AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from a reference made by the Government of Rajasthan, Labour and Employment Department dated October 29, 1985 under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, to the Industrial Tribunal, Jaipur, for adjudication of the justification and legality of the dismissal of ten workmen. The learned Tribunal issued an interim award dated October 14, 1986 granting interim relief to the ten dismissed workers, holding that the domestic enquiries into their alleged misconduct were not in accordance with the principles of natural justice. The Tribunal thereby allowed the employer (petitioner) to prove the misconduct of the workmen in adjudication. A dispute existed concerning who was the valid General Secretary of the Jaipur Syntex Sharmik Ekta Union (Lalchand Arya or Ram Bhai); Ram Bhai filed the application for interim relief on behalf of the Union. The petitioner challenged the Tribunal's interim award and related findings by filing the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Industrial Tribunal had jurisdiction to grant interim relief during the pendency of the reference and whether such relief could be granted by way of an interim award rather than a separate interim order.
  2. Whether Shri Ram Bhai, claiming to be General Secretary of the Union, had the competence and authority to file the application for interim relief on behalf of the Union and the workmen.
  3. Whether the domestic enquiries held by the management against the ten workmen complied with the principles of natural justice and were fair and proper.
  4. Whether the Tribunal could grant interim relief with effect from the date of dismissal of the workmen, rather than from the date of the application for interim relief.
  5. Whether the amount of interim relief awarded to each of the ten workers was excessive and, relatedly, whether the Tribunal properly applied rules (including standing orders) permitting interim relief during suspension.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The learned Tribunal, though having jurisdiction to order interim relief, erred in concluding that a case for granting interim relief was made out.
  • An objection was raised before the Tribunal about the competence of Shri Ram Bhai to file the application for interim relief; the Tribunal wrongly decided this issue in favour of the Union.
  • Even if interim relief were to be granted, it should have been done by a separate order and the Tribunal should have ordered payment of interim relief separately rather than combining issues in a composite order or interim award.
  • The amount awarded as interim relief to each of the ten workers is excessive.

Union / Non-petitioner Arguments

  • The Union (Jaipur Syntex Sharmik Ekta Union) was a party to the dispute; Ram Bhai claimed to be the General Secretary and filed the application for interim relief on 24 March 1986.
  • At the hearing in the High Court, Mr. Punomiya representing the Union suggested the Tribunal's interim award could be modified so that interim relief would be payable from the date of application (24 March 1986) rather than from the dates of dismissal in 1984.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the Tribunal's findings and the arguments raised by the petitioner. The analysis proceeded in distinct steps, each tied to materials and statutory provisions referenced in the opinion:

  1. Jurisdiction to grant interim relief and form of relief:
    • The court accepted that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to grant interim relief during the pendency of a reference under the Act.
    • The court examined statutory scheme and incidental powers referenced in Section 19 (sub-section (10) as described in the opinion) and subsection (4) of Section 10 of the Act, concluding that adjudication of an application for interim relief is incidental to the Tribunal's duties in a reference. Consequently, the Tribunal could grant interim relief and could do so by way of an interim award. The court noted a distinction in effect between an interim award (effective after publication/30 days) and an interim order (effective from date made) but held that granting interim relief by interim award was not illegal or objectionable.
  2. Competence of Shri Ram Bhai to represent the Union:
    • The court observed that it was an undisputed fact a union was a party to the dispute, and that only if the Union espoused the case would it become an industrial dispute as per Section 2(k) of the Act.
    • The court reasoned that internal disputes as to who was the General Secretary related to the Union's constitution and that the Tribunal could not conclusively decide which claimant was the General Secretary on the record before it. In the circumstances, and since nothing contradicted Ram Bhai’s claim until the Tribunal's order, the Tribunal did not err in holding that Ram Bhai had power and authority to present the application for interim relief on behalf of the Union and workmen.
  3. Fairness of domestic enquiries:
    • The Tribunal had examined the domestic enquiry conducted by the employer in respect of each of the ten workmen and concluded that none of those enquiries were fair and proper and that principles of natural justice had not been complied with.
    • The High Court found no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's conclusions on this question of fact and procedure: the Tribunal had addressed the matter in detail and the court saw no illegality in the finding that the domestic enquiries were unfair and not in accordance with natural justice.
  4. Temporal scope of interim relief (effective date):
    • The Tribunal had granted interim relief from the dates of the orders of dismissal (various dates in 1984), rather than from the date the application for interim relief was filed (24 March 1986).
    • The High Court expressed serious reservations about backdating interim relief to the dates of dismissal and concluded that interim relief could only be granted from the date of the application. The Union's representative at the bar agreed to this modification; accordingly, the High Court modified the interim award to make relief payable from 24 March 1986.
  5. Quantum of interim relief:
    • The court noted that under various standing orders and rules a workman during suspension is entitled to interim relief and that interim relief can be granted up to 75% (as per the rules/applicable standing orders referenced in the opinion).
    • The Tribunal, considering the facts and its conclusion that the domestic enquiries were unfair, had fixed the interim relief. The High Court found no ground to interfere with the Tribunal's direction as to the quantum awarded to each worker.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is partly allowed: the interim award of the Industrial Tribunal dated October 14, 1986 is modified to the extent that interim relief for each of the ten workmen shall be payable only from the date the application for interim relief was made, i.e., March 24, 1986.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal's interim award stands largely upheld (including the Tribunal's findings that the domestic enquiries were not fair and proper and the grant of interim relief), except that the effective date for payment of interim relief is limited to March 24, 1986 (the date of the application) rather than the various dates of dismissal in 1984.
  • The amount of interim relief awarded by the Tribunal was not found excessive by the High Court; the court accepted the Tribunal's approach consistent with standing orders permitting interim relief (up to 75% during suspension).
  • The court indicated that the Tribunal properly exercised its jurisdiction to determine competence of the Union representative and to adjudicate incidental matters (including interim relief) in the reference; the High Court did not set any broader legal precedent beyond affirming that such incidental adjudication lies within the Tribunal's powers under the Act as applied in this case.
  • Costs were noted in the court's result ("Cost made easy").

    Manager, Jaipur Syntex Ltd. v. P.O Industrial Tribunal, Jaipur And Others

    M.B Sharma, J.:— In a reference under Section 10(1) of the Indus-putes Act, 1947 (for short the ‘Act’), the learned Industrial Tribunal, Jaipur (for short the ‘Tribunal’) has made an interim award daed October 14, 1986 under which he granted interim relief to the 10 workers who have been dismissed from service by the petitioner and in respect of whom the reference has been made by the Government under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act. The learned Tribunal has held that the domestic enquiry in the alleged misconduct of the, 10 workers to be not in accordance with the principles of natural justice and has held it to be. He, therefore, allowed the employer petitioner herein to prove the misconduct of the workmen.

    2. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that though the tribunal has the jurisdiction to order for interim relief during the pendency of the reference before it, but no case for granting of interim relief was made out.

    3. He further contended that a question was raised before the Tribunal with regard to the competence of Shri Ram Bhai who is said to be the General Secretary of the Union to file an application for interim relief and the learned Tribunal wrongly decided it in favour of the Union. It is further contended that the learned Tribunal should have under separate order even if an interim relief order was to be made should have ordered the payment of interim relief and not in a compo-sit order.

    4. The Government of Rajasthan, Labour and Employment Department under its notification dated October 29, 1985 made a reference to the Tribunal for adjudication in respect of the justification and legality of the dismissal of workmen mentioned in the reference order. A claim was filed on behalf of Jaipur Syntex Sharmik Ekta Union, Behror (for short the ‘Uunion’) which was a party in the dispute and at that relevant time one Shri Lalchand Arya was the General Secretary of the Union. It appears that thereafter some disputes arose as to whether the said Arya continued to be the General Secretary or his place was taken or by Shri Ram Bhai who claims to be duly elected General Secretary of the Union. Shri Bhai filed an application before the learned Tribunal for interim relief and an objection was raised on behalf of the petitioner that the Union of which Ram Bhai is the General Secretary has neither the power nor the authority to file an application on behalf of employees for interim relief. I that objection the contention raised before the Tribunal was that the Union was represented by Shri Lal Chand. Arya who does not want to continue with the case. The learned Tribunal took this issue and came to the conclusion that the Union of which Shri Ram Bhai was the General Secretary was one of the parties to the dispute and therefore, it cannot be said that the Union has been replaced on take over by another union; The Tribunal held that it is not possible to say as to who amongst the two claimants was in fact the General Secretary of the Union. The Tribunal, therefore, held that Shri Ram Bhai as its General Secretary has the power and authority to present the application for interim relief.

    5. The tribunal further held that domestic enquiries which were held by the management in the alleged misconduct, of 10 workmen was against the principles of natural justice and without holding proper enquiry the orders of dismissal were passed to victimise the workman.—Thus, the tri bunal granted interim relief to each of the workmen during the pendency of the reference before it. The said interim relief was granted from the date of the order of dismissal and not from, the date the application for interim relief was filed or from the date the interim award became effective.

    6. The learned Tribunal has dealt in detail with the question as to whether a domestic enquiry which was held is proper or not. He examined the case of each, and every workman in order to see as to whether the enquiry against each of them was fair and proper or not? The learned Tribunal concluded that domestic enquiry against none of the 10 workmen was not fair and proper. In my opinion, no case for interference is made out in the conclusions arrived at by the learned Tribunal that the domestic enquiries was not fair and proper and the principles of natural justice have not been complied with in respect of all 10 workmen.

    7. Similarly, there is no dispute that one of the parties in dispute was the Union. It is apparent from the terms of reference and it is not the case of the petitioner that the reference was not made at the instance of the Union. Only if the Union espoused the case of the workmen it could; become an industrial dispute as defined in Section 2(k) of the Act. It is only under Section 2 of the Industrial Disputes Act that a dispute in respect of retrenchment or termination of an individual workman becomes industrial dispute and can be espoused by the individual workman, Thus in the instant case it was an undisputed fact that there was a dispute between Union and the Employer. Whether Shri Lal Chand Arya was the General Secretary of Union at the time when the dispute was raised or Ram Bhai was the General Secretary was such a matter which relates to the Constitution of Union and the learned Tribunal could not come to the conclusion as to what was the constitution of the Union. A workman is a party to a dispute and is entitled to be represented in any proceeding under the Act by any member of the executive or other office-bearer of a registered union of which he is a member; or of a federation of trade union to which the trade union referred to in clause (a) is affiliated or where the worker is not a member of any trade union, by any member of the executive or other office-bearer of any trade union connected with, or by any other workman employed in, the industry in which the worker is employed in, the industry in which the worker is employed and authorise in such manner as may be prescribed. Thus when Ram Bhai claimed to be the General Secretary and there was nothing to the contrary till the learned Tribunal made the order I find no illegality in the order of the learned Tribunal that Ram Bhai could have filed an application on behalf of the Union for interim relief for the workers. There is no doubt and even it has not been disputed that Ram Bhai was the General Secretary of the Union the Tribunal has jurisdiction to grant interim relief. Mr. Kala learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that the same cannot be granted by way of interim relief award. It appears that there is some conflict in the various High Courts as to whether the interim relief can be granted by way of interim award or under an order but there is no conflict so far as the power and jurisdiction of the Tribunal in granting an interim relief is concerned. To my mind the scheme of the Act is that only such of the matter which are to be referred to the Tribunal or Judge Labour Court are adjudicated but the Tribunal has powers to make an incidental order sub-section (10) of Section 19 of Act. Where in an order referring an industrial disputes to a Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal under the section or in a subsequent order, the appropriate Government has specified the points of disputes for adjudication, the Labour Court or the Tribunal or the National Tribunal, as the case may be shall confine its adjudication to those points and matters incidental thereto. It can, therefore, be said that it is incidental matter under subsection (4) of Section 10 of the Act to adjudicate the dispute of interim relief. Therefore, the learned Tribunal considering the material on record granted interim relief by way of interim award, in my opinion, there can be objection to it. Even assuming that only an order for interim relief could have been passed and it could not have been in the shape of-interim award, it does not make any difference except that like any other award even interim award becomes effective after 30 days of publication whereas the interim order which made shall be effective from the date it is made. An employer in my opinion, cannot and should not object if the interim relief is awarded by way of interim award. I do not find any illegality in granting interim relief by way of interim award. Merely because along with granting of interim relief the learned Tribunal has also proceeded to examine other connected issues it cannot be said that he could not have done so. The reason is that an objection was raised by the petitioner that Ram Bhai has no right to file an application seeking interim relief to the workers. Unless the tribunal would have decided that objection he could not have proceeded to grant interim relief. Similarly, the tribunal could under its separate order hold that the domestic enquiry in the alleged misconduct of the workmen unfair and the Tribunal in its same order also took the point for consideration and then proceeded to take up the matter of interim relief, nothing can be said to be objectionable. The reason is that if the Tribunal would have held that the domestic enquiry was fair and proper then the industrial dispute could have been decided within a reasonable time as the Tribunal would not have recorded any evidence and could have said that whether any case for interfering in the punishment is made out under Section 11-A of the Industrial Disputes Act. Therefore, the Tribunal first thought it proper to examine as to whether the enquiry was fair and proper and came to the conclusions that the domestic enquiry was not fair and proper and taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the case, including the fact that now the employer will have to prove the misconduct of the respondents workmen, proceeded to grant interim relief. It cannot be said that it could not do so. It is only for the disposal of one of the point as to whether the enquiry was fair or not that the Tribunal held that if was not held in a proper manner and is against the principles of natural justice. It does not mean that the Tribunal-held to be a cose of unfair labour practice or victimization bq an employer. If the employer is able to prove the misconduct against the workmen then the Tribunal will have to examine the evidence and pass the orders in accordance with law.

    8. It may be stated that I have my serious reservations as to whether while granting interim relief the tribunal could grant interim relief from the date of the order of dismissal. In the instant case an application for interim relief was made on behalf of the Union on 24th March, 1986 and the removal from service was sometime in the year 1984 on different dates. Mr. Punomiya representing the Union non-petitioner stated at the bar that the interim award of the Tribunal may be modi-fled to the extent that the interim relief shall be payable from the date of application and not from the date of dismissal of the workmen. In my opinion, the interim relief can only be granted from the date of the application and not from the date of dismissal.

    9. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that am ount awarded as interim relief each of the 10 workers is excessive. In my opinion, even under the various standing orders during the period of suspension during the pendency of the enquiry a workman is entitled to interim relief. The interim relief can be granted upto 75% in accordance with the rules. The Tribunal taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances came to the conclusion that the domestic enquiry was not fair and proper and was against the principles of natural justice and the order of dismissal could not have been made. I find no case for interfer ence in the direction exercised by the Tribunal.

    10. Consequently, this writ petition is partly allowed and the interim award of the learned Tribunal dated October 14, 1986 is only modified to the extent that the interim relief to each of the 10 workmen shall be paid only from the date the application was made i.e March 24, 1986. Cost made easy.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Manager, Jaipur Syntex Ltd. v. P.O Industrial Tribunal, Jaipur And Others
    (Feb 19, 1987)