AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 326, 149, 147, and 148 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not mentioned in this excerpt.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 326, 149, 147, and 148 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not mentioned in this excerpt.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arose out of an occurrence dated 29-7-1986 in which nine persons were charged under Sections 147, 148, 447, 325, 307, 302, 326 read with Section 149 of the IPC. Two persons—Kathalsab and Govindappa—died from their injuries, and Husensab (Kathalsab’s brother) was injured.

After evidence was recorded, the trial court (order dated 11-9-1987) acquitted eight appellants of all offences; Accused 9 was absconding and not tried. On the State’s appeal, the High Court of Karnataka (judgment dated 9-6-1992) set aside the acquittal only for offences under Sections 147/148/326/149 IPC, while maintaining acquittal for the other offences. The High Court imposed varying terms of imprisonment, with a maximum sentence of four years’ rigorous imprisonment for the offence under Sections 326/149 IPC.

The appellants filed the present appeals by special leave. After surrender, leave was granted on 27-8-1992, and by order dated 28-8-1992 the appellants were released on bail upon execution of bonds. At the time of this order, they were on bail.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants’ conviction for offences under Sections 147/148/326/149 IPC warranted interference in appeal.
  2. Whether, in the circumstances of the case (including passage of time and post-bail conduct), the substantive sentences of imprisonment should be modified and replaced with a sentence limited to the period already undergone, coupled with enhanced fines.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Senior counsel for the appellants questioned the conviction and sentence, but ultimately confined the challenge to the question of sentence only.

State/Respondent's Arguments

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the evidence and the findings of the High Court and held that the High Court’s findings were “cogent and sound,” concluding that the conviction for the offences under Sections 147/148/326/149 IPC was well merited and supported by the record. In light of this, the Court did not interfere with the conviction.

The Court then addressed sentencing. It considered that (i) the occurrence was in 1986, (ii) the trial court had acquitted the appellants in 1987, (iii) the High Court convicted them in 1992, and (iv) the Supreme Court had released them on bail in August 1992. The Court also noted that nothing had been brought to its notice to show that after release on bail the appellants had acted in any manner prejudicial to law and order.

Considering these factors collectively, the Court held that the “ends of justice” would be served by not sending the appellants back to jail at that stage. Accordingly, it reduced the substantive imprisonment to the period already undergone, but imposed substantial fines in addition, with default sentences if fines were not paid. It also directed distribution of realised fines to the heirs of the deceased and to the injured person.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF — The appeals were disposed of with modification of sentence: the convictions were maintained, the substantive sentences of imprisonment were reduced to the period already undergone, and fines were imposed with default imprisonment in case of non-payment.

Appellants 1 to 7 (Criminal Appeal No. 537 of 1992) were directed to pay a fine of Rs 15,000 each. Appellant Venkappa Dundappa Katti (Criminal Appeal No. 18 of 1993), having undergone a comparatively lesser term of imprisonment, was directed to pay a fine of Rs 25,000. In default, appellants 1 to 7 were to undergo one year’s rigorous imprisonment each, and Venkappa Dundappa Katti was to undergo 18 months’ rigorous imprisonment. The fines were to be deposited in the trial court within 8 weeks; failure to deposit within the stipulated time would result in custody to undergo the default sentence and cancellation of bail bonds.

Upon realisation, the fine was directed to be paid as follows: each set of heirs of Kathalsab and Govindappa to receive Rs 50,000, and Husensab (injured) to receive Rs 30,000. The direct effect of the order was to avoid further incarceration while ensuring monetary consequences and payment to the victims’ heirs and the injured; the opinion does not indicate that any new legal precedent was set.

    Habbalappa Dundappa Katti And Others v. State Of Karnataka .

    Order

    1. For an occurrence which took place on 29-7-1986, nine persons were charged for offences under Sections 147, 148, 447, 325, 307, 302, 326 read with Section 149 IPC. Two persons, namely, Kathalsab and Govindappa succumbed to their injuries and died, while Husensab, brother of Kathalsab, received injuries during the said occurrence. After recording evidence, the trial court vide order dated 11-9-1987 acquitted all the eight appellants (Accused 9 was absconding and was not tried) of all the offences. On appeal by the State, the High Court of Karnataka vide judgment dated 9-6-1992 set aside the acquittal of the eight appellants for offences under Sections 147/148/326/149 IPC while maintaining their acquittal in respect of other offences. The appellants were directed to undergo varying terms of imprisonment for offences under Sections 147/148/326/149 IPC. The maximum sentence awarded for the offence under Sections 326/149 IPC was four years' rigorous imprisonment.

    2. The appellants have questioned their conviction and sentence through the present appeals by special leave.

    3. After the appellants surrendered and furnished proof of surrender, leave was granted on 27-8-1992 and vide order dated 28-8-1992, all the appellants were directed to be released on bail on each of them executing a bond for a sum of Rs 5000 with two sureties for the like sum to the satisfaction of the Sessions Judge, Bijapur. At present they are all on bail.

    4. Mr R.K Jain, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants has questioned the conviction and sentence of the appellants but having regard to the evidence led in the case and the findings recorded by the High Court which to our mind are cogent and sound, we find that conviction of the appellants for various offences as noticed above is well merited and is supported by the evidence on record. Faced with this situation, learned counsel for the appellants confined himself to the question of sentence only.

    5. The occurrence took place as early as in 1986. The appellants were acquitted by the trial court vide order dated 11-9-1987 and after their conviction for offences under Sections 326/149, 147 and 148 IPC by the High Court on 9-6-1992, they were directed to be released on bail vide our order dated 28-8-1992. In our opinion keeping all these factors in view it would serve the ends of justice if the appellants are not now sent back to jail, as indeed nothing has been brought to our notice to show that after their release on bail they have acted in any manner prejudicial to law and order. We, therefore, reduce the substantive sentences of imprisonment of the appellants to the period already undergone by them for the various offences for which they have been convicted but we sentence each one of them to pay fine in addition to the sentence of imprisonment already undergone.

    6. Appellants 1 to 7 (in Criminal Appeal No. 537 of 1992) shall pay a fine of Rs 15,000 each and appellant Venkappa Dundappa Katti (appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 18 of 1993), who has undergone comparatively lesser term of imprisonment than the other appellants, shall pay a fine of Rs 25,000. In default of payment of fine, Appellants 1 to 7 (in Criminal Appeal No. 537 of 1992) shall undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year each and appellant Venkappa Dundappa Katti (appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 18 of 1993) shall undergo rigorous imprisonment for 18 months. The fine shall be deposited by the appellants in the trial court within 8 weeks. In case the appellants fail to deposit the amount of fine in the trial court within the stipulated period, they shall be taken into custody to undergo the sentence in default of payment of fine and their bail bonds shall stand cancelled. Fine on realisation shall be paid in the following manner:

    Each set of heirs, of Kathalsab and Govindappa, shall get Rs 50,000 (fifty thousand). Husensab, the injured shall receive a sum of Rs 30,000 (thirty thousand).

    7. With the aforesaid modification in the sentence, the appeals are disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Habbalappa Dundappa Katti And Others v. State Of Karnataka .
    (Feb 14, 2001)