AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 15(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 15(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Survey No. 650/1 in Palukur Village, Kurnool District (40 acres) contains limestone slabs, a minor mineral. The chronological events are as follows:

  • Venkatesan held a quarry lease that was to expire on 20 August 1987. He applied for renewal but withdrew the application on 17 July 1987.
  • On 18 July 1987, his son (Respondent 4) applied for a lease over 18 acres of the same land.
  • On 10 August 1987, the appellant, a Labour Cooperative Society, applied for a lease over the entire 40 acres.
  • Both applications were deemed rejected under Rule 13(1) after 90 days, leading to successful revisions that remitted them to the Deputy Director of Mines and Geology.
  • On 17 February 1988, Respondent 5 (another Labour Cooperative Society) applied for a lease over all 40 acres.
  • On 3 October 1988, the Deputy Director granted 18 acres to Respondent 4 and the remaining 22 acres to Respondent 5, rejecting the appellant’s application as time-barred.
  • The appellant’s first writ petition was dismissed for availability of an appellate remedy. Its statutory appeal was then dismissed on 28 March 1989, leading to Writ Petition No. 4748/1989.
  • The Single Judge upheld the grant to Respondent 4, set aside the grant to Respondent 5, and directed reconsideration between the appellant and Respondent 5.
  • On appeal, the Division Bench restored the grant to Respondent 5 and dismissed the appellant’s writ appeal, prompting the present Supreme Court appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. How should sub-rule (4) of Rule 12 of the A.P. Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1966 be interpreted, particularly the significance of the word “within” when coordinating with Rule 13(2)?
  2. Whether the appellant’s application dated 10 August 1987 was time-barred under the Rules.
  3. Whether the applications of Respondents 4 and 5 were validly entertained and granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Division Bench erred in declaring the appellant’s 10 August 1987 application as time-barred while treating Respondent 4’s application as timely.
  • If the appellant’s application is considered late, Respondent 5’s 17 February 1988 application—filed well after lease expiry—must also be considered out of time.
  • The preference scheme in Rule 12 should have favored the appellant over Respondent 5.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook a textual and contextual interpretation of Rules 12 and 13:

  1. Observed that the use of “within” in Rule 12(4) was inadvertent and should be ignored to maintain harmony with Rule 13(2).
  2. Outlined three hierarchical categories of applications:
    1. Renewal applications by existing lessees (Rule 13(2)).
    2. Applications filed between 90 and 30 days before lease expiry (Rule 12(4)).
    3. Applications filed within 30 days before or any time after lease expiry.
    Each category enjoys priority over the next.
  3. Applied the framework to the facts:
    • Venkatesan’s withdrawal removed category (a) consideration.
    • Respondent 4’s application fell into category (b) and was the only such application; its grant for 18 acres was proper.
    • The appellant’s and Respondent 5’s applications were both category (c) and therefore on equal footing; rejection of the appellant as time-barred was incorrect.
  4. However, given the elapsed lease period (five-year term largely spent), the Court declined to remand for fresh consideration, aiming to settle the dispute definitively.
  5. Preference between the two Labour Cooperative Societies was assessed on equitable grounds noted by the Division Bench:
    • Respondent 5 comprises members of the traditional stone-cutter “Vadde” community, a group at the lowest rung of backward classes.
    • The appellant already holds a 65-acre lease elsewhere, whereas Respondent 5 has only 15 acres besides the disputed 22 acres.
  6. These factors justified upholding the grant to Respondent 5 despite the procedural error concerning the appellant’s application.

Holding and Implications

The appeal was dismissed. The Supreme Court affirmed the Division Bench’s judgment, validating the leases granted to Respondent 4 (18 acres) and Respondent 5 (22 acres), and leaving the appellant without relief.

Implications: The decision clarifies the chronological priority scheme under Rules 12(4) and 13(2) and signals that minor drafting anomalies (“within” in Rule 12(4)) should not distort the intended hierarchy. No new binding precedent on broader mineral-lease jurisprudence was announced beyond this interpretive guidance.

    Labour Contract Coop. Society, Palikur v. Director Of Mines & Geology

    B.P Jeevan Reddy, J.— Leave granted.

    2. This appeal is directed against the judgment of a Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissing Writ Appeal No. 1062 of 1991 preferred by the appellant. The main issue in this appeal is the interpretation to be placed upon sub-rule (4) of Rule 12 of A.P Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1966.

    3. Survey No. 650/1 Palukur Village in Kurnool District is of an extent of 40 acres. It contains a minor mineral, limestone slab. One Venkatesan was granted a lease for the said extent earlier. The term of his lease was expiring on August 20, 1987. He applied for renewal of the lease 90 days before the expiry of his lease as contemplated by sub-rule (2) of Rule 13 of the said rules. On July 17, 1987 however he withdrew his application. On July 18, 1987 his son, respondent 4, applied for grant of lease in respect of 18 acres in the said survey number. No orders were passed thereon by the appropriate authorities. On August 10, 1987 the appellant, a Labour Cooperative Society, applied for lease in respect of the entire extent of 40 acres. Both these applications remained pending till the expiry of 90 days from the respective dates they were filed, with the result that they were deemed to have been rejected. Both of them filed revisions before the Government which were allowed and their applications remitted for disposal in accordance with law to the Deputy Director of Mines and Geology, Cuddapah.

    4. On February 17, 1988, respondent 5, which too is a Labour Cooperative Society applied for lease in respect of the entire extent of 40 acres.

    5. On October 3, 1988, the Deputy Director passed orders granting lease in respect of 18 acres in favour of respondent 4 (son of the previous lessee) and the remaining 22 acres in favour of respondent 5. The application filed by the appellant was rejected as barred by time. Against the said order the appellant filed a writ petition in the High Court which was rejected in view of the alternative remedy of appeal to Government, provided by the rules. Appellant accordingly preferred an appeal to the Government which was dismissed on March 28, 1989. He then filed the Writ Petition No. 4748 of 1989 from which the present appeal arises. The writ petition was heard and disposed of by a learned Single Judge, who held that the grant of lease in favour of respondent 4 is proper and valid but that the rejection of the application filed by the appellant is illegal. The grant in favour of respondent 5 was set aside and the Deputy Director directed to reconsider the applications of the appellant and respondent 5 in accordance with the rules. Against the judgment of the learned Single Judge the appellant preferred Writ Appeal No. 1062 of 1991 while respondent 5 preferred cross-objections. Both of them were heard by a Division Bench which disposed of the writ appeal in the following terms:

    (1) The order of the learned Single Judge confirming the grant in favour of the respondent 4 is unexceptionable.
    (2) The learned Judge was not right in setting aside the grant in favour of respondent 5. The grant in favour of respondent 5 is equally valid and proper. Accordingly the writ appeal was dismissed and the cross-objections filed by respondent 5 were allowed.

    6. Shri K. Madhava Reddy, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the Division Bench erred in holding that the application filed by the appellant on August 10, 1987 was barred by limitation and also in holding that the application of respondent 4 was well in time. He submitted that if the appellant's application submitted within 30 days of the expiry of the lease (in favour of Venkatesan, the previous lessee) is barred by time so is the application of respondent 5 which was filed long after the expiry of the said lease. The learned counsel also assailed the correctness of the holding that the application of respondent 4 was within time and that it was rightly allowed.

    7. For a proper appreciation of the issues in controversy it is necessary to notice the relevant rules. A.P Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1966 were framed by the Governor of Andhra Pradesh in exercise of the rule-making power conferred upon him by Section 15(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957. Rules 12 and 13 prescribe the manner in which the leases of minor minerals are to be granted and renewed. Insofar as they are relevant, they read as follows:

    “12. Grant of lease.—[Sub-rule (1) omitted as unnecessary.]
    (2) Whenever more than one application are received for grant of a quarry lease, the Deputy Director shall dispose of the applications in order of preference specified below:

    (i) Applications of Government Department and Government Corporations and Companies;

    (ii) Applications of Labour Contract Cooperative Societies;

    (iii) Applications of unemployed persons who possess any recognised qualification in Geology, Geophysics, or Mining Engineering or any other allied subjects;

    (iv) Other applications;

    (3) (Omitted as unnecessary.)
    (4) In case where the quarry lease holders fail to apply for renewal of the lease of the areas within ninety days before the expiry of the lease held by them, as required under sub-rule (2) of Rule 13, fresh application for grant of quarry lease, in respect of those areas, will be entertained thirty days before the expiry of the lease.
    13. Disposal of applications.— (1) The application for the grant of a quarry lease shall be disposed of within ninety days from the date of its receipt and if it is not disposed of within that period, the application shall be deemed to have been refused. The lease deed shall be executed within ninety days from the date of grant of lease or within such further period as the Director may allow in this behalf and if no such lease deed is executed within the said period due to any default on the part of the applicant, the Deputy Director may revoke the order granting the lease.
    (2) The application for the renewal of a quarry lease shall be made at least ninety days before the expiry of the period of lease to the Deputy Director and it shall be disposed of before the expiry of the lease period. If the application is not so disposed of within that period, it shall be deemed to have been not renewed:
    Provided that where an application for grant of quarry lease is rejected or deemed to have been refused under these rules, the fee paid by the applicant under sub-rule (1) of Rule 12 shall be refunded to the applicant:
    Provided further that where an application for grant of quarry lease is rejected on account of any lapse on the part of the applicant in supplying any material information, the fee paid by the applicant under sub-rule (1) of Rule 12 shall be forfeited to the Government.”

    8. We have heard the counsel for the parties on the interpretation to be placed upon the above rules. The presence of the word ‘within’ in Rule 12(4) has given room for some avoidable controversy. The said word appears to have crept into the sub-rule incautiously. The said word (‘within’) is not used either in sub-rule (2) of Rule 13 or for that matter in the latter portion of Rule 12(4). It must be noticed that the first half of Rule 12(4) [“In case where … under sub-rule (2) of Rule 13”] expressly refers to Rule 13(2) and says that if no application is made thereunder others can apply. The said words cannot and can never mean anything different than what is provided by Rule 13(2). It is for this reason that we say the word ‘within’ therein is inappropriate and ought to be ignored. The rule-making authority would be well advised to delete the same. On a proper and harmonious reading of Rules 13(2), 12(4) and other allied provisions, the following scheme emerges:

    (1) An existing lessee has to apply for renewal, if he so chooses, at least ninety days before the expiry of the period of his lease. Such application has to be disposed of before the expiry of his lease. If it is not so disposed of, the application must be deemed to have been rejected [Rule 13(2)].
    (2) Within ninety days of the expiry of the lease and thirty days before the expiry of the lease, it is open to others too to apply for grant of lease in respect of the area, or a part of the area, held by the lessee [Rule 12(4)]. These applications may be termed as second category applications. If any such application or applications are received under Rule 12(4) they should be considered and disposed of in accordance with law.
    (3) Applications for lease received within thirty days of the expiry of the lease and those received after the expiry of the lease constitute the third category. These applications too have to be considered and disposed of in accordance with law.
    (4) The above three categories are in the descending order. Each category enjoys a preference over the other. In other words, the application for renewal filed by the existing lessee under Rule 13(2) shall be taken up first and disposed of. If renewal is granted, exhausting the area of lease, no occasion arises for considering the applications falling in the second and third category. In case, however, where no application for renewal is filed or where it is filed but rejected, the second category applications shall have to be taken up and considered. If any of them are allowed and lease granted, exhausting the area of lease, there is no occasion for considering the third category applications. In case, no application falling in the second category is received or if received, is rejected, does the occasion arise for taking up and considering the third category applications.
    (5) We may clarify in the interest of unbroken exploitation of mineral wealth, that the authority can well receive the applications falling within all the three categories, if and when filed. For example, he ought not to refuse to receive the second category applications merely because the renewal application is filed and so on. But the applications received shall be placed in their proper category and considered in the order indicated above.

    9. Now let us consider the facts of this case in the light of the above understanding of the relevant rules. The existing lessee had indeed applied for renewal ninety days before the expiry of his lease. But before it could be granted (or rejected, as the case may be) it was withdrawn on July 17, 1987, which means that the field was now clear for considering the second category applications i.e those received in terms of Rule 12(4). The application of respondent 4 was the only application received in terms of Rule 12(4). The grant of the said application is, therefore, perfectly in order. However, it was only for 18 acres. Twenty-two acres still remained, in respect of which the third category applications had to be considered. As clarified hereinabove, the application received within thirty days of the expiry of the lease (like the one filed by the appellant) and the applications received after the expiry of the lease (like the one filed by respondent 5) stand on the same footing. The application of the petitioner was not entitled to any preferential consideration on account of the fact that it was filed before the expiry of the lease, because it was filed within thirty days of the expiry of the lease. It did not fall in the second category but only in the third category.

    10. It must, accordingly, be said that the authorities were not right in rejecting the appellant's application as barred by time. We do not, however, propose to send back the matter to the authorities in view of the time that has elapsed since the grant in favour of respondent 5. The term of the lease is five years only. A major portion of that term is already over. We, therefore, propose to give a quietus to the controversy. If so, question arises who among the two Labour Cooperative Societies should be preferred. The Division Bench has pointed out, rightly in our opinion, that among the two of them, respondent 5 is entitled to preference for more than one reason viz.:

    (1) The fifth respondent society is composed of member of Vadde Community who are the traditional stone-cutters. Though they do not belong to Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes, they are at the lowest rung among the backward classes, whereas the petitioner society is composed of mere labourers who do not necessarily belong to the traditional stone-cutter community.
    (2) The appellant/society admittedly holds a lease in respect of 65 acres whereas the fifth respondent has none apart from the one in controversy. Mr Madhava Reddy has brought to our notice that even the fifth respondent has a lease in respect of 15 acres. Even if we take that fact into consideration, still the fifth respondent is entitled to preference, because its area is far smaller than that of the appellants.

    11. For the above reasons, the appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.

    12. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Labour Contract Coop. Society, Palikur v. Director Of Mines & Geology
    (Sep 22, 1992)