AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 37 of the Act
  • Section 36 of the Act
  • Section 2, Subsection (1) of the Kerala Public Services Act
  • The Kerala Education Act, 1958
  • The Act and the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 37 of the Act
  • Section 36 of the Act
  • Section 2, Subsection (1) of the Kerala Public Services Act
  • The Kerala Education Act, 1958
  • The Act and the Rules
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The batch of matters consists of appeals from a judgment of the Kerala High Court and writ petitions filed directly under Article 32 of the Constitution. All of them challenge the validity of Government Order (G.O.) (MS) No. 162/98/G.Edn. dated 13-5-1998 issued by the State of Kerala. The G.O. reorganised the method of recruiting teachers for newly introduced Classes XI and XII (the “higher secondary grade”) following the adoption of the 10+2+3 National Education Policy structure in the State in 1992.

Prior to the impugned G.O., vacancies for higher secondary teachers were filled under Rule 43, Chapter XIV of the Kerala Education Rules (KER) by promoting qualified teachers already serving in the school, with direct recruitment used only when qualified internal candidates were unavailable. The 1998 G.O. altered this by:

  • Reserving 25 % of vacancies for promotion from qualified High School Assistants and Primary School Teachers, and
  • Filling the remaining 75 % by direct recruitment (through the Public Service Commission for Government schools and by the management for aided schools).

The High Court upheld the G.O. prompting the present proceedings before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Classes XI and XII, though situated within existing schools, are legally covered by the Kerala Education Act, 1958 and the Kerala Education Rules, thereby making Rule 43 (promotion based appointments) mandatory for higher secondary teachers.
  2. Whether, in the absence of specific statutory rules for higher secondary appointments, the State Government can regulate recruitment solely through an administrative order.
  3. Whether the 25 % promotional reservation contained in the G.O. is constitutionally or educationally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Private School Teachers (Appellants in some appeals)

  • Classes XI and XII remain part of “school education”; therefore the Kerala Education Act and Rule 43 of the KER govern recruitment.
  • The impugned G.O. contradicts Rule 43 by introducing large-scale direct recruitment and must be struck down as ultra vires the statutory scheme.

State of Kerala

  • The Act and Rules were framed before the higher-secondary concept existed; hence they do not extend to Classes XI and XII.
  • In the statutory vacuum, the State possesses plenary power to issue administrative orders regulating service conditions for higher secondary teachers.
  • The earlier practice of following Rule 43 was merely administrative and could be altered when found educationally unsuitable.

Management of Non-Minority Aided Schools

  • Endorses the State’s power to regulate recruitment by administrative order.
  • Contends that reserving 25 % for promotion is detrimental to students’ interests and should be invalidated in favour of 100 % merit-based direct recruitment.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court declined to undertake an exhaustive examination of each submission because statutory rules were imminent. Its analytic steps were:

  1. Affirmed that, in areas not covered by statute, the State may regulate service conditions through administrative orders.
  2. Observed that the Kerala Education Act and Rules pre-date the introduction of Classes XI and XII; thus the impugned G.O. was issued to fill that regulatory gap.
  3. Took judicial notice of a draft set of “Special Rules for Kerala Higher Secondary School Education Services” already forwarded to the Kerala Public Service Commission for scrutiny, indicating that a comprehensive statutory regime was forthcoming.
  4. Recalled interim orders previously passed by the Court permitting ad hoc appointments in both government and aided schools to prevent disruption of education pending final resolution.
  5. Balanced competing interests—stability of teachers already appointed, the uninterrupted running of higher secondary classes, and the need for a permanent legal framework—by issuing directions rather than striking down the G.O.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF with directions.

Key directives issued by the Court:

  • All teachers appointed during the pendency of the litigation—whether under interim orders or under the impugned G.O.—shall be deemed duly appointed; their services will not be annulled.
  • No further recruitment in either government or aided schools is permitted for a period of three months from the date of judgment.
  • The State Government must bring the proposed statutory recruitment rules for higher secondary teachers into force within the same three-month window.
  • If unforeseen circumstances delay notification of the rules and urgent appointments become necessary, parties may approach the Court for appropriate directions.

Practical Effect: Existing teachers retain their positions; recruitment is frozen temporarily; the State is compelled to replace ad hoc administrative mechanisms with a formal statutory regime. The decision sets no substantive precedent on the validity of Rule 43 vis-à-vis higher secondary education, leaving that question open until the new rules are promulgated.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M.M Dolichan And Others v. State Of Kerala And Others

    G.B Pattanaik, J.— These batch of cases, some of which are appeals against the judgment of the Kerala High Court, and some others are writ petitions directly filed under Article 32 of the Constitution in this Court relate to the same problem, namely, appointment of teachers for teaching Classes XI and XII and the procedure to be adopted for the same. The Kerala Education Act, 1958 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), was passed by the Kerala Legislature to provide for better organisation of general education in the State of Kerala. The said Act has been amended from time to time to meet the needs of the situation. The Act made provisions for the aided school, the existing school as well as for minority schools. Under the Act, qualifications for appointment of teachers have been provided for and mode of appointment of teachers in aided school also has been provided for together with the condition of service of such teachers. Section 36 of the Act confers power on the State Government to make rules and all such rules made are required to be laid before the Legislative Assembly for not less than fourteen days, as provided under Section 37. In exercise of the powers under Section 36 the Kerala Education Rules have been framed (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”). There are different chapters in the said Rule and each chapter contains a number of rules. The schools for general education are of two grades, called primary and secondary. Standards 1 to 7 are collectively known as the primary grade and the same again is sub-divided into lower primary and upper primary. Standards 8 to 10 are collectively known as secondary grade but when Standard 11 is added to 8 to 10 then they are collectively known as higher secondary grade. Such rules were framed keeping in view the courses of education available in the general line at the relevant point of time. Rule 43 in Chapter XIV provided for the manner in which vacancies in any higher grade of pay should be filled up by promotion of qualified hands in the lower grade according to the seniority. The aforesaid Rule is subject to Rules 44 and 45, which rules deal with the appointment of Headmaster. It is to be noted that until the National Educational Policy envisaging a common educational structure in the country to have 10+2+3-years' structure was formulated in the State of Kerala the schools used to impart education till Class 10 and a 2-year course used to be imparted thereafter, called pre-degree and then the degree courses used to be 3 years' course. The level in between the secondary and degree, which is of 2 years' duration and is commonly called higher secondary and the persons to be appointed for imparting education in those two standards are the subject-matter of challenge in these group of cases. There are different sets of appellants/applicants before us, namely, the teachers of private schools for these two classes, the teachers of government schools, the management of the schools, the private managers of non-minority schools, the managers of minority schools, as well as some unemployed qualified persons seeking employment to the schools. The State of Kerala issued a Government Order on 13-5-1998 indicating the Government permission for opening up of higher secondary grade during the academic year 1998-99 in the schools appended to the order. It also provided for a method for appointment of the teachers who would be required to teach in the higher secondary grade. As the method indicated thereunder was substantially varying from the method earlier adopted, writ petitions were filed before the High Court. It may be stated at this stage that in accordance with the National Educational Policy the system of 10+2+3 years' course was adopted in the State of Kerala in the year 1992 and since then till the Government letter dated 13-5-1998 emanated, the prescribed mode of appointment of teachers to teach in the higher secondary grade was same as the mode of appointment of teachers provided under the Rules in Rule 43 and thus existing qualified teachers were being appointed on the basis of their seniority and qualification and direct recruitment was being resorted to only when sufficient qualified teachers were not available in the schools concerned. The Government Order dated 13-5-1998, however, changed the mode of recruitment inasmuch as it provided for 25% of the vacancies to be reserved for appointment from qualified high school assistants and primary school teachers whereas remaining 75% of posts in government schools would be filled up by direct recruitment through the Public Service Commission. In private schools also 75% of vacancies were required to be filled up by direct recruitment to be done by the management. A detailed procedure had also been indicated in the said Government Order dated 13-5-1998. The aforesaid Government Order is extracted hereinbelow in extenso:

    “Higher Secondary Education — opening of Higher Secondary Schools for 1998 Sanctioned Orders issued
    General Education (T) Department
    GO (MS) no. 162/98.G.Edn., Thiruvananthapuram, Dated 13-5-1998
    Read: 1. Notification No. 11042.T/97.G.Edn. dated 2-4-1997
    2. GO (MS) No. 204/97.G.Edn. dated 12-6-1997.
    Order
    As per the GO read as second above, the Government have published a provisional list of government and aided schools in which higher secondary courses are proposed to be started in the year 1998-99. It was also ordered that the facilities available in the above schools will be verified. It was further ordered that after scrutinising the verification reports and satisfying the infrastructure available in each school, the Government will notify the final list of schools and courses to be offered in each school from 1998-99 onwards. Accordingly as authorised in GO (RT) No. 631/98.GE dated 13-2-1998 the Deputy Directors, Education, verified the facilities available in these schools and submitted their reports. The Government after considering the reports of the Deputy Directors, are pleased to sanction higher secondary courses in 95 government schools and 178 aided schools as detailed in the annexure to this order. The above schools are sanctioned higher secondary courses on the subjects noted against the name of each school subject to the following conditions:
    (i) The schools will be permitted to open Standard XI during the academic year 1998-99.
    (ii) The last date for students to submit their application form will be 30-6-1998.
    2. The posts of higher secondary school teachers in government higher secondary schools and aided-higher secondary schools will be filled up as follows:
    (i) 25% vacancies will be reserved for appointment from qualified high school assistants and primary school teachers.
    (ii) The remaining 75% of posts in government schools will be filled up by direct recruitment through the Public Service Commission. In the absence of select list with the Public Service Commission the vacancies will be filled up by candidates from the employment exchange. Should there be shortage of suitable candidates from the employment exchange, guest lecturers may be appointed as is done in colleges. The selection of employment exchange candidates will be done by the Director of Higher Secondary Education and that of the guest lecturers will be done by the Deputy Director, Education concerned by constituting a Selection Committee consisting of the Principal, Deputy Director/and President of the PTA concerned.
    (iii) Appointments to the 75% vacancies earmarked for direct recruitment in the aided-higher secondary schools will be done by the management. If qualified teachers are not available for appointment as mentioned in Item (i) above, the management will fill up such vacancies also by direct recruitment. Selection of candidates for direct recruitment in aided-higher secondary schools will be done by a Staff Selection Committee consisting of the Manager or his representative, the Principal of the school and a Government nominee from the panel of officers consisting of Deputy Director, Education, DEO of the area and DIET Principal of the district. The management can select a nominee from among the above officers. The above officers are permitted to attend the Staff Selection Committee meeting without further sanction.
    3. While making appointments the Manager will see that only part-time teachers are appointed when the periods to be taught are less than 15 in a week. This procedure will be followed in government schools also when direct recruitment is resorted to through the employment exchange. But the teachers appointed from the General Education Subordinate Service will be treated as appointment by promotion and they will be full-time teachers irrespective of the periods to be taught.
    In the schools where the course of Humanities is sanctioned for the year 1998-99, the subject of Sociology will be offered as an optional subject in place of Geography.”

    This order of the Government had been assailed in the High Court of Kerala and by the impugned judgment the High Court having upheld the validity of the aforesaid Government Order the present appeals by grant of special leave as well as writ petitions have been filed.

    2. The contention of Mr Gopal Subramanium, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the teachers of the private schools essentially is that Standards 11 and 12 appertain to higher secondary grade, and as such, the institution continues to remain as a school and, that being the position, the method of recruitment of teachers for teaching the higher secondary grade is required to be in accordance with the Act and the Rules made thereunder and the impugned order dated 13-5-1998 contravenes the statutory rules, more particularly, Rule 43 in Chapter XIV and, therefore, the order must be struck down. The contentions of Mr P.P Rao, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Kerala as well as Mr Vaidyanathan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the management of the non-minority institutions are to some stage similar but divergent at the later stage. According to Mr Rao the Act and the Rules had been enacted at a point of time when higher secondary grade consisting of Standards 11 and 12 were not in existence and, therefore, even if in the common parlance the institution could be called school, but in legal parlance the Act, as well as the Rules will have no application and necessarily therefore the mode of recruitment as well as service conditions of such employees could be determined and governed by the Administrative Order. According to Mr Rao until issuance of order dated 13-5-1998, it is no doubt true that the Government by issuance of similar Administrative Order had followed the practice as provided in Rule 43, namely, by appointing teachers by way of promotion of the qualified personnel available in the schools but since that method was found to be not in the interest of the students the Government issued the Administrative Order dated 13-5-1998 and the said order cannot be held to be discriminatory or violative of any provisions of the Act and Rules, as contended by Mr Subramanium. Mr Vaidyanathan, on the other hand though fully supports the contention of Mr Rao so far as the power of State Government to issue orders pertaining to the method of recruitment of teachers for the higher secondary grade is concerned, but he vehemently contended that reservation to the extent of 25% to be filled up by promotion from amongst the teachers of the schools provided they have necessary qualification, is grossly detrimental to the interest of the students and since their interest if of paramount consideration that part of the Government Order providing for reservation to the extent of 25% should be struck down.

    3. We are not proposing to examine in detail the submissions made by counsel of different parties in the light of the documents available on record, in view of the order we are proposing to pass in these batch of cases. Suffice it to say that the State Government has the power to issue Administrative Order governing the service conditions of its employees in the absence of any statutory provisions governing the field. In the case in hand the Government appears to have issued the impugned order in exercise of such power as in its opinion the provisions of the Act and the Rules will have no application to the institution imparting education to Standards 11 and 12 which is a concept subsequent to the enactment of rules on account of the National Education Policy. In the course of hearing, Mr Rao appearing for the State of Kerala produced before us a set of draft rules called Special Rules for Kerala Higher Secondary School Education Services framed in exercise of powers conferred under sub-section (1) of Section 2 of the Kerala Public Services Act and it was submitted also that the said set of Rules are now being examined by the Kerala Public Service Commission. It is, therefore, undisputed that statutory rules are in the offing and such statutory rules once having been notified the so-called Administrative Orders will have no force in relation to the matters provided under the statutory rules. It was also pointed out to us in course of hearing of these batch of cases that by the interim order of this Court dated 7-12-1999, in case of private-aided schools this Court permitted the schools to appoint from amongst the existing teachers of the school if suitably qualified candidates are available after they are selected and recommended by a Selection Committee constituted by the Manager or his representative of the school, but that appointment would be purely on ad hoc basis as stopgap arrangement. It was also stipulated that if suitable candidates will not be available then appointment could be made from the open market, but that also should be on ad hoc basis. So far as the government schools are concerned, the order dated 1-2-1999 passed by this Court was to the effect that the ad hoc appointments could be made from the list already said to have been prepared for the year 1997, but if qualified and suitable candidates are not available in the list then it would be open to the Government to appoint persons through employment exchange. Mr Vaidyanathan in course of his submission had also urged that several teachers have already been appointed in accordance with the procedure prescribed in the Government Order dated 13-5-1998.

    4. In the aforesaid premises, and keeping in view the fact that the statutory rules are in the process of being notified we would dispose of these batch of cases with the following directions:

    (1) All the teachers in the private schools who have been appointed during the pendency of these cases pursuant to the interim order dated 7-12-1999 would be held to be duly appointed to the post and their services will not be annulled.
    (2) All the teachers who have been appointed also in the government schools pursuant to the order dated 1-2-1999 shall also be held to be duly appointed and those appointments will not be annulled.
    (3) If there has been any appointment made pursuant to the Government Order of 13-5-1998 as on today those appointments also would continue and will not be annulled.
    (4) There will be no further appointment from any source either in the private school or in the government schools from today for a period of 3 months.
    (5) The State Government is directed to bring into force the Statutory Recruitment Rules within the aforesaid period of 3 months whereafter recruitment to the vacancies in the higher secondary grade could be dealt with in accordance with the said statutory rules.
    (6) If for any unforeseen circumstances the statutory rules cannot be notified and brought in force within the aforesaid period of 3 months and on such event there exists any necessity for immediate recruitment of teachers then it would be open for the parties to move this Court for appropriate direction.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.M Dolichan And Others v. State Of Kerala And Others
    (Nov 14, 2000)