ASHUTOSH MOHUNTA, J.(ORAL)
This writ petition is directed against the order dated 07-11-2001 passed in OA No. 633.HR/1996 by the Central Administrative Tribunal Chandigarh (Annexure P-1), vide which, the petitioner has not been empanelled to the higher post as he has not obtained the minimum qualifying marks.
Brief facts of this case are that the petitioner is working as a Head Clerk in the Establishment Bill Section, Office of the Chief Works Manager, Jagadhri Workshop, Jagadhri. The next promotion from the post of Head Clerk is to the post of Office Supdt. Grade-II (Establishment) in the pay scale of Rs. 1600-2660. For this promotion, a written test for selection to the post of Supdt. Grade-II was conducted on 07-04-1995, in which, the petitioner was found eligible and he was called for viva-voce test which was conducted on 02-06-1995. The grouse of the petitioner is that two persons, junior to him i.e Narinder Nath Sehgal and Rachhpal Singh, whose names appear at Sr. Nos. 6 and 11, in the list of candidates, have been selected, whereas, the petitioner, who was senior to them, has been ignored. It has been alleged by the petitioner that favouritism has been shown for Narinder Nath Sehgal and Rachhpal Singh. These persons do not have clean service record, whereas, there is nothing adverse against the petitioner. It has also been averred by the petitioner that the question paper did not have 50% objective type questions and that as per the letter issued by the Railway Authorities, the written paper was required to contain 50% Objective Type Questions and the remaining questions could be of narrative type, whereas, in the instant case, the paper did not contain 50% objective type questions.
A perusal of the impugned order passed by the Tribunal, which had examined the record, shows that the paper contained 50% objective type questions and, hence, this argument of the petitioner does not carry any weight. As far as the claim of the petitioner that he was senior to Narinder Nath Sehgal and Rachhpal Singh and that they were shown favouritism, has also been found to be incorrect by the Tribunal. The petitioner has not secured the minimum pass marks for being promoted to the post of Superintendent Grade-II. A candidate should have secured 60% marks in the professional ability and 60% marks in the aggregate which the petitioner did not secure and, whereas, both Narinder Nath Sehgal and Rachhpal Singh had secured the requisite 60% marks. The petitioner who has failed to secure minimum qualifying marks, as mentioned above, has rightly been ignored for promotion.
Apart from the above, there were other candidates also who were junior to Narinder Nath Sehgal and Rachhpal Singh but as they secured the requisite marks, i.e 60% in the aggregate as well as 60% in the professional ability, they have been selected. The petitioner has also challenged the selection process by challenging the rules requiring 60% for the professional ability.
The Apex Court in Dhananjay Malik and others v. State of Uttaranchal and others reported in 2008(2)SCT 659 has held that the petitioners who have participated in the selection process without any demur are estopped from complaining and are precluded from questioning the selection process. To the same effect is the judgment of Om Parkash Shukla v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla and others reported in 1986 S.C 1043 and Marripati Nagaraja and others v. Government of Andhra Pradesh and others reported in 2008(1)SCT 26.
In view of the above, we find no merit in the writ petition and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(ASHUTOSH MOHUNTA) JUDGE
(NIRMALJIT KAUR) JUDGE
January 07, 2009 gurpreet