Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 9 read with Rule 24 and Rule 26 of the Rajasthan Service of Engineers Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954 (hereinafter
  • Rule 9 in the Rajasthan Medical and Health Rules, 1963, analogous to Rule 9 of the Rules.
  • Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963. Rule 9 of the Rules
  • Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Services Rules, 1963
  • Rule 9 of the aforesaid Rules
  • Rule 9 & Rule 24(1) of the Rules
  • Rule 24(1) of the rules
  • provisions of Rule 9
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 9
  • Rule 9 and Rule 24 (1),
  • Rule 9 of the Rules
  • Rule 9, Sub-rule (2).
  • Rule 9 of Rules.
  • Sub-rule (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 9 read with Rule 24 and Rule 26 of the Rajasthan Service of Engineers Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954 (hereinafter
  • Rule 9 in the Rajasthan Medical and Health Rules, 1963, analogous to Rule 9 of the Rules.
  • Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963. Rule 9 of the Rules
  • Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Services Rules, 1963
  • Rule 9 of the aforesaid Rules
  • Rule 9 & Rule 24(1) of the Rules
  • Rule 24(1) of the rules
  • provisions of Rule 9
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 9
  • Rule 9 and Rule 24 (1),
  • Rule 9 of the Rules
  • Rule 9, Sub-rule (2).
  • Rule 9 of Rules.
  • Sub-rule (2)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — H. K. Hingorani (Writ Petition)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, H. K. Hingorani, challenged by this writ petition (filed to quash) an order of reversion dated 8-7-1974 and the appointments of respondents Nos. 3 to 20 to the post of Executive Engineer made on the recommendations of a Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC). He sought an order directing respondents No. 1 and 2 to make selections afresh according to law.

Relevant facts in the opinion:

  • The petitioner previously served as an Engineering Subordinate, was appointed Assistant Engineer on an ad hoc basis on 4-8-1961, and after a regular selection by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission was appointed to that post on 26-9-1961.
  • He was promoted temporarily to Executive Engineer by an order dated 17-5-1973.
  • In the 11 June 1964 seniority list of Assistant Engineers (Civil) of the Irrigation Department the petitioner appeared at serial No. 145.
  • The petitioner had two adverse confidential roll entries for 1961–62 and 1962–63, and no other adverse entries are recorded in the opinion.
  • He was suspended by the Chief Engineer on 3-5-1970, underwent a preliminary enquiry, and was reinstated by a State Government order dated 10-9-1971. About two years after reinstatement he was promoted to Executive Engineer (temporary promotion noted above).
  • The DPC met in 1964 and thereafter did not meet until June 1974; the State allegedly failed to determine vacancies year by year as required by Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Service of Engineers (Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954 ("the Rules").
  • The DPC in or about June 1974 is said to have clubbed vacancies for many years and made selections for all posts then existing; respondents Nos. 3–20 were appointed based on those recommendations. The petitioner was reverted from Executive Engineer to Assistant Engineer by an order dated 8-7-1974, which he asserts was not personally served on him.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the selections and promotions to the post of Executive Engineer effected by the DPC in or about June 1974 (by clubbing vacancies that had arisen over prior years) were contrary to Rule 9 read with Rule 24(1) of the Rajasthan Service of Engineers (Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954, and thus liable to be quashed.
  2. Whether the petitioner's order of reversion dated 8-7-1974 should be quashed as a consequence of any illegality in the promotional process.
  3. Whether the State must determine vacancies year by year and make promotions based on eligibility as of the time those vacancies arose (i.e., whether vacancies could be validly carried forward and filled later on the basis of subsequently acquired eligibility).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The DPC's procedure of clubbing vacancies accumulated over the years and making selections on the basis of eligibility at the time of the 1974 DPC meeting violated Rule 9 and Rule 24(1) of the Rules (and also the Rajasthan Services (Recruitment by Promotion against vacancies of Earlier Years) Rules, 1972).
  • The petitioner relied on a decision in M.P. Agrawal v. The State of Rajasthan and Anr (1978 WLN (UC) 383) interpreting an analogous Rule 9 in the Rajasthan Medical and Health Services Rules, 1963, arguing that it held it was impermissible to lump together vacancies from earlier years and make promotions on the basis of eligibility at the later selection date.
  • The petitioner asserted prejudice arising from the procedure used and argued the impugned appointments and his reversion should be quashed; he also referred to an alleged amendment consistent with the construction in M.P. Agrawal, but it was not shown to have been published in the Rajasthan Gazette.

State's Arguments (Respondent)

  • The State's counter-argument traversed the petitioner's claims and maintained that the selections made by the DPC were not contrary to law.
  • It argued Rule 9 requires determination of vacancies every year but does not mandate that the DPC itself must meet every year; Rule 24 likewise does not command that the DPC be held yearly.
  • The State contended that vacancies, if not filled, may be carried forward and that unfilled vacancies may lapse if unfilled beyond two years (as explained in their submission).
  • With reference to M.P. Agrawal, the State pointed out that the decision was under challenge in a special appeal and contended that the construction of the word "otherwise" in sub-rule (2) of Rule 9 should be given a broader meaning to cover varied contingencies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M.P. Agrawal v. The State of Rajasthan and Anr, 1978 WLN (UC) 383 Held that it is impermissible to lump together vacancies of previous years and make promotions on the basis of eligibility existing at the later date; interpreted Sub-rule (2) of Rule 9 to permit carrying forward vacancies for one year only where vacancies remained due to non-availability of suitable candidates or similar reasons beyond Government control. The court in the present opinion followed and applied the reasoning of M.P. Agrawal: it accepted that Rule 9 must be construed to prevent clubbing of vacancies and that the word "otherwise" in sub-rule (2) is to be read narrowly (limited to reasons beyond Government control). The court held that no such exceptional reason was shown here and that clubbing for about ten years prejudiced the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded in these steps (as stated in the opinion):

  1. The court noted that Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Service of Engineers (Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954 is worded exactly as the Rule 9 which was interpreted in the Rajasthan Medical and Health Services Rules, 1963; therefore the decision in M.P. Agrawal was directly analogous and required consideration.
  2. The court considered the purpose underlying Rule 9: that vacancies should be determined and filled up year by year on the basis of eligibility conditions existing at the time the vacancies occur. The court observed that construing the rule otherwise would allow abuse by clubbing vacancies and defeating claims of those who would have been eligible earlier.
  3. On the construction of the phrase "or otherwise" in sub-rule (2) of Rule 9 (addressed in M.P. Agrawal), the court accepted Agrawal J.'s analysis that the phrase must be read in light of the preceding expression "for non-availability of suitable candidates" and thus is limited to cases where vacancies could not be filled due to reasons beyond Government control (e.g., genuine non-availability), not merely because of Government inaction.
  4. Applying these principles to the present facts, the court observed that the State had not pointed out any reason beyond its control that prevented filling the vacancies in the relevant years; instead the DPC had not met for about a decade. Therefore, the clubbing of vacancies and selection on the basis of eligibility as of June 1974 resulted in prejudice to the petitioner (whose chance of selection might have been different if each year's vacancies had been determined and considered timely).
  5. The court addressed the petitioner's reference to an alleged amendment (purportedly aligning the Rules with the M.P. Agrawal construction) and noted that the petitioner had not shown the amendment was published in the Rajasthan Gazette; in the absence of publication, the alleged amendment could not be taken notice of, and the court declined to examine its applicability.
  6. On balance, having heard arguments of counsel for both sides, the court agreed with the M.P. Agrawal interpretation and concluded the clubbing practice in the present case was unlawful and prejudicial.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling emphasized): Writ petition allowed; the petitioner's order of reversion and the appointments of respondents Nos. 3 to 20 are quashed.

Consequential directions and immediate effects stated in the opinion:

  • The court directed that the vacancies for the posts of Executive Engineers should be filled by making selections from among persons who were eligible for consideration at the time when the vacancies had occurred (i.e., selections are to be made as of the dates vacancies arose, not after clubbing many years' vacancies together).
  • Because the operation of the petitioner's reversion had been stayed by this Court during proceedings, no further consequential order needed to be passed in his case.
  • The court ordered that costs of the writ petition shall be easy.

Broader precedent implication: The court expressly followed and applied the precedent in M.P. Agrawal for the construction of Rule 9; the opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal principle beyond adopting that construction for the present case.

    H.K. Hingorani v. The State Of Rajasthan And Ors.

    1. The petitioner H. K. Hingorani by this writ petition has sought to quash his order of reversion dated 8-7-1974 and has further sought to quash the appointments of respondents Nos. 3 to 20 on the post of Executive Engineers consequent to the recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee (for short, referred to as the 'DPC') by issuance of an appropriate writ, order or direction. He has further, sought a direction that the respondents No. 1 & 2 be ordered to make selections afresh according to law.

    2. The present writ petition arises under the following facts and circumstances. After serving as Engineering Subordinate the petitioner was appointed to be the post of Assistant Engineer on ad hoc basis by an order dated 4 8-1961 and after regular selection by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission for the post of Assistant Engineer the petitioner was appointed to the said post on 26-9-1961 and he was promoted as Executive Engineer temporarily by an order dated 17-5-1973. In the seniority list of the Assistant Engineers, Civil) of the Irrigation Department dated 11th June, 1964 his name was shown at serial No. 145. There were two adverse entries in the confidential roll of the petitioner for the year 1961-62 and 1962-63 and there appears to be no other adverse entry against the petitioner. The petitioner was placed under suspension by the order of the Chief Engineer, Irrigation, Rajasthan, dated 3-5-1970 but after preliminary enquiry, the petitioner was reinstated by an order of the State Government dated 10-9-1971. After two years of his reinstatement, he was promoted to the post of the Executive Engineer.

    3. For the purposes of making selections to the post of Executive Engineers, the DPC met in the year 1964 and thereafter, no meeting of the DPO took place till June, 1974, with the result that no selections and appointments were made year by year on the post of Executive Engineers as required by Rule 9 read with Rule 24 and Rule 26 of the Rajasthan Service of Engineers Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954 (hereinafter to be referred to as the 'Rules) The petitioner averred that the State Government did not determine the number of vacancies year by year as required by Rule 9 of Rules. Without doing so, the meeting of the DPC was convened to make selections for all the po9ts of Executive Engineers existent upto the date the DPC met by clubbing all the vacancies together. The DPC is said to have made selections for all the posts of Executive Engineers then existing and respondents No. 3 to 20 are said to have been appointed to the post of Executive Engineers on the recommendations of the DPC and it was alleged that the promotions were effected by an individual order and not by any consolidated order. It was further alleged that the respondents No. 3 to 14 were already officiating on the post of Executive Engineers and respondents No. 15 to 20 have been newly selected.

    4. By order dated 8-7-1974, the petitioner along with three others was reverted from the pout of Executive Engineer to the post of Assistant Engineer. According to the petitioner, no order of reversion was served on him and he has reproduced the order of reversion dated 8-7-1974 on the basis of the order served on Shri M.P. Rankawat.

    5. The petitioner has referred to some individual cases in his petition and has argued as to how he has been prejudicially affected by the impugned orders.

    6. The petitioner now seeks to challenge his order of reversion and the order of promotion of respondents No. 3 to 20 inter alia on the ground that the manner in which selections have been made by the DPC is contrary to law in as much as that the procedure laid down in rule 9 & Rule 24(1) of the rules have not been followed. Rule 9 of the Rules contained a mandate that number of vacancies will be determined year by year and Rule 24(1) of the rules lays down that as soon as the number of vacancies are determined, a meeting of the DPC will be convened and the process of selections by promotion shall be resorted to as provided in Rule 24(2) onwards. It was also alleged that apart from Rule 9 and Rule 24 (1), this is also the mandate of the Rajasthan Services (Recruitment by Promotion against vacancies of Earlier Years) Rules, 1972. The petitioner has also challenged the impugned orders on other grounds but it is not necessary to take into account those grounds for the disposal of the writ-petition.

    7. The writ petition has been opposed by the State of Rajas than and a counter to the writ petition has been filed traversing the claim of the petitioner. The case of the State is that the selections made by the DPC are not contrary to law. Rule 9 only requires that there should be determination of vacancies every year and it does not require that the DPC should be held every year. Likewise, Rule 24 does not command that the DPC should be held every year nor such an intention is spelt out by a combined reading of Rules 9 and 24. It was stated that mandate of the Rule 9 is that the vacancies should be determined every year and if not filed, they may be carried forward if remained unfilled beyond two years, then they will lapse.

    8. A rejoinder to the counter was also submitted by the petitioner.

    9. I have heard Shri M. Mridul, learned Counsel for the petitioners and Shri M D. Purohit, Additional Government Advocate for the State of Rajasthan.

    10. Shri Mridul submitted that there is Rule 9 in the Rajasthan Medical and Health Rules, 1963, analogous to Rule 9 of the Rules. A question with regard to the interpretation of Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Services Rules, 1963 came up for interpretation in the facts and circumstances of the case like the present one in M P. Agrawal v. The State of Rajasthan and Anr. 1978 WLN (UC) 383, in which this Court has held that it was not permissible for the Government to lump together all the vacancies which had occurred in the previous years and to make selections for promotion on those vacancies on the basis of eligibility existing on the date of making of selections. Shri Mridul submitted that the present case is squarely covered by the decision in M.P. Agarwal's case, so the impugned orders deserve to the quashed.

    11. Shri M.D. Purohit, on the other hand, submitted that the decision in M.P. Agarwal's case is under challenge in special appeal and he further urged that the view taken by Agrawal J. needs reconsideration with regard to the interpretation of Rule 9, Sub-rule (2). He urged that the word "otherwise" occurring in Sub-rule (2) is of wide import and general in nature and this word should be given an extensive and comprehensive meaning so as to embrace all possible contingencies and situations whereby vacancies remain unfilled.

    12. Having heard both the sides, I am of the opinion that the view taken by Agrawal J does not require any further consideration and I am in agreement with the view expressed in M.P. Agrawal's case as to the construction of Rule 9 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963. Rule 9 of the Rules is couched exactly in the same language as Rule 9 of the aforesaid Rules and a similar controversy arose in M P Agrawal's case as has arisen in the present case. Agrawal J. considered the purpose underlying the provisions of Rule 9 and having regard to the purpose of the said provision, proceeded to construe the said rule. It may be stated that there appears to be this logic and rationale of Rule 9 that after determination of vacancies, the vacancies shall be filled up by each method yearly on the then existing eligibility conditions. If the rules are not construed in this manner the rules may be open to abuse and some times claims may be defeated by clubbing of vacancies. If there will be timely determination of vacancies and filling up of the same, there would be lesser number of vacancies to be filled in by consideration of lesser number of eligible candidates on the existing eligibility condition, whereas by not determining the vacancies as contemplated by Rule 9 and clubbing the vacancies for many years and opening the selection to a larger number of employees to larger number of posts by eligibility conditions existing at the time of selection it may result in prejudice to those employees who could be earlier selected if the vacancies would have been determined earlier and their case would have been considered for promotion by the criterion then existing. As regards the construction of the word "otherwise", Vgrawal J. observed in that case that whether the enjusdem generis rule or the Nossitur a spclis rule is applied, the result is that, the expression "or otherwise" has to be construed in the light of the expression "for non availability of the suitable candidates" which precedes it and comprehends only those cases in which due to some reason beyond the control of the Government, it has not been possible for the Government to fill the vacancies in the particular year.

    13. Agrawal J. then concluded as under:

    I am therefore, of the view that Sub-rule (2) of Rule 9 provides for carrying forward for vacancies from one year only one year in those cases where the vacancies have remained vacant due to nonavailability of suitable candidates or for other similar reason and that merely because the Government has failed to take any action for the purpose of filling the vacancies in a particular year can be no ground for carrying forward the said vacancies in the subsequent years and to wake appointments on these vacancies on the basis of qualifications and other conditions of eligibility subsequently acquired.

    I am in agreement with the aforesaid view. Admittedly in the present case it has not been pointed out on behalf of the State that the vacancies could not be filled up due to any reason beyond the control of the Slate Government. There appears to be only in action on the part of the State Government and for about a decade, the DP 3. did not meet If the petitioner's case would have been considered in the manner as postulated under Rule 9, the result of selection might have been different and thus, the petitioner has been seriously prejudiced by the procedure adopted for making selection on the post of the Executive Engineers by clubbing the vacancies for about 10 years and by adopting a criterion of selection as was existing in June 1974.

    14. Shri Mridul also submitted that the construction put by this Court in M.P Agarwal's case on Rule 9 has been introduced by the State Government in rules by amendment thereof and thus, the Government has made that rule retrospective. So under the amended rule as well, the impugned orders deserve to be quashed Shri Midul referred to a typed copy. In this connection, suffice it to say that it has not been pointed out before me that the said amendment has been published in the Rajasthan. Gazette or not. In the absence of publication of the rules in the Gazette, the alleged amendment in the Rules, cannot be taken notice of So, I need not examine the applicability of the alleged amendment to the petitioner's case.

    15. In view of what I have considered above, the writ petition deserves to be accepted.

    16. In the result, the writ petition is allowed and the petitioner's order of reversion and the order of promotion of respondents No. 3 to 20 are quashed and it is directed that the vacancies for the posts of Executive Engineers should be filled by making selection from amongst persons who were eligible for consideration at the time when the vacancies have occurred. As the operation of the petitioner's reversion was stayed by this Court, so, no consequential order needs to be passed. In the circumstances of the case, costs of this writ petition shall be easy.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    H.K. Hingorani v. The State Of Rajasthan And Ors.
    (Nov 23, 1979)