Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2003 INSC 727
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 18 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 54 of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2003 INSC 727
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 18 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 54 of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Madhya Pradesh acquired land in the town of Mhow for the benefit of the Union of India under Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The acquired parcels contained houses and other structures owned by the landholders. In determining compensation, the Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) deducted 5% from the value of the houses as depreciation. At the behest of the landowners, the matter was referred under Section 18 of the Act. The Reference Court held that no depreciation should be applied and directed payment of the full value of the houses. The Union of India appealed to the Madhya Pradesh High Court, which upheld the Reference Court’s award and also rejected any deduction for materials purportedly removed by the owners. The Union then appealed to the Supreme Court, raising the same two questions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under para 44 of the Madhya Pradesh Land Acquisition Manual, a deduction for depreciation can be made from the present value of houses/structures while computing compensation.
  2. Whether, under paras 43 and 44 of the Manual, the value of building materials should be deducted from compensation where the owner has been given—and has exercised—an option to remove such materials.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant – Union of India

  • The age of the buildings must be considered; therefore a depreciation allowance is mandatory.
  • Para 43 gives owners an option to remove buildings or trees; once exercised, the value of removed materials must be deducted from compensation.
  • A letter from the LAO allegedly proves that owners were given this option and did remove materials.

Respondent – Claimant Landowners

  • Para 44 mandates compensation based on the present value of materials and current construction costs, leaving no room for any depreciation deduction.
  • Many owners did not remove any materials; hence no deduction can be made under para 43.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mysore Minerals Ltd. v. CIT (1999) 7 SCC 106 Definition and conceptual understanding of “depreciation.” Referenced to explain that depreciation reflects diminution in value due to wear and tear, reinforcing the Court’s analysis of whether such a deduction is compatible with para 44.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Depreciation Issue: Para 44 requires compensation to be calculated on (a) the present value of materials and (b) the cost of construction at current rates, less the value of any materials made over to the proprietor. Because both elements are based on “present” values, the Court held that once those present values are used, there is “no scope for making any further deduction” for depreciation. The Court contextualised the meaning of “depreciation” by citing definitions from Black’s Law Dictionary and other valuation literature, ultimately concluding that the Union’s request for a 5% deduction lacked substance.

Deduction for Removed Materials: Para 43 allows the Government, if it does not require the structures, to give the owner an option to remove them, with the value of the removed materials deducted from compensation. Para 44 then directs that the value of any materials “made over to the proprietor” must likewise be deducted. The Court noted that factual clarity on whether (1) the option was actually given and (2) materials were in fact removed was indispensable. The Union produced a letter and affidavits asserting removal; the landowners disputed this. Neither the Reference Court nor the High Court had examined these materials. Accordingly, this factual issue required reconsideration.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeals are ALLOWED IN PART. The claim for depreciation is rejected, but the matter is remitted to the Reference Court to determine, after giving both parties an opportunity to adduce evidence, whether any materials were removed under para 43 and, if so, what deduction should be made. No order as to costs.

Implications: The ruling affirms that, under para 44, depreciation deductions are impermissible when compensation is already based on present value and current construction costs. However, deductions for removed materials remain possible, contingent upon factual proof before the Reference Court. The decision sets no new legal precedent on valuation methodology beyond clarifying the application of paras 43 and 44, but it may influence similar land acquisition cases in Madhya Pradesh where the question of removal of structures arises.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India v. Savjiram And Another

    Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

    2. In these appeals, two interesting questions of primal importance arise for consideration. They relate to paras 43 and 44 of the Land Acquisition Manual of Madhya Pradesh (in short “the Manual”) applicable to valuation of lands acquired in the State of Madhya Pradesh.

    3. Background facts sans unnecessary details are as follows:

    In exercise of powers under Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (in short “the Act”), the State of Madhya Pradesh acquired certain lands for the benefit of the Union of India in the town of Mhow. On these acquired lands, landowners had also constructed their houses or structures. In the proceedings for determination of compensation before the Land Acquisition Officer (in short “the LAO”) in respect of land and the houses/structures standing on the land, one of the questions that arose was as to how the valuation of houses/structures was to be made. The LAO determined the compensation of the houses after deducting 5% towards depreciation. According to the LAO, the houses are also subject to depreciation and accordingly, he deducted 5% from the total valuation of houses and compensation insofar as it related to houses was determined.

    4. At the instance of the landowners, the matter was referred to the civil court under Section 18 of the Act. Before the civil court, the landowners' contention was that the LAO erred in deducting 5% by way of depreciation from the value of the houses. According to them, there was no need to deduct 5% by way of depreciation. The learned Reference Judge accepted the aforesaid contention of the landowners. In his opinion, there was no question of any deduction of depreciation while calculating the valuation of houses. Accordingly, the direction to deduct 5% by way of depreciated value of houses was held to be bad and it was directed that the landowners will get the full valuation of houses without deduction of 5% as determined by the LAO. This is what the learned Reference Court held in favour of the landowners in para 13 of its award:

    “Therefore, he has right to get the amount on account of 5% depreciation which has been deducted from the amount of award.”

    5. Against the award of the LAO, the Union of India filed an appeal before the Madhya Pradesh High Court under Section 54 of the Act. Essentially two points were raised before the High Court. The first question related to the question regarding grant of depreciation. The other related to the question about the deductions, if any, to be made for the value of the materials made over to the original proprietor of the land acquired. The High Court found that there was no scope for any determination for depreciation and also for making any deduction for the value of materials made over. Accordingly, the appeal filed by the Union of India was dismissed.

    6. In the present appeals, the two points urged before the High Court were reiterated with reference to paras 43 and 44 of the Manual. It was submitted that while making the valuation, the age of the building has necessarily to be taken note of and, therefore, depreciation has to be granted perforce. So far as the value of materials made over to the proprietors is concerned, it is submitted that in terms of para 43, option is given to the owner to remove any house, building or trees standing on the land to be acquired and the value of such materials as determined in the award has to be deducted from the compensation. In the instant case, option was given to the landowners who had removed the materials. Reference is made to a letter of the LAO, Mhow, District Indore in this regard. In essence, therefore, the stand is that the valuation as done by the Reference Court is unsustainable.

    7. Per contra, learned counsel for the claimant-landowners submitted that there is no scope for any depreciation when the present market value is to be determined in terms of para 44. It is the valuation of the land along with infrastructure standing thereon which has to be valued. There is no question of making any deduction on the ground of depreciation for any property permitted and purported to be removed. It was further urged that a large number of claimants did not remove anything and this was found to be factually the position by the Reference Court.

    8. For deciding the issue relating to grant of depreciation and deduction of materials, paras 43 and 44 of the Manual need to be quoted. They read as follows:

    “43. If any house, building or trees standing on the land to be acquired should not be required by the Government, the owner may be allowed the option of removing it within a reasonable period, to be fixed by the Collector, in which case the value of such materials, as determined in the award, will be deducted from the sum payable as compensation, or if compensation has been already paid will be recovered from the owner prior to the removal of the materials.
    44. Compensation for houses or buildings should be calculated on the present value of the materials plus cost of construction at present rates, less the value of any materials made over to the proprietor:
    Provided that, if the buildings have fallen into disuse, compensation should be allowed on the present value of the materials only. Separate compensation should be given for the land on which the buildings stand.
    When, however, the building and its site together constitute a single property, having a market value as a whole it is unnecessary to go into details of cost of construction, value of materials and value of site. The market value of the property as a whole can be ascertained with reference to the rent that it brings in to the owner, or with reference to the ascertained sale price of similar buildings and their sites.”

    9. A bare reading of para 44 shows that it is a method of calculation indicated relating to the computation of the compensation. The compensation for houses and buildings are required to be calculated on (a) the present value of materials, and (b) in addition to the cost of construction at present rates. Both the components for working out the compensation relate to present value of the materials and cost of construction at present rates less the value of any materials made over to the proprietor. Obviously, the calculation has to be done on the basis of the present value or the present rates, as the case may be. The expression “present” means in existence at the time at which something is spoken or written, being in a specified place, thing. Grammatically, it means denoting a tense of verbs used when the action or event described is occurring at the time of utterance or when the speaker does not wish to make any explicit temporal reference. It also means for the time being, now. Commonly, it denotes existence of a particular thing or a matter at the time of consideration. Obviously, therefore, after arriving at the cost of construction at the prevalent rate at the time of fixing the compensation or working out the value of the materials there is no scope for making any further deduction.

    10. Generally speaking, depreciation is an allowance for the diminution in the value due to wear and tear of capital asset employed by an assessee in his business. Black's Law Dictionary (5th Edn.) defines depreciation to mean, inter alia:

    “A fall in value; reduction of worth. The deterioration, or the loss or lessening in value, arising from age, use and improvements, due to better methods. A decline in value of property caused by wear or obsolescence and is usually measured by a set formula which reflects these elements over a given period of useful life of property. Consistent, gradual process of estimating and allocating cost of capital investments over estimated useful life of asset in order to match cost against earnings.”

    11. Parks in Principles and Practice of Valuation (5th Edn., at p. 323) states that as for building, depreciation is the measurement of wearing out through consumption, or use, or effluxion of time. Paton has in his Account's Handbook (3rd Edn.) observed that depreciation is an out-of-pocket cost as any other costs. He has further observed that the depreciation charge is merely the periodic operating aspect of fixed-asset costs.

    12. The above position was noted in Mysore Minerals Ltd. v. CIT (1999) 7 SCC 106.

    13. According to Webster's New Word Dictionary, “depreciation” means “a decrease in value of property through wear, deterioration or obsolescence; the allowance made for this in bookkeeping, accounting etc.”

    14. To put it differently, depreciation is the measure of the effective life of an asset owing to use or obsolescence during a given period.

    15. Therefore, the stand of the appellant Union with regard to depreciation has no substance.

    16. The other relevant question which needs to be determined is the essence of what is provided in paras 43 and 44 of the Manual. A bare reading of para 43 shows that when any house, building or trees on the land to be acquired, would not be required by the Government then the owner is given the option of removing it within a reasonable period to be fixed by the Collector. The option is to be given by the Collector and it is for the owner to avail the option and remove the materials within such time as may be fixed by the Collector. Once the option of removing the articles is exercised, the value of such materials has to be deducted from the sum payable as compensation, in case payment has not been made already. In case compensation has already been paid, it is to be recovered from the owner prior to removal of articles. Under para 43, at first the Government has to decide whether the house, buildings or trees standing on the land are required by the Government or not, and in case it is not required, the option of removal is given. As provided in para 44, from the compensation worked out on the basis of procedure laid down in the said para, value of materials made over to the proprietor has to be deducted. The combined reading of paras 43 and 44 makes the following position clear. Firstly, the Government has to take a decision whether the house, buildings and trees standing on the land are required by the Government. In case it is not required, the owner is allowed the option to remove the house, building or the trees, as the case may be, within a reasonable period. The period has to be fixed by the Collector and the value of materials removed is to be determined in the award. The amount determined has to be deducted from the sum payable as compensation, in case it has not been paid; and if it has already been paid, then there shall be recovery of the amount from the owner prior to the removal of the materials. The value of the materials made over to the proprietor has to be deducted from the compensation.

    17. According to the Union, the option was given to the owners and they had in fact removed the materials. This assertion is disputed by the learned counsel for the claimants. According to him, considering the large number of persons whose lands were required, there is no question of any removal of the articles and deduction as contemplated in paras 43 and 44 of the Manual. In any event, when acquisition is of the land with infrastructure, there is no scope for making further deduction.

    18. Whether the option of removal was given to the owners of the land is a question which has to be factually decided. The appellant has placed on record a letter issued by the authorities concerned showing that such option of removal was given. On affidavit it has further been stated that the materials were in fact removed. This assertion, as noted above, is seriously disputed by the learned counsel for the claimants. Both the Reference Court and the High Court do not appear to have taken note of the documents on which reliance is placed by the Union and objectively considered the claims, in detail. In the fitness of things, therefore, the Reference Court should decide as to whether there was any removal of the materials as claimed by the appellants or there was no removal as asserted by the respondent claimants. Since the matter is pending for a long time, it would be proper if the Reference Court decides this question alone permitting the parties to place materials and/or evidence in support of their respective stands as to the removal of the materials alone. After giving proper opportunities a fresh decision shall be taken by the Reference Court. We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case so far as that issue is concerned. The appeals are allowed to the aforesaid extent and the matter is remitted back to the Reference Court for adjudicating the limited question as indicated by us (supra) as expeditiously as possible, without delay. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. Savjiram And Another
    (Dec 17, 2003)