AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses a review petition filed after a prior appeal had been disposed of on merits by a judgment dated 13-2-1986 (1986) 2 SCC 138. The applicant sought review primarily on two grounds: (i) that the appeal had abated due to the deaths of original Respondent 2 (Smt. Sibadasi Mullick, widow of Shri Krishna Mohan Mullick) and original Respondent 5 (Smt. Kamalini Mullick, widow of Shri Khirode Mohan Mullick) during the pendency of the appeal; and (ii) a new contention (Ground D) alleging that the Court had been misled about the existence of the Society of Experimental Science, India and the public purpose of the land acquisition.

Regarding the abatement plea, the Court recorded that Respondent 2’s estate was already represented by her two sons, Respondents 3 and 4 (Lakshmi Kanto Mullick and Nilkanto Mullick), and Respondent 5’s estate was represented by her son, Respondent 6 (Ramendra Mullick), all of whom were on record during the appeal. The review petition was thus considered against this procedural backdrop and dismissed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appeal had abated due to the deaths of original Respondents 2 and 5 during its pendency, warranting setting aside of the Court’s judgment on merits dated 13-2-1986.
  2. Whether a new contention (Ground D)—that the Court was misled about the existence of the Society of Experimental Science, India and the public purpose of the acquisition—could be entertained in review when it had not been raised at the merits stage (nor, apparently, before the High Court) and would require investigation of new facts not on record.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The appeal had abated because original Respondent 2 and original Respondent 5 died during its pendency; therefore, the judgment on merits should be set aside.
  • Ground D: The Court was allegedly misled by documents presented as the petition of appeal; the Society of Experimental Science, India (for whom the land was purportedly acquired) was allegedly not in existence, and the land was not needed for a public purpose (constructing a hospital for crippled children) as claimed by the appellants.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Judgment dated 13-2-1986 (1986) 2 SCC 138 Not cited for a legal rule; referenced as the prior judgment on merits in the same matter. Used to establish that the appeal had already been decided on merits and to frame the context for the review petition seeking to unsettle that decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • On abatement: The Court found that despite the deaths of original Respondent 2 and original Respondent 5 during the pendency of the appeal, their estates were “sufficiently represented” because their legal heirs were already parties to the proceedings (Respondents 3 and 4 for Respondent 2; Respondent 6 for Respondent 5). Therefore, the plea that the appeal had abated was not sustainable, and the earlier judgment could not be set aside on this ground.
  • On Ground D (new contention): The Court noted that this ground had not been raised when the appeal was heard on merits and did not appear to have been raised even before the High Court. The Court declined to consider the new ground at the review stage, emphasizing that its consideration would necessitate investigation into new facts that were not part of the record when the appeal was decided on 13-2-1986. On this basis, the Court saw no reason to entertain the review petition.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED.

Implications: The review petition was rejected. The earlier judgment dated 13-2-1986 (1986) 2 SCC 138 remains undisturbed. The Court’s determination that the estates of the deceased respondents were sufficiently represented means there was no abatement of the appeal. The Court declined to entertain new grounds requiring fresh factual inquiry at the review stage. The order resolves the matter between the parties without setting out any broader legal precedent.

    Collector Of 24 Parganas And Others v. Lalith Mohan Mullick And Others

    Order

    1. This review petition has been instituted on the plea that original Respondent 2 Smt Sibadasi Mullick, widow of Shri Krishna Mohan Mullick had died during the pendency of the appeal in this Court and that original Respondent 5 Smt Kamalini Mullick, widow of Shri Khirode Mohan Mullick had also died during the pendency of the appeal in this Court which was disposed of on merits by a judgment and order dated 13-2-1986 (1986) 2 SCC 138 after hearing the parties. So far as Smt Sibadasi Mullick, widow of Shri Krishna Mohan Mullick is concerned, her two sons viz. Lakshmi Kanto Mullick and Nilkanto Mullick were already on record as Respondents 3 and 4. Therefore, the estate of the deceased was sufficiently represented before this Court. So far as Respondent 5 Smt Kamalini Mullick, widow of Shri Khirode Mohan Mullick is concerned, her son Ramendra Mullick was already on record as Respondent 6. In her case also the estate was sufficiently represented. Under the circumstances it is not possible to uphold the plea that the appeal had abated and the judgment on merits rendered by this Court on 13-2-1986 requires to be set aside on this ground.

    2. Learned counsel for the applicant has also raised the contention embodied in ground No. D reading as under:

    This Honourable Court was allowed to be misled by documents alleged to be the petition of appeal presented before this Honourable Court and not bringing to the notice of this Honourable Court the facts that the Society of Experimental Science, India for whom the land in dispute was sought to be acquired was not in existence and in fact the land was not at all needed by the appellants herein for public purpose for constructing a hospital for the crippled children as claimed by the appellants herein;

    So far as this ground is concerned, it was not raised before this Court when the appeal was heard on merits. It does not appear to have been raised even before the High Court. The new ground cannot be taken into consideration for the purposes of the review application, apart from the fact that it would also involve investigation of new facts which were not on record till the point of time when the appeal was disposed of by this Court on 13-2-1986. We see no reason to entertain this review petition which accordingly fails and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Collector Of 24 Parganas And Others v. Lalith Mohan Mullick And Others
    (Mar 10, 1988)