AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12(3)(b) of the Act
  • Section 114 of the Evidence Act
  • Section 12(3)(b) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947
  • Section 12(3)(a) of the Act
  • Section 12(2) of the Act
  • Section 27 of the General Clauses Act
  • paragraph two of Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act
  • Section 12(3)(a) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12(3)(b) of the Act
  • Section 114 of the Evidence Act
  • Section 12(3)(b) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947
  • Section 12(3)(a) of the Act
  • Section 12(2) of the Act
  • Section 27 of the General Clauses Act
  • paragraph two of Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act
  • Section 12(3)(a) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The landlords filed a suit for possession of the rented premises under the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947. The defendants were (i) M/s. Kulkarni Patterns Pvt. Ltd. (tenant), (ii) its Chairman Shri D.G. Kulkarni, and (iii) Mrs. M.D. Kulkarni, a director of the company.

The 7th Additional Small Causes Judge dismissed the suit, holding that service of the landlords’ notice dated 7 August 1980 was not proved and that the case did not fall under either Section 12(3)(a) or 12(3)(b) of the Act. On appeal, the 10th Additional District Judge, Pune, set aside that decision and decreed possession in favour of the landlords under Section 12(3)(b), finding both valid service of notice and persistent default in rent payment. The tenants’ writ petition before the Bombay High Court was dismissed on 30 August 1991, and the decree was affirmed. The present appeal to the Supreme Court was brought by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a presumption of valid service of the landlords’ notice dated 7 August 1980 could be drawn against the tenant company under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114 of the Evidence Act, satisfying Section 12(2) of the Bombay Rent Act read with Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act.
  2. Whether the tenants had complied with the mandatory requirements of Section 12(3)(b) of the Bombay Rent Act by depositing the entire arrears of rent on the first date of hearing and by paying subsequent rent regularly during the pendency of the suit and appeal, so as to avoid eviction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Additional District Judge erred in presuming service of notice; the only acknowledgement card (Ex. 51) was disputed, and defendant 2 denied his signature on it.
  • Once the presumption was rebutted by sworn denial, the burden shifted to the landlords to prove service through the postman or other evidence, which they failed to do.
  • Reliance was placed on Green View Radio Service v. Laxmibai Ramji (1990) 4 SCC 497, where this Court held that a credible denial of signature on an acknowledgement due receipt could rebut the presumption of postal service.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Green View Radio Service v. Laxmibai Ramji, (1990) 4 SCC 497 Presumption of service of registered post can be rebutted by credible denial; burden then shifts to sender to prove actual service. The Court accepted the principle but distinguished the facts, holding that only one of three notices was in dispute, and that service on the tenant company was still presumed and unrebutted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that three separate registered notices (postal receipts Exs. 52–54) were dispatched—one addressed to the tenant company itself. Although defendant 2 disputed the signature on a single acknowledgement card (Ex. 51), the Court held:

  • Under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, notice “sent by post to the party” is sufficient; service on the tenant company therefore satisfied statutory requirements.
  • Even applying Green View Radio Service, the rebuttal went only to one acknowledgement; no evidence was offered to rebut the presumption as to the notice addressed to the company.
  • The presumption under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114 of the Evidence Act therefore stood unrebutted for service on the tenant company.
  • On the merits of Section 12(3)(b), the tenants had deposited only Rs 66,000 against arrears of Rs 71,088 on the first date of hearing and failed to pay rent during the appeal, amounting to persistent default. The findings of the Additional District Judge on this point were unassailable.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.

The decree for possession under Section 12(3)(b) of the Bombay Rent Act, as affirmed by the High Court, stands. The immediate consequence is that the tenants must vacate the premises; the judgment turns on application of existing statutory presumptions and does not create new precedent beyond reaffirming the principles in Green View Radio Service.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Kulkarni Patterns Pvt. Ltd. And Others v. Vasant Baburao Ashtekar And Others

    Kasliwal, J..— This appeal by grant of special leave is directed against the judgment of the Bombay High Court dated August 30, 1991 in a suit for possession under the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’). The suit was dismissed by the 7th Additional Small Causes Judge. On appeal the learned 10th Additional District Judge, Pune by judgment dated April 25, 1991 set aside the order of the trial court and decreed the plaintiff's suit for possession. The tenants filed the writ petition in the High Court challenging the order of the Additional District Judge, but the same was dismissed and the decree for possession passed by the Additional District Judge was affirmed.

    2. The trial court held that the service of notice dated August 7, 1980 on the defendant-tenants was not held proved. The plaintiffs were unable to prove that the postal acknowledgement Ex. 51 contained the signatures of defendant 2 or 3. It was held that on the point of service of notice the case of the plaintiff was rather confusing and not clear. It was held that even assuming that the notice had been served yet the case did not fall under Section 12(3)(a) of the Act. The trial court also held that the case did not fall under Section 12(3)(b) of the Act the defendants had paid Rs 55,800 on January 16, 1984 and thereafter made regular payment of Rs 600 every month. According to the learned trial court the issues were framed on August 26, 1985 and before that the defendants had made full payment as demanded in the notice and as such no decree can be passed under Section 12(3)(b) of the Act.

    3. Learned Additional District Judge reversed the above finding of the trial court and held that the evidence of the plaintiff showed that the copy of the notice was sent to all the defendants by registered post. The postal receipts have been filed as Exs. 52, 53 and 54. Learned Additional District Judge further held that when the notices are sent by registered post it is presumed to have been served and mere denial by the tenants had no value, unless they proved some extraordinary happenings or events which prevented following of usual course of business. Learned Additional District Judge further held that the notice was sent on the address given in the plaint and it was admitted by the defendant in his statement that it contained the correct address. A presumption of service of notice was drawn under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114 of the Evidence Act. Learned Additional District Judge though affirmed the finding of the trial court that the case is not covered under Section 12(3)(a) of the Act, but the plaintiffs were entitled to a decree under Section 12(3)(b) of the Act. In this regard learned Additional District Judge recorded the finding that the entire arrears of rent amounted to Rs 71,088 but the defendant-tenant only deposited Rs 66,000 till the first date of hearing and thus remained in arrears of Rs 5088. It was also held that the provisions of Sections 12(3)(b) of the Act are mandatory provisions and those are required to be strictly complied with by the tenants during the pendency of the suit and also appeal when the landlord claims possession of the suit premises on the ground of Section 12(3)(b) of the Act. The defendant-tenant did not deposit the entire arrears on the first date of hearing and did not deposit the further rent during the pendency of the appeal. Thus the defendant persistently committed defaults during the pendency of the suit and also the appeal in paying the rent.

    4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have thoroughly gone through the record. It is important to note that M/s Kulkarni Patterns Pvt. Ltd. (defendant 1) was the tenant, defendant 2 Shri D.G Kulkarni was the Chairman of the company and defendant 3 Mrs M.D Kulkarni was the wife of defendant 2 and Director of defendant 1.

    5. The plaintiffs sent a notice dated August 7, 1980 to all the defendants vide postal receipts Exs. 52, 53 and 54. Ex. 51 is only one acknowledgement receipt which has been produced on record.

    6. It has been contended on behalf of the appellants that the learned Additional District Judge was wrong in drawing presumption of service of notice in the facts of the present case. It was submitted that the plaintiff initially stated that the acknowledgement receipt Ex. 51 contained the signatures of defendant 3, but subsequently admitted that it contained the signature of defendant 2. It was further argued that defendant 2 had appeared in the witness box and clearly denied his signatures on Ex. 51. It was thus contended that the presumption of service of notice was rebutted and thereafter the burden lay on the plaintiffs to prove the service of notice by examining the postman or by other evidence and the plaintiffs having failed to do so, the service of notice having not established, the suit was liable to be dismissed. Reliance in support of the above contention was placed on a decision of this Court to which one of us was a party in Green View Radio Service v. Laxmibai Ramji (1990) 4 SCC 497. Reliance was placed on the following observations made in the above case:

    “In this connection, we may also point out that the provisions of Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act require that notice to quit has to be sent either by post to the party or be tendered or delivered personally to such party or to one of his family members or servants at his residence or if such tender or delivery is not practicable, affixed to a conspicuous part of the property. The service is complete when the notice is sent by post. In the present case, as pointed out earlier, the notice was sent by the plaintiff's advocate by registered post acknowledgement due. The acknowledgement signed by the party was received by the advocate of the plaintiff. Thus in our view the presumption of service of a letter sent by registered post can be rebutted by the addressee by appearing as witness and stating that he never received such letter. If the acknowledgement due receipt contains the signatures of the addressee himself and the addressee as a witness states that he never received such letter and the acknowledgement due does not bear his signature and such statement of the addressee is believed then it would be a sufficient rebuttal of the presumption drawn against him. The burden would then shift on the plaintiff who wants to rely on such presumption to satisfy the court by leading oral or documentary evidence to prove the service of such letter on the addressee. This rebuttal by the defendant of the presumption drawn against him would of course depend on the veracity of his statement. The court in the facts and circumstances of a case may not consider such denial by the defendant as truthful and in that case such denial alone would not be sufficient. But if there is nothing to disbelieve the statement of the defendant then it would be sufficient rebuttal of the presumption of service of such letter or notice sent to him by registered post.”

    In the present case the plaintiffs had sent a copy of the notice to all the three defendants by registered post. Three postal receipts Exs. 52, 53 and 54 have been filed in the present case and Ex. 51, one acknowledgement receipt. As regards Ex. 51, the defendant 2 has appeared in the witness box and has denied his signatures. However, it has not been shown that this acknowledgement receipt was related to which of the three notices sent vide postal receipts Exs. 52, 53 and 54. The plaintiffs have clearly proved that three notices were sent by registered post and which is clearly borne out from the three postal receipts. Admittedly the premises were taken on rent in the name of the defendant 1 namely Kulkarni Patterns Pvt. Ltd. and it is proved that one of the notices by registered post was also sent to the company. It has been admitted by the defendant 2 in his statement that the notice was sent on the correct address. The defendant 2 in his statement has nowhere stated that no notice had been received by the company. The only denial is in respect of the acknowledgement receipt Ex. 51 and the only inference which could legitimately be drawn is that in respect of one notice, it was not proved as to who acknowledged the receipt of the notice. We do not approve the following statement of law made by the learned Additional District Judge “that the evidence of the defendant did not show any extraordinary happenings or the events which prevented the following of usual course of business and thus, his mere denial has no value”. However, in the present case three notices were sent by registered post and one of which was sent in the name of the defendant company who was the tenant, a presumption can legitimately be drawn that the notice dated August 7, 1980 had been served on the company. There is no rebuttal on behalf of the defendant as regards the notice served on the company and in the facts and circumstances of the present case we hold that notice dated August 7, 1980 sent by registered post was served on the defendant company. In Green View Radio Service (1990) 4 SCC 497 it was held that the acknowledgement due receipt contained the signature of the addressee himself and the addressee as a witness stated that he never received such letter and the acknowledgement due did not bear his signature and such statement of the addressee if believed then it would be a sufficient rebuttal of the presumption drawn against him. The burden will then shift on the plaintiff who wants to rely on such presumption to satisfy the court by leading oral or documentary evidence to prove the service of such letter on the addressee. Even applying this statement of law in the facts of the present case, the rebuttal, if any, made by defendant 2 can be related only with regard to Ex. 51 for one notice but not with regard to all the three notices sent by registered post vide Exs. 52 to 54. Thus, in the facts of the case in hand before us we are fully convinced that the service of notice shall have to be presumed so far as defendant company is concerned and there is no rebuttal to such presumption by the defendant appellants.

    7. The requirement of sending notice under Section 12(2) of the Act is to be done in the manner prescribed under paragraph two of Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act which reads as under:

    “106. … Every notice under this section must be in writing signed by or on behalf of the person giving it and either be sent by post to the party who is intended to be bound by it or be tendered or delivered personally to such party, or to one of his family or servants, at his residence, or (if such tender or delivery is not practicable) affixed to a conspicuous part of the property.”

    The reading of the above provision clearly shows that the notice can be sent by post to the party who is intended to be bound by it. Thus, the notice sent by registered post in the name of the defendant company who is the tenant is fully in accordance with the requirement of Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act.

    8. So far as the finding recorded by the learned Additional District Judge that the defendants were defaulter in the payment of rent and full amount of rent was not paid or deposited on the first date of hearing and no rent was paid month by month during the pendency of the appeal could not be assailed by the learned counsel for the appellants. Thus, the learned Additional District Judge as well as the High Court were right in passing a decree for possession under Section 12(3)(b) of the Act. As a result of the above discussion and findings recorded by us, we find no force in this appeal and the same is dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kulkarni Patterns Pvt. Ltd. And Others v. Vasant Baburao Ashtekar And Others
    (Jan 17, 1992)