Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1028
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 32, Constitution of India
  • Section 173, Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 173(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Sub-section (1) of Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Clause (g) of Article 51-A of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1028
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 32, Constitution of India
  • Section 173, Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 173(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Sub-section (1) of Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Clause (g) of Article 51-A of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A public interest litigation concerning the “Taj Heritage Corridor Project” was filed to protect the cultural heritage and ecology surrounding the Taj Mahal. Acting under Articles 32 and 49 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court directed the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to register an FIR on 18-9-2003 and to investigate the involvement of then Chief Minister Ms Mayawati, then Environment Minister Mr Naseemuddin Siddiqui, and various officials.

Following investigation, the Court on 27-11-2006 (M.C. Mehta (Taj Corridor Scam) v. Union of India, (2007) 1 SCC 110) ordered CBI to place its report before the Special Judge, who subsequently required sanction under Section 197 CrPC from the Governor of Uttar Pradesh. On 3-6-2007 the Governor refused sanction. An application by the Court-appointed amicus curiae then sought Supreme Court intervention to examine the Governor’s refusal and related questions. The opinion now summarised decides that application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Supreme Court Bench, in the context of a pending public interest litigation, should examine the correctness of the Governor of Uttar Pradesh’s order dated 3-6-2007 refusing sanction for prosecution of Ms Mayawati and Mr Naseemuddin Siddiqui under Section 197 CrPC.
  2. Whether sanction under Section 197 CrPC was necessary in the circumstances of the Taj Heritage Corridor investigation.
  3. Whether documents relating to sanction are part of the public domain and thus subject to disclosure.

Arguments of the Parties

Amicus Curiae’s Arguments

  • The Supreme Court, as protector of cultural heritage under Article 49, should set aside the Governor’s refusal because CBI might otherwise lose interest due to political pressures.
  • In cases of this nature, sanction under Section 197 CrPC is not mandatory.
  • The Governor’s sanction order should be produced before the Court and treated as a public document.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M.C. Mehta (Taj Corridor Scam) v. Union of India, (2007) 1 SCC 110 Directed CBI to place investigation material before Special Judge; emphasised demarcation between investigation and adjudication. Bench relied on this earlier order to state that all requisite directions had already been issued and need not be expanded.
Vineet Narain v. Union of India, (1998) 1 SCC 226 Concept of “continuing mandamus” and the Court’s role in ensuring proper investigation without taking over prosecution. Court invoked this precedent to confine its role to monitoring investigation, not to decide guilt or intervene in judicial discretion of lower courts.
Union of India v. Prakash P. Hinduja, (2003) 6 SCC 195 Clarified stages of investigation and the role of courts under Section 173 CrPC. Cited in support of the principle that decisions after filing of a final report rest with the magistrate alone.
Rajiv Ranjan Singh ‘Lalan’ (VIII) v. Union of India, (2006) 6 SCC 613 Illustrated instances where fresh PILs were entertained when other remedies were not pursued. Used to suggest that if aggrieved parties do not appeal lower-court orders, a separate PIL—not the existing Bench—may be the appropriate remedy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged its unique role in safeguarding cultural heritage but emphasised constitutional limits on judicial intervention:

  • Public interest litigation should not be converted into adversarial proceedings aimed at determining individual criminal liability.
  • The doctrine of continuing mandamus allows the Court to ensure a proper investigation, not to supplant the Special Judge’s statutory functions.
  • Once a final report under Section 173 CrPC is filed, only the magistrate has jurisdiction to decide on cognisance; appellate or revisional remedies exist if that jurisdiction is misused.
  • Setting aside a Governor’s order in the present context would entail the Court overstepping into the executive domain and pre-empting lower-court review mechanisms.
  • If sanction was legally unnecessary or wrongly refused, the appropriate trial court may rule on that question, and aggrieved parties can seek appellate redress; fresh PILs remain an option if necessary.

Given these principles, the Bench concluded that further intervention would exceed its mandate and disrupt the established criminal-justice hierarchy.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED – The Supreme Court declined to entertain the amicus curiae’s application challenging the Governor’s refusal of sanction.

Implications: The matter remains before the Special Judge, who may examine the necessity or validity of sanction and proceed according to law. The ruling reinforces the limited scope of the Supreme Court’s supervisory jurisdiction in ongoing criminal investigations and preserves the separation of functions between investigation, prosecution, and adjudication; no new substantive precedent was set.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M.C Mehta v. Union Of India And Others

    S.B Sinha, J.— Whether this Bench should consider the correctness of an order passed by the Governor of Uttar Pradesh refusing to grant sanction for prosecution of Ms Mayawati and Shri Naseemuddin Siddiqui is the prime question involved in this application.

    2. A public interest litigation was entertained by this Court in a writ application filed by the writ petitioner. This Court with a view to ensure proper maintenance of cultural heritage of India as also the ecology has been passing orders in the writ petition from time to time.

    3. A project known as “Taj Heritage Corridor Project” was initiated by the Government of Uttar Pradesh. One of the main purposes for which the same was undertaken was to divert River Yamuna and to reclaim 75 acres of land between Agra Fort and the Taj Mahal and use the reclaimed land for constructing food plazas, shops and amusement activities. The said activities on the part of the Government of Uttar Pradesh were brought to the notice of this Court. An exception thereto was taken. A detailed inquiry was directed to be made by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). Upon consideration of the report submitted before it by CBI, this Court in its order dated 18-9-2003 directed it to register a first information report and make further investigation in accordance with law. CBI investigated into the matter, including the roles played by Ms Mayawati, the then Chief Minister, and Mr Naseemuddin Siddiqui, the then Minister for Environment, Government of Uttar Pradesh. Investigations were also carried out against some officers.

    4. CBI was later on asked to furnish a self-contained note as regards its findings against the erring officers and holders of public posts. A detailed report was submitted by it. A question arose as to what directions, if any, should be issued by this Court having regard to the conflict in opinions expressed by different authorities of CBI in regard to Ms Mayawati and Mr Naseemuddin Siddiqui. The said question was considered by this Court in its judgment and order dated 27-11-2006 in M.C Mehta (Taj Corridor Scam) v. Union of India (2007) 1 SCC 110.

    5. Indisputably, the said order of this Court has been complied with. It now appears that the learned Special Judge directed CBI to obtain sanction of the Governor of Uttar Pradesh. By reason of an order dated 3-6-2007 the Governor of Uttar Pradesh has refused to accord the same.

    6. Mr Krishan Mahajan, learned amicus curiae, who has been assisting this Court very ably in the matter, filed an application, inter alia, praying for:

    “In the light of the facts and circumstances mentioned above it is most humbly prayed that this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, direction or order:
    (i) Concerning the legal validity of CBI seeking a sanction for the prosecution of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Ms Mayawati and Minister Naseemuddin Siddiqui under Section 197 CrPC by calling for the records of the materials it placed before the Governor for seeking such sanction.
    (ii) Directing CBI to produce a copy of the June 3, 2007 sanction order of His Excellency the Governor of U.P passed in connection with the case pending before the Special Judge/competent court based on FIR RC 0062003A0018.
    (iii) Passing appropriate directions on the legal validity or otherwise of the June 3, 2007 order of His Excellency the U.P Governor refusing under Section 197(1) CrPC sanction for the prosecution of Chief Minister Ms Mayawati and Minister Naseemuddin Siddiqui in relation to FIR RC 0062003A0018 registered against them by CBI pursuant to the September 18, 2003 order of this Hon'ble Court in IA 376 in CWP No. 13381 of 1984 (2003) 8 SCC 696 and the investigation on which with the opinion of the CBI Superintendent of Police was directed by this Hon'ble Court on November 27, 2006 to be placed before the court/Special Judge concerned for deciding the matter in accordance with law.
    (iv) Declaring that the sanction orders passed under Section 197(1) CrPC are in the public domain and hence cannot be classified as secret.”

    7. Mr Mahajan, in support of the said application, would submit that the task of protection of cultural heritage having been undertaken by this Court and keeping in view the provisions of Article 49 of the Constitution of India, the Court should interfere in the matter and set aside the order of the Governor of Uttar Pradesh refusing to accord sanction to prosecute Ms Mayawati and Mr Naseemuddin Siddiqui, keeping in view the political scenario in the country, as CBI may not show any further interest in the matter at all. It was urged that in a case of this nature, sanction in terms of Section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is not imperative.

    8. No doubt it is a unique case. In exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 32 of the Constitution of India and having regard to Article 49 and Clause (g) of Article 51-A of the Constitution of India, this Court while entertaining the public interest litigation at the instance of the writ petitioner had been taking all steps which have been thought necessary and proper in the matter. The question which, however, has arisen for our consideration is, should we undertake such an exercise. No doubt, a first information report has been lodged at the instance of this Court. Yet again this Court thought it fit to issue requisite directions in its order dated 27-11-2006 (2007) 1 SCC 110 directing the learned Special Judge to apply its mind on the materials collected during investigation by CBI and pass appropriate orders thereupon. This Court has been exercising its jurisdiction in public interest. It has been exercising its jurisdiction to issue a writ of continuous mandamus in the light of the decision of this Court in Vineet Narain v. Union of India (1998) 1 SCC 226.

    9. We have no doubt in our mind that judiciary may step in where it finds the actions on the part of the legislature or the executive are illegal or unconstitutional but the same by itself would not mean that public interest litigation, in a case of this nature, should be converted into an adversarial litigation. The jurisdiction of the Court to issue a writ of continuous mandamus is only to see that proper investigation is carried out. Once the Court satisfies itself that a proper investigation has been carried out, it would not venture to take over the functions of the Magistrate or pass any order which would interfere with his judicial functions. Constitutional scheme of this country envisages dispute resolution mechanism by an independent and impartial tribunal. No authority, save and except a superior court in the hierarchy of judiciary, can issue any direction which otherwise takes away the discretionary jurisdiction of any court of law. Once a final report has been filed in terms of sub-section (1) of Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, it is the Magistrate and Magistrate alone who can take appropriate decision in the matter one way or the other. If he errs while passing a judicial order, the same may be a subject-matter of appeal or judicial review. There may be a possibility of the prosecuting agencies not approaching the higher forum against an order passed by the learned Magistrate, but the same by itself would not confer a jurisdiction on this Court to step in. We should not entertain the application of the learned amicus curiae on such presupposition. A judicial order passed by a Magistrate may be right or wrong, but having regard to the hierarchy of the courts, the matter which would fall for consideration before the higher court should not be a subject-matter of a decision of this Bench. In an unlikely event of the interested parties in not questioning such orders before the higher forum, an independent public interest litigation may be filed. Instances are not unknown where this Court has entertained public interest litigation in cases involving similar question under Article 32 of the Constitution of India. [See Rajiv Ranjan Singh ‘Lalan’ (VIII) v. Union of India (2006) 6 SCC 613.]

    10. It will not be out of place to mention that in Vineet Narain (1998) 1 SCC 226 this Court categorically stated that unless a proper investigation is made, followed by a proper prosecution under the general law applicable to such investigation, the rule of law will lose its significance. This Court in its order dated 27-11-2006 (2007) 1 SCC 110 upon noticing Vineet Narain (1998) 1 SCC 226 and Union of India v. Prakash P. Hinduja (2003) 6 SCC 195 held: (M.C Mehta case (2007) 1 SCC 110)

    “26. Analysis of the above judgments shows that there is a clear-cut and well-demarcated sphere of activities in the field of crime detection and crime punishment. Investigation of an offence is the field reserved for the executive through the Police Department, the superintendence over which vests in the State Government. The executive is charged with a duty to keep vigilance over the law and order situation. It is obliged to prevent crime. If an offence is committed allegedly, it is the State's duty to investigate into the offence and bring the offender to book. Once it investigates through the Police Department and finds an offence having been committed, it is its duty to collect evidence for the purposes of proving the offence. Once that is completed, the investigating officer submits report to the court requesting the court to take cognizance of the offence under Section 190 CrPC and his duty comes to an end. Therefore, there are well-defined and well-demarcated functions in the field of crime detection and their subsequent adjudication by the court. Lastly, the term ‘investigation’ under Section 173(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code includes opinion of the officer in charge of the police station as to whether there is sufficient evidence or reasonable ground of suspicion to justify the forwarding of the case to the court concerned or not. This opinion is not legal evidence. At the stage of Section 173(2) the question of interpretation of legal evidence does not arise. In any event, that function is that of the courts.”

    11. The parameters within which this Court should function in such matters are, therefore, well defined.

    12. It is one thing to say that this Court will not refrain from exercising its jurisdiction from issuing any direction for protection of cultural heritage and the ecology and environment; but then in discharge of the said duty, this Court should not take upon itself the task of determining the guilt or otherwise of an individual involved in the criminal proceeding. It should not embark upon an enquiry in regard to the allegations of criminal misconduct so as to form an opinion one way or the other so as to prima facie determine guilt of a person or otherwise. Any direction which could be issued, in our opinion, has already been issued by us on 27-11-2006 (2007) 1 SCC 110, stating: (M.C Mehta case (2007) 1 SCC 110)

    “34. We, accordingly, direct CBI to place the evidence/material collected by the investigating team along with the report of the SP as required under Section 173(2) CrPC before the court/Special Judge concerned who will decide the matter in accordance with law. It is necessary to add that, in this case, we were concerned with ensuring proper and honest performance of duty by CBI and our above observations and reasons are confined only to that aspect of the case and they should not be understood as our opinion on the merits of accusation being investigated. We do not wish to express any opinion on the recommendations of the SP. It is made clear that none of the other opinions/recommendations including that of the Attorney General for India, CVC shall be forwarded to the court/Special Judge concerned.”

    13. We do not think that we should go beyond the same.

    14. We may observe that while entertaining a public interest litigation in a given case, this Court may exercise a jurisdiction to set aside the decision of a constitutional authority, but we are not concerned with such a situation. We, therefore, are of the view that we need not go further than what we have already said in our order dated 27-11-2006 (2007) 1 SCC 110 to go into the correctness or otherwise of the order of the Governor. If no sanction of the Governor was required or if he has committed an error in passing the said order, the appropriate court, in our opinion, would be entitled to deal therewith, but not this Bench.

    15. We, therefore, are of the opinion that this Bench should not entertain the application filed by the learned amicus curiae. The said application is dismissed with the aforesaid observations.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.C Mehta v. Union Of India And Others
    (Oct 10, 2007)