Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Rule 9 and Rule 10 of Order 26, C.P.C
  • provisions contained in Rules 9 and 10 and Order 26
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 67 of the General Rules (Civil) 1986,
  • provisions.7. Order 26, Rule 9. C.P.C
  • General Rules (Civil) 1986
  • Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C
  • Order 43, Rule I, C.P.C
  • 26, Rule 10, C.P.C,
  • 25, 1986. Rule 67
  • Order 26, Rule 9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Rule 9 and Rule 10 of Order 26, C.P.C
  • provisions contained in Rules 9 and 10 and Order 26
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 67 of the General Rules (Civil) 1986,
  • provisions.7. Order 26, Rule 9. C.P.C
  • General Rules (Civil) 1986
  • Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C
  • Order 43, Rule I, C.P.C
  • 26, Rule 10, C.P.C,
  • 25, 1986. Rule 67
  • Order 26, Rule 9
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff instituted a suit for injunction against the defendants, seeking to restrain them from transferring or dispossessing the plaintiff from plot No. 14 situated in Industrial Area, Raisinghnagar. The plaintiff also filed an application for temporary injunction, which the trial Court initially granted, restraining the defendants from interfering with the plaintiff's possession. However, the Additional District Judge allowed the defendants' appeal, reversing the trial Court's injunction order and directing that the original suit be decided within six months. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed an application under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C before the trial Court for appointment of a Commissioner to ascertain possession of the suit plot. The trial Court allowed this application, appointing a Commissioner, which led to the present revision challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Commissioner should be appointed under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C to decide a disputed question of fact, specifically regarding possession of the suit plot?
  2. Whether the power to appoint a Commissioner can be exercised to assist a party in collecting evidence that can otherwise be produced by the parties themselves through trial proceedings?
  3. Whether the discretionary power vested in the trial Court under Order 26, Rules 9 and 10, C.P.C was rightly exercised in appointing a Commissioner for local investigation in this case?

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The Commissioner cannot be appointed with the object of creating evidence favoring one party.
  • Possession must be proved by cogent evidence and cannot be determined solely on the Commissioner’s inspection report.
  • Relied on Basanta Kumar v. Baidya Kumar, AIR 1989 Orissa 118, to support the above contentions.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • Supported the impugned order appointing the Commissioner under the discretionary powers granted by Order 26, Rules 9 and 10, C.P.C.
  • Relied on several precedents including Mukhtiar Singh v. Tej Kaur (1978) 1 Rent LR 294 (P & H), Mahendra Nath v. Purnananda AIR 1988 Orissa 248, John v. Kamrunnisa AIR 1989 Ker 78, and Sanku Ranga Rao v. Devi Prasad Sahu AIR 1989 Orissa 21.
  • Contended that the Court has jurisdiction to appoint a Commissioner to elucidate points in dispute through local investigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Basanta Kumar v. Baidya Kumar, AIR 1989 Orissa 118 Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C - Limits appointment of Commissioner to cases where local investigation elucidates matters not otherwise provable by parties; Commissioner’s report is not binding evidence. The Court relied on this case to hold that appointment of Commissioner should not be used to assist a party to collect evidence that it can produce itself, emphasizing that possession is a disputed fact to be decided by evidence at trial.
Mukhtiar Singh v. Tej Kaur (1978) 1 Rent LR 294 (P & H) Discretionary power of Courts to appoint Commissioner for elucidating any point in dispute. The Court noted the principle but distinguished applicability due to local procedural rules and facts of the case.
Mahendra Nath v. Purnananda, AIR 1988 Orissa 248 Local investigation should ordinarily be allowed unless application is belated, mala fide or otherwise unjustified. The Court acknowledged the principle but found the present appointment unjustified because the disputed fact could be resolved by trial evidence.
John v. Kamrunnisa, AIR 1989 Ker 78 Local inspection under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C can be ordered even if defendant has not filed written statement. The Court noted this ruling but found it not applicable to the present facts where written statement was already filed and evidence could be produced at trial.
Sanku Ranga Rao v. Devi Prasad Sahu, AIR 1989 Orissa 21 Appointment of Court Commissioner is necessary where private Commissioner’s report is unreliable. The Court referenced this case to explain circumstances warranting appointment but found such necessity absent here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory provisions under Order 26, Rules 9 and 10, C.P.C which empower the Court to appoint a Commissioner for local investigation where it deems such inquiry requisite or proper to elucidate any matter in dispute. The Court also considered Rule 67 of the General Rules (Civil) 1986 (Rajasthan), which restricts referral of points to the Commissioner that can be conveniently substantiated by parties at trial.

It was noted that the defendants had already filed a written statement claiming possession of the disputed land, while the plaintiff claimed possession as well, making possession a disputed factual question to be adjudicated through evidence at trial. The Court reasoned that appointment of a Commissioner to decide such a disputed fact would be inappropriate and tantamount to assisting a party in collecting evidence that it can produce on its own.

The Court found the plaintiff’s reliance on precedents from Orissa, Punjab, Haryana, and Kerala inapplicable due to the existence of Rule 67 in Rajasthan, which the Court upheld as valid. Aligning with the view in Basanta Kumar v. Baidya Kumar, the Court held that the discretionary power to appoint a Commissioner should not be exercised to create evidence where parties can produce evidence themselves.

Consequently, the impugned order appointing the Commissioner was held to suffer from jurisdictional error and would cause failure of justice if allowed to stand.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the revision and set aside the impugned order dated January 17, 1998, which appointed a Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C for local investigation.

The direct effect of this decision is that the disputed question of possession must be resolved by recording evidence in the trial Court rather than by a Commissioner’s local investigation. No new precedent beyond the application of existing legal principles and local procedural rules was established.

    Union Of India And Another v. M/S. Kripal Industries .

    1. Instant revision impugns the order dated January 17, 1998 of the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) Raisinghnagar, whereby the application under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C, moved by the plaintiff-non-petitioner (for short the plaintiff) was allowed and Commissioner was appointed for making enquiry about the fact of possession of the plot in dispute.

    2. Brief résumé of the facts is that the plaintiff instituted a suit for injunction against the defendant-petitioners (for short the defendants) in the trial Court, seeking relief that the defendants be restrained from transferring plot No. 14 situated in Industrial Area, Raisinghnagar, in their names either by way of lease or by way of a sale deed. It was also prayed that the defendants be restrained from dispossessing the plaintiff from the said plot. Along with the plaint, an application seeking temporary injunction was also filed by the plaintiff. Learned trial Court allowed the application and restrained the defendants from interfering with the possession of the plaintiff and encroaching upon the suit plot. The Additional District Judge, however, allowed the appeal of the defendants preferred under Order 43, Rule I, C.P.C and reversed the finding of the trial Court with a direction that original suit be decided within six months. The plaintiff thereafter submitted an application under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C before the trial Court for appointing Commissioner to ascertain as to who was in possession of the suit plot on the relevant date. The application was allowed by the trial Court vide order under challenge.

    3. Mr. J.P Joshi, learned counsel for the defendants urged that Commissioner cannot be appointed with an object to create evidence in favour of one of the litigant parties. The question of possession has to be proved by cogent evidence and it cannot be determined on the basis of the inspection report of the Commissioner. Reliance was placed on Basanta Kumar v. Baidya Kumar, AIR 1989 Orissa 118.

    4. Mr. R.R Nagori, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff on the other hand supported the impugned order of the trial Court. Learned counsel attracted my attention towards the provisions contained in Rule 9 and Rule 10 of Order 26, C.P.C It was contended that the trial Court is vested with discretionary powers under the said provisions to appoint the Commissioner for elucidating any point in dispute. Reliance was placed on Mukhtiar Singh v. Tej Kaur, (1978) 1 Rent LR 294 (P & H); Mahendra Nath v. Purnananda, AIR 1988 Orissa 248; John v. Kamrunnisa, AIR 1989 Ker 78 and Sanku Ranga Rao v. Devi Prasad Sahu, AIR 1989 Orissa 21.

    5. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the rival submissions and carefully perused the impugned order.

    6. At this juncture it will be useful to examine the relevant statutory provisions.

    7. Order 26, Rule 9. C.P.C provides thus—

    “9. Commissions to make local investigations.— In any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market value of any property or the amount of any mesne profits or damages or annual net profits, the Court may issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court:

    Provided that, where the State Government has made rules as to the persons to whom such commission shall be issued, the Court shall be bound by such rules.”

    Order 26, Rule 10, C.P.C, reads as under—

    “10. Procedure of Commissioner.— (1) The Commissioner, after such local inspection as he deems necessary and after reducing to writing the evidence taken by him; shall return such evidence, together with his report in writing signed by him, to the Court.

    (2) Report and depositions to be evidence in suit.— The report of the Commissioner and the evidence taken by him (but not the evidence without the report) shall be evidence in the suit and shall form part of the record; but the Court, or with the permission of the Court, any of the parties to the suit may examine the Commissioner personally in open Court touching any of the matters referred to him or mentioned in his report, or as to his report, or as to the manner in which he has made the investigation.

    (3) Commissioner may be examined in person.— Where the Court is for any reason dissatisfied with the proceedings of the Commissioner, it may direct such further inquiry to be made as it shall think fit.”

    8. The High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan in exercise of powers conferred upon it by Article 227 of the Constitution of India and all other powers enabling it in that behalf and with the approval of Governor of Rajasthan, has made the General Rules (Civil) 1986 which came into force from the date of their publication in the Rajasthan Gazette i.e from December 25, 1986. Rule 67 of the said rules provides thus—

    “67.— Particulars to be given in the order for local investigation.— When issuing a Commission for making local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 the Court shall define the points on which the Commissioner has to report. No point which can conveniently and ought to be substantiated by the parties by evidence at the trial shall be referred to the Commissioner.”

    9. I have been taken through the certified copy of the application for the plaintiff moved under Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C Beginning lines of the said applicant are as under—

    10. A cursory look at the contents of the application demonstrates that the defendants have already filed written statement claiming their possession over the suit land whereas the case of the plaintiff is that he is in the possession of the said land. The disputed question of fact can be decided obviously by recording evidence.

    11. The point which requires determination in the instant revision is as to whether a Commissioner should be appointed to decide a disputed question of fact?

    12. Sanku Ranga Rao v. Devi Prasad, AIR 1989 Orissa 21, was a case where it was observed that—

    “Since the private Commissioner had once filed an affidavit contrary to his previous report appointing a Private Commissioner again would serve little purpose. Hence appointment of Court Commissioner was necessary.”

    13. Basanta Kumar v. Baidya Kumar, AIR 1989 Orissa 118, was a case where it was indicated that (Para 4)—

    “The object of O. 26, R. 9, C.P.C is not to assist a party to collect evidence where it can get the evidence itself. The object is for elucidating any matter in dispute by local investigation at the spot. Where on the evidence of experts on record, the Court is satisfied that for appreciating the opinion of the expert evidence, it should appoint an expert as Commissioner, it can on the facts and circumstances of the case, appoint a Commissioner. Where the Court is satisfied on the materials available on record that a party is not able to produce the desired evidence for reasonable circumstances, the Court may assist the party to appoint a Commissioner to get the evidence. However, such evidence is not binding on the Court which is to appreciate the same along with other evidence.”

    14. In John v. Kamrunnisa, AIR 1989 Ker 78, it was held that—

    “Where local inspection under O. 26, R. 9, Civil P.C is requisite and proper for elucidating matters in dispute in the suit, the same cannot be denied on the ground that the defendant has not yet filed his written statement. The said provision places no such bar on the Court exercising the power.”

    15. In Mahendra Nath v. Purnananda, AIR 1988 Orissa 248, it was laid down that (Para 4)—

    “Therefore, where the Court considers a local investigation to be requisite and proper, ordinarily it should not decline to exercise jurisdiction. It may decline jurisdiction if the motion is made at a belated stage, or if the motion is mala fide or in circumstances justifying refusal.”

    16. In Mukhtiar Singh v. Tej Kaur, (1978) 1 Rent LR 294 (P & H), it was propounded that—

    “From a bare reading of the rule, it is evident that a Court can appoint a Commission for elucidating any point in dispute. In the present case, there is a dispute regarding the possession of the house in dispute. The Court dismissed the application on the ground that the power to investigate regarding the possession of the house could not be delegated. The view taken by the learned trial Court appears to be erroneous on the face of it. Such a power could always be given to a Commission. In my view, the Court has acted in exercise of its jurisdiction illegally and the order is liable to be set aside.”

    17. A perusal of the provisions contained in Rules 9 and 10 and Order 26 goes to show that the trial Court is vested with the discretion to appoint Commissioner but such discretion should not be exercised where the point which is required to be referred to the Commissioner can conveniently be substantiated by the parties by evidence at the trial. Rule 67 of the General Rules (Civil) 1986, explains the scope of Order 26, Rule 9, C.P.C In Orissa, Punjab and Haryana and Kerala there is no such rule and the ratio of case law cited by Mr. Nagori, learned counsel for the plaintiff, is not applicable in the case on hand. I am unable to persuade myself to agree with the submission of Mr. Nagori, the learned counsel, that Rule 67 is ultra vires.

    18. Subscribing the view of Orissa High Court in Basanta Kumar v. Baidya Kumar (AIR 1989 Orissa 118) (supra) I hold that power of appointment of Commissioner for local investigation cannot be exercised by the Court to assist party to collect evidence where it can get evidence itself. In the case on hand the written statement has already been filed, therefore, the disputed question of fact can be adjudicated upon by the Court after framing the issues and recording the evidence of the parties. For such purpose assistance of Commissioner is neither necessary nor justified.

    19. The impugned order thus suffers from jurisdictional error and if it is allowed to stand it would occasion failure of justice.

    20. Resultantly, the revision succeeds and is hereby allowed. The impugned order stands set aside. No costs.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Another v. M/S. Kripal Industries .
    (Mar 6, 1998)