AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 162 of the Constitution, Article 299 of the Constitution, and Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 20 of the A.P Urban Area (Development) Act, 1975
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 162 of the Constitution, Article 299 of the Constitution, and Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 20 of the A.P Urban Area (Development) Act, 1975
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of Andhra Pradesh owned 72 acres of land in Shaikpet village, Hyderabad. In 1993 it handed 43 acres to the Hyderabad Urban Development Authority (HUDA) for residential development. Pursuant to a socio-economic policy aimed at supporting newspaper enterprises and educational institutions, the State resumed 10 acres and allotted two-acre parcels at a concessional price of Rs 200 per sq. yard to:

  • Roots Public School (G.O.Ms. No. 199, 23-2-1994)
  • M/s D.O.T. Publishers (G.O.Ms. No. 800, 5-8-1994)
  • M/s Balaji Administrative Services (P) Ltd. (G.O.Ms. No. 1096, 31-10-1994)
  • M/s Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd. (G.O.Ms. No. 1098, 31-10-1994)
  • M/s Creative Industries Pvt. Ltd. (G.O.Ms. No. 1099, 31-10-1994)

The Collector valued the land at the concessional rate, and each allottee was asked to deposit Rs 19,36,000. The three corporate assignees (Balaji, Maharshi and Creative) paid in full on 29-11-1994 yet were never given possession. By contrast, Roots Public School and D.O.T. Publishers obtained possession early, even before full payment.

Alleging hostile discrimination infringing Article 14 of the Constitution, the three unpaid assignees filed Writ Petitions Nos. 3384, 3376 and 4637 of 1996. A Single Judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court allowed the petitions on 1-5-1998 and directed delivery of possession within four weeks.

The State and HUDA appealed to a Division Bench and, during pendency of those appeals, issued G.O.Ms. No. 38 dated 16-1-2001 cancelling the original allotments and ordering refund of money. The writ petitioners responded with contempt petitions. On 8-5-2001 the Division Bench dismissed the appeals, quashed G.O.Ms. No. 38, and found the State’s conduct contumacious though it imposed no punishment.

The present Supreme Court appeals were filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh and HUDA challenging that common judgment. Leave to appeal was granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether refusal to give possession to the three writ petitioners, while similarly placed allottees received possession, violated Article 14 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether, in the absence of formal contracts compliant with Article 299 of the Constitution, the State could cancel the allotments without attracting constitutional scrutiny.
  3. Whether HUDA’s expenditure and zoning regulations justified non-delivery or cancellation of the allotments.
  4. Whether the concessional price of Rs 200 per sq. yard warranted cancellation on grounds of inadequacy vis-à-vis later market value.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (State of Andhra Pradesh & HUDA)

  • HUDA had invested over Rs 1 crore in developing the area; the State therefore could not resume the land.
  • Delivery of land to the writ petitioners would contravene existing zoning regulations.
  • The price of Rs 200 per sq. yard was far below the current market value, justifying cancellation.
  • No contracts satisfying Article 299 formalities existed; hence the Government was not bound to honour the allotments.

Respondents’ Arguments (Original Writ Petitioners)

  • They were identically situated with Roots Public School and D.O.T. Publishers yet were denied possession despite full payment, amounting to hostile discrimination under Article 14.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court concurred with both the Single Judge and Division Bench of the High Court, evaluating each contention as follows:

  • Article 14 violation: All assignees were similarly situated; selective denial of possession to the three respondents, contrasted with preferential treatment to Roots Public School and D.O.T. Publishers, was arbitrary and discriminatory.
  • HUDA’s expenditure: Under Section 20 of the Andhra Pradesh Urban Area (Development) Act, 1975, the land remained State property and could be resumed by appropriate government orders. HUDA did not challenge the resumption orders, which therefore became final.
  • Zoning objections: Regulations can be relaxed; moreover, if other assignees could operate in the area, identical use by the respondents could not exclusively violate zoning norms.
  • Price inadequacy: The Rs 200 valuation was fixed on the Collector’s 1994 report; subsequent price escalation could not retrospectively invalidate the allotments.
  • Article 299 defence: The Court held that the allotments arose from a socio-economic policy decision—an executive act under Article 162—rather than a commercial contract under Article 299. Hence non-compliance with Article 299 formalities did not legitimise cancellation.
  • Contumacious conduct: Issuance of G.O.Ms. No. 38 during pendency of appeals, contrary to the Single Judge’s order, was contemptuous. The High Court’s leniency in merely quashing the order was upheld.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s judgment, thereby:

  • Reinstating the allotments to M/s Balaji Administrative Services (P) Ltd., M/s Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd., and M/s Creative Industries Pvt. Ltd.
  • Confirming the State’s obligation to deliver possession of the respective two-acre parcels to each respondent.
  • Leaving undisturbed the High Court’s finding of contempt but without additional sanctions.

The decision reinforces constitutional protection against arbitrary state action under Article 14 and clarifies that executive allotments made pursuant to socio-economic policy cannot be rescinded on technical Article 299 objections or subsequent market fluctuations. No new legal precedent was created beyond application of settled equality principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Government Of A.P And Another v. Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd. And Others

    Srikrishna, J.— Leave granted.

    2. This group of appeals impugns the common judgment of the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court dated 8-5-2001 in WAs Nos. 1715, 1716, 1720 of 1998, CCs Nos. 114, 115 and 116 of 2001, dismissing the letters patent appeals filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh and quashing GOMs No. 38 dated 16-1-2001 (Annexure P-4) issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh.

    3. The short facts for disposal of these appeals are as under:

    The Government of Andhra Pradesh had taken a policy decision to encourage the functioning of newspaper concerns and educational institutions, which were finding it difficult to find land within the State at affordable prices. A large tract of 72 acres of vacant land in Survey No. 403 corresponding to TS No. 2 of Shaikpet village of Hyderabad district was owned by the State Government. Out of this land, an extent of 43 acres had been allotted to the Hyderabad Urban Development Authority (HUDA) for the purpose of development of residential plots, which could be sold and proceeds thereof utilized for the formation of Necklace Road around Hussain Sagar Lake. The possession of the aforesaid land was handed over to HUDA on 22-5-1993. Pursuant to its policy of granting land to members of the fourth estate and educational institutions, the Government resumed 10 acres out of the aforesaid 72 acres. Eight acres of land therefrom was allotted to newspaper concerns and 2 acres of land was allotted to Roots Public School. This was done pursuant to the policy of the Government and a scheme for encouraging newspaper concerns and educational institutions and to provide incentives to them by assigning lands at affordable prices. Pursuant to the said scheme by GOMs No. 199 dated 23-2-1994, 2 acres of land was assigned to M/s Roots Educational Society Private Limited at the rate of Rs 200 per sq yard and possession thereof was delivered to the said Society on 17-5-1994. By GOMs No. 800 dated 5-8-1994, 2 acres of land was assigned to M/s D.O.T Publishers (Publishers of Andhra Jyothi, daily newspaper). Similarly, by another GOMs No. 1096 dated 31-10-1994 (Annexure P-1), two acres of land was assigned to M/s Balaji Administrative Services (P) Ltd. By GOMs No. 1098 dated 31-10-1994 (Annexure P-1), two acres of land was assigned to M/s Maharshi Publishers Private Ltd. and by GOMs No. 1099 dated 31-10-1994 (Annexure P-1) two acres of land were assigned to M/s Creative Industries Private Limited.

    4. Before assignment of the lands, the State Government had called for a report from the District Collector for fixing the value of the assigned lands and for collecting the price from the assignees. The District Collector of Hyderabad sent a report fixing the value of the land at Rs 200 per sq yard. At that rate, each of the assignees was called upon to deposit Rs 19,36,000. M/s Balaji Administrative Services (P) Ltd., M/s Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd. and M/s Creative Industries Pvt. Ltd., each deposited the said amount of Rs 19,36,000 on 29-11-1994. However, for some reason, possession of the land was not delivered to the said three assignees though they had complied with all the conditions stipulated in the respective government orders. In glaring contrast, Roots Public School had been delivered possession even as early as 17-5-1994, although the full price had not been paid by it. The said School was given the facility of paying the amount in five equal instalments and it was admitted that possession was delivered after receipt of the first instalment equal to 1/5th of the price. Similarly, in the case of M/s D.O.T Publishers, possession was delivered on 31-8-1994 without collecting any amount from them, though, according to the State Government, M/s D.O.T Publishers had paid the amount of Rs 19,36,000 in two instalments of Rs 5 lakhs and Rs 14,36,000 respectively on 24-9-1994 and 26-9-1994. It would thus appear that advance possession had been given to M/s D.O.T Publishers on 31-8-1994 even before payment of the first instalment. Both Roots Public School and M/s D.O.T Publishers are in possession of the respective lands allotted to them and the assignments made in their favour by GOMs No. 199 dated 23-2-1994 and GOMs No. 800 dated 5-8-1994 are intact and have not been cancelled. Apart from these assignments, the State Government had also assigned 1200 sq yards of land to M/s A.B.K Publishers running the newspaper Vaartha in Gaganmahal area, near Indira Park, vide GOMs No. 1312 dated 23-12-1993. This assignment also remained intact and was not cancelled.

    5. Based on these facts, M/s Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd., M/s Creative Industries Private Limited and M/s Balaji Administrative Services (P) Ltd. filed Writ Petitions Nos. 3384, 3376 and 4637 of 1996 before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh, alleging hostile discriminatory treatment on the part of the State Government amounting to infringement of the right to equality guaranteed under Article 14 of the Constitution. The learned Single Judge who heard the writ petitions was satisfied that there was no substance in the contentions urged by the State authorities and HUDA and that there was a clear case of discrimination amounting to infringement of Article 14 was made out and that the writ petitioners were entitled to succeed. By his judgment dated 1-5-1998, the learned Single Judge after elaborately discussing the facts and the contentions urged, allowed the three writ petitions and directed the State Government to resume the lands concerned and hand over possession of the respective lands to the three writ petitioners within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.

    6. What transpired thereafter is somewhat strange. The State Government and HUDA filed writ appeals before the Division Bench of the High Court challenging the judgment of the Single Judge. Simultaneously, the State Government issued a fresh GOMs No. 38 dated 16-1-2001, by which it purported to cancel GOMs Nos. 1096, 1098 and 1099 dated 31-10-1994 and directed the Collector, Hyderabad to repay the amount deposited by the three writ petitioners with bank rate of interest as directed in the said GO. The three writ petitioners filed contempt petitions, being CC No. 114 of 2001 (by M/s Creative Industries Pvt. Ltd.) CC No. 115 of 2001 (by M/s Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd.) and CC No. 116 of 2001 [by M/s Balaji Administrative Services (P) Ltd.] The Division Bench heard the writ appeals filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh as well as HUDA against the common judgment of the learned Single Judge along with contempt petitions and disposed of the same by the common judgment dated 8-5-2001, which is impugned in the present appeals.

    7. The learned counsel for the appellant reiterated the contentions which were urged before the High Court. We are in agreement with the view taken by the learned Single Judge of the High Court, as approved by the Division Bench, that on the facts and material placed before the High Court, even in 1996, no developmental activity had been undertaken by HUDA and the stand taken by HUDA that it had spent more than Rs 1 crore and that the lands could not be resumed by the State Government, was untenable. The High Court also rightly took the view that the land originally belonged to the State Government and under Section 20 of the A.P Urban Area (Development) Act, 1975, the State Government could always resume the land by issuing the appropriate governmental orders. Finally, if at all HUDA was aggrieved by the act of the State Government resuming the lands which had been assigned to the aggrieved petitioners, HUDA should have challenged such orders. HUDA not having challenged the orders of resumption, the orders of resumption became final as far as HUDA was concerned. The contention that Zoning Regulations were likely to be violated by assigning and delivering possession of the land in favour of the writ petitioners, also has no substance. As rightly pointed out by the High Court, Zoning Regulations can always be relaxed, if necessary. In any event, if the other assignees were permitted to carry on the same business in the same area, it could hardly be contended that the Zoning Regulations were likely to be violated only in the case of the original three writ petitioners. The contention that the value of Rs 200 per sq yard is far too less as compared to the market price, is also of no avail. The value of the land was fixed on a report made by the Collector after due enquiry and, presumably, reflects the prevalent price in the year 1994. Merely because the land prices may have risen subsequently, after laying out the plots in the adjoining area and the provision of amenities, the assignments could not have been cancelled. Article 14 guarantees equal treatment to persons who are equally situated. That the three writ petitioners were situated equally as M/s D.O.T Publishers and Roots Public School, is beyond cavil. The High Court was therefore right in taking the view that there was infringement of Article 14.

    8. Another contention urged before the Division Bench of the High Court and reiterated before us, is that there were no contracts signed by complying with the formalities under Article 299 of the Constitution and therefore the Government was not obliged to honour its commitments. This contention has rightly been repelled by the Division Bench of the High Court by pointing out that the sale of the land was not as a result of any commercial transaction by the State Government, but pursuant to its declared socio-economic policy reflected in the scheme of allotment of land to give incentives to newspaper concerns and educational institutions. The High Court rightly held that this was an executive act falling within the province of Article 162 and not within the ambit of Article 299 of the Constitution. The material placed on record does clearly indicate that undue favour was shown to Roots Public School and M/s D.O.T Publishers as the assigned lands were handed over to them even without full payment being made. In the case of M/s D.O.T Publishers, not even a rupee had been paid by them as on the date on which advance possession was given to them. In the case of the three writ petitioners before the High Court, who, in our opinion, were equally situated, there was hostile discrimination against them in that, despite fully depositing the amount of Rs 19,36,000, possession was not handed over to them on one pretext or the other and they were driven to filing writ petitions before the High Court. In the circumstances, we are of the opinion that the judgment of the High Court under appeal holding that there was violation of the fundamental rights of the writ petitioners under Article 14 is justified and needs to be upheld.

    9. We are also in agreement with the view expressed by the Division Bench that the issuance of GOMs No. 38 dated 16-1-2001 (Annexure P-4) despite the judgment of the Single Judge and the pendency of the writ appeals filed by the State Government and HUDA before the High Court was contumacious on the part of the State Government. We think that the Division Bench took a somewhat gracious view of the matter in not inflicting punishment for contempt of court, but rested content with quashing the offending GOMs No. 38 dated 16-1-2001 (Annexure P-4). In our view, the appellants appear to have been lightly let off. There is no scope for interference on this count.

    10. In the result, we uphold the judgment of the High Court under appeal and dismiss the appeals. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Government Of A.P And Another v. Maharshi Publishers Pvt. Ltd. And Others
    (Nov 1, 2002)