AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • the 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text, but mentioned as a reference)
  • Section 12(1)(f) of Madhya Pradesh Accommodation Control Act, 1961
  • This Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 21 of the Act
  • Section 10 of the Act, subsection (3)(a)(iii)
  • The Act
  • Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • the 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text, but mentioned as a reference)
  • Section 12(1)(f) of Madhya Pradesh Accommodation Control Act, 1961
  • This Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 21 of the Act
  • Section 10 of the Act, subsection (3)(a)(iii)
  • The Act
  • Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondents 1 and 2 (father and son) filed a petition before the Rent Controller, Guntur, under Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960 (“the Act”) seeking eviction of the appellant-tenant from a shop-room. They asserted that the premises were bona fide required for Respondent 2, who had recently completed a B.Com degree and intended to start a ready-made garment business in the disputed premises.

The appellant contested the petition, denying any genuine need. The Rent Controller, after recording evidence, ordered eviction. An appeal to the Subordinate Judge, Guntur, was dismissed, and a further revision under Section 21 of the Act to the Andhra Pradesh High Court met the same fate. The tenant then obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an eviction order under Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Act can stand when the landlord’s petition does not expressly plead all statutory conditions, particularly the absence of any other non-residential premises in the landlord’s occupation.
  2. Whether the Supreme Court should entertain a pleading-deficiency objection raised for the first time at the stage of final appeal when all relevant facts are already on record and no prejudice is shown.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The eviction petition lacked averments that the landlords were not occupying any other non-residential building in the concerned locality, a mandatory condition under Section 10(3)(a)(iii); therefore, the eviction order is legally unsustainable.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • They bona fide require the centrally located shop-room for commencing a ready-made garment business for Respondent 2, giving detailed reasons for selecting the particular premises.
  • No suppression occurred: they disclosed other non-residential buildings owned by Respondent 1, all of which are tenanted and not in their occupation.
  • Because all material facts were before the tribunals and no contrary evidence exists, a technical pleading objection should not defeat their substantive right.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hasmat Rai v. Raghunath Prasad, (1981) 3 SCC 103 A landlord must both plead and prove (i) bona fide requirement and (ii) absence of any other suitable non-residential accommodation; proof without pleading is normally irrelevant. The Court reiterated the principle but distinguished the present case on procedural grounds, declining to set aside the eviction because the pleading objection was never raised earlier and all facts were already on record.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court acknowledged that the landlords failed to plead one of the three statutory ingredients—namely, that they were not occupying another non-residential building. Nonetheless, the Court refused to interfere, reasoning as follows:

  • Point not raised below: The tenant never took the pleading objection before the Rent Controller, the appellate authority, the High Court, or even in the special-leave petition; it surfaced only during final arguments.
  • Full factual record: The landlords had candidly disclosed ownership of other non-residential buildings, all tenanted, establishing that none was in their occupation. Hence, the factual predicate was effectively tried and proved.
  • Futility of remand: Sending the matter back for formal amendment of pleadings and additional evidence would serve no practical purpose, as no new material could alter the outcome.
  • Absence of prejudice: The tenant did not suggest that further opportunity would enable production of evidence to contradict the landlords’ case. Therefore, procedural strictness should yield to substantive justice.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The eviction order is affirmed.

Execution of the eviction decree is postponed until 31 March 1988, subject to the tenant filing an undertaking within four weeks to vacate by that date and continue paying use-and-occupation charges. The decision underscores that an appellate court may overlook pleadings defects when:

  • The objection is raised belatedly;
  • All requisite facts are already on record; and
  • No prejudice is caused to the opposing party.
  • No new precedent on substantive landlord-tenant law is set, but the judgment illustrates the Supreme Court's discretionary approach to procedural lapses.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Duggi Veera Venkata Gopala Satyanarayana v. Sakala Veera Raghavaiah And Another

    M.M Dutt, J.— This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissing the revision petition of the appellant against the order of the Subordinate Judge, Guntur, whereby he affirmed the order of the Rent Controller, Guntur, directing the eviction of the appellant from the disputed shop-room.

    2. Respondents 1 and 2 are respectively the father and son. The respondents filed a petition under Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960, hereinafter referred to as “the Act”, before the Rent Controller, Guntur, praying for an order of eviction against the appellant from the disputed shop-room on the ground that it was bona fide required for Respondent 2, who had passed the BCom Examination, and would start a business in readymade garments in the disputed shop-room. The petition was contested by the appellant. It was inter alia denied by the appellant that the shop-room was bona fide required by the respondents as alleged.

    3. The learned Rent Controller after considering the evidence adduced by the parties passed the eviction order against the appellant holding, inter alia, as follows:

    “Thus, after careful scrutiny of the entire evidence I had no two minds in coming to the conclusion that the petitioners required the suit shop for their personal occupation, namely, for the business of PW 2. I find there is an element of need and it is a bona fide one and not actuated by any oblique motive. I find there is absolute necessity for PW 2 to have his business in the suit shop. Thus, I find the petitioners had brought home the point in their favour. I find that there are valid grounds to order eviction of the respondent.”

    4. Being aggrieved by the said order of the learned Rent Controller, the appellants preferred an appeal to the Subordinate Judge, Guntur, who, however, affirmed the findings of the learned Rent Controller and dismissed the appeal. The appellant preferred a revision petition under Section 21 of the Act before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh against the order of the learned Subordinate Judge. As stated already, the High Court dismissed the revision petition. Hence, this appeal by special leave.

    5. The only point that has been urged on behalf of the appellant is that in the absence of any averment of the facts constituting the grounds or conditions of eviction, as contained in subsection (3)(a)(iii) of Section 10 of the Act, the courts below were not justified in passing the order of eviction against the appellant. Sub-section (3)(a)(iii) provides as follows:

    “(3)(a) A landlord may, subject to the provisions of clause (d), apply to the Controller for an order directing the tenant to put the landlord in possession of the building—
    (iii) in case it is any other non-residential building, if the landlord is not occupying a non-residential building in the city, town or village concerned which is his own or to the possession of which he is entitled whether under this Act or otherwise—
    (a) for the purpose of a business which he is carrying on, on the date of the application, or
    (b) for the purpose of a business which in the opinion of the Controller, the landlord bona fide proposes to commence:”
    [The provisos are not relevant for our purpose and, as such, they are omitted.]
    The conditions which are necessary to be fulfilled for the purpose of getting an order of eviction under sub-clause (iii) are:
    “(1) The building is a non-residential building.
    (2) The landlord is not occupying a non-residential building in the city, town or village concerned, either belonging to him or to the possession of which he is entitled under the Act or otherwise.
    (3) Either he requires the building for the purpose of business which he is carrying on or he bona fide proposes to commence a business.”

    6. There can be no doubt that under the law of pleadings facts mentioned in sub-clause (iii) are to be pleaded in the petition and thereafter proved at the trial for the purpose of an order of eviction against the tenant. In a decision of this Court in Hasmat Rai v. Raghunath Prasad (1981) 3 SCC 103, AIR 1981 SC 1711, (1981) 3 SCR 605 it has been observed by Desai, J. that in order to obtain an order of eviction of a tenant under Section 12(1)(f) of Madhya Pradesh Accommodation Control Act, 1961, the landlord has to plead and establish (i) that he bona fide requires the accommodation let to the tenant for non-residential purposes for the purpose of continuing or starting his business; and (ii) that he has no other reasonably suitable non-residential accommodation of his own in his occupation in the city or the town concerned. Further, it has been observed that any amount of proof offered without appropriate pleading is generally of no relevance. We respectfully agree with the above statement of law and reiterate the same. We are, however, not inclined to interfere with the impugned order of eviction in the instant case for the reasons stated hereinafter.

    7. The point was not taken in any of the courts below, nor has it been taken in the special leave petition. For the first time, it has been raised in the argument before us. Mr P.P Rao, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, has produced before us a copy of the memorandum of civil revision petition that was filed in the High Court. We do not, however, find that the point has been specifically taken in the grounds of revision. It is not disputed that the point was not also argued before the High Court.

    8. It is true that all the ingredients of sub-section (3)(a)(iii) of Section 10 have not been pleaded in the petition for eviction. The respondents have only pleaded their bona fide requirement of the disputed shop-room for the purpose of commencing a business therein. There is no pleading that the respondents are not occupying any non-residential building in the city, town or village concerned either belonging to them or to the possession of which they are entitled under the Act. The respondents, however, did not suppress any fact at the trial and disclosed the non-residential buildings owned by Respondent 1, but not in their occupation. It has also been observed by the High Court that the respondents have come forward with a clean and clear case and with reasons as to why they chose the disputed shop-room for the proposed business to be commenced by Respondent 2. Even if we set aside the eviction order and send the case back on remand to the Rent Controller allowing the parties to amend the pleadings and to adduce further evidence, it will be a futile exercise inasmuch as all the materials are already on record. It is not the case of the appellant that if he is given an opportunity to adduce further evidence after amendment of pleadings, he would be able to furnish any new material showing that the respondents are occupying any non-residential building suitable for commencing the proposed business therein and, as such, they are not entitled to an order for eviction. It is also not in dispute that the other non-residential buildings belonging to Respondent 1 are in occupation of tenants. The principal contention of the appellant before the courts below was that the respondents had no reasonable justification for choosing the disputed shop-room for the purpose of commencing a business therein for Respondent 2. This contention has been overruled by the courts below and also by the High Court inasmuch as the respondents had given sufficient reasons for selecting the disputed shop-room for the purpose of commencing a business in readymade garments. Indeed, it is the case of the respondents that the disputed shop-room is centrally located in the heart of Guntur city in a business locality, that there are a number of readymade garment shops in that locality, and that the disputed shop-room is the best place for commencing such a business.

    9. In view of the facts stated above, particularly of the fact that the point was not raised at any stage of the proceedings, we do not think that we shall be justified in interfering with the order of eviction.

    10. For the reasons aforesaid, the appeal is dismissed. There will, however, be no order as to costs.

    11. We, however, direct that the order for eviction of the appellant from the disputed shop-room shall not be executed till March 31, 1988 provided the appellant gives an undertaking to this Court in writing within four weeks from date that he will vacate and deliver up vacant and peaceful possession of the disputed shop-room on or before March 31, 1988 and regularly keep paying the respondents monthly damages calculated at the rate of rent for use and occupation in the meanwhile.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Duggi Veera Venkata Gopala Satyanarayana v. Sakala Veera Raghavaiah And Another
    (Dec 19, 1986)