AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1995 INSC 445
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1961
  • Section 16 of the 1961 Act (Provided that anything done or any action taken under any law so repealed shall be deemed to have been done or taken under the corresponding provision of this Act)
  • East Punjab Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation Act, 1948
  • Section 4(c) of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1898
  • Section 8 of the Panchayat Act
  • Punjab Gram Panchayat Act, 1952
  • Section 3(a) of the Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1953
  • 1953 Act
  • Haryana Municipal Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1974
  • The Pepsu Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1954
  • The Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1953
  • Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1995 INSC 445
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1961
  • Section 16 of the 1961 Act (Provided that anything done or any action taken under any law so repealed shall be deemed to have been done or taken under the corresponding provision of this Act)
  • East Punjab Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation Act, 1948
  • Section 4(c) of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1898
  • Section 8 of the Panchayat Act
  • Punjab Gram Panchayat Act, 1952
  • Section 3(a) of the Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1953
  • 1953 Act
  • Haryana Municipal Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1974
  • The Pepsu Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1954
  • The Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1953
  • Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The land in dispute was originally used for common village purposes such as “gair mumkin rasta” and “gao charand.” It was later classified as shamilat deh and consequently vested in the local Gram Panchayat by operation of Section 3(a) of the Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1953 (“1953 Act”). In 1974 the land was mutated in favour of the present appellant–the Notified Area Committee—under the Haryana Municipal Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1974. A Full Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court subsequently declared the 1974 Act void. Relying on Rule 3 of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Rules, 1965, the original owners (respondents) filed a suit seeking a declaration that the land had reverted to them.

The trial court dismissed the suit, but the Additional District Judge, Karnal, allowed the first appeal. The appellant’s second appeal to the High Court was dismissed in limine. The present appeal was therefore filed before the Supreme Court of India under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether inclusion of the entire Sabha area within a municipality/notified area is a condition precedent for the Notified Area Committee to claim vesting of Gram Panchayat land under Rule 3 of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Rules, 1965.
  2. Whether the proviso to Rule 3—providing for reversion of land vested in a Panchayat under the Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961—also applies to land that had earlier vested in the Panchayat under the repealed 1953 Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The entire Sabha area had to be included in the notified area before any vesting in the appellant could occur; partial inclusion was insufficient.
  • Even if inclusion were sufficient, the proviso to Rule 3 caused the land to revert automatically to the original owners when the village area was notified on 6-10-1975, a date before the proviso’s deletion on 22-12-1976; its subsequent omission could not alter their accrued right.

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Under Section 8(2) of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Act, 1952, partial inclusion of Panchayat territory merely reduces the Panchayat’s jurisdiction over the included part; it does not negate vesting of property in the Notified Area Committee.
  • The proviso to Rule 3 exclusively concerns land vested under the 1961 Act, not land vested under the 1953 Act; repeal of the 1953 Act by the 1961 Act did not disturb vested rights because of Section 4(c) of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1898.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Unnamed Full Bench decision of the Punjab & Haryana High Court declaring the Haryana Municipal Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1974 void Held the 1974 Act unconstitutional/void Explained why mutation in favour of the appellant under that Act could not by itself sustain ownership; nevertheless, it formed the factual backdrop and did not alter rights vested under the 1953 Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Issue 1 – Requirement of entire Sabha inclusion: The Court examined Section 8(2) of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Act, 1952 and observed that when only part of a Gram Panchayat area is included in a notified area, the Panchayat’s jurisdiction is simply reduced to the remaining portion. Nothing in the statute conditions vesting of assets on inclusion of the whole area. As no evidence suggested that the parcel in question lay outside the notified boundaries, the lower courts’ contrary view was legally unsound.

Issue 2 – Applicability of the proviso to Rule 3: The proviso expressly refers to land vested in a Panchayat under the Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961. The disputed land, however, vested earlier under the 1953 Act. Although Section 16 of the 1961 Act repealed the 1953 Act and preserved “anything done” under it, this saving clause does not disturb rights that had already vested; such rights are further protected by Section 4(c) of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1898. Accordingly, vesting under the 1953 Act persisted, and the proviso to Rule 3 could not be invoked to divest the Gram Panchayat (or its statutory successor, the appellant).

Because neither the main provision of Rule 3 nor its proviso aided the respondents, the Supreme Court concluded that the decisions of the Additional District Judge and the High Court were legally untenable.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; SUIT DISMISSED.

The land remains vested in the appellant Notified Area Committee, and the respondents’ claim of reversion is rejected. The Court clarifies that:

  • Partial inclusion of Panchayat territory within a notified area does not obstruct vesting of Panchayat property in the successor local authority.
  • The proviso to Rule 3 of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Rules, 1965 applies only to land vested under the 1961 Act; rights already vested under the repealed 1953 Act are unaffected.

No broader precedent was set beyond interpreting the interaction between the 1953 Act, the 1961 Act, and Rule 3; each party was directed to bear its own costs.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Notified Area Committee And Another v. Des Raj And Others

    B.L Hansaria, J.— The point for determination in this appeal is as to whether land included in shamilat deh which had come to be vested in the Gram Panchayat concerned by virtue of Section 3(a) of the Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1953 (for short, ‘the 1953 Act’) got divested because of what has been mentioned in the proviso to Rule 3 of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Rules, 1965, framed in exercise of powers conferred by Punjab Gram Panchayat Act, 1952 (hereinafter the ‘Panchayat Act’).

    2. The facts lie in narrow compass and are not disputed. The same are that the lands with which this appeal is concerned were being used, to start with, for common purposes like ‘gair mumkin rasta’ and ‘gao charand’, but were shown as shamilat deh afterwards and came to be vested in the Gram Panchayat concerned pursuant to what has been provided in Section 3 of the 1953 Act. Pursuant to what was provided in Haryana Municipal Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1974, the land was mutated in the name of the appellant. As that Act, however, came to be declared void by a Full Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court, the respondents, who were the owners of the lands earlier, filed a suit seeking declaration that the said land got reverted to them because of what has been mentioned in the aforesaid proviso. The suit was dismissed by the trial court, whereupon the plaintiffs preferred an appeal which came to be allowed by the Additional District Judge, Karnal. On the appellant approaching the High Court in second appeal, the same came to be dismissed in limine. Hence this appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution.

    3. There being no dispute as to the vesting of the land pursuant to 1953 Act in the Gram Panchayat concerned, all that we are required to decide is whether the stand of the plaintiffs-respondents that the same got reverted to them pursuant to what has been mentioned in the aforesaid proviso is correct or not.

    4. To decide the aforesaid question, let Rule 3 of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Rules, 1965 be noted, which reads as under:

    3. “If the whole of Sabha area is included in Municipality, cantonment or notified area all rights, obligations, property, assets and liabilities if any, whether arising out of any contract or otherwise shall vest in the Municipal Committee, Cantonment Board or Notified Area Committee as the case may be:
    Provided that the land, which vests in the panchayat under the Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961 or the land, management and control of which vests in the panchayat under the East Punjab Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation Act, 1948, shall revert to the co-sharers and owners thereof.”

    5. The respondents' first contention is that for the appellant to claim vesting of the land in it, the first requirement is that the whole of the Sabha area must have been included in it. It is then urged that even if this part of the requirement be held to be satisfied, because of what has been stated in the aforesaid proviso, the land did revert to them. The further leaf of this argument is that the omission of the proviso by notification dated 22-12-1976 cannot alter the position inasmuch as the area of Village Gudha, in which the land is admittedly situate, had been declared to be part of notified area on 6-10-1975; and so, the proviso operated by its own force on that date, because of which its omission later on could not alter the legal position.

    6. Insofar as the first contention is concerned, Shri Ashri, learned counsel appearing for the appellants, brings to our notice what has been stated in sub-section (2) of Section 8 of the Panchayat Act, which is in the following language:

    8. (2) “If the whole of the area of a Gram Panchayat is included in municipality, cantonment, notified area or small town area, the Gram Panchayat shall cease to exist and its assets and liabilities shall be disposed of in the manner prescribed. If a part of such area is so included, its jurisdiction shall be reduced by that part.”
    (emphasis added)

    This shows that the only effect of non-inclusion of the whole of the area of a Gram Panchayat is that the jurisdiction of the Notified Area Committee concerned shall get reduced and would be confined to the part included. As in the present case there is nothing to show that the part of the Gram Panchayat in which the suit land is situate had not been included in the territorial area of the appellant-committee, the first contention advanced on behalf of the respondents, which had found acceptance with the courts below, cannot be regarded as legally sound.

    7. The second question is whether the aforesaid proviso can be called in aid by the respondents. It is apparent that the proviso deals with the land which had come to be vested in the panchayat under the Punjab Village Common Land (Regulation) Act, 1961, whereas the lands at hand came to be vested in the panchayat concerned by the force of 1953 Act. It is because of this that a submission was advanced on behalf of the appellants before the learned Additional District Judge that the proviso has no operation. This contention was, however, not upheld because of what has been provided in Section 16 of the 1961 Act which reads as below:

    16. “Repeal and Saving.— The Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1953 and the Pepsu Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1954 are hereby repealed:
    Provided that anything done or any action taken under any law so repealed shall be deemed to have been done or taken under the corresponding provision of this Act, and shall continue to be in force accordingly, unless and until superseded by anything done or any action taken under this Act.”

    8. The learned Additional District Judge took the view that as the 1953 Act was repealed, vesting of the land in the appellant can be said to be only under the 1961 Act because of the proviso to Section 16. According to us, this was a wrong view to be taken because the proviso speaks of things done or action taken under the 1953 Act and allows them to continue in force unless and until superseded by anything done or any action taken under the 1961 Act. This proviso does not apply to rights which got vested by operation of the 1953 Act. These are protected by Section 4(c) of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1898, according to which, the repeal of an enactment does not affect, inter alia, any right acquired under the repealed enactment. As in the present case the Gram Panchayat had acquired the right under the 1953 Act, its repeal by 1961 Act did not in any way affect the right which the Gram Panchayat had acquired over the lands in question. So, the proviso did not operate qua the lands at hand.

    9. The aforesaid being the legal position, we hold that what has been stated in Rule 3 of the Punjab Gram Panchayat Rules either in its main part or in the proviso cannot be called in the aid by the respondents to claim reversion of the lands to them. The contrary view taken by the two courts below is not sustainable in law.

    10. The appeal is, therefore, allowed by setting aside the impugned judgment as a consequence of which the suit filed by the respondents stands dismissed. In the facts and circumstances of the case, we, however, leave the parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Notified Area Committee And Another v. Des Raj And Others
    (Aug 8, 1995)