Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, a permanent employee of the Department of Telecommunications, Government of India, was recruited in 1972 as an Engineering Supervisor and, after training, appointed on 30 March 1974. He was later redesignated as a Junior Telecom Officer (JTO) in the Kerala Circle. Having passed the departmental examination in 1985, he became eligible for promotion to Telegraph Engineering Service Group ‘B’ (TES Group ‘B’) under the TES Group ‘B’ Recruitment Rules, 1981.

In 1991 the Department upgraded 3,200 JTO posts to TES Group ‘B’ nationwide. Although more than 200 JTOs from the Kerala Circle were considered, only 118 TES Group ‘B’ posts were allotted to that Circle. The respondent, despite seniority, was posted to the Maharashtra Circle while certain juniors remained in Kerala. After an unsuccessful representation to the Government, he filed O.A. No. 1058 of 1990 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (Ernakulam Bench) seeking re-allotment to Kerala.

On 12 July 1991 the Tribunal quashed the transfer order and directed the administration to consider posting the respondent in Kerala within one year. The Union of India and the Telecom Commission appealed to the Supreme Court challenging that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Administrative Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction by quashing the respondent’s transfer on promotion from Kerala Circle to another Circle.
  2. Whether the impugned transfer order was vitiated by violation of statutory rules, mala fides, or arbitrariness so as to warrant judicial interference.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (Union of India & Telecom Commission)

  • The Tribunal interfered in a routine administrative matter relating to transfer and posting on promotion, which lies within the executive domain.
  • Officers in TES Group ‘B’ are liable to serve anywhere in India; no vested right exists to remain in a particular Circle.
  • No statutory rule was violated, and there was no allegation or proof of mala fides.
  • Relied on:
    • Union of India v. H.N. Kirtania (1989) 3 SCC 447 – Tribunal cannot interfere when a transfer is legal and bona fide.
    • Shilpi Bose (Mrs) v. State of Bihar 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659 – Courts should not interfere with transfers made in public interest unless violative of mandatory rules or tainted by mala fides.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Entitled to be included among the 118 TES Group ‘B’ posts allotted to Kerala based on seniority.
  • Some juniors were retained in Kerala, showing arbitrariness in the posting order.
  • Government policy favours posting husband and wife at the same station “as far as possible”, which was ignored.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. H.N. Kirtania (1989) 3 SCC 447 Tribunal or court should not interfere with transfer orders that are legal and free from mala fides. Supported the view that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to set aside the respondent’s transfer in absence of illegality or mala fides.
Shilpi Bose (Mrs) v. State of Bihar, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659 Courts should refrain from interfering with administrative transfers unless contrary to mandatory rules or tainted by mala fide intent. Reinforced that the respondent had no vested right to remain in Kerala and that routine transfers should not be judicially reviewed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that the respondent occupied a transferable post and therefore had no vested right to remain in Kerala. It found no statutory rule breached nor any mala fides alleged or proven in the transfer to Maharashtra. The fact that certain juniors were retained in Kerala and that the “spouse posting” policy existed did not confer an enforceable right to a Kerala posting.

The Court accepted the appellants’ reliance on H.N. Kirtania and Shilpi Bose, emphasizing judicial restraint in matters of administrative transfer. It noted that the Telecom Commission had subsequently considered the respondent’s request on compassionate grounds but could not accommodate him because many officers who had completed tenure were awaiting postings to Kerala. Consequently, the Tribunal’s direction was held to be an overreach of its jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; TRIBUNAL ORDER SET ASIDE.

The Supreme Court reinstated the transfer order, nullifying the Tribunal’s directive. Nevertheless, it observed that the appellants may re-examine the respondent’s request for a Kerala posting, along with similarly situated officers, within one year. The judgment reaffirms existing principles limiting judicial interference in routine administrative transfers and does not create new precedent beyond applying established case law.

    Union Of India And Another v. N.P Thomas .

    S. Ratnavel Pandian, J.— Leave granted.

    2. This appeal is directed by the appellants, namely, Union of India and the Telecom Commission challenging the correctness of the judgment and order of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench dated July 12, 1991 made in O.A No. 1058 of 1991.

    3. The respondent herein is a Kerala-based permanent employee in the Department of Telecommunications, Government of India. He was selected in 1972 and posted as Engineering Supervisor. On successful completion of training he was appointed in that capacity on March 30, 1974. Subsequently, he was redesignated as Junior Telecom Officer (for short ‘JTO’) and allotted to the Kerala Circle. The next higher post for promotion was Telegraph Engineering Service Group ‘B’ (for short ‘TES’) under the provisions of TES (Group ‘B’ Post) Recruitment Rules, 1981. The applicant passed the departmental qualifying examination in 1985 and became eligible for promotion to TES Group ‘B’ post but he was not given the promotion because of stagnation in that post. The administration of the department in 1991 upgraded 3200 posts of JTOs to TES Group ‘B’ after the approval of DPC. Appellant 2 ordered the promotion of 3200 JTOs to TES Group ‘B’ posts on all-India basis. Out of these, more than 200 JTOs were borne on Kerala Circle which, however, had only 118 posts of JTOs promoted to TES Group ‘B’ allotted to it.

    4. The respondent claimed that he was entitled to be posted in Kerala Circle by including his name in the above 118 posts. But he was allotted to Maharashtra Circle though some of his juniors were allotted to Kerala itself on promotion. He made a representation to the Government but failed. Therefore, he filed O.A No. 1058 of 1990 in the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam praying for a direction to the Central Government to re-allot him to Kerala Circle. It appears that the appellants before the Tribunal undertook to consider the claim of the applicant along with other similarly situated persons taking into account the vacancies that were existing as well as such of those which might arise in future within a period of one year. Having regard to the facts and submissions made by the parties, the Tribunal quashed the impugned order of transfer of the respondent from Kerala Circle to any other circle and directed the appellants to consider posting the respondent in Group ‘B’ post in Kerala Circle itself within a period of one year from the order of the Tribunal and also passed certain other directions. On being aggrieved by the judgment and order of the Tribunal, the present appeal is preferred by the appellants.

    5. According to the appellants, the Tribunal had exceeded its jurisdiction by interfering in the normal orders of transfer and posting on promotion of a Government servant and that the Tribunal was not justified in quashing the order of transfer especially when an officer of Group ‘B’ to the Telecom Commission has got a liability for service all over India. In support of their contentions, two decisions were relied upon: those being (1) Union of India v. H.N Kirtania (1989) 3 SCC 447, and (2) Shilpi Bose (Mrs) v. State of Bihar 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659.

    6. In H.N Kirtania case (1989) 3 SCC 447 it has been held that when the transfer order is legal and not vitiated by any unfairness and mala fides the Tribunal had no jurisdiction in issuing directions.

    7. In Shilpi Bose case 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659, the Court observed thus:

    “In our opinion, the courts should not interfere with a transfer order which is made in public interest and for administrative reasons unless the transfer orders are made in violation of any mandatory statutory rule or on the ground of mala fide. A government servant holding a transferable post has no vested right to remain posted at one place or the other, he is liable to be transferred from one place to the other. Transfer orders issued by the competent authority do not violate any of his legal rights. Even if a transfer order is passed in violation of executive instructions or orders, the courts ordinarily should not interfere with the order instead affected party should approach the higher authorities in the department. If the courts continue to interfere with day-to-day transfer orders issued by the Government and its subordinate authorities, there will be complete chaos in the administration which would not be conducive to public interest.”

    8. In the present case, it cannot be said that the transfer order of the respondent transferring him out of Kerala Circle is violative of any statutory rule or that the transfer order suffers on the ground of mala fides. The submissions of the respondent that some of his juniors are retained by Kerala Circle and that his transfer is against the policy of the Government posting the husband and wife in the same station as far as possible, cannot be countenanced since the respondent holding a transferable post has no vested right to remain in the Kerala Circle itself and cannot claim, as a matter of right, the posting in that circle even on promotion.

    9. Learned counsel for the appellants brought to our notice the order of the Government of India, Telecom Commission dated April 20, 1992 showing that the case of the respondent for modification of posting to Kerala Circle has been considered on compassionate grounds by giving due weightage and consideration to employment of spouse and other personal problems in such cases, but it is not possible to accommodate such officer in Kerala Circle itself as several officers who have completed their tenure postings are waiting for their postings in Kerala Telecom Circle.

    10. For all the aforementioned reasons, we hold that the Tribunal was not justified in quashing the order of transfer of the respondent and accordingly we set aside the order of the Tribunal.

    11. Before parting with this judgment, we, in the light of the observation made by the Tribunal reading that “the respondents 1 and 2 are prepared to consider the claims of the applicant along with other similarly situated persons taking into account the vacancies that are at present existing and such of those which may arise in future within a period of one year”, would like to observe that the appellants herein, notwithstanding the allowance of this appeal, may consider the case of the respondent along with the case of the other similarly situated persons within a period of one year from today since there was an ex parte interim stay dated November 25, 1991 of the order of the Tribunal and then the modified order dated January 27, 1992 directing status quo instead of interim stay which orders, in our opinion, might have stood in the way of considering the case of the respondent along with others as agreed upon by the appellants before the Tribunal.

    12. The appeal is allowed subject to the above observation.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Another v. N.P Thomas .
    (Sep 22, 1992)