Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 486
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Notification No. 1093 dated 27-7-1991 issued under Section 4-A of the Act
  • Section 4-A of the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948
  • Central Sales Tax Act
  • State Sales Tax Act
  • The Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax Act, 1948
  • Section 4-A of the Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax Act, 1948 (U.P Act 15 of 1948)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 486
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Notification No. 1093 dated 27-7-1991 issued under Section 4-A of the Act
  • Section 4-A of the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948
  • Central Sales Tax Act
  • State Sales Tax Act
  • The Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax Act, 1948
  • Section 4-A of the Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax Act, 1948 (U.P Act 15 of 1948)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise out of a dispute concerning the extent of tax exemption available to M/s Modipan Fibres Company (“the respondent”), a manufacturer of nylon and polyester yarn, under Section 4-A of the U.P. Trade Tax Act, 1948 and Notification No. 1093 dated 27-7-1991. For the relevant assessment year, the respondent produced 12,222.827 metric tonnes of yarn and reported total sales (including inter-State sales and stock transfers) of 11,782.945 metric tonnes. Its eligibility certificate fixed “base production” at 9,460 metric tonnes.

The respondent claimed exemption on the turnover corresponding to 2,322.945 metric tonnes (total sales minus base production). The assessing authority limited the exemption to 1,321.756 metric tonnes on the ground that base production was not achieved until 4-1-1993 and that exemption could only apply to sales made thereafter.

On appeal, the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals) allowed the respondent’s claim in full. The Commissioner of Trade Tax (“the appellant”) successfully appealed to the Trade Tax Tribunal, which restored the assessing authority’s view. The respondent then filed revision petitions before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, which set aside the Tribunal’s order and reinstated the Deputy Commissioner’s decision. The present civil appeals were filed by the appellant before the Supreme Court challenging the High Court’s ruling.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Notification No. 1093 dated 27-7-1991, a unit that has undertaken expansion/modernisation is entitled to tax exemption on (a) all turnover during an assessment year that exceeds the base production, or (b) only on turnover realized after the date on which the base production figure is first achieved within that year.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Exemption can be considered only after the unit actually attains base production; sales made before that date should not be exempt.
  • Section 7(1) of the Act and Rule 41(1) require filing monthly returns and payment of admitted tax on actual turnover; granting exemption on a yearly, “hypothetical” basis would conflict with these provisions.
  • A harmonious reading of Section 7(1), Rule 41(1) and the notification necessitates first achieving base production before exemption becomes operative.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Clause (6)(b) of the notification permits exemption on turnover “in any assessment year” that exceeds the quantity deemed as base production under clause (6)(a); therefore, the whole year’s turnover should be compared to base production.
  • The statutory scheme contemplates adjustment at the time of final assessment, so monthly return requirements do not impede calculation of exemption on an annual basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court performed a textual analysis of Notification No. 1093, focusing on:

  • Clause (1-B)(a) – grants exemption on turnover of goods manufactured “in excess of the base production”.
  • Clause (6)(a) – defines “turnover of base production” for any assessment year as the quantity up to base production plus leftover stock of base production from prior years.
  • Clause (6)(b) – states that “only the turnover of goods in any assessment year in excess of the quantity referred to in clause (a) shall be entitled to the exemption”.

The Court noted that “assessment year” is defined in Section 2(j) of the Act as the twelve months ending on 31 March. Reading the clauses together, it concluded that the measure for exemption is the turnover for the entire assessment year minus the base production, irrespective of the date within that year when base production is first achieved.

The Court rejected the appellant’s reliance on the monthly return mechanism. It held that monthly filings and provisional tax payments are subject to adjustment at final assessment, and therefore do not restrict the statutory entitlement conferred by the notification. The language of the notification was found “clear and unambiguous,” requiring exemption to be computed on the full year’s turnover exceeding base production.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Dismissed.

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s decision, restoring the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals)’ order that granted the respondent full exemption for the assessment year on turnover exceeding base production. The ruling confirms that, under Notification No. 1093, expanded or modernised units calculate exemption by comparing total annual sales to base production, without waiting to attain base production before the benefit begins. The decision provides clarity on the interpretation of the notification but does not announce a broader new legal principle beyond this statutory context.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Commissioner Of Trade Tax, U.P v. Modipan Fibres Co. .

    Ashok Bhan, J.— This order shall dispose of Civil Appeals Nos. 1760-61 of 2001 and 1762-65 of 2001 as the point involved in all these appeals is common. The High Court had also disposed of the revision petitions by a common order. These appeals are directed against a common order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Trade Tax Revisions Nos. 1071-72 of 1997 whereby the High Court allowed the revision filed by the respondent assessee (hereinafter referred to as “the respondent”) and set aside the order of the Trade Tax Tribunal, Bench No. 2, Ghaziabad (for short “the Tribunal”). Before adverting to the facts, it is necessary to mention a few preliminary facts on the statutory provision of the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948 (for short “the Act”) and Notification No. 1093 dated 27-7-1991 issued under Section 4-A of the Act.

    2. Section 4-A inter alia empowers the State Government to exempt from tax on the sale or purchase of such goods by such person or class of persons, as the State Government may by notification in the gazette exempt. In pursuance of the powers vested in it under Section 4-A, the State Government issued Notification No. S.T-2-1093.XI-7(42)-68 U.P Act 15-48-Order-90 dated 27-7-1991. Under the notification the State Government for the purpose of promoting the development of certain industries in the State granted exemption from or reduction in rate of tax to new units and also to units which have undertaken expansion, diversification or modernisation. To appreciate the submissions advanced by the counsel for the parties it would be appropriate to reproduce the relevant provisions of the notification dated 27-7-1991, which are as under:

    “Whereas the State Government is of the opinion that for promoting the development of certain industries in the State it is necessary to grant exemption from or reduction in rate of tax to new units and also to units which have undertaken expansion, diversification or modernisation;
    Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers under Section 4-A of the Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax Act, 1948 (U.P Act 15 of 1948), hereinafter referred to as the Act the Governor is pleased to declare that—
    (1-A)***
    (1-B) In respect of any goods manufactured in a unit other than the units of the type mentioned in Annexure II, which ‘has undertaken expansion, diversification or modernisation’ on or after 1-4-1990 but not later than 31-3-1995 in the areas mentioned in column 2 of Annexure I, no tax shall be payable or, as the case may be, the tax shall be payable at the reduced rates specified in column 4 of Annexure I, by the manufacturer thereof for the period specified in column 3 of the said Annexure I, or till the maximum amount of tax relief by such exemption from or reduction in rate of tax as specified in column 5 of Annexure I is achieved, whichever is earlier, on the turnover of sales—
    (a) of the quantity of goods manufactured in excess of the base production in the case of units undertaking expansion or modernisation; and
    (b) of goods manufactured by the unit which are of a nature different from those manufactured earlier by such unit in the case of units undertaking diversification.
    (2) The period of such facility shall be reckoned from the first date of production—
    (i) of goods of a nature different from those manufactured earlier by such unit in case of diversification; and
    (ii) of the goods manufactured in excess of the base production in the case of units undertaking expansion or modernisation.
    (3)-(4)***
    (5) Base production of a unit undertaking expansion or modernisation shall be deemed to be—
    (a) maximum production achieved during any of the preceding five consecutive assessment years; or
    (b) 80 per cent of the installed annual production capacity; whichever is higher.
    (6)(a) Turnover of sale of goods in any assessment year to the extent of the quantity covered by base production of that year and the stock of base production of previous years shall be deemed to be the turnover of base production.
    (b) Only the turnover of goods in any assessment year in excess of the quantity referred to in clause (a) shall be entitled to the exemption from or reduction in the rate of tax.”

    3. Facts are taken from Civil Appeals Nos. 1760-61 of 2001.

    4. The respondent, M/s Modipan Fibres Company, deals in production and sale of nylon and polyester yarn. It was granted an eligibility certificate under Section 4-A of the Act in terms of Notification No. 1093 dated 27-7-1991. For the assessment year under consideration, the respondent disclosed total production at 12,222,827 metric tonnes. It disclosed sales of 313.206 metric tonnes in the State of U.P and 1008.55 metric tonnes as inter-State sales. 10,461.189 metric tonnes of goods were shown as stock transfer. The assessee thus claimed that total sale of the goods was 11782.945 metric tonnes. The base production according to the eligibility certificate granted to the dealer was 9460 metric tonnes. It claimed exemption from payment of tax on turnover (for the entire year) of sale of goods weighing 2,322.945 metric tonnes i.e after reducing the base production from the total sale of goods in a year. The assessing authority, however, granted exemption to the extent of turnover on the sale of 1,321.756 metric tonnes of goods. The claim of the respondent was restricted on the ground that the base production was achieved on 4-1-1993 and the exemption from payment of tax can be granted on the sale of goods after the base production is achieved.

    5. Aggrieved against the order passed by the assessing authority, the respondent filed two appeals i.e one under the State Sales Tax Act and the other under the Central Sales Tax Act before the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals), which were accepted by the order dated 4-2-1997. The order passed by the assessing authority was set aside and the respondent was granted exemption on the goods as claimed by it. Feeling aggrieved by the order passed by the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals), the Commissioner of Trade Tax, U.P (for short “the appellant”) filed two appeals being Appeals Nos. 70 and 71 of 1997, before the Tribunal, which by its order dated 24-9-1997 accepted the appeals, set aside the order passed by the first appellate authority and restored the order passed by the assessing officer. Aggrieved by the order passed by the Tribunal, the respondent filed revision petition in the High Court which have been accepted by the impugned order. The High Court has set aside the order passed by the Tribunal as well as the assessing authority and restored that of the first appellate authority.

    6. Although before the High Court a number of points were raised but the only submission advanced before us is as to whether the assessee is entitled to avail of the exemption on the basis of the turnover of sale of goods in an assessment year minus the base production or on the sale of goods after achieving the base production.

    7. Dr. Padia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants contends that the base production has to be achieved first, and it is only thereafter the question of exemption on the turnover of sale of goods in excess of base production can be considered. To support his submission Dr. Padia has referred to the provisions of Section 7(1) read with Rule 41(1) and submitted that the dealer is required to file monthly return on the basis of actual turnover and not on hypothetical basis. The dealer is also required to deposit the admitted tax at the time of filing of monthly return. That in case the contention of the assessee is accepted then the provisions of Section 7(1) read with Rule 41(1) and the notification under consideration cannot be interpreted harmoniously. As against this, Shri Ganguli, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents contends that the facility of exemption can be availed on the turnover of sale of goods in an assessment year in excess of the quantity referred to in sub-clause (a) of clause (6) of the notification. According to him, exemption is to be granted after taking into consideration the turnover of sale of goods of the entire assessment year.

    8. Purpose of granting exemption under the notification dated 27-7-1999 was to promote the development of certain industries in the State. By the said notification, exemption from payment of tax or reduction in rate of tax was granted to new units as also to the units which had undertaken expansion, diversification or modernisation. The units of dealers in all the revisions are units, which had undertaken expansion/modernisation. The units of the dealers (the respondents) are covered by clause (1-B)(a) of the notification. Exemption granted is on the turnover of sales of quantity of goods manufactured in excess of base production. Under clause (6)(a) of the said notification, turnover of sale of goods in any assessment year to the extent of quantity covered by the base production of that year and balance stock of base production of previous years, shall be deemed to be turnover of the base production. Under clause (6)(b) of the notification, the facility of exemption can be availed on the turnover of goods in “any assessment year” in excess of the quantity referred to in sub-clause (a) of clause (6). A conjoint reading of clause (1-B)(a), clauses (6)(a) and (b) makes it clear that the dealer is entitled to claim exemption in respect of the turnover of sale of goods of an assessment year in excess of the base production. “Assessment year” has been defined in Section 2(j) to mean the twelve months ending on March 31. If that be the case then the extent of entitlement to exemption will depend on the sale of goods in the assessment year minus the base production determined under the Act (sic notification). Simply because the dealer has to file returns from month to month and deposit the admitted tax at the time of filing of the return does not mean that the question of exemption on the turnover of the production in excess of the base production can be considered only after the base production is achieved. Returns filed every month and the tax paid would be subject to adjustment at the time of the finalisation of the assessment. Intention of the legislature is clear and unambiguous. Exemption is to be given on the turnover of sale of goods in an assessment year in excess of the base production. We do not find any substance in the submission advanced on behalf of the appellants.

    9. For the reasons stated above, we do not find any merit in these appeals and dismiss the same, leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Trade Tax, U.P v. Modipan Fibres Co. .
    (Aug 2, 2006)