Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Rajasthan Act and Sections 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the Madhya Pradesh Act
  • Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act, 1951. Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act
  • Rajasthan Societies Registration Act, 1958 (Rajasthan Act 28 of 1958)
  • Rajasthan Act. Section 2(9) of the Rajasthan Act
  • Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act.
  • Section 8(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Act.
  • SECTION 9 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Rajasthan Public Trust Act, 1959
  • Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act
  • Section 22 of the Rajasthan Act
  • clauses (i) to (x) of Section 4(3).
  • Sub Section 2 of Section 21
  • Sub Section 1 of Section 21
  • Rajasthan Public Trust Act.
  • Public Trust.4. Section 16
  • Section 8(1), Section 4(5)
  • Section.8. Section 20
  • Order 1 Rule 8 CPC
  • Madhya Pradesh Act
  • Section 4(3).14.
  • Section 4(1),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Rajasthan Act and Sections 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the Madhya Pradesh Act
  • Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act, 1951. Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act
  • Rajasthan Societies Registration Act, 1958 (Rajasthan Act 28 of 1958)
  • Rajasthan Act. Section 2(9) of the Rajasthan Act
  • Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act.
  • Section 8(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Act.
  • SECTION 9 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Rajasthan Public Trust Act, 1959
  • Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act
  • Section 22 of the Rajasthan Act
  • clauses (i) to (x) of Section 4(3).
  • Sub Section 2 of Section 21
  • Sub Section 1 of Section 21
  • Rajasthan Public Trust Act.
  • Public Trust.4. Section 16
  • Section 8(1), Section 4(5)
  • Section.8. Section 20
  • Order 1 Rule 8 CPC
  • Madhya Pradesh Act
  • Section 4(3).14.
  • Section 4(1),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (V.S. Kokje, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff (who is the revision petitioner before the High Court) instituted a suit under Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act claiming that the Shri Narshing Bhagwan Temple at Jalore was his private ancestral property but had been wrongly declared and registered as the property of a public trust under the Act. After the Temple was declared to be public trust property, the plaintiff appealed under Section 20 of the Act; that appeal was rejected. Thereafter the plaintiff instituted a suit under Section 22 seeking cancellation of the registration entry and the entry in the public trust register showing the property as trust property. The respondent contested maintainability, arguing that a person who challenges the existence of the trust and asserts an adverse title cannot maintain a suit under Section 22. The Trial Court framed and decided a preliminary issue against the plaintiff on maintainability. The plaintiff filed the present revision petition against that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person who objects to a property being declared public trust property can maintain a suit under Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act challenging the entries made in the Register of Public Trusts.
  2. Whether the expression "person having interest" in Section 22 (and related registration provisions) can include a person claiming an interest adverse to the public trust (i.e., a claimant asserting private ownership of property recorded as trust property).
  3. Whether the definition of "person having interest" in Section 2(9) of the Rajasthan Act (as compared to the absence of such a defined term in the Madhya Pradesh Act) produces a different result with respect to maintainability of suits under the corresponding provision.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner / Plaintiff

  • The plaintiff asserted ownership of the Shri Narshing Bhagwan Temple as private and ancestral property and challenged its registration as public trust property under the Rajasthan Public Trust Act by bringing a suit under Section 22.
  • Counsel for the revision petitioner argued that the Supreme Court decision in Abdul Karim Khan (which was decided under the Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act) is distinguishable because the Madhya Pradesh Act did not define "person having interest," whereas the Rajasthan Act does define that expression in Section 2(9). The petitioner contended that this defined (inclusive) phrase in the Rajasthan Act could encompass persons asserting adverse ownership and therefore would permit maintenance of a Section 22 suit by such a person.

Respondent / Non-petitioners

  • The respondent contended that a person who challenges the very existence of the trust and sets up a title adverse to the public trust cannot maintain a suit under Section 22 to cancel register entries. In other words, a person with a claim adverse to the trust is not a "person having interest" for the purposes of Sections 18–22.
  • Counsel for the non-petitioners submitted that the definition of "person having interest" in Section 2(9) of the Rajasthan Act does not include a person whose interest is adverse to the public trust and thus does not change the legal position established by precedent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mehta Charitable Trust v. Gulam Rasool The opinion records that the Trial Court relied on this decision as supporting the view that a person asserting an adverse title cannot maintain a suit under the public trust registration provisions. The High Court noted that the Trial Court mainly relied on this decision (along with Abdul Karim Khan). The High Court examined the principle but primarily grounded its analysis in the Supreme Court's decision in Abdul Karim Khan; Mehta Charitable Trust was treated as a supporting precedent relied upon by the Trial Court.
Abdul Karim Khan & Others v. Municipal Committee, Raipur (Supreme Court) The Supreme Court held that the statutory inquiry before the Registrar (under the Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act) concerns whether a trust is public or private and does not extend to contested questions of private title; "person having interest" must be read as the interest of beneficiaries or those entitled to manage the trust and does not include a party asserting a wholly adverse claim; only persons who were parties or could have been parties to the Registrar's inquiry can be considered "aggrieved" for purposes of filing a subsequent suit or appeal under the relevant provision. The High Court treated the decision as controlling on the legal question. It reproduced and relied on the reasoning in paragraphs 10–14 of Abdul Karim Khan to conclude that a person asserting an adverse title is not a "person having interest" for the limited and specific purposes of the Act's registration and post-registration remedy provisions. The High Court applied these principles to hold that a Section 22 suit was not maintainable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by examining the scheme of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act, 1959, and comparing it with the Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act, 1951, because the principal precedent (Abdul Karim Khan) arose under the latter statute. The Court summarized relevant registration provisions in the Rajasthan Act:

  • Sections 16–21: administrative scheme establishing the Assistant Commissioner as the officer in charge of registration, the form and content of registration applications (Section 17), the inquiry process before registration (Section 18), recording of findings (Section 19), the right of appeal to the Commissioner (Section 20), and the making and publication of entries in the register (Section 21), with Sub‑section (2) of Section 21 providing that the entries are, subject to the Act, final and conclusive.
  • Section 22: provides a civil remedy to "any working trustee or the person having interest in a public trust or any property found to be the trust property" to institute a suit within six months of publication of entries under Section 21 to have such entries cancelled or modified.

The controlling question was whether the phrase "person having interest" in Section 22 may include someone who claims ownership of the property and whose claim is adverse to the public trust.

The Court analyzed Abdul Karim Khan at length. The Supreme Court in that case had held (as summarized in paragraphs 10–14 of that judgment and relied upon by this Court) that:

  • The statutory inquiry before the Registrar is limited to determining whether a trust is public or private and does not encompass contested private title disputes between claimants.
  • Only persons who are "interested in the public trust" (for example beneficiaries or those who claim the right to manage the trust) are required or permitted to file objections to the Registrar's inquiry; persons who dispute the existence of the trust or who claim exclusive private ownership are not within that limited class.
  • The "interest" referred to in the provision permitting a suit or appeal must be read, in that statutory context, as the interest of beneficiaries or persons connected with the trust (not an adverse title-holder).
  • The right to file a suit or appeal is confined to persons who were parties to (or who could have appeared in) the Registrar's inquiry; a stranger to those proceedings who did not participate cannot be said to be "aggrieved" by the Registrar's findings within the meaning of the Act's appellate or suit‑provisions.

The petitioner attempted to distinguish Abdul Karim Khan on the ground that the Madhya Pradesh Act lacked a statutory definition of "person having interest" while the Rajasthan Act expressly defines that phrase in Section 2(9). The Rajasthan definition enumerates categories (in the context of temples, maths, societies, and other public trusts—specifying attendants, disciples, members of a registered society, and beneficiaries) and is framed in inclusive terms.

The Court rejected the petitioner's distinction. It explained that:

  • The absence of the definition in the Madhya Pradesh Act did not prevent the Supreme Court from concluding that a person asserting an adverse title is not a "person having interest" within the statutory scheme. Consequently, the mere presence of a non‑exhaustive or inclusive definition in the Rajasthan Act does not automatically broaden the class to include adverse title‑holders.
  • The categories specifically enumerated in Section 2(9) indicate the types of persons contemplated (beneficiaries, worshippers, disciples, society members). Applying the rule of ejusdem generis, those categories point to similar kinds of interest — i.e., interests connected positively to the trust — and by necessary implication exclude persons asserting interests adverse to the trust.
  • Thus, even under the Rajasthan definition, a person claiming exclusive private title adverse to the trust does not fall within "person having interest" for the limited purposes of the registration enquiry, appeal under Section 20, or suit under Section 22.

On that basis the Court concluded that the Trial Court was correct in holding that the suit under Section 22 was not maintainable.

The Court's analysis limits itself to the statutory scheme and the precedents cited; it does not purport to adjudicate any private title dispute raised by the plaintiff in a regular civil forum.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that a suit under Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act by a person asserting a title adverse to the public trust is not maintainable. The Trial Court's finding of non‑maintainability was affirmed and the revision petition was disposed of accordingly.

Direct Effect on the Parties: The plaintiff cannot pursue cancellation of the register entries under Section 22 in respect of a claim that is essentially an adverse private title. However, the Court expressly clarified that this conclusion does not bar the plaintiff from pursuing a regular civil suit for determination of title under Section 9 of the Civil Procedure Code. The Trial Court remains free to consider conversion of the present proceedings into a Section 9 suit or to entertain a separate civil suit, subject to the general law.

Broader Implications: The opinion applies and follows the Supreme Court's reasoning in Abdul Karim Khan and treats the Rajasthan statutory definition as not broadening the remedy to include adverse title‑holders. The Court did not indicate that it was laying down any novel, separate precedent beyond applying existing authority to the facts of this case.

    Gheesu Dass v. Narsingh Kansara & Ors.

    V.S Kokje, J.:— The question involved in this case is as to whether a person, who objects to a particular property to be the property of a public trust, could maintain a suit relating to that property under Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act. The plaintiff-revision petitioner brought a suit under Section 22 of the Act claiming that Shri Narshing Bhagwan Temple situated in Jalore was the private and ancestral property of the plaintiff which has been wrongly declared to be and registered to be public trust under the Act. On the Temple declared to be property of public trust, the plaintiff filed an appeal under Sec. 20 of the Act which was rejected. He therefore filed a suit under Section 22 of the Act for cancellation of an entry regarding registration of the public Trust as well as the suit property being shown as property of the public Trust. The respondent objected to the maintainability of the suit on the ground that a person who is challenging the existence of the Trust and who is setting up a title adverse to the public trust cannot maintain a suit under Section 22 of the Act for cancellation of entries in the Register of public Trust. The Trial Court framed a preliminary issue on the point and decided it against the plaintiff. The plaintiff has filed revision petition against that order.

    2. The trial court has mainly relied on the decision of this court in Mehta Charitable Trust v. Gulam Rasool (1) and decision of the Supreme Court in Abdul Karim Khan & Others v. Municipal Committee, Raipur, Raipur (2). The learned counsel for the revision petitioner has submitted that the decision of the Supreme court in Abdul Karim Khan (supra), on which Mehta Charitable Trust's case (supra) was based, was in a case to which Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act applied. The learned counsel submitted that in Madhya Pradesh Act ‘person having interest’ has not been defined, whereas in the Rajasthan Act it has been defined under Section 2(9), which will make a difference and the ruling would not be applicable to cases under Rajasthan Public Trust Act. The learned counsel for the non-petitioners submitted that the definition of the expression ‘person having interest’ would not make any difference to the situation as even the definition given under Section 2(9) does not include a person having interest adverse to the interest of the Public Trust.

    3. In order to appreciate the controversy correctly, I will have to examine the scheme of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act, 1959 as well as the Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act, 1951. Section 22 of the Rajasthan Public Trust Act falls in Chapter 5 which relates to registration of Public Trust.

    4. Section 16 provides that the Assistant Commissioner shall be incharge of the registration of all public Trusts having principle places of business within the local limits of the area of his jurisdiction. It also provides that the Assistant Commissioner shall maintain the Register of Public Trust and such other Books and registration in such form as has been prescribed.

    5. Section 17 of the Act provides for registration of public trust. The application for registration has to be in a prescribed form and has to contain the particular about the urgent nature and object of public trust and the designation by which the public trust is or shall be known, the place where the principal office or the principal place of business of the public trust is situate, the name and address of the working trustee and the Manager, the mode of succession to the office of the trustee, the list of movable and immovable trust property and such description and particulars as may be sufficient for the identification there of, the approximate value of the movable and immovable property etc.

    6. Section 18 provides for an inquiry before registration on receipt of an application under Section 17 or upon an application made by any person having interest in a public trust or on his own motion, the Assistant Commissioner has to make an enquiry in the prescribed manner for the purpose of ascertaining whether a trust exists and whether such trust is a Public trust, whether any property is the property of such trust, whether the whole or any sub-stantial portion of the subject matter of the trust is situate within his jurisdiction etc. The Assistant Commissioner has to give a public notice in prescribed manner of the inquiry proposed to be made by him under the provision and invite all persons having interest in the public trust under inquiry to refer within 60 days objections, if any, in respect of such trust.

    7. Section 19 of the Act provides that on completion of the inquiry provided for under Section 18, the Assistant Commissioner shall record his findings with the reasons therefor as to the matters mentioned in the said Section.

    8. Section 20 provides for an appeal against the findings of the Assistant Commissioner. Any working trustee or person having interest in a public trust or in any property found to be trust property, aggrieved by a finding of the Assistant Commissioner under Section 19, may within two months from the date of its publication on the notice board of the Assistant Commissioner, file an appeal before the Commissioner, to have such findings set aside or modified.

    9. Section 21 provides that the Assistant Commissioner shall cause entries to be made in the register in accordance with the findings recorded by him under Section 19 or, if an appeal has been filed under Section 20, in accordance with the decision of the Commissioner on such appeal, and shall cause to be published on the notice board of his office and at a conspicuous place in the city, town or village where the principal office or the principal place of business of the public trust is situate, the entries made in the register. Sub Section 2 of Section 21 provides that the entries so made shall, subject to the other provisions of the Act and subject to any change recorded under any provision of the Act or a rule made thereunder, be final and conclusive.

    10. It is in this setting that Section 22 of the Act provides for a civil suit against the entries made under Section 21. It provides that any working trustee or the person having interest in a public trust or any property found to be the trust property, aggrieved by any entry made under Section 21 may within six months from the date of publication thereof on the notice board of the office of the Assistant Commissioner under Sub Section 1 of Section 21 institute a suit in a civil court to have such entries cancelled or modified.

    11. The aforesaid provisions of the Rajasthan Act and Sections 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the Madhya Pradesh Act are parimateria.

    12. The question arising in this case is whether ‘person having interest’ mentioned in Section 22 can be a person who has interest adverse to the public trust and who is claiming the property found to be the trust property to be his own property and not the public trust property.

    13. In Abdul Karim Khan & Others v. Municipal Committee, Raipur, Raipur (supra) the plaintiffs, residents of a locality belonging to the Muslim community filed a representive suit under Order 1 Rule 8 CPC for a permanent injunction against the Raipur Municipality claiming that the suit land was old Kabristan registered under the Madhya Pradesh Public Trust Act and was a trust property and as such the Raipur Municipality could not claim any right or title to the said land. The Raipur Municipality disputed the claim. It was contended that the suit land was given to the Municipality by the State Govt. on a fixed rent and the Municipality had constructed some school buildings on the same. Several issues were raised, but the issue relevant for the purpose of this case related to the registration of the plot in the register kept under the provisions of the Trust Act and its effect. The plaintiffs contended that the registration of the plot as a trust property in the register of the Registrar of Trust was conclusive against the Municipality and in favour of the plaintiff. The trial court rejected the contention. Appeal of the plaintiffs was dismissed and a second appeal was also dismissed by the High Court. The matter then went to the Supreme Court. It was contended before the Supreme Court that if any person, who claims interest in the property which is alleged to be the trust property, fails to satisfy the Registrar about his claim, he can file a suit under Section 8(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Act. The provision allows a suit to be filed subject to the condition prescribed by it and right to file such a suit is given to the working trustee, or a person having interest in a public trust or any property found to be the trust property. The Municipality was interested in the property. In suit which was found to be the trust property and since it did not avail itself of the right to file a suit within the specified time, the order passed by the Registrar must be held to be final and conclusive against its claim if finality did not attach to such an order even after 6 months had expired within the meaning of Section 8(1) then the provision contained in Section 4(5) will serve no purpose whatsoever. After examining the entire scheme of the Act, the Supreme Court rejected the contention. Observations in paragraphs 10, 11, 12, 13, and 14 in Abdul Karim's case (Supra) conclude the issue. It would be useful to reproduce relevant excerpts from them to understand the full meaning of the decision.

    “10. In testing the validity of this argument, we must bear in mind the important fact that the Act is concerned with the registration of public, religious and charitable trust in the State of Madhya Pradesh, and the enquiry which its relevant provisions contemplate is an enquiry into the question as to whether the trust in question is public or private. The enquiry permitted by the said provisions does not take within its sweep questions as to whether the property belongs to a private individual and is not the subject-matter of any trust at all. It cannot be ignored that the Registrar who, no doubt, is given the powers of a civil court under Section 28 of the Act, holds a kind of summary enquiry and the points which can fall within his jurisdiction are indicated by clauses (i) to (x) of Section 4(3). Therefore, prima facie, it appears unreasonable to suggest that contested questions of title, such as those which have arisen in the present case, can be said to fall within the enquiry which the Registrar is authorised to hold under Section 5 of the Act.

    11. Besides, it is significant that the only persons who are required to file their objections in response to a notice issued by the Registrar on receiving an application made under Section 4(1), are persons interested in the public trust not persons who dispute the existence of the trust or who challenge the allegation that any property belongs to the said trust. It is only persons interested in the public trust, such as beneficiaries or others who claim a right to manage the trust, who can file objections, and it is objections of this character proceeding from persons belonging to this limited class that fall to be considered by the Registrar.

    12. It is true, Section 8(1) permits a suit to be filed by a person having interest in the public trust or any property found to be trust property. The interest to which this Section refers must be read in the light of Section 5(2) to be the interest of a beneficiary or the interest of a person who claims the right to maintain the trust or any other interest of a similar character. It is not the interest which is adverse to the trust set up by a party who does not claim any relation with the trust at all.

    13. Then again the right to file a suit to which Section 8(1) refers is given to persons who are aggrieved by any finding of the Registrar.

    Having regard to the fact that the proceedings before the Registrar are in the nature of proceedings before a civil court, it would be illogical to hold that the respondent who was not a party to the proceedings can be said to be aggrieved by the findings of the Registrar. The normal judicial concept of a person aggrieved by any order necessarily postulates that the said person must be a party to the proceedings in which the order was passed and by which he feels aggrieved. It is unnecessary to emphasise that it would be plainly unreasonable to assume that though a person is not a party to the proceedings and cannot participate in them by way of filing objections, he would still be found of file a suit within the period prescribed by Section 8(1) if the property in which he claims an exclusive title is held by the Registrar to belong to a public trust.

    14. Similarly, the right to prefer an appeal against the Registrar's order prescribed by Section 4(5) necessarily implies that the person must be a party in the proceedings before the Registrar; otherwise how would he know about the order? Like Section 8(1), Section 4(5) also seems to be confined in its operation to persons who are before the Registrar, or who could have appeared before the Registrar under

    Section 5(2). The whole scheme is clear; the Registrar enquires into the question as to whether a trust is private or public, and deals with the points specifically enumerated by Section 4(3).’

    14. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner tried to distinguish this decision on the ground that ‘person having interest’ was not defined in the Madhya Pradesh Act and has been defined in the Rajasthan Act. Section 2(9) of the Rajasthan Act reads as under:—

    Section 2(9):— ‘person having interest’ or any expression signifying a person having interest in a public

    (a) in the case of a temple, a person who is entitled to attend or is in the habit of attending performance of worship or service in the temple or who is entitled to partaking or is in the habit of partaking in the distribution of gifts thereof;

    (b) in the case of math, disciple of the math or a person of the religious persuasion to which the math belongs;

    (c) in the case of a society registered or deemed to be registered under the Rajasthan Societies Registration Act, 1958 (Rajasthan Act 28 of 1958) or under any other analogous law in force in any part of the State, any member of such society; and

    (d). in the case of any other public trust, any beneficiary;’

    15. It is contended that a person setting up an interest adverse to the public trust or claiming ownership of a property declared to be the public trust has not been excluded from the definition of ‘person having interest’ and therefore such a person would still be a person having interest in the property. It was pointed out that the definition was inclusive and not exhaustive and therefore a person having adverse interest to the trust in relation to the property declared to be the trust property shall also be a person having interest in the property.

    16. In view of clear pronouncement of law on the point by the Supreme Court in Abdul Karim's case (supra), the contention cannot be accepted. It makes little difference whether the expression ‘person having interest’ has been defined in the statute or not. When without the expression being defined in the Act, the Supreme Court came to the conclusion that a person having adverse interest cannot under the scheme of the Act be taken a person having interest, inclusive and not exhaustive, definition contained in the Rajasthan Act would not make any difference. If the definition in Rajasthan Act had specifically included a person claiming adverse interest to the trust in the property declared to be the trust property, to be included in the expression person having interest, that would have made difference because then the Legislative intent would clearly have been to include such a person also in persons having interest. When an inclusive definition is given, the categories of persons specifically included gives an indication of the other categories of persons which are not specifically mentioned, but which could all the same fall in the definition. Rule of Ejusdem generis has to be applied in the case. When all the four categories enumerated as included in the definition relating to the persons who have interest in favour of the public trust, it has to be held that by necessary implication those who held interest against the trust have to be excluded. This would further weaken the case of the revision petitioner-plaintiff.

    17. In view of the aforesaid discussion, it has to be held that suit under Section 22 of the Rajasthan Act was not maintainable and has been rightly held to be so by the trial court. However, it has to be clarified that the plaintiff could file a regular civil suit under Section 9 of the Civil Procedure Code and non maintainability of this suit should not be taken as a bar to entertainment of a regular civil suit or conversion of the present suit into a suit under Section 9 of Civil Procedure code subject to the General Law of the land. The trial court shall be free to decide upon this in accordance with law. The revision petition is disposed of with aforesaid observations.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gheesu Dass v. Narsingh Kansara & Ors.
    (Mar 31, 1999)