Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 309 of the Constitution
  • Article 26(51) of the Civil Services Regulations
  • Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 309 of the Constitution
  • Article 26(51) of the Civil Services Regulations
  • Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Bank Note Press, Dewas (“the Press”) was set up in 1972 to print and process Indian bank notes. Because no service cadres or recruitment rules then existed, the Press decided—after consultation with the Ministry of Finance—to staff 50 % of the newly-sanctioned posts of Inspector (Control) with experienced personnel drawn on deputation from sister organisations, notably the India Security Press, Nasik Road (“ISP”), and to fill the other 50 % by direct recruitment.

Six officers from ISP (the present appellants) joined the Press on deputation between February 1973 and January 1974. Meanwhile, respondents 3–9 were recruited directly between October 1973 and January 1975 as Apprentice Assistant Inspectors (Control) and were later promoted to Inspector (Control) after completing probation.

The first set of statutory recruitment rules for Class III posts at the Press was promulgated on 20 November 1974 and amended on 1 December 1975. Under these rules the deputation route was expressly recognised for the first time (as a contingency after promotion and transfer). In January 1976 six permanent posts of Inspector (Control) were created; on 22 March 1976 the appellants were permanently absorbed in those posts with effect from 22 January 1976, and their lien in ISP was terminated.

Seniority lists published by the department, including one dated 18 September 1979, placed the appellants above the direct recruits. Two vacancies of Deputy Control Officer arose, and on 21 August 1978 the two seniormost appellants were promoted.

Respondents 3–9 challenged (i) the 1975 recruitment rules, (ii) the promotions of the appellants, and (iii) the seniority lists before the Madhya Pradesh High Court; the matter was transferred to the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench. By judgment dated 26 April 1990 the Tribunal accepted their contentions, quashed the seniority list, and treated the appellants’ promotions as provisional. The present appeal by the deputationists came before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether service rendered by officers on deputation in their parent department must be counted for seniority after their permanent absorption in the borrowing department.
  2. Whether appointments made on deputation prior to the 1 December 1975 amendment were invalid because the original 1974 rules did not expressly provide for deputation.
  3. Whether the Tribunal erred in directing that seniority be determined solely by continuous officiation from the date of absorption rather than by date of confirmation or earlier service.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (Deputationists)

  • Their initial deputation was valid because, in the absence of statutory rules at the time (pre-1974), appointments could lawfully be made through administrative instructions.
  • They were already permanent Inspectors (Control) in ISP; therefore, upon absorption, the length of their prior service should be credited for seniority.
  • The Tribunal’s view that deputationists cannot carry past service for seniority is contrary to settled service jurisprudence and previous Supreme Court authority.

Respondents 3–9 (Direct Recruits/Writ Petitioners before the Tribunal)

  • Contended that the 1975 recruitment rules were unconstitutional and discriminatory.
  • Asserted that deputation was not an authorised mode of recruitment prior to 1 December 1975, rendering the appellants’ earlier service irrelevant for seniority.
  • Sought quashing of the seniority list and of the appellants’ promotions to Deputy Control Officer.

Respondents 1–2 (Union of India & General Manager, Press)

  • Defended the seniority list on the ground that, in the absence of specific seniority rules, seniority was fairly determined by the date of confirmation, which favoured the appellants.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.S. Moghe v. Union of India, (1981) 3 SCC 271 Government may, as a matter of policy, choose the sources of recruitment for a new service, and deputationists can be granted seniority over direct recruits. Relied on to uphold the policy of drawing experienced personnel from sister organisations and to affirm that deputationists could rank senior to direct recruits.
K. Madhavan v. Union of India, (1987) 4 SCC 566 Service rendered by a government servant prior to transfer/deputation must be counted for seniority in the transferee cadre; deputation is akin to transfer. Cited to support the proposition that the appellants’ earlier service as Inspectors (Control) in ISP must be credited for seniority in the Press.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Validity of the initial deputation: The Court held that, before statutory rules are framed under Article 309, appointments may legally be made through executive instructions. Hence, the appellants’ deputation in 1973-74 could not be invalidated merely because deputation was formally incorporated in the rules only on 1 December 1975.

2. Seniority principles: Drawing on Moghe and Madhavan, the Court observed that when personnel from different sources are integrated into a single cadre, their pre-existing service on equivalent posts under the same employer “must be respected.” The appellants’ permanent lien in ISP was terminated only upon absorption; therefore, their entire prior service as Inspectors (Control) had to be credited.

3. Tribunal’s errors: The Tribunal overlooked (a) the administrative policy that created a 50 % deputation quota to ensure trained manpower, and (b) the absence of any seniority rules excluding past service. It also misapplied the concept of confirmation; in the peculiar circumstances, using date of confirmation was a reasonable and equitable criterion adopted by the employer.

4. Equitable considerations: Respondents 3–9 were still apprentices or probationers when the appellants were already functioning—and being notionally promoted—as Inspectors (Control). Denying the appellants credit for that service would offend “basic tenets of service jurisprudence.”

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – Tribunal’s judgment dated 26 April 1990 set aside; the claim petition of Respondents 3–9 dismissed.

Immediate Effect: The seniority list placing the appellants above the direct recruits stands restored, and the promotions of the first two appellants as Deputy Control Officer become final.

Broader Implications: The Court reaffirmed that, in integrated cadres drawn from multiple sources, pre-existing service in equivalent posts must be honoured for seniority unless specific rules provide otherwise. No new statutory rule was created, but the decision reinforces established principles governing deputation, transfer, and seniority in Indian service law.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    S.K Mathur And Others v. Union Of India And Others

    S. Saghir Ahmad, J.— The Bank Note Press, Dewas (for short “the Press”), which is a departmental undertaking of the Government of India and is engaged in the sovereign function of the printing of bank notes, was established in 1972. The job of printing and processing of bank notes is said to be a unique job which requires intensive and highly technical training with impeccable integrity. According to the counter-affidavit filed before us, the production of bank notes is completed in two parts, namely, (i) printing of bank note sheets and (ii) processing of bank notes right from cutting of sheets into the sizes of notes to the final delivery to Reserve Bank of India at their cash-chests. The processing wing is known as Control Wing.

    2. Since at the time of its establishment, the Press did not have its own cadres of various posts, including the post of Inspector (Control), nor were any Recruitment Rules made for these posts, it approached the Government of India for certain posts in the Control Wing being sanctioned and on its request the Government of India sanctioned 20 posts in the grade of Inspector (Control). Since it was felt that it would not be safe or possible to entrust the responsibilities of processing and final supply of bank notes to the Reserve Bank of India, to raw hands, namely the new recruits, the Press, in consultation with the Ministry of Finance decided to fill up 50% posts of Inspector (Control) from qualified and trained persons working in the sister organisations, namely the India Security Press, Nasik Road, as also the Security Paper Mill, Hoshangabad, and the remaining 50% by direct recruitment. Consequently, the Press issued a requisition letter dated 1-6-1972 to the sister organisations, including the India Security Press, Nasik Road, for sponsoring the names of the candidates willing to take up appointment as Inspector (Control), for which the eligibility criteria was five years' experience as Assistant Inspector (Control).

    3. The appellants, who were appointed as Assistant Inspector (Control) at the India Security Press, Nasik Road, on the following dates, applied for appointment as Inspector (Control) in the Press and were appointed on those posts on deputation on the dates mentioned below:

    S. No. Name (S/Shri) Date of appointment as Assistant Inspector (Control) in India Security Press, Nasik Road Date of initial appointment in Bank Note Press on deputation 1. S.K Mathur 9-2-1961 9-2-1973 2. M. Laxminarayanan 28-7-1961 9-2-1973 3. H.R Sharma 16-1-1962 3-10-1973 4. V.P Bhalla 22-7-1965 3-10-1973 5. S.B Deshmukh 7-1-1966 3-10-1973 6. S.B Khadilkar 7-6-1962 10-1-1974

    4. In the meantime, all the appellants were promoted, though notionally, on the posts of Inspector (Control) in their parent department during the period 1974-75 and confirmed on those posts.

    5. The Central Government, by its notification dated 20-11-1974, promulgated the Bank Note Press (Class III Posts) Recruitment Rules, 1974, for the posts of Inspector (Control), made by the President under Article 309 of the Constitution. The mode of recruitment indicated in these Rules was that the posts of Inspector (Control) shall be filled up to the extent of 50% by direct recruitment and remaining 50% by promotion. These Rules were amended by notification dated 1-12-1975. The method of recruitment was altered. It was provided that 25% of the posts would be filled up by direct recruits while the remaining 75% by promotion, failing which, by transfer; failing both, by transfer on deputation and failing all, by direct recruitment.

    6. The promotion quota was indicated as under:

    Promotion

    (i) 50% from Head Checkers with 8 years' regular service in the grade of Rs 380-560.

    (ii) 25% from Head Clerk, Confidential Secretary, Senior Stenographer and Hindi Translator in the grade of Rs 425-700 and Deputy Accountant in the grade of Rs 425-640 with at least 3 years' regular service in the respective grades.

    7. The posts from which appointment on transfer could be made on the post of Inspector (Control) were indicated as under:

    Transfer

    (i) Inspector Control (Rs 550-800) belonging to the Currency Note Press, Nasik Road, failing which

    (ii) Assistant Inspector Control belonging to the Currency Note Press, Nasik Road, with at least 5 years' regular service in the grade of Rs 425-640.

    8. In 1976, six permanent posts of Inspector (Control) were sanctioned by the Government with effect from 22-1-1976. Respondents 3 to 10 (sic 9), who are the direct recruits, were initially appointed as Apprentice Assistant Inspectors (Control) between October 1973 and January 1975 on a fixed stipend of Rs 350 per month. They were appointed in substantive capacity in 1977. The relevant dates of their initial appointment as Apprentice Assistant Inspector (Control), their appointment as Inspector (Control) (on probation) and their appointment in substantive capacity, are indicated below:

    S. No. Name S/Shri Date of appointment as Apprentice Assistant Inspector Control Date of appointment as Inspector (Control) (probation) Date of substantive appointment as Inspector Control 1. P.R Sharma 5-10-1973 5-4-1975 1-8-1977 2. Mohinder Singh 10-10-1973 10-4-1975 1-8-1977 3. Paresh Joshi 5-10-1973 11-4-1975 1-8-1977 4. V.H Chitale 5-10-1973 12-4-1975 1-8-1977 5. G.L Damor (ST) 19-10-1973 19-4-1975 1-8-1977 6. Chhattar Singh 3-8-1974 3-9-1975 3-9-1977 7. D.D Mathur 3-8-1974 3-9-1975 3-9-1977 8. N.L Jat 3-8-1974 3-9-1975 3-9-1977 9. Ramesh Gajbhaiye (SC) 20-1-1975 20-1-1976 Left the department

    9. Since, on the date on which the posts of Inspector (Control) were proposed to be filled up on permanent basis, no eligible officer in the feeder line for promotion was available, and the direct recruits being on probation, were also ineligible, the appellants, who were holding the posts of Inspector (Control) on deputation and had already held these posts in their parent department on permanent basis, were considered by the Departmental Promotion Committee convened on 1-2-1976/2-2-1976. The DPC recommended that the appellants may be permanently absorbed on the posts of Inspector (Control) in the Press with effect from 22-1-1976, the date on which these permanent posts were created. Consequently, by order dated 22-3-1976, the appellants were appointed as Inspector (Control) in substantive capacity with effect from 22-1-1976. In their order of appointment, it was indicated as under:

    “2. Consequent on their acquiring liens on the permanent posts of Inspector Control to which they have been substantively appointed the liens held by them in the India Security Press, Nasik Road, stand terminated under FR 14-A(g) and they have severed all connections with that organisation.”

    10. The direct recruits, namely, Respondents 3 to 9 were appointed on the posts of Inspector (Control) in substantive capacity in 1975 on the dates indicated above.

    11. Having regard to the above facts, when the seniority list of Inspectors (Control) was issued by the department, the appellants were shown as senior to the direct recruits, namely, Respondents 3 to 9, specially in the seniority list published on 18-9-1979.

    12. It may be pointed out that two posts of Deputy Control Officer (Group ‘B’ Gazetted), being the promotional posts for Inspector (Control) became available. The Recruitment Rules for these posts were published by notification dated 26-12-1975, in which the mode of recruitment was indicated to be “promotion”, failing which, by transfer and failing both these modes, the posts were to be filled up by transfer on deputation. Since Inspectors (Control) having requisite length of service were not available nor were candidates for appointment by transfer on deputation available, the eligibility condition in the Recruitment Rules was relaxed by the Government in consultation with the Union Public Service Commission and the appellants S.K Mathur and M. Laxminarayanan were appointed as Deputy Control Officers on regular basis with effect from 21-8-1978. It may be pointed out that these two appellants, who were the seniormost persons and who were inducted on the post of Inspector (Control) in the Press from India Security Press, Nasik Road, had already been given ad hoc promotion on the post of Deputy Control Officer for a short term of one year. S.K Mathur was appointed on such short-term promotion with effect from 9-7-1975 while M. Laxminarayanan was appointed with effect from 4-7-1976.

    13. Respondents 3 to 9, feeling aggrieved by the absorption of the appellants on permanent basis on the posts of Inspector (Control) as also by being treated as junior to the appellants, filed a writ petition in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in November 1980, which was transferred to the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench. The relevant claims were:

    “(a) to declare that the Recruitment Rules notified by the Ministry of Finance in 1975 (i.e Recruitment Rules for the post of Inspector (Control) vide dated 1-12-1975 (Annexure R-4) are unconstitutional being violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution;

    (b) to quash the order of promotion of Shri S.K Mathur and Shri M. Laxminarayanan to the post of Deputy Control Officer by writ in the nature of certiorari;

    (c) to quash the seniority list published on 18-9-1979 [i.e seniority of Inspector (Control)];

    (d) to direct the department to treat the petitioners' seniority over Respondents 3 to 8 (sic 9).”

    14. The Tribunal, by the impugned judgment dated 26-4-1990, held that the present appellants could not be treated as senior to Respondents 3 to 9 and the service rendered by them prior to 1-12-1975 could not be reckoned for purposes of determining their seniority as their appointment on deputation on the posts of Inspector (Control) was not in accordance with the Rules as they existed prior to 1-12-1975 when there was no provision for appointment being made on those posts by deputation. The Tribunal was of the view that a provision for appointment on deputation on the posts of Inspector (Control) was made for the first time by amendment made in the Rules on 1-12-1975 and since the appellants were absorbed in substantive capacity on those posts with effect from 22-1-1976, they could reckon their seniority with effect from that date, while Respondents 3 to 9, who were also appointed as Inspector (Control) would be entitled to reckon their seniority from the date of continuous officiation on that post irrespective of the fact that Respondents 3 to 9 had completed their probation period subsequent to the substantive absorption of the appellants. The Tribunal was also of the view that since deputation was not one of the modes of recruitment for appointment on the post of Inspector (Control), the deputationists, namely, the present appellants would not be entitled to carry the benefit of their past service, including the service rendered in the India Security Press, Nasik Road, to the department in which they were ultimately absorbed in substantive capacity. The Tribunal, consequently, quashed the seniority list and directed that a review DPC be convened to consider the cases of promotion from the post of Inspector (Control) with reference to the respective position of the candidates in the revised seniority list. It was further provided that till this was done, the promotion of S.K Mathur and M. Laxminarayanan shall be treated as provisional.

    15. After having heard learned counsel for the parties, we are of the opinion that the Tribunal was wholly in error in quashing the seniority list and in coming to the conclusion that a person working on deputation is not entitled to the benefit of service rendered by him in the parent department.

    16. The appellants, who were initially working as Assistant Inspector (Control) in the India Security Press, Nasik Road, were appointed on the posts of Inspector (Control) in the Press on deputation during the period from 9-2-1973 to 10-1-1974, while there were no Recruitment Rules for regulating the appointments or other conditions of service in the Press, which was established only in 1972. In the absence of rules made under Article 309 of the Constitution, the authorities decided to fill up the posts of Inspector (Control) by direct recruitment to the extent of 50% and the remaining 50% by bringing in the qualified and trained persons from sister organisations so as to constitute a nucleus of trained and experienced persons in the cadre. This decision was taken in view of the delicacy of the post and the requirements of intensive and highly technical training coupled with unimpeachable integrity required to man those posts. Having taken this administrative decision, the authorities circulated a letter dated 1-6-1972 to sister organisations, namely, the India Security Press, Nasik Road, as also the Security Paper Mill, Hoshangabad, for sponsoring the names of the suitable candidates who were willing to take up the appointment in the Press at Dewas. The appellants, whose names were sponsored and who had also expressed their willingness to work at Dewas, were consequently appointed as Inspector (Control) on deputation. The Rules, namely, the Bank Note Press (Class III Posts) Recruitment Rules, 1974 were promulgated on 20-11-1974 when the appellants had already been appointed. Their appointment on deputation, therefore, could not have been faulted by the Tribunal on the ground that there was no provision for appointment on deputation on the posts of Inspector (Control) under the Recruitment Rules as it is well settled that in the absence of Statutory Rules made under Article 309 of the Constitution, appointments and other conditions of service can be regulated by administrative orders or executive instructions.

    17. The question relating to the inter se seniority of direct recruits, namely, Respondents 3 to 9, and the persons brought on deputation, namely, the present appellants who were ultimately absorbed on permanent basis in the Press at Dewas, has also been erroneously decided by the Tribunal by denying them the benefit of their past service.

    18. From the facts given in the beginning of this judgment, it will be seen that the appellants were working on the posts of Assistant Inspector (Control) in their parent department when they were sent on deputation to the Press at Dewas. In due course, they were promoted to the posts of Inspector (Control) in their parent department and were also given “permanent” status. They were subsequently absorbed on permanent posts in the Press at Dewas with effect from 22-1-1976. They were already working on the posts of Inspector (Control) on deputation, having been appointed during the period between 9-2-1973 to 10-1-1974, when Respondents 3 to 9 joined the Press, having been appointed as Apprentice Assistant Inspectors (Control) during the period between 5-2-1973 (sic 5-10-1973) to 20-1-1975. They were subsequently appointed as Inspector (Control) and placed on probation during the period 5-4-1975 to 20-1-1976 and were subsequently appointed on substantive basis in 1977, five of them on 1-8-1977 and three on 3-9-1977.

    19. Respondents 1 and 2, namely, the Union of India and the General Manager, Bank Note Press, Dewas, contended before the Tribunal that in the absence of any seniority rules, they had assigned seniority with reference to the date of confirmation. Since the appellants were confirmed prior to the confirmation of Respondents 3 to 9, the former, namely, the appellants, were treated as senior. The Tribunal after considering their contention held as under:

    “However, in the peculiar case of the BNP, Dewas where Respondents 3 to 8 have been inducted from other sister organisations at a time when no Recruitment Rules existed and the subsequent rule provided for deputation but without retrospective effect not much reliance can be placed on the general principle of seniority which Respondents 1 and 2 have cited in support of arranging the seniority of the petitioners and Respondents 3 to 8 according to the dates of their confirmation. It is also not normal to confirm a person from the date of regular absorption as has been done in the case of Respondents 3 to 8. Confirmation is related to the performance and other criteria and the cases of confirmation have to be referred to the DPC as required by Article 26(51) of the Civil Services Regulations. Although Respondents 3 to 8 may have been initially deputed but only after their absorption they become employees of the new organisation, i.e, in this case the SNP, Dewas. Thus, when they were absorbed on 22-1-1976 their cases of confirmation had to be taken up and considered like any other departmental employees. They cannot be automatically confirmed from the same date as the date of absorption. In other words if the DPC has not examined the cases of the confirmation of Respondents 3 to 8 and Respondents 1 and 2 have confirmed them from 22-1-1976, the date of confirmation of the respondents would have to be treated as an arbitrary one resulting in invidious discrimination against the petitioners. Where quotas are provided then confirmation has also to take place against the vacancies in terms of the quotas. The respondents have not produced any DPC record, in regard to the confirmation of the petitioners and Respondents 3 to 8 as Inspector Control. Therefore, the dates of confirmation of Respondents 3 to 8 as well as the petitioners on which the seniority lists of 1977, 1978 and 1979 are based cannot be held to be proper or valid for the reasons discussed above. In any case the date of appointment of Respondents 3 to 8 prior to 1-12-1975 cannot be accepted for purposes of reckoning seniority. For these reasons these seniority lists cannot be upheld and are liable to be quashed.”

    20. After recording the above finding, the Tribunal proceeded to record the further finding as under:

    “In the circumstances of the case, the only valid principle for determining seniority between the petitioners and Respondents 3 to 8 would be the principle of continuous officiation from the dates of their regular absorption as regular Inspector (Control) irrespective of the fact that the petitioners completed their probation period subsequently. The dates of substantive appointments are not necessarily the dates of confirmation but the dates of regularisation. Substantive appointment does not mean that an official has to be confirmed. He holds a substantive appointment if he has been appointed in a regular manner or regularised against a clear civil post. Thus, the dates of continuous officiation on the posts of Inspector (Control) would be reckoned from the dates of their regular absorption. Respondents 1 and 2 should, therefore, revise the seniority list in the respective orders and rearrange them in accordance with the principle indicated above and in the light of our observations. The seniority lists of 1977, 1978 and 1979 are quashed.”

    21. In recording the above finding, the Tribunal fell into patent error in overlooking the vital fact that the appellants who were already working as Inspector (Control) in the sister organisation had been appointed as Inspector (Control) in the Press at Dewas in pursuance of the administrative decision taken by Respondents 1 and 2 as there were no Recruitment Rules in existence. The appellants held a permanent lien in the sister organisation and on their absorption at Dewas, their lien in the parent department was terminated. Under the circumstances, they were entitled to the benefit of service rendered by them in the parent department on identical posts. This benefit cannot be legally denied to them. The Tribunal erred in holding otherwise.

    22. This Court in S.S Moghe v. Union of India (1981) 3 SCC 271 has already held that when a new service is proposed to be constituted by the Government, it is fully within the competence of the Government to decide as a matter of policy the sources from which the personnel required for manning the service are to be drawn.

    23. In this decision, it was also laid down that the deputationists, who had already put in a number of years of service in their parent department, were to be given seniority over the direct recruits for purposes of promotion.

    24. Again, in K. Madhavan v. Union of India (1987) 4 SCC 566, (1987) 5 ATC 91 while considering the question of seniority of a deputationist who was subsequently absorbed on permanent basis in the new department, it was observed as under:

    “21. We may examine the question from a different point of view. There is not much difference between deputation and transfer. Indeed, when a deputationist is permanently absorbed in the CBI, he is under the rules appointed on transfer. In other words, deputation may be regarded as a transfer from one government department to another. It will be against all rules of service jurisprudence, if a government servant holding a particular post is transferred to the same or an equivalent post in another government department, the period of his service in the post before his transfer is not taken into consideration in computing his seniority in the transferred post. The transfer cannot wipe out his length of service in the post from which he has been transferred. It has been observed by this Court that it is a just and wholesome principle commonly applied where persons from different sources are drafted to serve in a new service that their pre-existing total length of service in the parent department should be respected and presented by taking the same into account in determining their ranking in the new service cadre.”

    25. We are in respectful agreement with the above view. We are of the opinion that where recruitment is made from two different sources and an integrated seniority list is prepared of the persons so recruited, the benefit of service already rendered on a similar post in a similar organisation under the same employer will have to be given to the person appointed on the new post. We are also of the opinion that in the particular facts and circumstances of the present case, benefit of service rendered by the appellants on the post of Inspector (Control) in the parent department could not have been legally denied to them, particularly as there were no rules of seniority made under Article 309 of the Constitution providing specifically that benefit of past service would not be allowed. The Tribunal was not justified in allowing seniority to Respondents 3 to 9 on the basis of continuous officiation on the post of Inspector (Control) even though the appellants had been appointed earlier. The Tribunal was in error in treating the appellants to have joined the department only from the date of their substantive absorption. By treating Respondents 3 to 9 as senior to the appellants, the Tribunal acted contrary to the basic tenets of service jurisprudence discussed above.

    26. In addition to what has been stated above, Respondents 1 and 2, who had assigned seniority to the appellants on the basis of the respective dates of their confirmation, could not be said to have acted contrary to law, at least in the particular circumstances of the case where Respondents 1 and 2 had to balance the equities in the matter of seniority between the appellants and Respondents 3 to 9. While Respondents 3 to 9 had been directly recruited in the service and after completing their apprenticeship, were placed on probation for the post of Inspector (Control), the appellants had already worked for quite a number of years on this post in their parent department where they were given notional promotion as they were on deputation in the Press as Inspector (Control) on which posts they were also confirmed earlier than Respondents 3 to 9. In this situation, Respondents 1 and 2 were fully justified in adopting “date of confirmation” as the basis of seniority, particularly as there were no service rules regulating seniority of the persons working in the Press. On this criteria, which, in our opinion, is wholly reasonable in the facts of this case, the appellants were rightly treated by Respondents 1 and 2 as senior to Respondents 3 to 9.

    27. Viewed from any angle, the appellants have to be held as senior to Respondents 3 to 9.

    28. In view of the above, the appeal is allowed, the judgment dated 26-4-1990 passed by the Tribunal is set aside and the claim petition filed by Respondents 3 to 9 is dismissed, but without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.K Mathur And Others v. Union Of India And Others
    (Jan 13, 1998)