Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Judicial Opinion (Sham Sunder, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 7.12.1988 Chander Wali (deceased), his wife Sudama Devi and Munshi Ram were waiting near the New Corner Hotel, Patiala, to board a bus bearing No. PUV-2423. The conductor announced the destination and Chander Wali boarded the bus; his wife could not. The deceased requested the driver to stop the bus to allow his wife to board; the bus was slowed. While Chander Wali was alighting, the driver (Kewal Ram) allegedly accelerated without ensuring that Chander Wali had got down. As a result, Chander Wali fell and the rear wheel of the bus ran over him. He sustained injuries and died on the way to the hospital.

At the time of death Chander Wali was about 25 years old. The claim petition averred he worked as a labourer and ran a tea stall with a monthly income stated in the petition as Rs. 2,100/-. The petition under the Motor Vehicles Act sought compensation of Rs. 5,00,000/-. Sudama Devi (wife) and five children (two sons and three daughters; some minors) were pleaded as dependent on the deceased.

The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Patiala framed issues and after evidence awarded compensation dated 8.3.1990: the Tribunal found driver was rash/negligent, assessed the deceased's monthly income at Rs. 700/- with monthly dependency of Rs. 400/-, applied multiplier 16 and awarded Rs. 76,800/- with interest at 12% per annum.

Two appeals arose from that award: (1) FAO No. 673 of 1990 by the claimants-appellants seeking enhancement of compensation; and (2) FAO No. 723 of 1990 by the Pepsu Road Transport Corporation (owner of the bus) seeking dismissal of the claim petition. The judgment under summary disposes both appeals: FAO No. 673 was partly accepted and compensation enhanced; FAO No. 723 was dismissed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Chander Wali died due to rash and negligent driving of bus No. PUV-2423 by its driver Kewal Ram? (Issue No. 1 as framed by the Tribunal)
  2. To what amount of compensation the claimants are entitled and from whom? (Issue No. 2 as framed by the Tribunal)
  3. Relief (general) as framed by the Tribunal (Issue No. 3)
  4. Appellate questions: (a) Whether the Tribunal's finding of negligence by the driver should be set aside (Pepsu Road Transport Corporation's appeal seeking dismissal of the claim); and (b) Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal should be enhanced (claimants' appeal).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents 1–3 (written statement)

  • Challenged maintainability of the petition alleging not all legal heirs of Chander Wali had been impleaded.
  • Admitted the accident but denied rash or negligent driving by the driver.
  • Asserted that Chander Wali tried to board a slow-moving bus but could not and fell due to his own negligence.
  • Denied other averments in the petition as wrong.

Pepsu Road Transport Corporation (FAO No. 723) — Appellant's Arguments

  • Contended that the Tribunal was wrong in concluding the driver of the bus was negligent; argued the bus was full and at slow speed and that Chander Wali fell while attempting to board and thus the accident was the deceased's own fault.

Claimants-Appellants (FAO No. 673) — Appellants' Arguments

  • Contended that the Tribunal awarded a meager amount and erred in assessing the deceased's monthly income at Rs. 700/-; asserted deceased's income was about Rs. 2,000/- per month.
  • Argued that the appropriate multiplier was 25 given the deceased's age of about 25 years.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed evidence and proceeded on two principal questions: liability (negligence) and quantum of compensation.

Liability/Negligence:

  • The court found Sudama Devi's (AW-1) testimony credible: she was present at the time of the accident, described the conductor announcing the destination, that her husband boarded via the front door, requested the driver to slow/stop so she could board, and that the driver later suddenly increased speed causing her husband to fall and be run over. Her cross-examination did not successfully challenge these points.
  • The court noted corroboration of her testimony by Exhibit A-1 (a copy of the FIR).
  • The defendant-side witnesses (conductor Sat Pal, RW-1, and driver Kewal Ram, RW-2) were disbelieved. The court observed that a criminal case under Section 304-A IPC had been registered against the driver and he had been arrested at the spot; the driver and conductor did not make contemporaneous statements to police exonerating the driver nor press higher authorities to claim false implication. The court treated their silence and lack of steps to clear themselves as supporting the finding of negligence.
  • On the basis of witness testimony and corroboration, the court affirmed the Tribunal's finding that the accident resulted from rash/negligent driving by the bus driver.

Quantum of Compensation:

  • The court examined the oral evidence on income. Sudama Devi (AW-1) did not give income details. Karnail Singh (AW-2) stated the deceased worked for him as a labourer at Rs. 30 per day. Shish Kumar (AW-3) stated the deceased earned Rs. 40–50 daily selling tea on a hand cart, but no documentary proof supported the hand-cart business.
  • The court accepted AW-2's evidence that the deceased earned Rs. 30 per day and concluded a labourer in 1988 could fetch Rs. 30/day; this yields a monthly income of Rs. 900/-, higher than the Tribunal's finding of Rs. 700/- and lower than the claimants' asserted Rs. 2,000/-. The court thus fixed monthly income at Rs. 900/-.
  • Considering the deceased's family obligations (wife and four minor children), the court allowed Rs. 225/- per month as the deceased's personal expenses and therefore fixed monthly dependency for the claimants at Rs. 675/- (rounded figure).
  • The court applied the same multiplier as the Tribunal (16) rather than the 25 urged by appellants, given the factual matrix (age about 25 years and composition of family) and computed compensation as: Rs. 675 × 12 × 16 = Rs. 1,29,600, plus Rs. 2,000 as funeral expenses, producing a total of Rs. 1,31,600/-. (The court used the figures and arithmetic set out in the judgment to arrive at Rs. 1,31,600/-.)
  • The court considered the interest awarded by the Tribunal at 12% per annum to be excessive and reduced the rate to 9% per annum, to run from the date of filing the application until realization.

Miscellaneous/Administrative Directions:

  • The court ordered that the enhanced amount be paid to the appellants-claimants in equal shares.
  • The shares of minors (Durga Devi, Laxmi Devi, Rajiv Kumar and Ranjit Kumar) were to be deposited in fixed deposit receipts (FDRs) in their names until they attain majority, if they had not already attained majority.
  • Respondents No. 1 to 3 were held jointly and severally liable to pay the enhanced compensation.
  • Any amount already received by the claimants under the no-fault liability clause was to be adjusted against the compensation awarded by the court.

Holding and Implications

FAO No. 673 of 1990 — PARTLY ACCEPTED.

The court enhanced the compensation awarded by the Tribunal from Rs. 76,800/- to Rs. 1,31,600/-. Interest was reduced from 12% to 9% per annum from the date of filing of the application until realization. The enhanced amount is to be distributed equally among the appellants-claimants; minors' shares to be kept in FDRs until majority. Respondents No. 1 to 3 are jointly and severally liable to pay the enhanced amount. Any no-fault liability payments already received shall be adjusted against this award.

FAO No. 723 of 1990 — DISMISSED.

The appeal by the Pepsu Road Transport Corporation challenging the Tribunal's finding of negligence was dismissed. The Tribunal's finding of negligence was affirmed by the court.

Consequences: The direct effects are enhancement of monetary relief to the claimants, modification of the interest rate, and administrative directions for secure retention of minors' shares. The opinion does not discuss or establish any broader legal precedent beyond the adjudication of the present facts and claims.

    Sudama Devi And Others v. Kewal Ram And Others

    Sham Sunder, J.:— This judgment shall dispose of the afore-stated two appeals, the first filed by the claimants-appellants for the enhancement of compensation, and the second filed by the Pepsu Road Transport Corporation, the owner of the bus, for dismissal of the claim petition, arising out of one and the same award dated 8.3.1990, rendered by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Patiala, relating to the same accident.

    2. On 7.12.1988, Chander Wali deceased, his wife Sudama Devi and Munshi Ram her brother had come to see off his (Chander Wali's) sister and her husband, and were waiting for a bus, near the New Corner Hotel, Patiala. A bus bearing No. PUV-2423, reached there, and the conductor of the bus was repeating time and again that the same was going to Nabha and at this Chander Wali, deceased stepped into the bus from its front side window, but Sudama Devi, however, could not board the same. Since Sudama Devi could not board the bus, he requested the conductor to stop the same, as a result whereof, it was stopped for a while, in between the railway gate No. 18 and the crossing near Corner Hotel, Patiala. At that time, Chander Wali tried to get down from the bus, but Kewal Ram, driver of the same, started it at once without ensuring that he had actually got down therefrom. On account of the rash or negligent act of the driver of the bus Chander Wali fell down from the bus and sustained injuries. When he was being taken to the hospital, he died on the way.

    3. At the time of accident and death of Chander Wali, he was aged about 25 years. He was a labourer, and also running a tea stall. His monthly income was Rs. 2100/-. Sudama Devi, widow, Durga Devi and Laxmi Devi, minor daughters, Rajiv Kumar and Ranjit Kumar, minor sons of Chander Wali were completely dependent upon him, for their livelihood. Accordingly, a petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, claiming compensation, in the sum of Rs. 5 lacs was filed.

    4. Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 put in appearance, and filed written statement, wherein they took up various objections and contested the petition. It was pleaded that was not maintainable, as all the legal heirs of Chander Wali, had not been impleaded, as a party. The accident was admitted, but it was denied that the driver of the bus was rash or negligent in driving the same. On the other hand, it was stated that Chander Wali, deceased tried to board the bus which was at a slow speed due to rush on the road, but he could not board the same as a result whereof he fell down and received injuries. It was further stated that Chander Wali was himself negligent, as a result whereof, the accident took place. The remaining averments, were denied, being wrong.

    5. Respondents No. 4 and 5 were duly served but were not present. They were proceeded against ex-parte by the Tribunal.

    6. In the replication filed by the appellants, they re-asserted all the averments, contained in the petition, and repudiated, those contained in the written statement.

    7. On the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were struck by the Tribunal:—

    “1. Whether Chander Wali died due to rash and negligent driving of bus No. PUV-2423 by its driver Kewal Ram? OPP

    2. To what amount of compensation the claimants are entitled and from whom? OPP

    3. Relief.?

    8. The parties led evidence. After hearing the learned Counsel for the parties, and, on going through the evidence, on record, the Tribunal came to the conclusion, that the driver of the bus, was rash or negligent in driving the same, as a result whereof, the accident took place, leading to the death of Chander Wali, deceased. The Tribunal further held that the monthly income of the deceased was Rs. 700/- and the dependency of the claimants-appellants was to the tune of Rs. 400/- per month. Accordingly, by applying multiplier of 16, the Tribunal awarded compensation, in the sum of Rs. 76,800/- with interest at the rate of 12% per annum.

    9. Feeling aggrieved, against the award dated 8.3.1990 rendered by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Patiala, two appeals, referred to hereinbefore, were filed.

    10. I have heard the learned Counsel for the parties, and have gone through the record of the case, carefully.

    11. The learned Counsel for the appellants in FAO No. 723 of 1990 (Pepsu Road Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Sudama Devi) contended that the Tribunal was wrong, in coming to the conclusion, that the driver of the bus was negligent in driving the same, as a result whereof, the accident took place, resulting into the death of Chander Wali. He further contended that the bus was full of passengers, and was at a slow speed, when Chander Wali tried to board the same. He was unsuccessful in his attempt, as a result whereof, he fell down, resulting into injuries on his person, and leading to his death. The submission of the learned Counsel for the appellant, in this appeal, does not appear to be correct. Sudama Devi, AW-1 was present with Chander Wali at the relevant time. She in clear-cut terms stated that the bus came and the conductor was crying that it was going to Nabha. Her husband boarded the bus, from the front door. She further stated that Chander Wali requested the driver to stop the bus as his wife remained on the road, as a result whereof, he slowed down the bus. When Chander Wali was coming out of the bus, which was being driven, at a slow speed, the driver all of a sudden, increased the speed thereof, resulting into fall of her husband. She further stated that the rear wheel of the bus, ran over her husband as a result whereof, when he was being taken to Rajindra Hospital, Patiala he died on the way. Her statement during the course of cross-examination could not be successfully challenged. No doubt, she did not state the number of the bus, as also the name of the driver thereof. However, the appellant-respondent in this appeal along with respondents No. 1 and 2 in appeal No. 673 of 1990, in their joint written statement, admitted the accident but only denied the rash or negligent act, on the part of the driver. The statement of Sudama Devi (AW-1) is also corroborated by Ex. A-1, copy of the FIR. When the bus slowed down and Chander Wali was allowed to come out of the same, it was the duty of the driver of the same to ensure that he had already got down, from the same only after ensuring that Chander Wali had got down, from the bus, the driver could speed up the same. In the instant case, the driver of the bus, did not do so and without ensuring as to whether Chander Wali had already got down, from the same, which was at a very slow speed, suddenly increased the speed thereof. It, therefore, could be said that he was extremely negligent, in driving the bus, as a result whereof, the accident took place, leading to the death of Chander Wali. There was no reason on the part of Sudama Devi, widow of the deceased, to depose falsely. Her presence at the time of the accident stood proved. The Tribunal was, thus, right in holding that the accident took place on account of the rash or negligent act of the driver of the bus, in question, resulting into injuries on the person of Chander Wali, and leading to his death. The submission of the learned Counsel for the appellant-respondent in this appeal, being without merit, must fail, and the same stands rejected.

    12. It was next contended by the learned Counsel for the appellant, in this appeal, that from the evidence of Sat Pal, RW-1, who was the conductor of the bus, at the relevant time, it was proved that the driver thereof was neither rash nor negligent. He stated, in his statement, that the bus was at a slow speed. During the cross-examination, it was admitted by him, that a criminal case under Section 304-A IPC was registered against the driver of the bus and he was facing trial therein. Even Kewal Ram, RW-2, driver of the bus, himself admitted that he was arrested at the spot. In case, Kewal Ram was not negligent, in driving the bus, at the time of accident, resulting into the death of Chander Wali, he could make a statement before the police officials, in that regard. In case, the police officials of the concerned Police Station, were not ready to hear him, then he could certainly approach the higher police authorities, that he had been falsely implicated, in a criminal case, and the accident did not take place, on account of his rash or negligent act. He could also move an application, before his higher officers that he was not at fault, but the accident took place, on account of the negligent act of Chander Wali. He, however, did not do so, and kept mum. His mere silence, for a long time, in itself is sufficient to prove that he was negligent, in driving the bus, at the relevant time, as a result whereof, the accident took place, leading to the death of Chander Wali. The statement of Sat Pal, RW-1 and Kewal Ram, RW-2, were rightly disbelieved by the Tribunal. The contention of the learned Counsel for the appellant, being without merit, must fail, and the same stands rejected. The findings of the Tribunal, on issue No. 1 being correct, are affirmed.

    13. In FAO No. 673 of 1990, the Counsel for the appellants-claimants, contended that the Tribunal was wrong in awarding, a meager compensation. He further contended that the income of Chander Wali, at the time of his death, was about Rs. 2,000/- per month. He further contended that the Tribunal was thus, wrong in coming to the conclusion that the monthly income of Chander Wali was Rs. 700/-. He further contended that the multiplier, in this case, was required to be applied as 25, as the age of the deceased at the time of the accident was 25 years. The contention of the learned Counsel for the appellants is partly correct. Sudama Devi, widow of the deceased, when appeared as, AW-1, did not state about the income of the deceased. Karnail Singh, AW-2, stated that Chander Wali was working with him, as a labourer, and was getting Rs. 30/- per day. Shish Kumar, AW-3, no doubt, stated that Chander Wali was earning Rs. 40-50/- daily by selling tea on a hand cart. However, no document was produced, on record, to show that Chander Wali was selling tea on a hand cart. On the other hand, it was proved from the statement of Karnail Singh, AW-2, that he was a labourer and earning Rs. 30/- per day. In the year 1988, a labourer could certainly fetch at Rs. 30/- per day as his wage. The income of Chander Wali, at the time of his death could, therefore, be said to be Rs. 900/- per month, and not Rs. 700/- per month, as held by the Tribunal. He was aged about 25 years, as is proved from the evidence on record. At the time of his death, he was having four minor children and wife. Since Chander Wali was to support a large family he must be spending minimum amount for his maintenance. In my opinion, he was keeping Rs. 225/- per month for his personal maintenance thereby leaving a sum of Rs. 675/- per month (round figure) for the maintenance of the appellants-claimants. The appellants-claimants, thus, were entitled to compensation in the sum of Rs. 1,31,600/- (Rs. 675/- × 12 × 16 + 2000/- as funeral expenses). The interest awarded by the Tribunal was on the higher side. It is thus reduced to 9% per annum. The amount of compensation is thus, required to be enhanced to the extent indicated above. The findings of the Tribunal on issue No. 2, are modified, as indicated above.

    14. For the reasons recorded herein before, FAO No. 673 of 1990 is partly accepted, with no order as to costs, and the amount of compensation is enhanced to Rs. 1,31,600/- from Rs. 76,800/-, awarded by the Tribunal. All the appellants-claimants shall be entitled to receive the compensation in equal share. They shall also be entitled to interest at the rate of 9% per annum instead of 12% per annum for the date of filing the application, till the realization of the amount of compensation. The shares of the appellants-claimants, Durga Devi, Laxmi Devi, Rajiv Kumar and Ranjit Kumar, who were minors at the time of filing the claim petition, shall be deposited in FDRs, in their names, if they have not already attained majority, and they shall be entitled to receive the same, on attaining majority. Respondents No. 1 to 3 are held jointly and severally liable, to pay the amount of enhanced compensation. Any amount received by the appellants/claimants under the no fault liability clause shall stand adjusted against the amount of compensation.

    15. FAO No. 723 of 1990 titled as Pepsu Road Transport Corporation v. Sudama Devi, is dismissed with no order as to costs.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sudama Devi And Others v. Kewal Ram And Others
    (Nov 28, 2007)