AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 read with Section 115 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 read with Section 115 CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition under Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 read with Section 115 CPC challenges the order dated 18.7.2000 of the Rajasthan Wakf Tribunal, Jaipur (Case No. 29/2000) by which a temporary injunction was granted in favour of the plaintiff (referred to in the opinion as the plaintiff non-petitioner).

The plaintiff instituted a suit before the Tribunal with an application for temporary injunction, alleging that land in Sub-town Bayana, District Bharatpur (khasra no. 1217) is a graveyard measuring 29 bighas 11 biswas and was entered as "Aheale Islam" for entries from Samvat 2002 to 2005 (1945 to 1948). The plaintiff alleged encroachment by the defendant petitioners who had commenced construction on the disputed graveyard.

The defendant petitioners filed a written statement and reply to the injunction application and placed documents on record. Revenue records (as set out in the opinion) show the oldest entry (Samvat 1955 / 1898) in the name of Pema Singh, subsequently in the name of Ganeshi Lal, and after allotment in 1962 the land was entered in the name of Panchayat Samiti Bayana. It was also noted that Tamari Wakf Committee, Bayana had earlier filed Writ Petition No. 6650/91 before the High Court, which was dismissed on 11.7.1995 on the ground that a dispute of title made Article 226 inappropriate.

The Wakf Tribunal, by order dated 18.7.2000, granted the temporary injunction as prayed by the plaintiff. The defendant petitioners approached the High Court by way of this revision petition challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal properly granted the temporary injunction to the plaintiff non-petitioner in light of the documentary evidence and revenue entries favouring the Panchayat Samiti.
  2. Whether the plaintiff non-petitioner had a prima facie case and whether balance of convenience and irreparable injury considerations favoured grant of a temporary injunction.
  3. Whether issues of title and possession (including prior dismissal of a writ and long possession by Panchayat Samiti) affect the maintainability of the suit and the right to obtain interim relief.
  4. Whether procedural defects (such as alleged non-compliance with notice provisions under Section 109 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Act) bear upon maintainability — this objection was expressly raised in the proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff non-petitioner (as pleaded)

  • The land bearing Khasra No. 1217 in Sub-town Bayana is a graveyard measuring 29 bighas 11 biswas and was entered as Aheale Islam between Samvat 2002–2005 (1945–1948).
  • The defendant petitioners have encroached upon the graveyard and commenced construction, and they have no right to enter upon or construct on the disputed land.
  • The plaintiff sought and obtained a temporary injunction from the Wakf Tribunal (order dated 18.7.2000).

Defendant petitioners / Revision petitioners (as pleaded and argued)

  • Revenue entries going back to Samvat 1955 (1898) show title progression: Pema Singh → Ganeshi Lal → after 1962 allotment, Panchayat Samiti Bayana. These revenue records were not challenged and have attained finality.
  • The Panchayat Samiti has been in possession of the land for about 40 years; the plaintiff has not taken action during that period.
  • A prior writ by Tamari Wakf Committee, Bayana was dismissed on 11.7.1995 (Article 226 remedy considered inappropriate where title is disputed), undermining the plaintiff's remedy on the same subject.
  • On these factual and documentary grounds, the plaintiff lacks locus and has no prima facie case warranting a temporary injunction.
  • Specific procedural objection: maintainability of the suit for want of notice under Section 109 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Act was raised.
  • Defendant counsel cited multiple precedents in support of these contentions (see the Table of Precedents below).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mewa Ram v. The State of Raj., RLW 1998 (1) Raj. 555 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. The court observed many authorities were cited but stated it was unnecessary to refer to or decide all these contentions; this specific precedent was not discussed further.
Dep Darsa Grah Nirman Sahkari Samiti Ltd. v. U.I.T, 1997 (1) RLR 200 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not addressed in the court's reasoning; court did not rely on it.
Sikar Central co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Ram Raichhpal Jat—1998 (1) RLR 303 : 1991 (1) WLC 84 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not addressed in the court's reasoning; court did not rely on it.
Municipal Corporation Murwara—Kanti v. Lalchand Jaiswal—2000 (2) MPLJ 288 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not addressed further by the court.
Bhurji v. Urban Improvement Trust, Alwar—1995 (2) RLR 240 : 1996 (3) WLC (Raj.) 155 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not discussed in the judgment.
Chief General Manager State Bank of India v. Shri Brij Mohan Shukla—2000 (2) WLC (Raj.) 347 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not relied upon in the court's analysis.
Ladu Singh v. State of Raj.—2000 (2) RLR 140 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not discussed in the court's reasoning.
Sujan Singh v. R.S.R.T.C—1997 (2) RLR 159 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not addressed in the judgment.
Mathew Phillips… v. P.O Koshy… Koshy—AIR 1966 Mysore 74 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not considered in the court's final reasoning.
T.A George v. D.D.A—AIR 1995 Delhi 131 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not applied in the decision.
Anant Shri Sukhramii Trust v. Union of India—AIR 1997 Raj. 32 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. No application of this precedent is set out in the opinion.
Radhakisan v. State of Rajasthan—AIR 1967 Raj. 1 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not applied in the court's analysis.
The Board of Muslim Wakfs for Rajasthan, Jaipur v. Bhanwar Chand—1980 WLN 344 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. No discussion or application in the judgment.
Punjab Wakf Board Ambala v. Gram Sabha, Basoli—AIR 1986 Himachal Pradesh 23 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not relied upon in the reasoning.
Pooran Singh v. Rajasthan Board of Muslim Wakf, Jaipur—S.B Civil 11 Appeal No. 244/94 decided on 4.3.1997 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. The court did not engage with this authority in its analysis.
The Madras State Wakf Board, Madras v. Khazi Moideen Sheriff—AIR 1974 Madras 225 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not applied by the court.
Mysore State Board Of Wakfs v. K.S Lakshmaiah Setty—AIR 1974 Karnataka 28 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. No application by the court is recorded.
Punjab Wakf Board v. Gram Pancayat @ Gram Sabha—2000 WLC (SC) 51 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not discussed in the court's reasoning.
K. Rausan Din v. H. Mohd. Sharif—AIR 1936 Lahore 87 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not addressed in the judgment.
Zafar Hussain v. Main Mohammad Ghias-ud-Din—AIR 1937 Lahore 552 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not applied by the court.
Mohammad Ali v. Dinesh Chandra Roy Coudhuiy—AIR 1940 Calcutta 417 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not discussed in the reasoning.
The Karnataka Wakf Board v. State of Karnataka—AIR 1996 Karnataka 55 Cited by defendant petitioners; specific rule/principle not stated in the opinion. Not engaged with by the court in its analysis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded to allow the revision petition essentially on a single point and did not find it necessary to adjudicate all contentions or to digest every cited authority. The principal analytical steps taken by the court are:

  • The Tribunal's order was found to reflect a one-sided view and an inadequate appreciation of documentary evidence produced by the defendant petitioners. Although the Tribunal accepted that documentary evidence regarding title was in favour of the defendant petitioners, it did not provide cogent reasons for granting the injunction in favour of the plaintiff, giving an impression of a pre-determined decision in favour of the plaintiff.
  • The court recited the unchallenged revenue entries: earliest entry (Samvat 1955 / 1898) in the name of Pema Singh, thereafter Ganeshi Lal, and following allotment in 1962 the entry in the name of Panchayat Samiti Bayana. Those revenue entries were not challenged by the plaintiff and had attained finality.
  • The court placed weight on the fact that the Panchayat Samiti had been in possession of the land for about 40 years and that the plaintiff had not taken action during that period. This long possession and the documentary record undermined the plaintiff's claim to a prima facie case for interim relief.
  • Given that the land was entered as Sawai Chak (agricultural) and in Panchayat Samiti's name, the court found it was not justified to restrain the Panchayat Samiti from putting any construction on the land at the interim stage.
  • The court assessed the interim relief principles: prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury. It concluded that the plaintiff did not have a prima facie case sufficient to warrant a temporary injunction, that balance of convenience did not favour the plaintiff, and that non-grant of injunction would not cause irreparable injury to the plaintiff.
  • The court also observed that the Tribunal had decided the matter on affidavits (evidence on affidavit) and that allowing the Tribunal's injunction order to stand would occasion a failure of justice and cause irreparable injury to the defendant petitioners by preventing them from constructing on the land.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition succeeds and is allowed. The court quashed and set aside the order dated 18.7.2000 of the Rajasthan Wakf Tribunal, Jaipur. The opinion records that in the facts of the case there is no order as to costs. As a result of allowing the revision petition, the stay application was also dismissed.

Implications:

  • The immediate effect is vacatur of the temporary injunction previously granted by the Wakf Tribunal on 18.7.2000.
  • The court's decision removes the interim restraint on the defendant petitioners (Panchayat Samiti) that would have prevented construction; the opinion emphasizes that permitting the injunction to stand would have caused irreparable injury to the defendant petitioners.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new general precedent; it resolves the application on the specific facts and documentary record before the court (revenue entries, long possession and prior writ dismissal).

    State Of Raj. & Ors. v. Rajasthan Board Of Muslim Wakf, Jaipur & Anr.(40)

    S.K Keshote, J.:— This revision petition under Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 read with Section 115 CPC is directed against the order dated 18.7.2000 of the Rajasthan Wakf Tribunal, Jaipur in Case No. 29/2000 under which the temporary injunction was granted in favour of the plaintiff non-petitioner.

    2. The plaintiff non-petitioner instituted a suit before the Tribunal along with an application for temporary injunction alleging that in Sub-town Bayana Distt. Bharatpur land falling in khasra no. 1217 is graveyard measuring 29 Bighas 11 biswas. It is averred that the land in dispute was shown/entered as Aheale Islam between Samvat 2002 to 2005 (1945 to 1948). A grievance has been made that the defendant petitioners have encroached upon the graveyard and have started construction. It is stated that the defendant petitioners have no right to enter upon and construct on the disputed graveyard. The defendant petitioners submitted the written statement as well as reply to the application filed by the plaintiff non-petitioner for grant of temporary injunction.

    3. The documents have also been produced on record. It is pleaded that in the oldest entry as is available of way back in Samvat 1955 (year 1898) the land of Khasra No. 1217 was entered in the name of Pema Singh. Thereafter it was entered in the name of one Ganeshi Lal. Later on upon allotment in the year 1962 the land has been entered in the name of Panchayat Samiti Bayana. It is also pointed out that earlier Tamari Wakf Committee, Bayana moved a Writ Petition No. 6650/91 before this court which was dismissed on 11.7.1995 observing that there being dispute of title between the parties, remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution is not appropriate. It is pleaded that for want of the title the plaintiff non-petitioners have no locus standi to institute the suit. The plaintiff Wakf Board was also party to that petition. Apart from these pleadings the conduct of the plaintiff non-petitioners of concealing material facts about possession of Panchayat Samiti on the land for last 40 years was also highlighted. Specific objection about maintainability of suit for want of notice u/s. 109 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Act was also raised. Under the order dated 18.7.2000 the application filed by the plaintiff non-petitioners to grant temporary injunction was allowed and a temporary injunction as prayed for therein has been granted. Hence this revision petition.

    4. Learned counsel for the defendant petitioners raised manifold contentions challenging the order of the Tribunal. He has also cited following decisions in support of his contentions.

    (1) Mewa Ram v. The State of Raj., RLW 1998 (1) Raj. 555.

    (2) Dep Darsa Grah Nirman Sahkari Samiti Ltd. v. U.I.T, 1997 (1) RLR 200.

    (3) Sikar Central co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Ram Raichhpal Jat—1998 (1) RLR 303 : 1991 (1) WLC 84.

    (4) Municipal Corporation Murwara—Kanti v. Lalchand Jaiswal— 2000 (2) MPLJ 288

    (5) Bhurji v. Urban Improvement Trust, Alwar—1995 (2) RLR 240 : 1996 (3) WLC (Raj.) 155.

    (6) Chief General Manager State Bank of India v. Shri Brij Mohan Shukla—2000 (2) WLC (Raj.) 347.

    (7) Ladu Singh v. State of Raj.—2000 (2) RLR 140.

    (8) Sujan Singh v. R.S.R.T.C—1997 (2) RLR 159.

    (9) Mathew Phillips,… v. P.O Koshy,…. Koshy—AIR 1966 Mysore 74.

    (10) T.A George v. D.D.A—AIR 1995 Delhi 131.

    (11) Anant Shri Sukhramii Trust v. Union of India—AIR 1997 Raj. 32.

    (12) Radhakisan v. State of Rajasthan—AIR 1967 Raj. 1.

    (13) The Board of Muslim Wakfs for Rajasthan, Jaipur v. Bhanwar Chand—1980 WLN 344.

    (14) Punjab Wakf Board Ambala v. Gram Sabha, Basoli—AIR 1986 Himachal Pradesh 23.

    (15) Pooran Singh v. Rajasthan Board of Muslim Wakf, Jaipur—S.B Civil 11 Appeal No. 244/94 decided on 4.3.1997

    (16) The Madras State Wakf Board, Madras v. Khazi Moideen Sheriff—AIR 1974 Madras 225.

    (17) Mysore State Board Of Wakfs,… v. K.S Lakshmaiah Setty,…. Setty—AIR 1974 Karnataka 28.

    (18) Punjab Wakf Board v. Gram Pancayat @ Gram Sabha—2000 WLC (SC) 51.

    (19) K. Rausan Din v. H. Mohd. Sharif—AIR 1936 Lahore 87.

    (20) Zafar Hussain v. Main Mohammad Ghias-ud-Din—AIR 1937 Lahore 552.

    (21) Mohammad Ali v. Dinesh Chandra Roy Coudhuiy—AIR 1940 Calcutta 417.

    (22) The Karnataka Wakf Board v. State of Karnataka—AIR 1996 Karnataka 55.

    5. Learned counsel for the plaintiff non-petitioners supported the order of the learned Wakf Tribunal.

    6. As this revision petition deserves to succeed only on one point, I do not consider it necessary to refer, digest and decide all these contentions.

    7. The Tribunal has looked into the proceedings and decided the matter having only one-sided view. It has very conveniently avoided to appreciate properly the documentary evidence produced by the defendant petitioners. It has though accepted the fact that the documentary evidence re the title of the land is in favour of the defendant petitioners but without giving cogent and justified reasons and as if it was pre-determined to decide the matter in favour of the plaintiff non-petitioner has proceeded and ultimately reached to this decision. The land is agricultural land and the oldest entry m respect thereof available is of Samvat 1955 which is in the name of Pema Singh. Thereafter it was entered in the name of one Ganeshi Lal. Later, on upon allotment in the year 1962 the land has been entered in the name of Panchayat Samiti Bayana. These entries of the revenue record were not challenged by the plaintiff non-petitioners and same attained finality. Claiming it to be the Wakf property, the writ petition before this court was also filed which was dismissed on 11.7.1995 Yet mere is another important fact which has not properly been appreciated that Panchayat Samiti is in possession of the land in dispute for last 40 years, but no action has been taken what-so-ever by the plaintiff non-petitioner in respect thereof. In the presence of this documentary evidence and further that the land is entered in the name of Panchayat Samiti, I am satisfied that the plaintiff non-petitioner has no prima facie case in its favour and that too to the extent it warrants, justifies and needs a grant of temporary injunction in its favour.

    8. In the revenue record the land was entered as Sawai Chak which was allotted to Panchayat Samiti and it is in its possession for about 40 years. It is not justified, warranted and necessary to injunct it at this stage from putting any construction thereon. The suit had been filed but the plaintiff non-petitioner has no prima facie case in its favour and more so if it succeeds whatever construction put thereon can be ordered to be removed hence it is not a fit case for grant of temporary injunction. In view of this fact non-grant of temporary injunction will not cause any irreparable injury to the plaintiff non-petitioner. Balance of convenience also in the facts of the case does not favour for grant of temporary injunction. In this case learned Tribunal has decided the matter on affidavits. The evidence has been taken on affidavit and ultimately arguments were also heard in the suit. The suit has not been decided and this temporary injunction matter has been decided and the order impugned has been passed. In the facts of this case in case the order of the Tribunal is allowed to stand certainly it will occasion a failure of justice and will cause irreparable injury to the defendant petitioner as it will not be able to put construction on the land.

    9. Accordingly, the revision petition succeeds and the same is allowed. The order dated 18.7.2000 of Rajasthan Wakf Tribunal, Jaipur is quashed and set aside. In the facts of the case no order as to costs.

    10. As a result of the disposal of the revision petition, the stay application is also dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Raj. & Ors. v. Rajasthan Board Of Muslim Wakf, Jaipur & Anr.(40)
    (Jul 12, 2002)