AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 4(1) notification of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 4(1) notification of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation (U.P. SIDC) required large tracts of land for planned industrial development. A notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued on 25-04-1972. The Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) passed an award on 30-11-1976, fixing the market value at Rs 2 per square yard. Dissatisfied landowners sought references under Section 18 of the Act.

The Reference Court delivered multiple decisions: some references were rejected while others resulted in enhancement to Rs 8 per square yard. On further appeals, the High Court fixed the value at Rs 8 or Rs 9 per square yard, depending on location. U.P. SIDC appealed to the Supreme Court challenging these High Court enhancements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in enhancing the market value of the acquired lands from Rs 2 to Rs 8/9 per square yard.
  2. Whether the sale deed dated 28-05-1971 relied upon by the SLAO provided an accurate benchmark for valuation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (U.P. SIDC)

  • The High Court wrongly enhanced the rate; the SLAO had correctly relied on a sale deed of 28-05-1971 (executed shortly before the Section 4(1) notification) evidencing value at Rs 2 per square yard.
  • The acquired lands were largely agricultural, some containing deep pits, and therefore could not be valued as developed industrial plots.
  • The High Court’s reliance on its earlier judgment in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984 was misplaced, as the validity of that very judgment was under challenge before the Supreme Court.

Respondents (Landowners)

  • The SLAO wrongly treated the lands as purely agricultural despite acknowledging their industrial potential.
  • The sale deed of 28-05-1971 concerned inferior land with ten-foot-deep pits located away from the bypass road and was therefore not a reliable exemplar.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reviewed the High Court’s detailed re-appreciation of evidence conducted in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984. Key findings accepted by the Court included:

  • The acquired land abutted the Ghaziabad Bypass Road, enjoyed proximity to existing industrial areas, and possessed clear building potential.
  • The sale deed of 28-05-1971 concerned land with significant physical disadvantages (deep pits, inferior location) and was therefore unsuitable for valuation comparison.
  • The Reference Court erred in ignoring sworn testimony about the land’s advantageous location and instead relied on counsel’s argument.

Given these factual determinations, the Court held that the High Court’s valuations of Rs 9 and Rs 8 per square yard were neither arbitrary nor unreasonable.

Holding and Implications

Appeals dismissed; High Court awards affirmed.

The compensation payable to landowners remains at the enhanced rates fixed by the High Court (Rs 9 or Rs 8 per square yard, as applicable). The judgment resolves the dispute between the parties but sets no new precedent beyond affirming the evidentiary weight of comparable sales and land potentiality in valuation assessments.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    U.P State Industrial Development Corpn. Ltd. v. Shakti Bhatta Udyog And Others

    Shivaraj V. Patil, J.— These appeals are by U.P State Industrial Development Corporation (U.P SIDC) questioning the validity and correct-ness of the impugned judgments of the High Court enhancing the amount of compensation and fixing the market value of the lands acquired at the rate of Rs 8 or Rs 9 per square yard, as the case may be. Large extent of land was notified for acquisition for U.P SIDC for planned development of industries. In that regard notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short “the Act”) was published on 25-4-1972. The Special Land Acquisition Officer passed award on 30-11-1976 fixing the market value of the lands at the rate of Rs 2 per square yard. Some landowners, not being satisfied with the market value so fixed, made applications to the Collector under Section 18 of the Act for making reference. The Reference Court, by its judgment dated 2-9-1980, rejected six References Nos. 4, 5, 6, 8, 11 and 12 of 1977, upholding the market value of the lands fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer finding that there was no evidence to enhance the market value. The Reference Court in References Nos. 7, 9, 45 and 100 of 1977 enhanced the market value of lands to Rs 8 per square yard by its common judgment dated 18-12-1981. The Reference Court in References Nos. 21, 25, 32 and 42 of 1977 rejected the references affirming the market value of the lands awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer. The High Court in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984, filed against the order made by the Reference Court in LAR No. 32 of 1977, and in First Appeal No. 537 of 1980, arising out of the order passed in LAR No. 21 of 1977, enhanced the market value of lands to Rs 9 per square yard and in First Appeals Nos. 536 of 1980 and 548 of 1994 arising out of LARs Nos. 25 and 42 of 1977 enhanced the compensation to Rs 8 per square yard. Hence these appeals as already stated above.

    2. The learned counsel for the appellants urged that the High Court was not right and justified in enhancing the market value of the lands acquired at the rate of Rs 8 or Rs 9 per square yard, as the case may be, as against the rate of Rs 2 per square yard fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer; Section 4(1) notification was issued on 25-4-1972 for acquiring the lands in question and the Land Acquisition Officer was right in relying upon the relevant material, evidence contained in sale deed dated 28-5-1971 executed a few months prior to issuance of Section 4(1) notification, that too executed by two of the claimants. According to the learned counsel, on the basis of this sale deed the Land Acquisition Officer rightly fixed the market value of the lands in question at the rate of Rs 2 per square yard; the High Court failed to notice that the lands in question were agricultural lands and in some of the lands there were deep pits; they could not have been valued on the basis of the developed lands for the purpose of industrial sites. The learned counsel also urged that the High Court relied on the judgment passed in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984. This judgment was followed in First Appeals Nos. 536-37 of 1980 in respect of some of the lands acquired under the very same Section 4(1) notification. But the correctness and validity of the judgment in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984 is itself under challenge in one of these appeals; although special leave petition filed against this judgment was rejected, later it was reviewed, leave was granted and the special leave petition is now registered as Civil Appeal No. 7121 of 2000.

    3. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents argued in support of the impugned judgments. They urged that the Special Land Acquisition Officer committed an error in taking the lands as agricultural lands in fixing the market value even after noticing their potentialities.

    4. The High Court in the common impugned judgment dated 10-12-1999 in First Appeal No. 225 of 1982 and connected appeals pointed out to the following observations of the Land Acquisition Officer, made in the “award” dated 30-11-1976:

    “The area under acquisition is on Howrah-Delhi main double line of Northern Railway and some of the industries had already been established in its surroundings. This area is adjoining to the industrial areas of Ghaziabad and this area is being acquired for establishing more industrial units. In these circumstances, the disputed land has building potentiality and it is appropriate to award the market value on the special rate of per sq yard.”

    As to the sale deed dated 28-5-1971, referred to above in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984, infirmities were pointed out and reasons were recorded for rejecting it, observing thus:

    “In the cross-examination, PW 1 Shri Rajendra Kumar, stated to have seen the land covered by the sale deed (Ext. A-1) filed by the State and he denied that such land was levelled and he stated that it entertained ten-feet-deep pits. He, further denied that the land covered by Ext. A-1 was very near to the land in question. On the contrary, it was stated to be at a distance. In the evidence adduced on behalf of the opposite parties, there is no whisper or assertion that the land covered by Ext. A-1 was levelled or was close to the appellant's land. In such circumstances, reliance upon the sale deed dated 28-5-1971, in respect of land, which was away from the land in question and which had pits ten-feet-deep, cannot be upheld.
    In this regard, one more patent error committed by the Reference Court, is apparent. The Reference Court observed that:
    ‘This is noteworthy that there is no highway near this land. During the course of arguments, the counsel for the opposite party has, however, admitted that a bypass was not in existence, when Section 4(1) notification was made, so the question that the value increased because of existence of this road in the year 1972, does not arise.’
    Curiously enough, to draw the inference about the non-existence of the bypass road, the Reference Court relied upon the argument of the counsel for the opposite parties, instead of the statement on oath of PW 1 Shri Rajendra Kumar, who categorically stated that the disputed land abutted Ghaziabad Bypass Road. In cross-examination also, he reiterated this fact. To ignore the statement on oath and to rely on an argument, that too of the counsel for the opposite parties, cannot be said as legal. The abuttance of the land in question to Ghaziabad Bypass Road on the basis of evidence on record, is evident.”

    It was further observed:

    “The Reference Court clearly erred in relying upon Ext. A-1 without considering the fact that it had ten-feet-deep pits; it was at a distance from the land in question and also it did not abut to the bypass road, while the land in question abutted to Ghaziabad Bypass Road, surrounded by abadis and without pits. In view of proved superiority of the land in question, both in location and quality, it deserved a much higher rate, than Rs 2 per sq yard at which the land covered by Ext. A-1 was transacted.”

    The High Court, after reappreciation of the entire material placed on record in the abovesaid First Appeal No. 808 of 1984, concluded thus:

    “Keeping in view the entirety of facts, circumstances and the attending features, I am satisfied that it would be just, proper and befitting, if the market value of the land in question is assessed at the rate of Rs 9 per sq yard.”

    5. Having regard to the facts found and reasons recorded by the High Court in First Appeal No. 808 of 1984 it cannot be said that the market value of the lands fixed by the High Court at the rate of Rs 9 per square yard in the impugned judgment is either unreasonable or arbitrary. No fault can be found with fixing the market value at the rate of Rs 8 per square yard by the High Court in First Appeals Nos. 548 of 1994 and 536 of 1980 having regard to the location and other factors as stated in the judgment of the High Court.

    6. Thus, having regard to all aspects of the matter and keeping in view the facts and circumstances and the reasons recorded by the High Court in the impugned judgments, we do not find any merit in these appeals. Consequently, these appeals stand dismissed, but with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    U.P State Industrial Development Corpn. Ltd. v. Shakti Bhatta Udyog And Others
    (Aug 19, 2004)