Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 11(1) of Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 read with Rule 27 of Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955
  • u/s 11(1) of CRPF Act, 1949
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 11(1) of Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 read with Rule 27 of Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955
  • u/s 11(1) of CRPF Act, 1949
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — Jasbir Singh, J. (9 January 2009)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent (petitioner) was employed in the Central Reserve Police Force and proceeded on leave in December 1994, with a scheduled return to duty on 14.1.1995. He remained absent without leave from 14.1.1995 until 10.6.1995. A warrant of arrest dated 9.2.1995 was issued against him but was later cancelled.

Departmental disciplinary proceedings under Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 read with Rule 27 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 were initiated on charges of neglect of duty/overstaying leave and disobedience. The respondent pleaded guilty before the enquiry officer, and after the enquiry report was supplied and an opportunity to file defence was given, the respondent reiterated his plea of guilt by application dated 16.9.1995. By order dated 7.10.1995 the respondent was dismissed from service; appellate and revisional remedies were unsuccessfully pursued.

The respondent filed Civil Writ Petition No. 2771 of 1997 in the High Court challenging the dismissal. A learned Single Judge, by judgment and order dated 15.11.2006, quashed the order of dismissal dated 7.10.1995 and the appellate/revisional orders dated 31.1.1996 and 26.8.1996; the Single Judge ordered reinstatement with full consequential benefits, including salary, increments and promotion, and directed implementation within three months.

The appellants appealed limited to the question of grant of back wages. On 25.4.2007 the High Court issued notice limited to back wages and condoned delay in filing/refiling the appeal. The appeal court heard submissions and considered whether full back wages for the period out of service were justified.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent is entitled to full back wages (including salary and increments) for the entire period he remained out of service following his dismissal, after being reinstated by the Single Judge.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The grant of full back wages was not justified because the respondent was responsible for overstaying leave and for disobeying orders of the competent authorities; departmental proceedings were instituted for these reasons.
  • The fact that, during the enquiry, the period of absence was ordered to be treated as extraordinary leave (without pay) does not absolve the respondent of the disobedience that led to dismissal.
  • The respondent could not claim wages for periods when he had not worked for the appellants; the writ petition did not plead that the respondent was not gainfully employed elsewhere during the dismissal period.
  • The appellants therefore prayed that the appeal be allowed and the order granting back wages be set aside.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Counsel for the respondent contended that the orders of dismissal, appeal and revision were the result of highhandedness by the appellants and that the Single Judge set aside the dismissal on merits rather than on technical grounds.
  • Relying on the fact that the absence period had been ordered to be treated as extraordinary leave (without pay) during the enquiry, counsel argued that reinstatement with full wages was appropriate.
  • Counsel opposed the modification of the Single Judge's award of full back wages.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.P. State Brassware Corpn. Ltd. & Anr. v. Uday Narain Pandey, (2006) 1 SCC 479 The principle that although payment of full back wages used to be the usual result on a declaration that termination was invalid, courts now take a pragmatic view: full back wages are not automatically awarded and depend on facts and circumstances; an employer should not be compelled to pay for unproductive periods. The High Court applied this principle to reject the automatic grant of full back wages and to justify a fact-sensitive reduction in the award to the respondent.
M.L. Binjolkar v. State of M.P., (2005) 6 SCC 224 Illustrates that on reinstatement courts may award partial back wages (the Supreme Court in that case upheld an award of 50% back wages where large-scale compulsorily retired employees were reinstated). The court relied on this precedent by analogy and concluded that 50% of salary and increments for the disputed period would be just in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded from the settled procedural posture: the Single Judge had reinstated the respondent and granted full consequential benefits including back wages; the appeal was limited to the question of back wages.

The court examined the factual matrix: the respondent overstayed leave for 148 days, a warrant of arrest was issued and later cancelled, a departmental enquiry was conducted under Section 11(1) CRPF Act 1949 read with Rule 27 CRPF Rules 1955 on charges of neglect of duty and disobedience, and the respondent pleaded guilty before the enquiry officer and again in an application to the punishing authority dated 16.9.1995. During the enquiry, the absence period had been ordered (by order dated 28.8.1995) to be treated as extraordinary leave (without pay).

On these facts, the court evaluated the parties' submissions. The appellants argued that the respondent's misconduct (overstaying leave and disobedience) made him partly responsible for his dismissal and that he should not receive full back wages for a period he had not worked for them. The respondent's counsel argued that the Single Judge had set aside the dismissal on merits and that the extraordinary leave order supported the grant of full back wages.

The court considered authoritative precedents that endorse a pragmatic, fact-specific approach to awarding back wages. Relying on U.P. State Brassware Corpn. Ltd. v. Uday Narain Pandey, the court noted the modern approach that full back wages are not an automatic consequence of reinstatement and depend upon whether the employee contributed during the period or whether payment would be unjust to the employer. The court also considered M.L. Binjolkar v. State of M.P., where the Supreme Court affirmed awarding 50% back wages in comparable circumstances.

The court emphasized several factual findings that weighed against awarding full back wages: (1) the respondent had pleaded guilty to the charges and had failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for the absence; (2) the order treating the absence as extraordinary leave did not, in the court's view, eliminate the element of disobedience; (3) the respondent did not plead in the writ petition that he was not gainfully employed during the dismissal period and, in fact, admitted during argument that he had been engaged in selling vegetables; and (4) the respondent remained an able-bodied person with a family and thus was likely to have taken up other work.

On balancing these factors and guided by precedent, the court concluded that awarding full back wages would be unjustified. The court therefore reduced the monetary relief to be granted on reinstatement, while leaving intact the directions regarding promotion.

Holding and Implications

Appeal disposed of with modification: the award of full back wages was reduced to 50% for salary and increments for the disputed period; directions regarding promotion were left undisturbed.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The respondent remains reinstated in service as ordered by the Single Judge, but entitlement to back wages and increments for the period he was out of service is limited to 50% instead of full payment.
  • The court expressly refrained from modifying the directions related to promotion given by the Single Judge.
  • No costs were awarded.
  • The opinion applies established precedent to a fact-specific denial of full back wages; it does not purport to lay down a new general rule—rather it follows the settled principle that grant of full back wages is discretionary and depends on facts and circumstances.

Judge: Jasbir Singh, J. — Order dated 9.01.2009 (T.S. Thakur, Chief Justice recorded)

    The Union Of India And Others v. Balram

    Jasbir Singh, J.

    A learned Single Judge of this Court has by his judgment and order dated 15.11.2006 quashed order dated 7.10.1995 (P-3), vide which, respondent (petitioner) was dismissed from service. Appellate and revisional orders dated 31.1.1996 and 26.8.1996, dismissing the appeal and revision respectively of the respondent were also set aside. It was further ordered that the respondent be reinstated in service with full consequential benefits, including salary, increment, promotion etc. Directions were also issued to do the needful within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of the order by the authorities, referred to above.

    On 25.4.2007, in this appeal following order was passed:-

    “Limited to the question of grant of back wages, notice of motion be issued to the respondent, returnable on 2.8.2007

    Notices of the applications for condonation of delay in filing and refiling the appeal be also issued to the respondents for that date.”

    After hearing counsel for the parties, we propose to condone delay in filing and refiling of this appeal.

    Now, it is to be seen whether respondent (petitioner) is entitled to get full back wages for the period, he remained out of service or not?

    It is apparent from the records that the respondent proceeded on leave in the month of December 1994. He was to return back on duty on 14.1.1995 Without any leave, he remained absent till 10.6.1995 In the meantime, warrant of arrest was also issued against him on 9.2.1995, which was later on got cancelled. For the above misconduct, departmental enquiry, under Section 11(1) of Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 read with Rule 27 of Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 was instituted against the respondent (petitioner) on the following article of charges:-

    “Article-I

    That the said No. 89032001 S/K Bal Ram while functioning as a member of the Force, committed an act of neglect of duty/misconduct in his capacity as a member of the Force, u/s 11(1) of CRPF Act, 1949 in that

    he overstayed leave from 14.1.95 to 10.5.95 without sanction of leave/permission of the competent authority.

    Article-II

    That, the said No. 890320031 S/K Balram, while posted in 32 Bn. CRPF, Srinagar committed an act of ‘Disobedience’ in his capacity as a member of the force u/s 11(1) of CRPF Act 1949 in that he remained OSL for 148 days from 14.1.95 to 10.6.95 without proper permission ignoring the directions issued vide letter No. 1.II-10/95-32-EC-II dated 21.1.95 and 10.2.95 to join duties immediately. He had reported for duties only after issue of a Warrant of Arrest against him on 9.2.95 which was later on got cancelled.”

    It is an admitted fact that before the enquiry officer, the respondent pleaded guilty, with regard to charges framed against him. On receipt of enquiry report, the competent authority supplied a copy of the enquiry report to the respondent and he was also provided an opportunity to submit his defence, if any, with regard to findings given against him by the enquiry officer. The respondent by moving an application dated 16.9.1995 again pleaded guilty and failed to bring any new facts to the notice of the punishing authority. Thereafter, order dismissing him from service, was passed on 7.10.1995 Respondent (petitioner) failed in appeal and revision.

    Respondent (petitioner) filed Civil Writ Petition No. 2771 of 1997 in this Court primarily on the ground that before passing the order of dismissal, during pendency of departmental enquiry, vide order dated 28.8.1995, absence period in question was ordered to be treated as extra ordinary leave (without pay). Record reveals that by taking note of the same, the learned Single Bench set aside the order of dismissal and also consequential orders passed in appeal and revision. Reinstatement was ordered with all consequential benefits, including payment of salary for the period respondent remained out of service.

    So far as reinstatement is concerned, it has become final. As noticed earlier, notice of motion in this petition was issued, limited to the question of grant of back wages only.

    Counsel for the appellants vehemently contended that grant of full back wages, for the period respondent remained out of service, was not justified. It was the respondent (petitioner), who was responsible for overstaying his period of leave. On account of his disobedience shown to the orders passed by the competent authorities, departmental enquiry was instituted against him. Merely because in the meantime, period of absence was ordered to be treated as extra ordinary leave (without pay), it does not absolve the petitioner of disobedience shown by him to the orders passed by the authorities. He further submitted that for the period, the respondent (petitioner) has not worked with the appellants, he was not entitled to get wages for the same. It was also brought to our notice that in the writ petition, it has no where been stated that after his dismissal, the respondent (petitioner) was not gainfully employed any where. Counsel for the appellants prayed that the appeal be allowed and order granting back wages to the respondent (petitioner) be set aside.

    Prayer made has vehemently been opposed by Ms. Shashi Ghuman, Advocate appearing for the respondent (petitioner). By making reference to the order, dismissing the respondent (petitioner), dismissing his appeal and revision, she argued that the orders passed were the result of highhandedness on the part of the appellants. Despite noticing that absence period has been ordered to be treated as extra ordinary leave (without pay), the appellate authority failed to intervene and set aside order passed by the punishing authority, dismissing the respondent (petitioner) from service. She further argued that as the authorities were negligent in passing the order of dismissal, the same has been set aside on merits and not on any technical ground, as such, on reinstatement, full wages have rightly been allowed in favour of the respondent (petitioner).

    After hearing counsel for the parties and on perusing the record, we are of the opinion that grant of full back wages in favour of the respondent (petitioner), by the learned Single Bench, was not justified.

    In U.P State Brassware Corpon. Ltd. And another v. Uday Narain Pandey, (2006) 1 Supreme Court Cases 479, their Lordships of the Supreme Court, dealing with a similar situation, have observed as under:-

    17. Before adverting to the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the parties, we may observe that although direction to pay full back wages on a declaration that the order of termination was invalid used to be the usual result but now, with the passage of time, a pragmatic view of the matter is being taken by the court realizing that an industry may not be compelled to pay to the workman for the period during which he apparently contributed little or nothing at all to it and/or for a period that was spent unproductively as a result whereof the employer would be compelled to go back to a situation which prevailed many years ago, namely, when the workman was retrenched.

    It was further opined ‘that no precise formula can be laid down as to under what circumstances payment of entire back wages should be allowed. Indisputably, it depends upon the facts and circumstances of each case and grant of full back wages is not automatic.’

    Similarly, in M.L Binjolkar v. State Of M.P., (2005) 6 Supreme Court Cases 224, taking note of the facts of that case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, on reinstatement, granted back wages only to the extent of 50%. In the above said case, 559 employees were compulsorily retired by the State of Madhya Pradesh. Order passed against them, was set aside by the Tribunal and they were held entitled to get full back wages for the period they remained out of service. Matter went before the High Court and it was ordered that 50% of the back wages and other allowances shall be paid to the above said employees. Order was affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the judgment, referred to above.

    It is apparent from the records that before the authorities concerned, respondent (petitioner), has failed to give any satisfactory explanation for the period of his absence i.e 148 days. Departmental proceedings were initiated against him on two counts firstly; for remaining absent for the period, referred to above and secondly, showing disobedience, in not joining service, in response to the order passed by the competent authority. During pendency of departmental enquiry, absence period was ordered to be treated as extra ordinary leave (without pay). We feel that above said fact was not sufficient to wash away the element of disobedience shown by the respondent to the order passed by the higher authority. Before the enquiry officer and also before the punishing authority, respondent (petitioner) pleaded guilty to the charges issued against him. We feel that for getting order of dismissal, passed against him, the respondent (petitioner) was also responsible to some extent.

    Contention of learned counsel for the appellants that in writ petition filed by the respondent (petitioner), he has failed to state that during period of his dismissal, he was not gainfully employed any where, appears to be correct. Before the learned Single Bench also, no such plea was raised at the time of arguments. In view of above fact, on this aspect, virtually no finding was given by the learned Single Bench.

    It is not in dispute that the respondent (petitioner) is able-bodied person. He has a family. It is therefore evident that he could not afford to sit idle at home for a long period of about 13 years.

    At the time of arguments, counsel for the respondent, on our query, hesitantly admitted that during the period, in dispute, respondent (petitioner), was engaged in the business of selling vegetables.

    In view of facts mentioned above, we feel that grant of full back wages to the respondent (petitioner), for the period he remained out of service, was not justified. We are of the opinion that ends of justice would be met in case respondent (petitioner) is held entitled to get salary and amount of increment(s) due, to the extent of 50% for the period, in dispute. We are not interfering so far as the directions issued with regard to promotion are concerned.

    With above mentioned modifications, this appeal stands disposed of. No costs.

    (JASBIR SINGH) JUDGE

    9.01.2009 (T.S THAKUR)

    gk CHIEF JUSTICE

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Union Of India And Others v. Balram
    (Jan 9, 2009)