AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • CPC (Code of Civil Procedure)
  • Section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • CPC (Code of Civil Procedure)
  • Section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was appointed Assistant District Manager in M.P. State Commodities Trading Corporation Limited on 10 September 1980. Under the appointment order the services of either party could be terminated on one month’s notice or payment of one month’s salary in lieu thereof.

By order dated 11 May 1981 the respondent terminated the appellant’s services with effect from 11 June 1981. The termination notice was served only on 8 June 1981 and the appellant was relieved on 10 June 1981 without payment of the stipulated salary in lieu of notice.

The appellant sued for a declaration that the termination was void and for reinstatement. The trial court decreed the suit, holding that the termination violated a condition precedent in the contract. On appeal, the District Judge reversed the decree, limiting relief to one month’s salary, relying on a Full Bench decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The High Court, in second appeal, affirmed the District Judge and later dismissed a review petition.

The appellant sought special leave, resulting in the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether termination of employment without giving one month’s notice or salary, as required by the appointment order, is void ab initio, entitling the employee to reinstatement.
  2. Whether the relationship between the parties was purely contractual (“master and servant”) or governed by adopted government service rules, and the effect of that characterisation on the remedy available.
  3. Whether the first appellate court’s failure to consider the appellant’s application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC vitiated its judgment.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The termination order violated the express condition in the appointment letter because neither notice nor salary in lieu thereof was given; hence the order is void.
  • Service rules applicable to State Government employees had been adopted by the respondent, negating the characterization of a purely contractual relationship.
  • The appellant would forego back wages and would be satisfied with mere reinstatement.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The appellant had remained unauthorisedly absent and, being only a temporary employee, was at best entitled to one month’s salary.
  • The relationship was that of master and servant, creating no statutory obligation to continue the appellant in service.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kusum Gupta v. Haryana State Small Industries & Export Corporation, (1986) 3 SCC 506 Non-payment of one month’s salary required by contract renders termination void; employee entitled to reinstatement. The Supreme Court found the facts “almost identical” and relied on this precedent to hold the termination void and to restore the trial court’s decree.
Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. Shibbulal, 1988 Jab LJ 20 (FB) (AIR 1988 MP 3) Discharged employee is only entitled to one month’s salary; non-payment does not invalidate termination. Relied on by lower courts, but the Supreme Court implicitly rejected its applicability in the present factual context.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted the undisputed fact that the respondent neither gave the requisite notice nor paid one month’s salary. This violated a condition precedent expressly contained in the appointment order. The trial court had therefore rightly declared the termination void.

The first appellate court’s failure to consider the appellant’s application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC—by which the appellant sought to introduce service rules suggesting a statutory flavour—rendered its decision deficient. Nevertheless, remand was considered unnecessary owing to (i) the age of the dispute (termination occurred in 1981) and (ii) the admitted facts which already established illegality.

Drawing on Kusum Gupta, the Court held that when an employer fails to comply with a contractual notice clause, the resultant termination is void and reinstatement is the appropriate remedy. The alternative view adopted by the Full Bench of the High Court in Central Cooperative Bank was distinguished on its facts and not followed.

Given the appellant’s concession, the Court limited relief to reinstatement without back wages.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED; judgments of the District Judge and High Court set aside; trial court decree restored with the sole modification that the appellant will not receive back wages.

The direct consequence is reinstatement of the appellant into service, though without monetary arrears. The decision reaffirms that failure to comply with a contractual notice requirement in a termination clause renders the action void and warrants reinstatement, even where the employment is ostensibly contractual and not governed by a distinct statutory scheme.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Prabhudayal Birari v. M.P Rajya Nagrik Aapurti Nigam Ltd. .

    Shivaraj V. Patil, J.— Delay condoned.

    2. Leave granted.

    3. The facts that are not in dispute are that the appellant was appointed as Assistant District Manager in M.P State Commodities Trading Corporation Limited, Indore (the respondent herein) by Order No. 4383 dated 10-9-1980. As per the terms of the appointment, the services of the appellant could be terminated on one month's notice or on payment of one month's salary in lieu of notice by either side. The respondent is a government company within the meaning of Section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956. The respondent by order dated 11-5-1981 terminated the services of the appellant with effect from 11-6-1981. The notice of termination was served on the appellant on 8-6-1981 and he was relieved on 10-6-1981. The appellant was not paid one month's salary also.

    4. Faced with the situation, the appellant filed a suit for declaration that the order terminating his services was illegal and that he be treated as continuing in the service of the respondent contending that the order of termination of services was in contravention of the terms of employment.

    5. The respondent resisted this suit on the ground that the relationship between the parties was contractual of “master and servant” and as such the appellant could not claim specific performance of the contract; the respondent was under no statutory obligations to keep the appellant in service.

    6. The trial court decreed the suit of the appellant holding that neither the appellant was given one month's notice nor one month's salary as per Condition 5 of Ext. P-1 — the appointment order dated 10-9-1980. According to the trial court, the order of termination of services was one passed without complying with the condition precedent. It was void. Hence the suit was decreed.

    7. The respondent, aggrieved with the judgment and decree of the trial court, filed appeal in the Court of the District Judge, Bhopal. The learned District Judge allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court and declared that the appellant was only entitled to one month's salary in lieu of notice from the respondent employer. According to the learned District Judge, the only question that arose for determination in the appeal was whether the appellant was entitled to a declaration that termination of his services was void ab initio and he could be treated still to be in service. He referred to the decision of this Court in Kusum Gupta v. Haryana State Small Industries & Export Corpn. (1986) 3 SCC 506, (1986) 2 MPWN 108 in which it is held that the Corporation was bound to pay one month's salary to the employee while terminating her services but did not pay the same and as such the order of termination of the services was void. The learned District Judge however took the view that no statutory restriction existed in the case of the appellant and there was only contractual liability arising out of “master and servant” relationship. Hence he was not entitled to reinstatement in service. He preferred to rely upon a Full Bench decision of the High Court in Central Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Shibbulal 1988 Jab LJ 20, AIR 1988 MP 3, 1987 MPLJ 766 (FB) to state that a discharged employee was only entitled to one month's salary in lieu of notice; but on the ground of non-payment of one month's salary, the order of termination of service would not be illegal.

    8. The appellant filed second appeal in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur. In the said appeal, the appellant urged that the order of termination of his services was against the principles of natural justice as well as against the Rules relating to his services. According to him, the Rules that govern the service conditions of the State Government servants were adopted by the respondent Corporation; since the Rules were not produced by the respondent, he produced them before the first appellate court with an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC. But the said application was not at all considered by the first appellate court. The learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment has stated that the only question to be considered was whether the order of termination of services of the appellant was illegal. He referred the judgment of Kusum Gupta (1986) 3 SCC 506, (1986) 2 MPWN 108 of this Court but simply observed that the said judgment did not help the appellant without saying why. He relied on the Full Bench decision of the High Court in Central Cooperative Bank Limited 1988 Jab LJ 20, AIR 1988 MP 3, 1987 MPLJ 766 (FB) aforementioned and dismissed the appeal.

    9. The appellant filed an application for review of the impugned judgment dated 28-10-1994 passed by the learned Single Judge in the second appeal raising the grounds that application filed under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC filed before the first appellate court was not at all considered. Consequently the judgment and decree of the first appellate court were vitiated. Along with the said application, the appellant produced documents to establish that his services were governed by the service rules which were applicable to the employees of the Madhya Pradesh Government; it was not a mere case of contractual relationship of master and servant. The review application was dismissed by the High Court on 11-8-1999. It is thereafter the appellant filed these special leave petitions challenging the judgment and decree passed in the second appeal and the order made in the review application.

    10. The learned counsel for the appellant urged that the first appellate court as well as the High Court were not justified in law and on facts of the case in disturbing the judgment and decree passed by the trial court; admittedly the order terminating the services of the appellant was made without complying with a condition mentioned in the very appointment order, i.e, he was neither given one month's notice nor one month's salary in lieu of such notice; when the order of termination of services was made in violation of the condition governing the services, it was void and consequently the appellant is entitled to reinstatement in service. He submitted that the appellant would be satisfied if only he is reinstated in service and he would not insist on payment of back wages.

    11. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the appellant remained unauthorisedly absent; he at best was entitled to only one month's salary on the ground that the appellant was only a temporary employee.

    12. As already noticed above, it is not disputed that the order of termination of services of the appellant was made without giving one month's notice or one month's salary. The order of termination of services of the appellant dated 11-5-1981 was served on the appellant on 8-6-1981 and made to be effective from 10-6-1981. The trial court on the basis of the evidence, recorded finding that the order of termination of services was made in violation of the conditions mentioned in the order of appointment itself. As such the said order was void and illegal. Consequently, it granted decree in favour of the appellant. The first appellate court did not consider the application made under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC under which Rules governing the services of the appellant were sought to be produced to show that the respondent adopted the Rules of the State Government governing its employees. The learned District Judge refers to Kusum Gupta case (1986) 3 SCC 506, (1986) 2 MPWN 108 but states that the said case did not help the appellant as there was no statutory restriction. Had he only considered the application made under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, perhaps the position would have been different. He relied on the Full Bench decision of the High Court and held that the discharged employee was only entitled to one month's salary in lieu of notice. Unfortunately the learned Single Judge did not consider the respective contentions of the parties touching the question of law but has simply referred to the judgments in the cases of Kusum Gupta (1986) 3 SCC 506, (1986) 2 MPWN 108 and Central Coop. Bank Ltd. 1988 Jab LJ 20, AIR 1988 MP 3, 1987 MPLJ 766 (FB) aforementioned and concluded that the lower appellate court did not commit any mistake in reversing the judgment and decree passed by the trial court. The learned Judge did not consider the effect of non-consideration of application made under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC by the first appellate court. Without examining the facts of the case, he has simply stated that the case of Kusum Gupta (1986) 3 SCC 506, (1986) 2 MPWN 108 aforementioned did not help the appellant. When admittedly the order of termination of services of the appellant was made in contravention of the specific condition mentioned in the very appointment order, in our view, the trial court was right and justified in decreeing the suit of the appellant. As the application filed under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC was not considered by the first appellate court, the case could have been remanded. But we do not propose to do so for two reasons (1) the order of termination of services is of the year 1981, and (2) admitted facts and circumstances of the case also do not warrant such a remand. The facts being almost identical, the judgment of this Court in the case of Kusum Gupta (1986) 3 SCC 506, (1986) 2 MPWN 108 supports the appellant, having regard to the admitted facts and the circumstances of the case in hand. Further the learned counsel for the appellant has fairly submitted that the appellant would not insist for payment of back wages and he would be satisfied if he is reinstated in service.

    13. Having regard to the facts stated and reasons given above, the judgments and decrees of the first appellate court as well as the High Court are set aside and the judgment and decree of the trial court are restored with the modification that the appellant shall not be entitled to any back wages. In other words, the judgment and decree of the trial court except to the extent of modification stated above, shall stand restored. Appeals are allowed to the extent indicated. Parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prabhudayal Birari v. M.P Rajya Nagrik Aapurti Nigam Ltd. .
    (Aug 22, 2000)