Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 371
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 371
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, Mr. M. Mathivanan, was selected as a Postal Assistant on 28 December 1981 and initially worked on a daily-wage basis. After training he entered the Reserve Training Pool (RTP) awaiting regular absorption. In August 1983 he voluntarily enrolled in the Army Postal Service (APS) and, by order dated 19 August 1983, was appointed as Postal Assistant, Cuddalore, on an ad hoc and temporary basis with specific conditions about seniority and future regularisation. He was enrolled as a Warrant Officer in the regular army from 30 September 1983, pursuant to an appointment order signed by the President of India.

The Department of Posts introduced a Time-Bound Promotion Scheme (TBPS) effective 30 November 1983, granting placement in the “next higher grade” after sixteen years of service in Group ‘C’ or ‘D’. The respondent opted into the Scheme in January 1988, was finally regularised as a Postal Assistant on 18 July 1989, and re-joined Cuddalore Division on 6 August 1991.

In 1999 he sought TBPS benefits, counting his service from 30 September 1983, but the Department rejected the claim, stating he would be eligible only in 2007. His departmental appeal failed, prompting Original Application No. 1094/2001 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Madras Bench. CAT allowed his claim; the High Court of Madras dismissed the Department’s writ petition (WP No. 25452/2002). The Union of India appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted interim stay but ultimately heard the matter on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under paragraph 1 of the Time-Bound Promotion Scheme, completion of sixteen years of service must be regular service or whether any service in the grade suffices for placement in the next higher grade.
  2. Consequently, whether the respondent, having served continuously since 30 September 1983 but regularised only in 1989, was entitled to TBPS benefits from 1999.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (Union of India)

  • Paragraph 1 must be read with paragraph 2; only sixteen years of regular service qualify an employee for TBPS benefits.
  • The respondent’s regular appointment dates from September 1989; thus he would be eligible only in 2005/2007, not 1999.
  • CAT and the High Court misinterpreted the Scheme, and their orders should be set aside.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Paragraph 1 of the Scheme deliberately omits the word “regular”; it requires only sixteen years of service in the grade.
  • He had uninterrupted service from 30 September 1983 and therefore satisfied the sixteen-year criterion in 1999.
  • Supreme Court precedents—Dwijen Chandra Sarkar v. Union of India and Union of India v. V.N. Bhat—support counting earlier service even when transfer was voluntary.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dwijen Chandra Sarkar v. Union of India, (1999) 2 SCC 119 Distinction between “time-bound promotion” and “regular promotion”; TBPS requires only sixteen years’ service in the grade, not necessarily regular service. Relied upon to affirm that para 1 of TBPS confers eligibility after sixteen years’ service, regardless of regularisation date.
Union of India v. V.N. Bhat, (2003) 8 SCC 714 Even employees who transferred voluntarily are entitled to count prior service for TBPS; loss of seniority does not entail loss of other benefits. Cited to reject the Department’s argument that voluntary transfer deprived the respondent of TBPS eligibility.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined paragraphs 1 and 2 of the TBPS. Paragraph 1 covers “placing of officials in the next higher grade” and refers to those who “have completed 16 years of service in that grade”, without qualifying the word “service” with “regular”. Paragraph 2, dealing with Departmental Promotion Committees for promotion, explicitly requires sixteen years of regular service.

The Court held that these are two distinct concepts: (a) time-bound placement in a higher grade (a financial up-gradation meant to alleviate stagnation), and (b) regular promotion involving change of cadre and seniority considerations. Because paragraph 1 is silent on “regular” service, the respondent needed only to demonstrate sixteen years in the grade, which he had from 30 September 1983 to 30 September 1999.

The Court rejected the Department’s contention that voluntary transfer disqualified the respondent, citing Dwijen Chandra Sarkar and V.N. Bhat, which clarified that past service counts for TBPS even when seniority is forfeited. The linguistic clarity of paragraph 1, coupled with these precedents, led the Court to affirm the Tribunal and High Court decisions.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.

The Supreme Court upheld the CAT and Madras High Court orders, directing that the respondent be granted TBPS benefits effective 30 September 1999. The ruling confirms that, for paragraph 1 of the 1983 TBPS, any sixteen-year period of service in the relevant grade—regular or otherwise—suffices for placement in the next higher grade. It reinforces earlier precedent that employees who transfer voluntarily do not forfeit TBPS entitlement, though they may lose seniority for regular promotions. No new legal doctrine was created, but the decision solidifies interpretative consistency regarding TBPS eligibility.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Others v. M. Mathivanan .

    C.K Thakker, J.— This appeal is directed against an order dated 3-4-2002 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Madras Bench in OA No. 1094 of 2001 and confirmed by the High Court of Judicature at Madras on 16-4-2003 in Writ Petition No. 25452 of 2002.

    2. The relevant facts leading to the present appeal are that the respondent herein, Mr M. Mathivanan was selected for recruitment to the cadre of Postal Assistant on 28-12-1981 and was appointed as Postal Assistant on daily-wage basis. He underwent necessary training and was placed in Reserve Training Pool (RTP), Postal Assistant to be absorbed as regular Postal Assistant and was posted to work in the post offices in Cuddalore Postal Division. In August 1983 the respondent volunteered for enrolment in the Army Postal Services (APS). By an order dated 19-8-1983 his request was accepted and he was appointed as Postal Assistant, Cuddalore with effect from 27-8-1983. The appointment was made subject to the following conditions:

    (i) The appointment is purely on ad hoc and temporary basis and candidate will have no claim for regular absorption in preference to his seniors in the RTP list of this division.
    (ii) The inter se seniority between the candidates who volunteered for APS and candidates who were appointed in the civil wing will not be disturbed merely by virtue of the above appointment of volunteers in the civil wing for deputation to APS.
    (iii) If the candidate is declared medically unfit for enrolment to the APS, he will revert back to the RTP list and take his chance for absorption as regular PA in the normal course as and when it is due.

    3. In September 1983, while he was working in Reserve Training Pool as Postal Assistant, he was asked by the Superintendent of Post Offices, Cuddalore division to appear before the authorities for selection in Army Postal Services. Accordingly, he appeared and was selected as Warrant Officer with effect from 30-9-1983. By an order dated 20-10-1983 the respondent was appointed as Postal Assistant in Cuddalore division with effect from 30-9-1983 on the conditions mentioned in the said order. After his enrolment in the Army Postal Services, an order was passed by the Hon'ble the President of India appointing him on the establishment of regular army with effect from 30-9-1983.

    4. It was the case of the respondent that Time-Bound Promotion Scheme was formulated by the authorities vide a memorandum dated 17-12-1983. The instructions were sent to all the Heads of Circles (Postal). The Scheme, inter alia, provided placing of officers in the “next higher grade” who had completed sixteen years of service in Groups ‘C’ and ‘D’. The Scheme came into effect from 30-11-1983. According to the respondent, he had shown his willingness vide letter dated 29-1-1988 for being governed by the said Scheme. It is not in dispute that the respondent was appointed as Postal Assistant on “regular” basis from 18-7-1989. He was transferred to Cuddalore division and joined there on 6-8-1991. In 1999, the respondent made an application to the Superintendent of Post Office, Cuddalore division for granting benefit of Time-Bound Promotion Scheme as he had completed sixteen years considering the starting point of 30-9-1983. He also stated that he was in continuous service from 1983 and as such he was entitled to get the benefit from 30-9-1999. Unfortunately, however, his name was not included in the Time-Bound Promotion Scheme. Finally, he was informed by a communication dated 24-3-2000 that his case for time-bound promotion would be considered only from 2007. His appeal against the said order also came to be dismissed by the Superintendent of Post Offices on 18-10-2000.

    5. Being aggrieved by the said orders, the respondent approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras by filing original application. The Central Administrative Tribunal allowed his application holding that his services ought to have been considered from 30-9-1983 and since he had completed sixteen years in 1999, he was entitled to the benefit of Time-Bound Promotion Scheme. Accordingly, the application was allowed. The writ petition filed by the appellant herein was dismissed by the High Court of Madras which order has been challenged by the appellants in the present appeal.

    6. On 23-1-2004, notice was issued on special leave petition by this Court since there was delay of 155 days in approaching this Court. Meanwhile, however, interim stay was granted against the operation of the orders passed by CAT and confirmed by the High Court. On 12-9-2005, after hearing the parties, delay was condoned, leave was granted, appeal was admitted, while interim relief was ordered to be continued and the appeal was ordered to be expedited for final hearing.

    7. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    8. Mr Parasaran, learned Additional Solicitor General, appearing for the appellants, contended that the Tribunal as well as the High Court committed an error of law in not considering in its proper perspective, the Time-Bound Promotion Scheme and by granting benefit of the said Scheme to the respondent. According to him, the provision in the Scheme is clear and an employee would be entitled to the benefit of time-bound promotion, only if he has completed sixteen years of “regular” service. Admittedly, the respondent was regularly appointed in September 1989 and joined Cuddalore division in 1991. The Department was, therefore, perfectly justified in rejecting the prayer for granting time-bound promotion as according to the Department, he was not entitled to such promotion. He also submitted that the respondent was initially appointed in 1981, but the Scheme required completion of sixteen years of service on “regular” basis. The counsel, therefore, submitted that the order passed by the Tribunal and confirmed by the High Court deserves to be set aside by upholding the action of the Department and by rejecting the prayer of the respondent.

    9. The learned counsel for the respondent employee, on the other hand, supported the order passed by the Tribunal and confirmed by the High Court. He urged that the Scheme had been properly interpreted by the Tribunal and benefit was extended to him which was confirmed by the High Court. He also relied upon decisions of this Court in which similar action had been set aside by this Court by granting benefits to the employees. He, therefore, submitted that the appeal deserves to be dismissed.

    10. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, in our opinion, the order passed by CAT and confirmed by the High Court deserves no interference. It is not in dispute by and between the parties that the respondent was enrolled as Reserve Training Pool Postal Assistant and was appointed initially as Postal Assistant in the year 1981. It is also not in dispute that in 1983, he volunteered for enrolment in Army Postal Services and was absorbed in August 1983 by an order dated 19-8-1983. In the conditions referred to earlier, it was stated that the appointment was purely on ad hoc and temporary basis and the respondent would have no right to claim regular absorption in preference to his seniors in RTP list of the division. It was also stated that the inter se seniority between the candidates who volunteered for such services and candidates who were appointed in the civil wing would not be disturbed. It is also undisputed that pursuant to the willingness shown by the respondent, he was regularised in 1989. But it cannot be disputed and is not disputed before us that he was appointed as Warrant Officer in September 1983. The order passed by the Hon'ble the President of India appointing the respondent as Warrant Officer on the establishment of regular army reads thus:

    “To
    M. Mathivanan
    Greetings
    You are hereby appointed to be a Warrant Officer on the establishment of the regular army, from the 30th day of September, One thousand nine hundred and eighty-three.
    You are therefore carefully and diligently to discharge your duty as such; and you are to obey such orders and observe such directions as from time to time you shall receive from me or any of your superior officers according to the rules, regulations and order for the governance of the regular army.
    Given at New Delhi the sixth day of Magha of the Saka year, one thousand nine hundred and eight corresponding to Tuesday, sixth day of the month of January of the year One thousand nine hundred and eighty-seven AD.
    Zail Singh
    President of India”

    11. The learned counsel for the respondent, in our opinion, is right in relying on para 1 of the Time-Bound Promotion Scheme. Para 1 which relates to placing of an employee in “next higher grade” reads thus:

    “(1) The Scheme will come into effect from 30-11-1983. All officials belonging to basic grades in Group ‘C’ and Group ‘D’ to which there is direct recruitment either from outside and/or by means of limited competitive examination from lower cadres, and who have completed 16 years of service in that grade, will be placed in the next higher grade. Officials belonging to operative cadres listed in Annexure A-1 to the agreement will be covered under the Scheme.”

    12. Para 2 speaks of “promotion” and reads as under:

    “The Heads of Circles/Divisional Superintendents/Heads of other functional units will take immediate action to identify the officials who have completed sixteen years of regular service in the cadres covered under the Scheme as on 30-11-1983 as well as the officials who will complete 16 years of service from 1-12-1983 to 30-3-1984. Thereafter, action will be initiated by the Heads of Circles to convene Departmental Promotion Committee meetings to consider promotion of the officials in the operative cadres to the next higher scale of pay. The Departmental Promotion Committee which will be constituted in accordance with the existing instructions applicable to the different cadres will assess the fitness of the identified officials for promotion to the higher scale of pay. The formalities in this regard should be complete within a period of three months. The promotion to the next higher scale of pay will be granted from the date following the date on which the identified officials complete sixteen years of regular service. In case of officials who have completed sixteen years of service before 30-11-1983, the promotions to the next higher scale of pay will take effect from 30-11-1983.”

    13. Reading of the above two paragraphs makes it abundantly clear that so far as placing of an officer in the “next higher grade” is concerned, what is relevant and material is that such official belonging to basic grades in Groups ‘C’ and ‘D’ must have completed “sixteen years of service in that grade”. The said paragraph nowhere uses the connotation “regular” service. Para 2 which provides for the Departmental Promotion Committee and consideration of cases of officials for “promotion”, provides for sixteen years of “regular” service. The Tribunal, therefore, rightly considered para 1 as relevant and held that basic eligibility condition for being placed in the next higher grade is that the officer must have completed sixteen years of service in the basic grade in Group ‘C’ and Group ‘D’. Though in other paragraphs, the service was qualified by the adjective “regular”, the said qualification was not necessary for the purpose of para 1. Since the employee wanted the benefit of placement in “next higher grade”, what was required to be established by him was that he had completed sixteen years of service in the grade and the said requirement had been complied with in view of the fact that with effect from 30-9-1983 he was appointed as Warrant Officer. He was, therefore, entitled to the benefit of “next higher grade” under para 1 from 1999. The authorities were, therefore, not justified in rejecting the claim and accordingly the petition was allowed. The High Court rightly upheld the direction of CAT.

    14. The learned counsel for the respondent is also right in placing reliance on the decision of this Court in Dwijen Chandra Sarkar v. Union of India (1999) 2 SCC 119. Almost in similar circumstances, the Court considered the extent and applicability of Time-Bound Promotion Scheme and held that the benefit of the said Scheme would be available to a person who had completed “sixteen years of service” in the grade. In that case, two appellants were working in the Posts and Telegraphs Department and they had claimed the benefit of the Scheme. Initially, they were serving to the Rehabilitation Department of the Government of India, but were transferred to the Department of Posts and Telegraphs afterwards. The question before the Court was whether the appellants were entitled to count the services rendered by them earlier in the Rehabilitation Department of the Government of India and whether they would be entitled to the benefit of the Scheme by taking into account past services. The Court considered the scheme of December 1983 and held that what was required under the Scheme was completion of sixteen years of service in that grade. If the said requirement is complied with, an employee would be entitled to be placed in the next higher grade. It was observed that two concepts, namely, (i) “time-bound promotion”, and (ii) “regular promotion” were different. So far as the “time-bound promotion” was concerned, the Court observed that since there were large number of employees who were not likely to get promotion in the near future because of their comparatively low position in the seniority, the Government thought it necessary that in order to remove frustration, the employees should be placed in the “next higher grade” in terms of emoluments while retaining them in the same cadre. This is what is generally known as the “time-bound promotion”. Such “time-bound promotion” does not affect seniority of those higher up.

    15. The Court then stated:

    “12. If that be the true purpose of a time-bound promotion which is meant to relieve frustration on account of stagnation, it cannot be said that the Government wanted to deprive the appellants who were brought into the P&T Department in public interest — of the benefit of a higher grade. The frustration on account of stagnation is a common factor not only of those already in the P&T Department but also of those who are administratively transferred by the Government from the Rehabilitation Department to the P&T Department. The Government while imposing an eligibility condition of 16 years' service in the grade for being entitled to time-bound promotion, is not intending to benefit only one section of employees in the category and deny it to another section of employees in the same category. (emphasis supplied) The common factor for all these employees is that they have remained in the same grade for 16 years without promotions. The said period is a term of eligibility (emphasis in original) for obtaining a financial benefit of a higher grade.”

    The Court added that for the purpose of “regular promotions” to the higher cadre in the Department, their seniority should be counted only from the date of their transfer in the Posts and Telegraphs Department.

    16. The Court, therefore, concluded:

    “14. The words ‘except seniority’ in the 1983 circular, in our view, mean that such a benefit of a higher grade given to the transferees will in no way affect the seniority of employees in the P&T Department when the turn of the P&T employees comes up for promotion to a higher category or post. The said words ‘except seniority’ are intended to see that the said persons who have come from another department on transfer do not upset the seniority in the transferee department. Granting them higher grade under the Scheme for time-bound promotion does not, therefore, offend the condition imposed in the transfer order. We are, therefore, of the view that the appellants are entitled to the higher grade from the date on which they have completed 16 years and the said period is to be computed on the basis of their total service both in the Rehabilitation Department and the P&T Department.”

    17. It is no doubt true as observed by the High Court that Dwijen Chandra Sarkar (1999) 2 SCC 119 was not an identical case, inasmuch as in that case, the appellants were transferred “in public interest”, whereas in the instant case, the transfer was volunteered by the respondent employee for enrolment in army. That, however, in our opinion, does not make difference since to us, the language of para 1 of the Scheme is clear, unambiguous and leaves no room for doubt. That aspect was also considered in Dwijen Chandra Sarkar (1999) 2 SCC 119. But, in any case, even that point is also finally concluded by another decision of this Court in Union of India v. V.N Bhat (2003) 8 SCC 714 in which the employee was initially appointed in the Ministry of Defence and voluntarily transferred himself to the office of the Post Master General. The question which came up for consideration was as to whether he would be entitled to get benefit of the Scheme. Relying on Dwijen Chandra Sarkar (1999) 2 SCC 119 this Court held that the employee would be entitled to the benefit of the Scheme on completion of sixteen years of service.

    18. Relying on Dwijen Chandra Sarkar (1999) 2 SCC 119 this Court observed: (V.N Bhat case (2003) 8 SCC 714)

    “The well-settled principle of law that even in the case where the transfer has been allowed on request, the employee concerned merely loses his seniority, but the same by itself would not lead to a conclusion that he should be deprived of the other benefits including his experience and eligibility for promotion. In terms of the Schemes aforementioned, promotion is to be granted for avoiding stagnation only within the said parties. The said Schemes have been framed because they are beneficial ones and are thus required to be implemented. The Scheme merely perused that any person having rendered 16/26 years of service without obtaining any promotion could be entitled to the benefit therefor. It is, therefore, not a case where promotion to the higher post is to be made only on the basis of seniority.”

    19. Since the respondent had completed sixteen years of service in 1999, he would be entitled to the benefit of para 1 of the Time-Bound Promotion Scheme and the action of the authorities in not granting the said benefit was illegal and contrary to law. The Central Administrative Tribunal as well as the High Court were, therefore, right in setting aside the said action and by directing the authorities to extend the benefit of the Scheme to the respondent. We see no infirmity in the reasoning adopted and conclusion recorded by CAT or by the High Court and find no substance in the appeal of the appellants.

    20. For the foregoing reasons, the appeal deserves to be dismissed and is accordingly dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. M. Mathivanan .
    (Jun 9, 2006)