Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 323, 354, 452, 458, 389, 500, 506 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC.
  • Section 197 Cr.P.C
  • Section 482 Cr.P.C
  • Section 245 Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 323, 354, 452, 458, 389, 500, 506 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC.
  • Section 197 Cr.P.C
  • Section 482 Cr.P.C
  • Section 245 Cr.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (RITU BAHRI, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C seeks quashing of the order dated 10.3.2008 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Panchkula (Annexure P4).

The petitioner-complainant, Smt. Urmila Devi, a pharmacist serving in an ESI Dispensary at HMT Pinjore and residing in official accommodation, filed a complaint under Section 500 IPC against Smt. Maya Rani alleging authorship of a letter using objectionable language. A separate complaint by Maya Rani (dated 4.6.1997) alleged that Urmila Devi had a relationship with Shri R.C. Chopra. An inquiry by the then Tehsildar on 20.6.1997 and subsequent investigation led to a visit by an investigation team (including DSP Mrs. Rajshri Singh, ASI Onkar Singh and Head Constable Om Parkash) to Urmila Devi's residence at about 10:00 P.M.; Shri R.C. Chopra was present and both were medically examined. No arrest was made and no case was registered arising from that visit.

The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Panchkula, by order dated 30.7.2001, summoned accused Nos. 1 to 10 and 12 to face trial under Sections 323, 354, 452, 458, 389, 500, 506 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC. Accused No.1 (the SDM-cum-SDO, Kalka) applied to recall the summoning order; that application was dismissed on 4.7.2007. A revision filed before the Sessions Judge was allowed by order dated 10.3.2008 (Annexure P4), which set aside the earlier summoning and related orders on the ground that Section 197 Cr.P.C barred summoning the SDM to face trial without sanction.

The present petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C challenges the Sessions Judge's order dated 10.3.2008. The High Court heard arguments, reviewed the factual background and the authorities cited, and concluded that there was no infirmity in the Sessions Judge's order. The petition was dismissed with no order as to costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the SDM (accused No.1), a public servant, could be validly summoned to face criminal trial in view of the protection/bar under Section 197 Cr.P.C.
  2. Whether the revision accepted by the Sessions Judge on 10.3.2008 setting aside the summoning orders dated 30.7.2001 and related orders was legally tenable.
  3. Whether the acts alleged against the SDM fell within the course of his official duties (such that Section 197 Cr.P.C would be applicable), or whether they were acts outside the scope of official duty (such that Section 197 would not protect him).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The acts attributed to accused Nos.1 to 6 (including the SDM) did not fall within the scope or ambit of discharge of official duty; there was no occasion to forcibly enter the complainant's house and the actions complained of (harassment, examination by a male doctor, public humiliation of Shri R.C. Chopra) could not be said to be in the course of performance of official duties.
  • When an authority vested in a public servant is misused (acts not permitted by law), such acts cannot claim protection under Section 197 Cr.P.C. (reliance placed on Choudhury Parveen Sultana v. State of West Bengal (2009) 3 SCC 398).
  • Summoning is an interim order and can be revisited by the Magistrate later; the accused can be discharged under Section 245 Cr.P.C after evidence is recorded (reliance placed on Dev Raj Garg v. State of Punjab (1997) and Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal (2004)).
  • The question of sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C can be raised at any time after cognizance — immediately after cognizance, at framing of charge, at conclusion of trial, or even after conviction; a complaint should not be quashed at the initial stage solely because sanction was not obtained (reliance placed on Raj Kishor Roy v. Kamleshwar Pandey (2002)).

Respondent's Arguments

  • Maya Rani had lodged a complaint alleging that Urmila Devi was living with Shri R.C. Chopra though not legally married to him; upon that complaint the SDM marked an inquiry to the Tehsildar, who reported facts warranting further investigation.
  • An investigation led by DSP Mrs. Rajshri Singh was conducted to verify the complaint; Shri R.C. Chopra was found at the residence of Urmila Devi, both were medically examined, and no arrests were made. The respondent contends these actions were within the ambit of official duties.
  • The SDM acted in the course of official duty in marking and overseeing the inquiry and investigation; Section 197 Cr.P.C should be liberally construed in favor of public servants where acts fall within official duty (reliance was placed on State of Maharashtra v. Dr. Budhikota Subharao (1993), Abdul Wahab Ansari v. State of Bihar (AIR 2000 SC 3187), State of Orissa through Kumar Raghvendra Singh v. Ganesh Chandra Jew (2004), K. Kalimuthu v. State (2005), Sankaran Moitra v. Sadhna Das (2006)).
  • Once an act committed by a public servant falls within the four corners of official duty, it must be given a liberal and wide construction so as to attract the protection of Section 197 Cr.P.C.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Choudhury Parveen Sultana v. State of West Bengal (2009) 3 SCC 398 When authority vested in a public servant is misused by doing things not permitted by law, such acts cannot claim protection under Section 197 Cr.P.C. The petitioner relied on this authority to argue that misuse of authority should deny Section 197 protection. The Court noted this reliance but, on the facts, found the SDM's presence and actions were within the course of official duty and therefore Section 197 applied.
Dev Raj Garg v. State of Punjab (1997 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 26) Summoning order is an interim order; accused can be discharged later under Section 245 Cr.P.C after evidence is recorded. Cited by the petitioner to argue that summoning could be revisited. The Court recorded this submission but proceeded to decide the Section 197 question on the factual matrix, concluding that the SDM's acts fell within official duty.
Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal (2004 (7) J.T 243) Supports view that summoning is an interim order and can be altered upon further proceedings. Relied upon by the petitioner; the Court acknowledged the point but did not accept it as sufficient to negate the application of Section 197 in the present factual circumstances.
Raj Kishor Roy v. Kamleshwar Pandey (2002 (3) R.C.R (Criminal) 873) The question of sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C can be raised at any time after cognizance; a complaint should not be quashed at the initial stage merely for lack of sanction. Cited by the petitioner to argue the question of sanction could be left to later stages. The Court noted this authority but ultimately found on facts that the SDM's acts were within official duty, making Section 197 applicable at the summoning/revision stage.
State of Maharashtra v. Dr. Budhikota Subharao (1993 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 482) Authority for construing Section 197 Cr.P.C in a manner favorable to public servants when acts are in course of official duty. Relied upon by the respondent. The Court referred to the line of authorities favoring liberal construction of Section 197 and applied this understanding in concluding that the SDM's presence and conduct were part of official duty.
Abdul Wahab Ansari v. State of Bihar (AIR 2000 Supreme Court 3187) Supports liberal construction of Section 197 Cr.P.C for acts done in the course of official duty. Relied upon by the respondent; the Court considered this authority as part of the jurisprudential backdrop supporting its conclusion that the SDM's acts fell within official duty.
State of Orissa through Kumar Raghvendra Singh v. Ganesh Chandra Jew (2004 (4) J.T 52) Authority in support of broad/liberal interpretation of official duty under Section 197 Cr.P.C. Relied upon by the respondent; the Court treated it as part of the line of cases justifying protection where the act is connected with official duty.
K. Kalimuthu v. State by D.S.P (2005 (4) S.C.C 512) Section 197 Cr.P.C must be given a liberal and wide construction once it is found the public servant was discharging his duty; reference made to the principle in Matajog Dobey. The Court expressly relied on this decision. Applying its principle, the Court held that the SDM's presence at the investigation was in discharge of official duty and consequently Section 197 applied, supporting the Sessions Judge's order.
Sankaran Moitra v. Sadhna Das (2006 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 389) Supports view that acts falling within official duty attract protection under Section 197 Cr.P.C. Relied upon by the respondent as part of the authorities backing liberal construction of Section 197; the Court treated it as reinforcing the approach adopted in K. Kalimuthu and related authorities.
Matajog Dobey v. H. C. Bhari (AIR 1956 SC 44) Principle: the offence alleged must have a reasonable connection with the discharge of official duty; there must be a reasonable (not fanciful) claim that the act was done in course of official duty. The Court quoted this principle and applied it: finding a reasonable connection between the SDM's actions (seizing of the complaint, marking of inquiry and presence at the investigation) and his official duty, thereby supporting application of Section 197.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the factual matrix and the sequence of events: (i) a continuing quarrelsome relationship between Smt. Maya Rani and Smt. Urmila Devi; (ii) a complaint by Maya Rani alleging cohabitation of Urmila Devi with Shri R.C. Chopra; (iii) an inquiry by the Tehsildar concluding that Shri R.C. Chopra visited and stayed at Urmila Devi's residence; and (iv) an investigation led by the DSP to verify these facts, during which Shri R.C. Chopra was found at the residence and both were medically examined, with no arrests or registration of a case.

The Court observed that the SDM was seized of the complaint and had marked inquiries that led to the investigation. The SDM's presence during the investigation was not denied and, at best, the allegations against him could amount to an act of omission while performing official duty. The Court referred to binding and persuasive precedents (in particular K. Kalimuthu and Matajog Dobey) to state the applicable legal principle: an act or omission by a public servant will attract the protection of Section 197 Cr.P.C if it bears a reasonable connection with the discharge of official duty, and once such a connection is established, Section 197 is to be given a liberal and wide construction.

Applying those principles to the facts, the Court concluded that the SDM's conduct—seizing and dealing with the complaint, marking an inquiry to the Tehsildar and referring the matter to the DSP for verification—fell within the official duties of his office. Therefore, the protection contemplated by Section 197 Cr.P.C applied. The Court noted the petitioner's reliance on authorities that counsel limiting scrutiny at the summoning stage and the view that sanction questions can be raised later; however, on the facts, the Court found the SDM's actions were sufficiently connected to his official duties to justify the Sessions Judge's reliance on Section 197.

The Court concluded there was no infirmity in the Sessions Judge's order dated 10.3.2008 (Annexure P4) that had accepted the revision and set aside the earlier summoning orders.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C is dismissed; the High Court found no infirmity in the order dated 10.3.2008 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Panchkula (Annexure P4).

Implications:

  • The Sessions Judge's order dated 10.3.2008, which set aside the summoning orders dated 30.7.2001 and related orders insofar as they sought to summon the SDM (accused No.1), stands upheld by the High Court.
  • The Court concluded that, on the facts of this case, the SDM's acts were connected with the discharge of official duty and therefore attracted the protection afforded by Section 197 Cr.P.C; consequently, the accused SDM could not be summoned to face trial in the circumstances established on the record.
  • There is no order as to costs.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel or broader precedent beyond the application of established principles (no separate/new precedent was declared in this judgment).

End of summary.

    Smt. Urmila Devi Petitioner v. Sh. Yudhvir Singh

    RITU BAHRI, J.

    This petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C is for quashing of order dated 10.3.2008 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Panchkula (Annexure P4).

    The petitioner/complainant-Urmila Devi is a Pharmacist and is serving in ESI Dispensary situated in the premises of HMT Pinjore for the last about 20 years. The complainant is living along with her two daughters and son in official accommodation allotted to her by the dispensary authorities in Quarter No. 8-4 ESI Dispensary, HMT Pinjore on the first floor. In the same premises, one Maya Rani is living on the ground floor. The petitioner filed a complaint under Section 500 IPC against Smt. Maya Rani on the allegation that she has authored a letter using objectionable and filthy language. The relationship between the petitioner and Smt. Maya Rani has not been cordial.

    On 20.6.1997, Bir Singh the then Tehsildar Kalka conducted an inquiry by coming to the house of the petitioner. After conducting the search, petitioner was directed to be present in the office on 23.6.1997 When she visited the office she came to know that Smt. Maya Rani had lodged a complaint against the petitioner accusing her of having relationship with one R.C Chopra, SSI Ambala. Shri R.C Chopra was also present there. Smt. Maya Rani had initiated a complaint dated 4.6.1997 against the petitioner. After getting a copy of this letter a complaint under Section 500 IPC was filed against Smt. Maya Rani in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Panchkula. Maya Rani and others were summoned to face the trial in his Court. One day before the evidence was to be recorded in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate on the complaint filed by the petitioner under Section 500 IPC at about 10:00 P.M Shri R.C Chopra visited the house of the petitioner. At this time, a team consisting of ASI Onkar Singh, Head Constable Om Parkash and two persons with Video Movie Camera entered the house of the complainant in civil dress. They were followed by DSP Mrs. Rajshri Singh. During the investigation, Tehsildar along with SDM, Kalka, entered the house and directed the search of the house. The allegation in the complaint is that they threatened the petitioner/complainant to withdraw the complaint which was fixed for next day for evidence. It is alleged that the SDM had threatened the complainant and Shri R.C Chopra that if they do not withdraw the complaint they will not remain in service. The allegation in the complaint is that the SDM-accused No. 1 threatened the petitioner and Shri R.C Chopra to withdraw the case against Smt. Maya Rani. Vide order dated 30.7.2001 the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Panchkula, summoned accused No. 1 to 10 and 12 to face the trial under Sections 323, 354, 452, 458, 389, 500, 506 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC. The accused No. 1-SDM-cum-SDO (Civil), Kalka, filed an application for recalling the summoning order dated 30.7.2001 (Annexure P2). This application was dismissed on 4.7.2007 (Annexure P3) on the ground that the summoning order had been passed way back on 30.7.2001 and by holding that it would amount to recalling and reviewing the order which was not permissible. A revision was filed against this order before the Sessions Judge who vide detailed order dated 10.3.2008 (Annexure P4) accepted the revision petition and set aside the orders dated 30.7.2001 and 17.4.2007 stating that in view of the bar enjoined under Section 197 Cr.P.C the SDM could not be summoned to face the trial.

    Mr. Jai Veer Yadav, counsel for the petitioner, has referred to the earlier order dated 30.7.2001 (Annexure P2). After going through the entire facts mentioned in the complaint the Court had come to the conclusion that the acts of accused No. 1 to 6 did not fall in the scope and ambit of discharge of duty. There was no occasion to forcibly enter the complainant's house on the fateful night. The complainant was questioned about her relationship with Shri R.C Chopra. The complainant and Shri R.C Chopra were harassed by the police officials and accused No. 7 and 8 who had come with Video Movie Cameras further enhanced their harassment. Shri R.C Chopra was made to take off his clothes in front of other officials. The complainant was examined by a male doctor as per her statement Dr. S.K Gupta and Dr. Dewan. By no stretch of imagination this was done in the course of performance of official duties. He has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Choudhury Parveen Sultana v. State of West Bengal(2009) 3 Supreme Court Cases 398 to contend that when an authority vested in a public servant is misused by doing things which are not otherwise permitted under law, such acts cannot claim protection of Section 197 Cr.P.C At the time of summoning of an accused the Magistrate has not to scrutinize the evidence in detail.

    Counsel for the petitioner cites 1997 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 26 (Dev Raj Garg… v. State Of Punjab…) and 2004 (7) J.T 243 (Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal) to contend that summoning order is an interim order. The accused can be discharged by the Magistrate under Section 245 Cr.P.C after recording the evidence he comes to the conclusion that no case against the accused is made out. Finally he has argued by placing reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Raj Kishor Roy v. Kamleshwar Pandey 2002 (3) R.C.R (Criminal) 873 that the question of sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C can be raised any time after the cognizance, may be immediately after cognizance or framing of charge or even at the time of conclusion of trial and after conviction as well. Complaint cannot be quashed at the initial stage on the ground that no sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C was taken. The question of sanction should be left to be decided in the main judgment.

    Mr. Balram Gupta, Sr. Advocate, for the respondent, on the other hand, has vehemently argued that the respondent had received a complaint dated 19.6.1997 (Annexure R1) from Maya Rani in which it was alleged that false complaints have been made against her by Shri R.C Chopra and Smt. Urmila Devi. It was alleged that Smt. Urmila Devi was living in Quarter No. B-4 since 1978 with the person named R.C Chopra, who is not her husband. Shri R.C Chopra was married to one Savitri who has a son about 27 years of age. Without divorcing his wife, he is residing with Smt. Urmila Devi. A petition is pending against Shri R.C Chopra which has been filed by his wife (Smt. Savitri). Three employees of the dispensary where Smt. Urmila Devi is working have been made witnesses. Shri R.C Chopra and Smt. Urmila Devi have initiated civil suits against these employees. They have given statement to the police that they did not know each other and have no relationship of any type. On this complaint, the SDM marked an inquiry to the Tehsildar. The Tehsildar vide his report dated 30.8.1997 concluded that some facts in the complaint were correct that Shri R.C Chopra visited the house of Smt. Urmila Devi. The summons for Shri R.C Chopra were sent on the address of Smt. Urmila Devi. It was concluded that he lives with Smt. Urmila Devi or comes regularly to her house. Shri R.C Chopra has admitted his relationship with Smt. Urmila Devi. He admitted that a divorce petition is pending with his first wife in Court. Maya Rani is also a quarrelsome lady and it was recommended that both of them may be transferred to different places. After this report, a detailed investigation was marked to DSP Kalka to find out whether Shri R.C Chopra is staying with Smt. Urmila Devi and whether they are staying as husband and wife. In pursuance to this, an investigation was conducted on 26.6.1997 by the investigation team led by DSP Mrs. Rajshri Singh. During investigation, Shri R.C Chopra was found in the residence of Smt. Urmila Devi. They were medically examined. No case was registered against them and they were not arrested. The respondent acted only within the ambit of his official duties. He has placed reliance on the judgments of the Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v. Dr. Budhikota Subharao 1993 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 482, Abdul Wahab Ansari v. State of Bihar AIR 2000 Supreme Court 3187, State of Orissa through Kumar Raghvendra Singh v. Ganesh Chandra Jew 2004 (4) J.T 52, K. Kalimuthu v. State by D.S.P2005 (4) S.C.C 512 and Sankaran Moitra v. Sadhna Das 2006 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 389 to contend that Section 197 Cr.P.C should be liberally construed in favour of a public servant. Official duties implies that the act or omission must have been done by the public servant in course of his service and such act or omission must have been performed as part of duty which further must have been official in nature. Once the act committed comes in the four corners of official duty then it must be given a liberal and wide construction so far its official nature is concerned.

    Heard learned counsel for the parties.

    After going through the facts of the above case, one thing is clear that there was an on-going rift between Smt. Maya Devi and Smt. Urmila Devi. They are both quarrelsome in nature and have been instigating each other on a number of occasions. On a complaint made by Smt. Maya Devi, who is a widow, inquiry was conducted by Tehsildar who concluded that Smt. Urmila Devi was residing with Shri R.C Chopra without being legally wedded to him. To verify this fact the SDM had referred an inquiry to the DSP. In pursuance to this, a team had visited the house of Smt. Urmila Devi at 10:00 P.M led by DSP Mrs. Rajshri Singh, ASI Onkar Singh and HC Om Parkash to verify the contents of the complaint made by Maya Devi. Shri R.C Chopra was found residing with Smt. Urmila Devi. They were medically examined. No case was registered and they were not arrested. In a complaint by Maya Rani it was alleged that a divorce petition was pending between Shri R.C Chopra and his wife Savitri. Shri R.C Chopra and Smt. Urmila Devi had given false statements to the police in investigation that they did not know each other at all. The allegation that the SDM was present when the Investigation team visited the house is not being denied. After marking an inquiry, SDM was ceased of the complaint and his presence at best can be an act of omission towards his official duty. It cannot be said that his presence was not in the course of his service. The allegation in the complaint that he harassed the complainant Smt. Urmila Devi and Shri R.C Chopra when the investigating team was doing their work can at best be termed as act of omission while doing official duty. As per the Supreme Court judgment in K. Kalimuthu v. State by D.S.P2005 (4) S.C.C 512 it has to be given a liberal and wide construction once it is found that the public servant was discharging his duty. In this judgment, reference has been made to a judgment in Matajog Dobey v. H. C. Bhari AIR 1956 SC 44 wherein it has been observed as under:-

    “The offence alleged to have been committed (by the accused) must have something to do, or must be related in some manner with the discharge of official duty …. there must be a reasonable connection between the act and the discharge of official duty; the act must bear such relation to the duty that the accused could lay a reasonable (claim) but not a pretended or fanciful claim, that he did it in the course of the performance of his duty.”

    In the facts of the present case, seeing the nature of the complaint, this Court is of the view that there was an on-going rift between the two families who were residing in the same building and had been initiating complaints against each other. The petitioner/complainant had initiated a complaint under Section 500 IPC against Smt. Maya Devi in which the evidence was going on. Maya Devi had filed a complaint (Annexure P1) alleging that Shri R.C Chopra and Smt. Urmila Devi were residing without being legally wedded and were in the habit of quarreling. They had given false statement to the police during investigation that they did not know each other at all. It was only to put an end to the factual dispute that inquiry had been marked by the SDM to verify whether Shri R.C Chopra was staying with Smt. Urmila Devi and in what capacity. He was seized of the complaint. For all intents and purposes it comes within the official duty. He was present in discharge of his official duty.

    There is no infirmity in order dated 10.3.2008 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Panchkula (Annexure P4).

    The petition is dismissed with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Urmila Devi Petitioner v. Sh. Yudhvir Singh
    (Jul 20, 2011)