent, a Class IV employee with no position of confidence, had been reinstated in 1989 and served without blemish for many years.
  • Given these circumstances, and the limited scope of Article 136, interference would be inequitable even if technically permissible.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Division Bench’s decision, leaving the respondent’s reinstatement intact. The ruling underscores the Court’s reluctance to exercise Article 136 jurisdiction where equitable factors favour the workman and highlights that procedural non-compliance—though serious—may not nullify disciplinary action if circumstances warrant flexibility. No new legal doctrine was created; the decision’s impact is confined to the parties.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Pandiyan Roadways Corpn. Ltd. v. N. Balakrishnan .

    S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.

    2. The respondent herein was employed as a helper at Kumuli Depot of the appellant. A criminal complaint was lodged against him for alleged commission of theft of Rs 37,086.05 on 3-11-1985. A disciplinary proceeding was also initiated against him. He pleaded not guilty to the said charge both before the disciplinary authority as also the criminal court. In the disciplinary proceeding, he was, however, found to be guilty of the said charge. He was dismissed from services only after a show-cause notice was served on him.

    3. The appellant filed an application for approval of the said order of removal purported to be in terms of Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short “the Act”). Approval sought for was not granted on the premise that in passing the said order of termination, Clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders of the Corporation, which required the management to take into account the past record before passing the order of dismissal, was not complied with.

    4. During pendency of the said proceedings before the Tribunal, admittedly the criminal court held the respondent not guilty of commission of the charge of removal of the said amount of Rs 37,086.05. He was, therefore, acquitted.

    5. A writ petition was filed by the appellant questioning the said order of the Labour Court which was marked as Writ Petition No. 1485 of 1990. A learned Single Judge of the said Court allowed the writ petition. Aggrieved by and dissatisfied therewith, the respondent preferred an appeal before a Division Bench of the High Court. By reason of the impugned judgment, the said appeal has been allowed holding:

    “14. Unfortunately, the learned Judge while accepting the case of management, committed two errors. The first one is that he proceeded that the charge levelled against the workman relates to misappropriation. It is not in dispute that based on the complaint of the management, prosecution was launched against the workman for the offence of theft, which also ended in acquittal in CC No. 75 of 1986 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate, Uthamapalayam dated 14-10-1987. Secondly, the learned Judge committed an error in holding that when an employee is involved in the case of misappropriation of funds, no lesser punishment than the dismissal from service can be imposed. However, according to the learned Judge when a major punishment is to be imposed depending upon the nature or gravity of the offence, then the factors mentioned in Clause 17(5) of the Standing Orders have some relevance.”

    6. The appellant is, thus, before us.

    7. Mr T. Harish Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, would submit that Clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders of the Corporation cannot be held to be imperative in character. According to the learned counsel, in a case of misconduct involving criminal breach of trust, the employer would be justified in imposing a punishment of termination of services and in that view of the matter, question of looking into the past conduct of the employee would not arise.

    8. It was contended that past conduct of an employee would be taken into consideration, only in the event the misconduct proved is not a grave one. In a matter involving commission of grave misconduct on the part of the workman, it was contended, there is no place for generosity or sympathy and the case has to be dealt with firmly. Reliance, in this behalf, has been placed on Janatha Bazar (South Kanara Central Coop. Wholesale Stores Ltd.) v. Secy., Sahakari Noukarara Sangha (2000) 7 SCC 517 and Divisional Controller, KSRTC (NWKRTC) v. A.T Mane (2005) 3 SCC 254.

    9. The learned counsel argued that it was not a case where the High Court could have taken into consideration the question as to whether the punishment imposed was shockingly disproportionate to the misconduct proved. It was urged that the jurisdiction of the Labour Court in considering the petition under Section 33(2)(b) of the Act being limited; it could not reappraise the evidence adduced in the disciplinary proceeding. Even acquittal in a criminal proceeding Mr Harish Kumar submitted, could not have any effect in a domestic enquiry, in view of the fact that the standard of proof in criminal proceeding and domestic enquiry is entirely different. Strong reliance, in this behalf, has been placed on South Bengal State Transport Corpn. v. Sapan Kumar Mitra (2006) 2 SCC 584 and N. Selvaraj v. Kumbakonam City Union Bank Ltd. (2006) 9 SCC 172

    10. Mr S. Guru Krishna Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent, on the other hand, would submit that it is not a case where this Court should exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. It was contended that Clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders was clearly applicable and the conditions laid down therein must be considered before imposition of punishment keeping in view its cumulative effect. The learned counsel would contend that Clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders is mandatory in character. It was also contended that admittedly past conduct of the respondent has not been considered while imposing the punishment. It was urged that the conduct of the respondent was otherwise blemishless. Our attention, in this behalf, has been drawn to the fact that in terms of the order of the Labour Court refusing to grant approval, the respondent was taken back in service in the year 1989 and since then he has been working in the bank without any blemish whatsoever. The learned counsel would submit that the order of acquittal passed by the criminal court having been taken into consideration by the Division Bench, the same should be considered to be an additional factor apart from the factors contained in clause 17(5) of the Certified Standing Orders.

    11. Clause 17(5) of the Standing Orders of the Corporation reads as under:

    “17(5). In awarding the punishment under this Standing Order the employer shall take into account the gravity of the misconduct, the previous record of the workman and any other extenuation or aggravating circumstances that may exist.”

    On a plain reading of the said provision and particularly in view of the fact that the word “shall” has been used, prima facie it would be construed to be imperative in character. It may, however, be held to be directory in certain situation. While construing a statute of this nature, the context plays an important role. Interpretation of a statute would also depend upon the fact situation obtaining in the case. There are, however, certain exceptions to the said rule. The question came up for consideration before this Court in U.P SEB v. Shiv Mohan Singh (2004) 8 SCC 402 wherein it was, inter alia, noticed:

    “96. Ordinarily, although the word ‘shall’ is considered to be imperative in nature but it has to be interpreted as directory if the context or the intention otherwise demands. (See Sainik Motors v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1961 SC 1480, AIR para 12.)
    97. It is important to note that in Crawford on Statutory Construction at p. 539, it is stated:
    ‘271. Miscellaneous implied exceptions from the requirements of mandatory statutes, in general.—Even where a statute is clearly mandatory or prohibitory, yet, in many instances, the courts will regard certain conduct beyond the prohibition of the statute through the use of various devices or principles. Most, if not all of these devices find their justification in considerations of justice. It is a well-known fact that often to enforce the law to its letter produces manifest injustice, for frequently equitable and humane considerations, and other considerations of a closely related nature, would seem to be of a sufficient calibre to excuse or justify a technical violation of the law.’
    105. Only because the expression ‘shall’ has been employed in sub-section (4) of Section 4, the same may not be held to be imperative in character having regard to the fact that not only, as noticed hereinbefore, a contract of apprenticeship commences but also in view of the fact that an application for registration of apprenticeship contract is required to be made within a period of three months in terms of Rule 4-B of the Apprenticeship Rules, 1992. The Act nowhere provides for the consequences of non-registration.
    109. It is now a well-settled principle of law that if the language used in a statute is capable of bearing more than one construction, the true meaning thereof should be selected having regard to the consequences resulting from adopting the alternative constructions. A construction resulting in hardship, non-fulfilment of the purpose for which the statute has been brought in force should be rejected and should be given that construction which avoids such results.”

    12. Yet again in P.T Rajan v. T.P.M Sahir (2003) 8 SCC 498 this Court observed:

    “45. A statute as is well known must be read in the text and context thereof. Whether a statute is directory or mandatory would not be dependent on the user of the words ‘shall’ or ‘may’. Such a question must be posed and answered having regard to the purpose and object it seeks to achieve.
    46. What is mandatory is the requirement of sub-section (3) of Section 23 of the 1950 Act and not the ministerial action of actual publication of Form 16.
    47. The construction of a statute will depend on the purport and object for which the same had been used. In the instant case the 1960 Rules do not fix any time for publication of the electoral rolls. On the other hand Section 23(3) of the 1950 Act categorically mandates that direction can be issued for revision in the electoral roll by way of amendment in inclusion and deletion from the electoral roll till the date specified for filing nomination. The electoral roll as revised by reason of such directions can therefore be amended only thereafter. On the basis of direction issued by the competent authority in relation to an application filed for inclusion of a voter's name, a nomination can be filed. The person concerned, therefore, would not be inconvenienced or in any way be prejudiced only because the revised electoral roll in Form 16 is published a few hours later. The result of filing of such nomination would become known to the parties concerned also after 3.00 p.m
    48. Furthermore, even if the statute specifies a time for publication of the electoral roll, the same by itself could not have been held to be mandatory. Such a provision would be directory in nature. It is a well-settled principle of law that where a statutory functionary is asked to perform a statutory duty within the time prescribed therefor, the same would be directory and not mandatory. (See Shiveshwar Prasad Sinha v. Distt. Magistrate of Monghyr AIR 1966 Pat 144 (FB), Nomita Chowdhury v. State of W.B (1999) 2 Cal LJ 21 and Garbari Union Coop. Agricultural Credit Society Ltd. v. Swapan Kumar Jana (1997) 1 CHN 189.)
    49. Furthermore, a provision in a statute which is procedural in nature although employs the word ‘shall’ may not be held to be mandatory if thereby no prejudice is caused. [See Raza Buland Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Board AIR 1965 SC 895, State Bank of Patiala v. S.K Sharma (1996) 3 SCC 364, Venkataswamappa v. Special Dy. Commr. (Revenue) (1997) 9 SCC 128 and Rai Vimal Krishna v. State of Bihar (2003) 6 SCC 401.]”

    13. In Ashok Lanka v. Rishi Dixit (2005) 5 SCC 598 it was held:

    “53. The question as to whether a statute is mandatory or directory would depend upon the statutory scheme. It is now well known that use of the expression ‘shall’ or ‘may’ by itself is not decisive. The court while construing a statute must consider all relevant factors including the purpose and object the statute seeks to achieve. (See P.T Rajan v. T.P.M Sahir (2003) 8 SCC 498 and U.P SEB v. Shiv Mohan Singh (2004) 8 SCC 402.)”

    14. There cannot also be any doubt that ordinarily consequences flowing from contravention of an imperative character of a statute have to be given effect to. A statutory provision may be substantive or procedural. If it is substantive, the requirements laid down in the statute should ordinarily be complied with. However, when the provisions contain a procedural matter, substantial compliance thereof would serve the purpose.

    15. Application of a statute or principle of law, however, may vary from case to case.

    16. Only because the statute is imperative, it may not necessarily lead to a declaration that the order impugned is a nullity.

    17. In State Bank of Patiala v. S.K Sharma (1996) 3 SCC 364 this Court has, inter alia, laid down the law in the following terms:

    “33. We may summarise the principles emerging from the above discussion. (These are by no means intended to be exhaustive and are evolved keeping in view the context of disciplinary enquiries and orders of punishment imposed by an employer upon the employee):
    (4)(a) In the case of a procedural provision which is not of a mandatory character, the complaint of violation has to be examined from the standpoint of substantial compliance. Be that as it may, the order passed in violation of such a provision can be set aside only where such violation has occasioned prejudice to the delinquent employee.
    (b) In the case of violation of a procedural provision, which is of a mandatory character, it has to be ascertained whether the provision is conceived in the interest of the person proceeded against or in public interest. If it is found to be the former, then it must be seen whether the delinquent officer has waived the said requirement, either expressly or by his conduct. If he is found to have waived it, then the order of punishment cannot be set aside on the ground of the said violation. If, on the other hand, it is found that the delinquent officer/employee has not waived it or that the provision could not be waived by him, then the court or tribunal should make appropriate directions (include the setting aside of the order of punishment), keeping in mind the approach adopted by the Constitution Bench in MD, ECIL v. B. Karunakarv (1993) 4 SCC 727, (1993) 25 ATC 704. The ultimate test is always the same viz. test of prejudice or the test of fair hearing, as it may be called.”

    18. Ordinarily, although sub-clause (5) of Clause (17) of the Certified Standing Orders is required to be complied with, the same, in our opinion, would not mean that in a given situation, there cannot be any deviation therefrom. In a case where dismissal or removal from service is to be ordinarily followed e.g in a case of grave misconduct like misappropriation, strict enforcement of the rule may not be insisted upon. When, we say so, we are not oblivious of the law that an executive agency is ordinarily bound by the standard by which it professes its actions to be judged. (See Harjit Singh v. State of Punjab (2007) 9 SCC 582, (2007) 3 Scale 553.) But where a procedural provision merely embodied the principles of natural justice, in view of the decision of this Court in State Bank of Patiala (1996) 3 SCC 364 the question as to whether the principle has been followed or not, will depend upon the fact situation obtaining in each case. (See Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India (2007) 4 SCC 54, (2007) 3 Scale 517.)

    19. It will be useful to note that in State of Punjab v. Sukhwinder Singh 1999 SCC (L&S) 1234 this Court has held that the words “gravest act of misconduct” occurring in Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules need not be used in the order of punishment, as it can be found out from the factual matrix obtaining in each case.

    20. However, there is another aspect of the matter which cannot be lost sight of. The respondent, in the meanwhile, has been acquitted. The factum of his acquittal has been taken into consideration by the Division Bench, which was considered to be an additional factor. Ordinarily, the question as to whether acquittal in a criminal case will be conclusive in regard to the order of punishment imposed upon the delinquent officer in a departmental proceeding is a matter which will again depend upon the fact situation involved in a given case.

    21. There are evidently two lines of decisions of this Court operating in the field. One being the cases which would come within the purview of Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Gold Mines Ltd. (1999) 3 SCC 679 and G.M Tank v. State of Gujarat (2006) 5 SCC 446. However, the second line of decisions show that an honourable acquittal in the criminal case itself may not be held to be determinative in respect of order of punishment meted out to the delinquent officer, inter alia, when: (i) the order of acquittal has not been passed on the same set of facts or same set of evidence; (ii) the effect of difference in the standard of proof in a criminal trial and disciplinary proceeding has not been considered (see Commr. of Police v. Narender Singh (2006) 4 SCC 265), or; where the delinquent officer was charged with something more than the subject-matter of the criminal case and/or covered by a decision of the civil court (see G.M Tank (2006) 5 SCC 446, Jasbir Singh v. Punjab & Sind Bank (2007) 1 SCC 566, (2006) 11 Scale 204 and Noida Entrepreneurs' Assn. v. Noida (2007) 10 SCC 385, (2007) 2 Scale 131, para 18).

    22. In Narinder Mohan Arya v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2006) 4 SCC 713 this Court held:

    “39. Under certain circumstances, a decision of a civil court is also binding upon the criminal court although, converse is not true. (See Karam Chand Ganga Prasad v. Union of India (1970) 3 SCC 694.) However, it is also true that the standard of proof in a criminal case and civil case is different.
    40. We may notice that in Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Gold Mines Ltd. (1999) 3 SCC 679, this Court observed:
    ‘35. Since the facts and the evidence in both the proceedings, namely, the departmental proceedings and the criminal case were the same without there being any iota of difference, the distinction, which is usually drawn as between the departmental proceedings and the criminal case on the basis of approach and burden of proof, would not be applicable to the instant case.’
    41. We may not be understood to have laid down a law that in all such circumstances the decision of the civil court or the criminal court would be binding on the disciplinary authorities as this Court in a large number of decisions points out that the same would depend upon other factors as well. See e.g Krishnakali Tea Estate v. Akhil Bharatiya Chah Mazdoor Sangh (2004) 8 SCC 200 and Manager, Reserve Bank of India v. S. Mani (2005) 5 SCC 100. Each case is, therefore, required to be considered on its own facts.”

    23. In Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. v. Ganesh Dutt (1972) 4 SCC 834 this Court stated:

    “31. Mr Sharma referred us to Para 40 of the Certified Standing Orders of the appellant Company Ext. M-4 to the effect that in the order deciding to dismiss the workman, the appellant Company has not taken into account, as it is bound to, the previous record, if any, of the workmen. This contention cannot be accepted because in the order dated May 9, 1966, communicated to each of the workmen, in the penultimate paragraph it has been stated that while arriving at the decision to dismiss the employees from the service for misconduct, all relevant circumstances including the past record of service, have been fully taken into consideration. So far as we could see, no challenge has been made by the workmen that the appellant has not taken into account his past record.”

    24. We are, however, of the opinion that it is not a fit case where this Court should exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. The respondent had been taken back in service in the year 1989. The occurrence took place in the year 1985. The application under Section 33(2)(b) of the Act was filed on 16-6-1986. It was rejected by an order dated 19-4-1989. The respondent, thereafter, was taken back in service. Despite the fact that the writ petition filed by the appellant was allowed on 8-10-1999, by reason of an interim order of stay granted by the Division Bench, he continued in his service. By reason of the impugned judgment, the Division Bench, as noticed hereinbefore, set aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge. The respondent is merely a Class IV employee, he does not hold any office of confidence. He was not charged with an offence of criminal breach of trust.

    25. Thus, it is now well-settled principle of law that this Court shall not exercise its jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, only because it may be lawful to do so. [See Transmission Corpn. of A.P Ltd. v. Lanco Kondapalli Power (P) Ltd. (2006) 1 SCC 540 and Chandra Singh v. State of Rajasthan (2003) 6 SCC 545.]

    26. For the reasons aforementioned, the appeal is dismissed. However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pandiyan Roadways Corpn. Ltd. v. N. Balakrishnan .
    (May 15, 2007)