AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 76 of U.P Municipalities Act, 1916
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The 1964 Act (implied by context)
  • Section 34, Chapter II of the Act
  • Section 34(1-B) of the Act, Rule 5(1) of the Rules
  • Section 34(1-B) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1916
  • Section 34, sub-section (1-B) of the U.P Municipalities Act, 1916
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 76 of U.P Municipalities Act, 1916
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The 1964 Act (implied by context)
  • Section 34, Chapter II of the Act
  • Section 34(1-B) of the Act, Rule 5(1) of the Rules
  • Section 34(1-B) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1916
  • Section 34, sub-section (1-B) of the U.P Municipalities Act, 1916
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Municipal Board, Kannauj dismissed seventy-four sweeper-employees on 9 April 1964 after the employees allegedly launched an abrupt strike that created insanitary conditions in the town. The Executive Officer invoked the proviso to Rule 5(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipal Boards Servants (Inquiry, Punishment and Termination of Service) Rules and dispensed with the usual inquiry before dismissal.

More than a year later, on 12 May 1965, the State Government, acting under Section 34(1-B) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1916, issued a notification prohibiting “the execution or further execution” of the dismissal order, terming it illegal, improper and adverse to public interest.

The Municipal Board challenged that notification in a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court. A learned Single Judge and, on appeal, an Appellate Bench upheld the State Government’s action. The Board obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 34(1-B) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1916 empowers the State Government to prohibit the execution or further execution of a dismissal order that is self-operative and requires no further steps for its implementation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant: Municipal Board, Kannauj

  • Section 34(1-B) applies only where a resolution or order still requires positive steps for execution; it cannot be used to nullify an order that becomes effective immediately upon being made.
  • By “prohibiting execution,” the State Government in substance cancelled or set aside the dismissal order—an action not authorised by the statute.

Respondent 1: State Government of Uttar Pradesh

  • The dismissal violated Rule 5 because the employees were not afforded an opportunity of being heard, rendering the order illegal and prejudicial to public interest.
  • Section 34(1-B), especially after its 30 November 1964 amendment, permits intervention where an order is in flagrant breach of law or contrary to public interest.

Employee-Respondents

  • Denied that any strike occurred and alleged that the Board’s action was motivated by spite.
  • Maintained that there was no sanitation emergency that justified the wholesale dismissal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shujaat Ullah Khan v. State of U.P., 1966 ALJ 499 Section 34(1-B) authorises only a prohibitory order directed at future acts; it does not permit cancellation of an order that has already taken effect and exhausted itself. The Supreme Court adopted the same reasoning to conclude that the State Government could not nullify a self-executing dismissal order by invoking Section 34(1-B).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the text and structure of Section 34. Sub-sections (1) and (1-A) confer similar powers on other authorities, while sub-section (1-B) empowers the State Government to “prohibit the execution or further execution” of a resolution or order that is prejudicial to public interest or passed in abuse of power.

Justice D. G. Palekar noted that the phrase “prohibit the execution or further execution” necessarily contemplates situations where prospective acts remain to be done in pursuance of the impugned resolution or order. When an order is self-operative—such as an order of dismissal that takes effect immediately—no future act remains to be executed. Consequently, there is nothing the State Government can prohibit without in substance cancelling or setting aside the order, a power the statute does not confer.

The insertion of additional grounds for intervention by the 1964 amendment (flagrant breach of law or abuse of power) did not enlarge the nature of the remedy; it still remains purely prohibitory. The Court found support in the Allahabad High Court decision in Shujaat Ullah Khan, where an exoneration resolution was held to be beyond the reach of Section 34(1-B) once it had taken effect.

Accordingly, the State Government’s notification, issued more than a year after the dismissals and purporting to prohibit their “execution,” was ultra vires because the dismissals had already come into force and required no further implementation.

The respondents’ late contention that the dismissal order had never been communicated was rejected because it was not raised in the High Court and the record showed contemporaneous steps to communicate the decision, including subsequent appeals by several employees.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; STATE GOVERNMENT NOTIFICATION DATED 12 MAY 1965 QUASHED.

By annulling the State Government’s intervention, the Supreme Court reinstated the legal efficacy of the Municipal Board’s dismissal order. The decision clarifies that Section 34(1-B) provides only a prospective, prohibitory remedy and cannot be used to cancel or set aside resolutions or orders that have already taken effect. No broader precedent was laid down beyond delineating the statutory limits of Section 34(1-B).

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Municipal Board, Kannauj v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others

    D.G Palekar, J.— This appeal by special leave against the decision of the Appellate Bench of the Allahabad High Court involves the question of the legality and validity of an order, dated May 12, 1965, passed by the State Government purporting to act under Section 34(1-B) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1916 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). The impugned order is as follows:

    “U.P Government
    Department of Municipal Board,
    Serial No. 1725 GI IIP 1964/64, 12-5-1965.
    NOTIFICATION
    The then Executive Officer of Municipal Board, Kannauj dismissed 74 sweepers of Municipal Board, Kannauj from April 9, 1964, under Section 76 of U.P Municipalities Act, 1916.
    The dismissal of the above sweepers was illegal and improper because the procedure prescribed in Rule 5 of the Uttar Pradesh Municipal Karamchari (Janch, Dand tatha Seva Sampati) Niyamawali (U.P Municipal Boards Servants (Enquiry, Punishment and Termination of Service Rules) was not followed and they were not given any opportunity of being heard and the opinion of the State Government is that the above order of April 9, 1964, by the present Executive Officer, Municipal Board, Kannauj is adverse to public interest and the order has been made by seriously defying the rules of Uttar Pradesh Municipal Karamchari Janch Dand tatha Seva Sampati Niyamawali (U.P Municipal Boards Servants (Enquiry, Punishment and Termination of Service Rules).
    So, the Governor of Uttar Pradesh in exercise of his power under Section 34, sub-section (1-B) of the U.P Municipalities Act, 1916 (U.P Act 2 of 1916) prohibits the execution of the above order of April 9, 1964 and any act done by any person in pursuance of that order and the continuance of that order.

    By Order

    Pran Nath Kapoor

    Secretary.”

    This order is challenged in a writ petition before the High Court by the Municipal Board, Kannauj as being illegal and invalid on several grounds.

    2. The substance of the allegations in the petition by the Municipal Board was that, on account of certain disputes between the Board and the sweeper-employees of the Board, there was a sudden strike by the latter on April 7, 1964. As many as 74 sweepers struck work without notice. By reason of the strike, insanitary conditions developed in the down endangering public health. The Board had, therefore, to act quickly as in an emergency to recruit sweepers to do the job but it was difficult to recruit new men unless continuous employment was given to them and, hence, on April 8, 1964, the Board arranged to have it announced by beat of drum in the town that, unless the striking employees resumed duties by the evening of April 9, 1964, they were liable to be dismissed. The strikers did not join duties by the evening of April 9, 1964, and, therefore, the Executive Officer of the Board dismissed the 74 strikers who were made parties to the petition. It was admitted that the procedure laid down by Rule 5(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Municipal Boards Servants (Inquiry, Punishment and Termination of Service) Rules (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”) was not adopted before taking disciplinary action by way of dismissal; but the Board justified its action by reference to the proviso to Rule 5(1) which stated that the provision of Rule 5(1) shall not apply where the person concerned had absconded and where, for reasons to be recorded in writing, it was impracticable to communicate with him. After the dismissal of the 74 employees on April 9, 1964, some of the employees appealed against the order of dismissal and most of them were reinstated. The others did not appeal and, therefore, the order of dismissal stood in their case. New recruits were appointed in their place. Later i.e more than a year after the order of dismissal, the State Government, purporting to act under Section 34(1-B) of the Act, passed the above order prohibiting the execution or further execution of the order of dismissal passed by the Executive Officer. It was contended that no such order under Section 34(1-B) of the Act could be validly made by the State Government.

    3. The State Government, which was Respondent 1 to the petition, supported its order and contended that the order had been passed in the public interest as, in its opinion, the order of the Executive Officer was illegal and arbitrary and had the effect of throwing a large body of employees out of employment making them suffer privation and misery on account of the continuing operation of the order which was illegally passed. The employee-respondents, on the other hand, denied the more substantial allegations in the petition. They alleged that, as a matter of fact, the employees had not gone on strike and, therefore, there was no question of their abstaining from doing their duties either on April 7, 8 or 9, 1964. There was no question also of any insanitary conditions developing in the town and there was no good reason at all for passing an order of dismissal of all the employees in a body. They further alleged that the order had been passed out of sheer spite in order to teach them a lesson.

    4. The High Court did not, obviously, undertake an inquiry into the disputed facts. What was, however, relevant for its decision was whether, in case the State Government honestly formed the opinion that the order of the Executive Officer was prejudicial to the public interest or was in flagrant breach of a provision of any law — in this case, Rule 5(1) of the Rules, the order prohibiting the execution or further execution of the order would be valid. The learned Single Judge, who considered the petition in the first instance, and the Appellate Bench held that it was open to the State Government, on its own inquiry, to form the opinion that the order passed by the Executive Officer dismissing a large body of employees was against public interest and in violation of the law in force and, consequently, the order passed by the State Government under Section 34(1-B) of the Act was a valid order. On that view of the matter, the Board's petition was dismissed by the High Court and, hence, the present appeal.

    5. The only point of substance urged by the Board before this Court was that the provisions of Section 34(1-B) of the Act were incapable of application to an order of dismissal. The contention was that, when an order of dismissal is passed, the order operates by its own force and no further steps are necessary to implement such an order. It was submitted that the sub-section applied only to those cases where the resolution of the Board or order required some steps to be taken to effectuate the resolution or the order and not when the resolution or order was effective by its own force. In other words, where on the passing of the resolution or order it exhausted itself, the State Government could hardly “prohibit the execution or further execution” of that resolution or order; and, therefore, where the State Government interfered by prohibiting the execution or further execution of the resolution or order, it really intended to cancel or set aside the resolution or order which, in the submission of the petitioner, was beyond the powers of the State Government. It appears to us that there is considerable force, in this submission.

    6. Section 34 is in that part of Chapter II of the Act which deals with the subject “Control of Board”. The marginal note to the section is “Power of the State Government or the Prescribed Authority or the District Magistrate to prohibit execution of or further execution of resolution or order of the Board”. Sub-sections (1) and (1-A) deal with the powers of the Prescribed Authority and the District Magistrate in this respect. Sub-section (1-B) deals with the powers of the State Government and is as follows:

    “(1-B) The State Government may, of its own motion or on report or complaint received by order prohibit the execution or further execution of a resolution or order passed or made under this or any other enactment by a board or a committee of a board or a joint committee or any officer or servant of a board or of a joint committee, if in its opinion such resolution or order is prejudicial to the public interest, or has been passed or made in abuse of powers or in flagrant breach of any provision of any law for the time being in force, and may prohibit the doing or continuance by any person of any act in pursuance of or under cover of such resolution or order.”

    7. It should be noted that the words italicised above were inserted by an amendment which came into force on November 30, 1964, that is to say, much after the order of dismissal by the Executive Officer had been passed, though before the order of the State Government, dated May 12, 1965. Before the amendment, the State Government could pass the order of prohibition of execution only when, in its opinion, the resolution or order was prejudicial to the public interest but, after the amendment, such an order could also be made by the State Government if, in its opinion, the resolution or order was made in abuse of powers or in flagrant breach of any provision of any law for the time being in force. It was contended on behalf of the Board that it was not competent for the State Government in this case to make the order on the ground that the order of dismissal was in flagrant breach of a provision of the law for the time being in force. But that point is only of academic interest, because the order itself shows that it had been passed also on the ground that the order of dismissal was prejudicial to the public interest. We assume, therefore, that the State Government was satisfied that the order of dismissal passed by the Executive Officer was prejudicial to the public interest. The question, however, is whether, after the order of dismissal had been passed on April 9, 1964, the State Government had the power virtually to set aside or cancel the order under the cover of purporting “to prohibit the execution or further execution of that order”. In our opinion, that sub-section does not clothe the State Government with such a power. The resolution of the Board or the order of a duly authorised officer of the Board is not liable to be cancelled or set aside under this section. All that could be done under it is to prohibit the execution or further execution of the resolution or order, or the doing or continuance by any person of any act in pursuance of or under cover of such resolution or order. Where the resolution or order does not require any acts to be performed or steps to be taken for the execution or further execution of the resolution or order of the Board or of its Officer, as in the present case, there is really nothing to prohibit. It was contended on behalf of the State that, when the State Government was empowered to order prohibition of the execution of the resolution or order, it was virtually empowered to set aside or cancel the order and, in support of this view, a reference was made to sub-section (4) of that section which provides that it shall be the duty of the Board, if so required by the authority making the order under sub-section (1-B) to take any action which it would have been entitled to take, if the resolution or order had never been made or passed, and which is necessary for preventing any person from doing or continuing to do anything in pursuance of the resolution or order. If the object of the provision was to clothe the State Government with the power to cancel or set aside the resolution of the Board or order, it would have simply said so without resorting to the circumlocution “prohibit the execution or further execution of the resolution or order”. We do not, therefore, think that sub-section (1-B) read with sub-section (4) applies to any resolution or order which exhausts itself after it is passed or made. That is the view taken by a learned Judge of the Allahabad High Court in Shujaat Ullah Khan v. State of U.P 1966 ALJ 499.

    8. In that case, a resolution was passed by the Board exonerating Shujaat Ullah Khan, who was the Executive Officer of the Board, from certain charges their had been framed against him. The State Government, thereupon, purporting to act under Section 34(1-B) of the Act, quashed the Board's resolution on the ground that it was illegal, not having been passed by 2/3rds of the members constituting the Board and was otherwise prejudicial to the public interest. This order of the State Government was challenged by Shujaat Ullah Khan on several grounds, one of them being that no order under Section 34(1-B) could be passed, because the resolution of the Board had been fully implemented and nothing remained to be executed in respect thereof. This contention was accepted by the learned Judge who observed as follows:

    “It is clear that the only order that can be passed by the State Government under this sub-section is a prohibitory order to prevent something being done in the future. It is not open to the Government, acting under this sub-section, to give any positive direction such as has been given in the present case, where the Government has ordered the Board to reconsider its report and to make a further enquiry and take a fresh decision. The resolution passed by the Board, exonerating the Executive Officer and dropping the charges against him, exhausted itself as soon as it was passed, for the charges were straightaway dropped and the Executive Officer stood exonerated. There remained nothing to be done in the future and there was nothing left for execution or further execution that could be prohibited by the State Government under Section 34(1-B).”
    In our opinion, that reasoning equally applies to the present case. The order of dismissal was self-operative and nothing remained for execution or further execution which could be prohibited by the State Government under that section. On that ground alone, the order passed by the State Government will have to be set aside.

    9. It was next contended on behalf of the employee-respondents that there was really no effective order of dismissal, because that order had not been communicated to the employees. We asked the learned counsel whether this contention was taken earlier either in the reply filed by them to the petition or in the arguments before the High Court. He was not able to show that this had been done. On the other hand, reference was made by the learned counsel for the petitioner to an order passed by the Executive Officer on April 9, 1964, for communication of the order of dismissal to the sweepers and also to the letter, dated May 8, 1965, written by the President of the Board to the District Magistrate which is appended to the petition as Annexure ‘C’. This letter says that the orders of dismissal had been communicated to the sweepers on April 10, 1964. Moreover, we have on record a letter written by and on behalf of the sweepers to the Secretary, Local Self Government Department, U.P, which clearly goes to show that the sweepers had come to know that they had been dismissed from service. This letter was received in the office of the Secretariat on April 21, 1964, which only shows that the sweepers must have been communicated the order of dismissal much earlier. We also know that many sweepers had filed appeals. In any case, since the contention is put forward for the first time now in this Court and involves consideration of facts, it cannot be permitted to be raised.

    10. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the order of the State Government, dated May 12, 1965, is quashed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Municipal Board, Kannauj v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others
    (Aug 12, 1971)