AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 146 of the Customs Act, 1962
  • Section 146, Sub-section (2) of the Customs Act
  • Section 146 of the Customs Act in the year 1984
  • The Customs Act, 1962
  • The Sea Customs Act, 1878
  • Report of the Committee for Subordinate Legislation, submitted in the year 1983
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 146 of the Customs Act, 1962
  • Section 146, Sub-section (2) of the Customs Act
  • Section 146 of the Customs Act in the year 1984
  • The Customs Act, 1962
  • The Sea Customs Act, 1878
  • Report of the Committee for Subordinate Legislation, submitted in the year 1983
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Federation of Customs House Agents' Association and others filed a writ petition in the Delhi High Court challenging the validity of the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1984 (“1984 Regulations”), framed by the Central Board of Excise and Customs under Section 146 of the Customs Act, 1962. The Delhi High Court dismissed the petition, upholding the Regulations. The Federation appealed to the Supreme Court.

Parallel proceedings in the Calcutta High Court had resulted in a contrary ruling, striking down the same Regulations insofar as they permitted the grant of temporary licences. Appeals arising from that judgment (Union of India v. Jagat Bandhu Mukherjee and connected matters) were heard and disposed of by the same Bench on the strength of the principal judgment delivered in the Federation’s case.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Regulation 8 of the 1984 Regulations—allowing an applicant to operate as a Custom House Agent for up to two years on a temporary licence before passing the prescribed examination—is ultra vires Section 146 of the Customs Act, arbitrary, irrational or unconstitutional.
  2. Whether the Central Board of Excise and Customs possessed the statutory authority under Section 146(2) to frame a regulation permitting such temporary licensing.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Regulation 8 introduces an arbitrary system by which persons who have not yet qualified in the mandatory written/oral examination may nevertheless function as Custom House Agents, thereby diluting professional standards that were safeguarded under the 1960 Rules and the 1965 Regulations.
  • The temporary licence places untested agents on par with those who have qualified through examinations, which is discriminatory and contrary to the objectives of effective customs administration.
  • Reports such as the 1967 Study Team on the Customs Department and the 1983 Committee on Subordinate Legislation emphasised stricter, not looser, control over clearing agents; hence the Regulation conflicts with accepted policy recommendations.
  • International practice (e.g., the United States and Australia) requires examinations at the threshold, supporting the appellants’ position that the Indian scheme should likewise mandate prior testing.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandrakant Krishnarao Pradhan v. Collector of Customs, (1962) 3 SCR 108; AIR 1962 SC 204 Upheld the validity of Rule 9 of the 1960 Rules mandating written/oral examination for licence applicants. The Court distinguished the case, noting that no question of temporary licensing arose there; therefore, it provided no support for striking down Regulation 8.
D.V. Bakshi v. Union of India, (1993) 3 SCC 663 Considered the marking scheme under Regulations 8 and 9 of the 1984 Regulations and underlined the relevance of assessing a candidate’s performance as a temporary licence-holder. Cited to demonstrate that the Supreme Court had already recognised the utility of temporary licences for evaluating candidates’ practical performance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court began by examining Section 146 of the Customs Act. Sub-section (1) merely imposes a bar on unlicensed agency work, while sub-section (2) delegates broad regulatory powers to the Board. Nothing in the statute precludes temporary licensing.

Regulation 8 was found to be consistent with recommendations of the 1983 Committee on Subordinate Legislation, which proposed initially issuing temporary licences for two years, monitoring performance, and converting them into permanent licences upon satisfactory turnover and efficiency. Hence the Regulation could not be labelled irrational when it mirrors legislative policy advice.

The Court rejected the appellants’ comparison with foreign jurisdictions, emphasising that even under Regulation 8 a candidate must pass the prescribed examination—only the timing is deferred. The Regulation contains adequate safeguards: the applicant must already have at least one year’s relevant experience (Regulation 6), financial viability, and must clear the examination within one year (extendable by another year under strict conditions).

The amendment to Regulation 6 (Notification 74/91-Cus.) further linked the requisite experience to holding a permanent pass under Regulation 20, reinforcing that both experience and merit are pivotal.

Finally, the Court observed that temporary licensing enables authorities to assess a candidate’s real-world competence, as highlighted in D.V. Bakshi. Consequently, Regulation 8 embodies a rational balance between experience, examination, and administrative oversight.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court upheld the validity of Regulation 8 and the 1984 Regulations in their entirety. The connected appeals arising from the Calcutta High Court’s contrary decision were allowed, and the writ petitions there were dismissed.

Implications: The decision confirms the Central Board of Excise and Customs’ power to grant temporary licences under the 1984 Regulations, ensuring continuity of customs-clearing services while maintaining ultimate examination requirements. No new legal principle was created; the ruling primarily sustains the existing regulatory framework and harmonises divergent High Court decisions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Federation Of Customs House Agents' Association And Others v. Union Of India And Others

    N.P Singh, J.— The Federation of Customs House Agents' Association and others have filed this appeal against the judgment of the High Court of Delhi, dismissing the writ petition filed on behalf of the appellants, questioning the validity of the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as the 1984 Regulations) which have been framed by the Central Board of Excise and Customs under Section 146 of the Customs Act, 1962 (hereinafter referred to as the Customs Act).

    2. It may be mentioned that the Customs Act repealed the Sea Customs Act, 1878 under which Customs House Agents Licensing Rules, 1960 had been framed (hereinafter referred to as the 1960 Rules). Rule 2(c) of the said rule defined “Custom House Agent” to mean a person licensed under those rules to act as agent for the transaction of any business relating to the entrance or clearance of any vessel or the import or export of goods or baggage in any Custom House. Rule 6 prescribed the conditions which had to be fulfilled by the applicant before the grant of licence to act as Custom House Agent, saying:

    “6. Certain conditions to be fulfilled by the applicant before the grant of licence.—An applicant for a licence shall—
    (a) furnish to the Customs Collector satisfactory evidence as to his respectability, reliability and financial status;
    (b) produce satisfactory evidence to the Customs Collector that he would be in a position to muster sufficient clientele and business in the event of his being granted the licence;
    (c) furnish an income tax clearance certificate.”

    3. Rule 9 laid down the details and procedure for examination of the applicant with a view to ascertain his knowledge of customs law and procedure and his fitness to render proper service, to importers and exporters. Such examination could be oral or written or both. In view of Rule 10, the Customs Collector was empowered to reject an application for the grant of a licence to act as Custom House Agent, if the applicant failed to pass the examination prescribed under those rules or if the applicant was not considered suitable due to any other reason to be stated in writing. After coming into force of the Customs Act, the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as the 1965 Regulations) were framed in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (2) of Section 146 of the said Act. Regulation 2(c) defined “Custom House Agent” to mean a person licensed under those regulations to act as agent for the transaction of any business relating to the entrance or clearance of any vessel or the import or export of goods or baggage in any Custom House. Regulation 5 provided that an application for a licence to act as a Custom House Agent was to be made in the form prescribed. Regulation 6 prescribed the conditions to be fulfilled by the applicant before the grant of licence:

    “6. Certain conditions to be fulfilled by the applicant before the grant of licence.—An applicant for a licence shall—
    (a) furnish to the Collector of Customs satisfactory evidence as to his respectability and financial status;
    (b) produce satisfactory evidence to the Collector of Customs that he would be in a position to muster sufficient clientele and business in the event of his being granted the licence;
    (c) furnish an income tax clearance certificate.”

    4. Regulation 9 contained the provision and procedure regarding examination of the applicant with a view to ascertain his knowledge of custom law and procedure and his fitness to render service to importers and exporters. This examination could be oral or written or both to be conducted by the Collector of Customs or by a committee of officers of customs to be appointed by him for that purpose. The regulations which were framed in exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (2) of Section 146 of the Customs Act in the year 1984 referred to above repealed the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1965. Several changes were introduced in the 1984 Regulations. Regulation 2(c) defines “Custom House Agent” to mean a person licensed under the regulations to act as agent for the transaction of any business relating to the entry or departure of conveyance or the import or export of goods at any customs station. In view of Regulation 4, the Collector may invite applications for the grant of a licence to act as Custom House Agent in the month of January every year in the from prescribed. Regulations 6 and 8 which are the subject-matter of controversy in the present appeal provided the conditions which have to be fulfilled by the applicant and conceive grant of temporary licences as well:

    “6. Conditions to be fulfilled by the applicant.—The applicant or the person referred to in clause (b) of sub-regulations (2) and (3) of Regulation 5 as the case may be, shall prove to the satisfaction of the Collector that:
    (a) he has the experience of work relating to clearance of goods through the customs for a period of not less than one year; and
    (b) the applicant has financial viability supported by a certificate issued by a Scheduled Bank or such other proof acceptable to the Collector evidencing possession of assets of the value of not less than Rs 1 lakh in the case of applicants for the grant of licence in respect of any one of the Customs Stations at Bombay, Calcutta, Madras, Cochin, Kandla, Goa, Mangalore, Tuticorin or Visakhapatnam and not less than Rs 50,000 in the case of each of the other Customs Stations, situated at places other than those specified above:
    Provided that in cases where a Collector's jurisdiction extends to more than one Customs Station the Collector may issue one licence for all the Stations or more than one such Station to be specified in the licence, waiving the need for separate compliance of the provisions of clauses (a) and (b) above for such additional Customs Stations. The Collector may also waive the need for separate compliance of the requirement of Regulation 11 in such cases:
    Provided further that in places where there is more than one Collector exercising jurisdiction over different Customs Stations and Custom House Agents, licensed under the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1965 have been operating in the said Customs Stations on the basis of one licence, it shall be open to such agents to obtain a temporary licence under Regulation 8 from the Collector other than the one who has issued them the existing licence, without being required to comply with the requirements of Regulation 6 in regard to financial viability or the requirements as to fresh deposit in terms of Regulation 11.
    8. Grant of temporary licence.—Any applicant, whose application is received within the last date specified in Regulation 4 and who satisfies the requirements of Regulations 5 and 6, shall be permitted to operate as Custom House Agent at the Customs Station for which the application is made initially for the period of one year against temporary licence granted by the Collector in this regard in Form B:
    Provided that when evidence is produced to the Collector that the applicant has already availed of two chances for qualifying in the written or oral examination prescribed in these regulations and would like to avail of the third chance as soon as the next examination is held in terms of Regulation 9 and that the applicant has been able to account for the minimum volume of work prescribed for such agents in the course of one year's working, the Collector may extend the aforesaid period of one year for which the temporary licence has been granted by another six months or such further period not exceeding one year to enable the applicant to avail of the third chance for qualifying in the examination in terms of Regulation 9. While granting such extension, the Collector of Customs shall satisfy himself that the requirements of Regulations 10(1)(a) and 10(1)(b) had been fully met by the applicant.”

    5. On a plain reading in view of Regulation 6, the applicant has to prove to the satisfaction of the Collector that he has an experience of work relating to clearance of goods through the customs for a period of not less than one year. Incidentally, it may be mentioned that clause (a) of Regulation 6 has been substituted by Notification No. 74/91(N.T)-Cus., dated 15-11-1991 and now it reads as follows:

    “6. Conditions to be fulfilled by the applicant.—The applicant or the person referred to in clause (b) of sub-regulations (2) and (3) of Regulation 5 as the case may be, shall prove to the satisfaction of the Collector that:
    (a) is an employee of a licensee and that he possesses a permanent pass in Form G prescribed under Regulation 20 and has the experience of work relating to clearance of goods through the customs, for a period of not less than one year, in the capacity of such a pass-holder; and ….”

    This was not required under the 1960 Rules and the 1965 Regulations. Regulation 8 provides that an applicant shall be permitted to operate as Custom House Agent at the Customs Station for which the application is made initially for the period of one year against temporary licence granted by the Collector in Form B. In view of the proviso to the said Regulation 8, such applicant is entitled to avail of two chances for qualifying in the written or oral examination prescribed in those regulations. However, he may avail of the third chance in the next examination to be held in terms of Regulation 9 on the conditions prescribed in the proviso to Regulation 8. The Collector has been empowered to extend the aforesaid period of one year for which the temporary licence had been granted by another six months or such further period not exceeding one year to enable the applicant to avail of the third chance for qualifying in the examination. Regulation 9 gives the details of such examination which is to be conducted twice every year. A licensee may, having regard to the volume of business transacted by him in view of Regulation 20 “employ one or more persons to assist him in his work as Custom House Agent”. Such appointment of a person by the licensee is to be made only after obtaining the approval of the Assistant Collector of Customs. Regulation 20(3) prescribes the condition subject to which such persons can be appointed by the licensee to assist him in his work as Custom House Agent. Regulation 20(3) requires such person who has been employed by the licensee to pass the examination conducted by the Assistant Collector of Customs within six months from the date of his appointment to ascertain the adequacy of his knowledge regarding the provisions of the statutes subject to which goods and baggage are cleared through the Customs.

    6. The appellants challenged the validity of Regulation 8 aforesaid saying that it has introduced an arbitrary and irrational provision regarding grant of temporary licence before an applicant qualifies at the examination to be held. According to them, the 1960 Rules and the 1965 Regulations required the applicant first to appear at the examination and only after such applicant was selected, a licence was to be granted to him to act as Custom House Agent, but Regulation 8 of the 1984 Regulations enables the applicant, who has not at all appeared at any such examination to act as a Custom House Agent on the basis of temporary licence granted to him by the Collector. On the basis of such temporary licence he can act as Custom House Agent for a period of one year as a matter of course and up to the period of two years on the condition prescribed by the proviso to Regulation 8 which is per se arbitrary, inasmuch as a person is allowed to act as Custom House Agent on the basis of temporary licence without his suitability and qualifications being tested which was a must under the earlier rules and regulations. It was pointed out that the holders of such temporary licences without the evaluation of their merit can transact any business relating to entry or departure of the conveyance or import or export of goods at the Customs Station, on a par with regular licensees who have got the licence after passing the examinations conducted for their selection. In this connection reference was made to the Report of the Study Team on the Customs Department, submitted in the year 1967. In the said report in respect of the clearing agency system it was suggested that the clearing agency rules should be tightened to provide effective control over the clearing agents. For that object strict tests for grant of licence or approval to conduct Custom House business should be held. It also recommended that clearing agents' associations should be encouraged to arrange their affairs like a disciplined guild with a code of conduct, fair scales of charges, arrangements for training their staff and regulations regarding employing unqualified or undesirable persons. It was also pointed out that the aforesaid recommendation, that the clearing agency rules should be tightened to provide effective control over the agents had been accepted by the Government. Reference was also made to the Report of the Committee for Subordinate Legislation, submitted in the year 1983 in which the procedure for inviting applications for grant of licence to act as Custom House Agent, conduct of a written or oral examination to satisfy regarding the suitability of the applicant was recommended apart from other requirements. However, it may be pointed out that the said Committee itself had felt:

    “… the present restriction on the number of Custom House Agents should be done away with and that the licences should be thrown open to all eligible candidates….”

    The Committee also recommended:

    “The licence should be issued initially for a period of 2 years and performance of the applicant watched. The licence will, therefore, be a temporary one and its conversion into a permanent licence will be conditional on the applicants' showing satisfactory turnover and a minimum level of efficiency.”

    We are not able to appreciate as to how the Report of the Committee for Subordinate Legislation helps the appellants when the said Committee itself recommended that temporary licence should be issued initially for a period of two years and performance of the applicant be watched and the conversion of the temporary licence into a permanent licence should be conditional on the applicants' showing satisfactory turnover and a minimum level of efficiency. Regulation 8 of the 1984 Regulations, appears to have been framed on the basis of the aforesaid recommendation regarding grant of temporary licence for a period of one year which period can be extended up to 2 years on conditions prescribed in the proviso to Regulation 8. If Regulation 8 has been framed on the pattern suggested by the Committee for Subordinate Legislation, we are unable to appreciate as to how Regulation 8 can be held to be invalid, arbitrary or ultra vires.

    7. The learned counsel, who appeared for the appellants, could not point out that a regulation in the nature of Regulation 8 could not have been framed in exercise of the power conferred by sub-section (2) of Section 146 of the Customs Act. Sub-section (1) of Section 146 prescribes a bar that no person shall carry on business as an agent relating to the entry or departure of a conveyance or the import or export of goods at any Customs Station unless such person holds a licence granted in this behalf in accordance with the regulations. None of the clauses of sub-section (2) of Section 146 prescribe any restriction on grant of temporary licence. The Committee for Subordinate Legislation aforesaid had also recommended under the heading “eligibility conditions” that the applicant must be at least a graduate and the desirable qualification should be at least 3 years' experience which could be reduced to 6 months in deserving cases. Then it recommended that such applicant should pass a written examination which shall be held annually. It also recommended that temporary licence should be issued initially for a period of two years and the performance of the applicant be watched. The Committee did not say that such temporary licence should be issued only after the applicant had passed the written examination, rather it laid emphasis that a temporary licence should be converted into a permanent one “on the applicants showing satisfactory turnover and a minimum level of efficiency”. In this background, it is difficult to hold that when Regulation 8 provides for grant of temporary licence for a period of one year before the applicant has qualified in the written or oral examination so prescribed, it is invalid, arbitrary or unconstitutional in any manner. Regulation 8 has proper check and balance in which the experience of work relating to clearance of goods through the customs as well as the performance at the qualifying written or oral examination both have been taken note of. The amendment which was introduced in clause (a) of Regulation 6 by the aforesaid notification dated 15-11-1991 links the experience of such applicant acquired in accordance with Regulation 20. It cannot be said that by postponing the qualifying examination for a period of one year and on fulfilling the conditions of the proviso to Regulation 8 up to 2 years in respect of temporary licensee any procedure has been prescribed or adopted. From reading Regulations 6, 8 and 20 it is apparent that the 1984 Regulations have given due weight to the experience as well as to the merit.

    8. It was pointed out that in many countries like the United States and Australia, written examination for such Custom House Agents is a must and that test should be held at the threshold. Even under Regulation 8 a qualifying written or oral test is a must for a temporary licensee. Regulation 8 requires the applicant who has been permitted to operate as Custom House Agent to qualify at the written or oral examination prescribed within the period of one year and under certain specified conditions within a further extended period of one year.

    9. On behalf of the appellant, reference was made to the judgment of this Court in the case of Chandrakant Krishnarao Pradhan v. Collector of Customs (1962) 3 SCR 108, AIR 1962 SC 204 and it was pointed out that Rule 9 of the 1960 Rules which provided for examination, written or oral or both, was upheld by this Court. Admittedly, in that case neither was there any controversy nor could have been in respect of grant of temporary licence for a limited period before qualifying at the written or oral examination, as there was no such provision in those rules. That judgment is of no help to the appellants. Attention was also drawn to the judgment of this Court in the case of D.V Bakshi v. Union of India (1993) 3 SCC 663, (1993) 25 ATC 206 where in a different context Regulations 8 and 9 of the 1984 Regulations had been challenged. A grievance had been made that 100 marks for written test and 50 marks for oral test was arbitrary and irrational. The controversy with which we are concerned was not involved in that case. However, incidentally it may be mentioned that in respect of grant of temporary licence for a period of one year under Regulation 8, it was said:

    “The importance of the oral interview lies in the fact that the examiners have an opportunity to assess his performance as a temporary licence-holder and also seek his clarification in regard to certain matters which might have come to their knowledge during the period he worked as a temporary licence-holder. The Regulations have, therefore, taken care to ensure that he has experience of at least one year as an apprentice to an agent before he applies for the grant of licence. In order to assess his work he is given a temporary licence before he qualifies by clearing the prescribed examination. The authorities have the opportunity of assessing his knowledge regarding the laws and procedure through the written examination. It must be remembered that the customs station is a place of work. Observance of regulations is absolutely essential as movement of very valuable goods takes place and only sufficiently experienced hands can be permitted to act as agents. He must satisfy the authorities that he has adequate knowledge regarding the laws and the procedure connected with the clearance of goods and that he actually is in a position to handle the work from the moment he is licensed. The assessment of his work during the period he holds the licence is, therefore, of great relevance and that can be done at the oral test only. The assessment has to be made on the basis of his performance as a temporary licence-holder and his capacity to handle goods as an agent at the customs station.”

    It can be said that in the aforesaid judgment this Court has impressed the utility of the temporary licence for purpose of the assessment of the work of such temporary licence-holder.

    10. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    [Connected Judgments and Orders by same Bench]
    (Before N.P Singh and S. Saghir Ahmad, JJ.)
    Civil Appeal No. 9224 of 1996
    UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS . . Appellants;
    Versus
    JAGAT BANDHU MUKHERJEE AND OTHERS . . Respondents.
    With
    Civil Appeal No. 821 of 1994
    SHRI HRIDEY RANJAN CHATTERJEE . . Appellant;
    Versus
    JAGAT BANDHU MUKHERJEE AND OTHERS . . Respondents.
    Civil Appeals No. 9224 of 1996 with No. 821 of 1994, decided on July 15, 1996
    Judgment

    1. Leave granted in SLP (C) No. 10440 of 1994.

    2. These appeals have been filed on behalf of the Union of India and others for setting aside the judgment of the Calcutta High Court, holding that the 1984 Regulations so far they allow temporary licence to be issued on conditions prescribed therein were invalid. On that finding, the writ petition filed by the respondents in the present appeals were allowed. In view of the judgment which has been delivered today by us in CA No. 2632 of 1985, these appeals are allowed. The judgment of the High Court is set aside and the writ petition filed on behalf of the respondents is dismissed. No costs.

    (Before N.P Singh and S. Saghir Ahmad, JJ.)
    PASHUPATI ENTERPRISES AND ANOTHER . . Appellants;
    Versus
    JAGAT BANDHU MUKHERJEE AND OTHERS . . Respondents.
    Civil Appeal No. 9225 of 1996, decided on July 15, 1996
    Order

    1. Delay condoned.

    2. Leave granted.

    3. This appeal has been filed against the judgment dated 2-7-1993 passed by the Calcutta High Court in OA No. 518 of 1988. It is allowed in terms of the judgment in CA No. 821 of 1994 delivered today.

    (Before N.P Singh and S. Saghir Ahmad, JJ.)
    PAGODA SHIPPING CORPORATION AND ANOTHER . . Appellants;
    Versus
    JAGAT BANDHU MUKHERJEE AND OTHERS . . Respondents.
    Civil Appeals No. 822 of 1994 with Nos. 823 and 824 of 1994, decided on July 15, 1996
    Order

    These appeals have been filed against the judgment dated 2-7-1993 passed by the Calcutta High Court in OA No. 518 of 1988. These appeals are allowed in terms of the judgment in Civil Appeal No. 821 of 1994, delivered today.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Federation Of Customs House Agents' Association And Others v. Union Of India And Others
    (Jul 15, 1996)