Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions (Crl. Misc. Nos. 14294-M, 14292-M and 14289-M of 1996) were heard together because they involve the same question of law and fact. The principal petition (Crl. Misc. 14294-M of 1996) was filed by T.P. Singh Kalra, Director of M/s Orion Auto and Steel Pvt. Ltd., seeking quashing of a complaint (Annexure P2) under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and the Magistrate's order (Annexure P1) declining to discharge him.

The complainant is M/s Star Wire India Limited, a public limited company, which alleged that it supplied iron and steel products to the accused's company and raised bills (Nos. 33 and 34 dated 22.4.89 and 24.4.89). In lieu of those bills the accused issued cheque No. 013343 dated 14.6.89 drawn on Central Bank of India for Rs. 2,19,135.70 in favour of the complainant; that cheque was deposited and returned dishonoured with the remark "Exceeds arrangement" (insufficient funds). Notice was sent on 9.8.89 as required by Section 138-B, but the accused did not make payment within the statutory period.

The Judicial Magistrate First Class, Faridabad recorded preliminary evidence and on 15.3.1990 found sufficient grounds to proceed under Section 138. A Single Judge earlier quashed proceedings against co-accused Harbhajan Singh Kalra by order dated 6.9.1991 (Crl. Misc. 3703-M of 1990). T.P. Singh Kalra applied to be discharged before the Magistrate on grounds including non-service of notice upon him personally, premature filing of the complaint, non-impleadment of the company, absence of allegations that he was in charge of the company's business, and that the complaint disclosed only civil liability; the Magistrate declined to discharge him.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is liable to be quashed as to T.P. Singh Kalra because no notice was served upon him personally as required by the Act (the notice was served on the company only).
  2. Whether the complaint is premature for being filed before the expiry of the statutory 15-day notice period (i.e., whether the complaint was filed within the statutory notice period and therefore defective).
  3. Whether the complaint against the director (T.P. Singh Kalra) is competent in the absence of impleading the company (M/s Orion Auto & Steel Pvt. Ltd.).
  4. Whether the absence in the complaint of an allegation that the director was "in charge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of the business" (as required by Section 141) requires quashing of the complaint as to the director.
  5. Whether, on the face of the complaint and the record, no conviction would be possible and thus the complaint should be quashed as being only a civil dispute.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (T.P. Singh Kalra) Arguments

  • No notice as required under Section 138/Section 138-B was served on him personally; service on the company (or on another private company) is not a substitute for personal notice to the director.
  • The complaint was premature because notice addressed to M/s Orion Auto & Steel Industries was received on 14.8.89 and complaint was filed on 29.8.89 (allegedly before expiry of the statutory period).
  • The company which allegedly received the notice was not impleaded as a party; impleadment was necessary.
  • The complaint failed to allege that he was "in charge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company" as required by Section 141, and therefore no criminal offence is disclosed against him.
  • The allegations at best disclose civil liability arising from a contract for supply and payment; a criminal complaint should be quashed where conviction would be impossible.
  • A prior High Court order quashing proceedings as to co-accused Harbhajan Singh Kalra (on the ground that notice had been served on the company without naming persons) provided parity and required the same result for him.
  • Delay (seven years since complaint filing) had caused hardship to the petitioner.

Respondent's (Complainant / Counsels for the complaint) Arguments

  • The cheque was signed by T.P. Singh Kalra as Director; the complaint specifically alleged that the cheque was signed by the accused being a director of the company (para 2 of the complaint).
  • Section 141 contemplates that when a company commits an offence, every person who at the time of the offence was in charge and responsible for the conduct of the business shall be deemed guilty "as well as the company" — the words indicate that directors may be proceeded against independently without impleading the company.
  • Reference was made to Sawant v. K.G & Traders (1995 Banking Cases 346) as supportive authority for the proposition that there was no need to implead the company in order to proceed against the directors.
  • Whether the notice was adequate, or whether it was served in the manner required by law, and whether allegations as to who was in charge and responsible are present are matters of evidence to be decided at trial rather than on a quashing petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Amrit Rani v. Surinder Kumar Sachdeva, 1992 (2) RCR 16 Where there is no allegation that an accused was in charge of the business and responsible for its conduct, no criminal offence may be made out against that accused under provisions dealing with company liability. The court distinguished Amrit Rani on facts: in that case the accused did not sign the cheque and there was no allegation of being in charge; in the present case the cheque was signed by T.P. Singh Kalra, so Amrit Rani's reasoning did not control the outcome.
Sushil Singla v. Haripal Singh, 1994 (1) RCR 621 Where cheques are issued by a company's managing director and there are no averments that other directors were in charge or responsible, the complaint as to those other directors may be quashed. The court noted the rule but observed that Section 141's language ("as well as the company") permits complaint to proceed against directors independently without impleading the company; this supported the view that impleadment of the company was not indispensable in every situation.
Sawant v. K.G. & Traders, 1995 (Banking Cases) 346 Cited in support of the proposition that a complaint may proceed against directors independently and that impleadment of the company may not be necessary in order to prosecute directors. The court relied on the respondent's citation of this case as sustaining the position that directors could be proceeded against without impleading the company.
Smt. Sharda Aggarwal v. Addl. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate-II, Kanpur, 1992 (3) RCR 499 Where a cheque is issued by the managing director of a private limited company, a complaint may not be competent against other directors unless it is stated that they were in charge of and responsible for the company's business at the relevant time. The court acknowledged the authority cited by the petitioner but treated the question of who was in charge and whether requisite averments existed as matters of evidence to be determined at trial, not by quashing at this stage.
Crl. Misc. 3703-M of 1990 (order dated 6.9.1991) — quashing qua Harbhajan Singh Kalra High Court quashed proceedings against Harbhajan Singh Kalra on the ground that notice had been served upon the company without naming persons liable for issuing cheques. The petitioner's attempt to claim parity with that earlier order was considered; the court found factual distinctions (notably that the cheque in the present case was signed by T.P. Singh Kalra) and treated the adequacy of notice and related matters as evidentiary questions for trial rather than grounds for quashing at this stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by addressing the petitioner's specific grounds against the backdrop of statutory text and the authorities cited.

  1. Statutory context: the court reproduced Section 141 which makes every person who, at the time an offence by a company under Section 138 was committed, was "in charge of and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business," liable along with the company. The court treated the language "as well as the company" as significant.
  2. Distinguishing precedents: the court distinguished Amrit Rani because that case involved a person who had not signed the cheque and where there was no allegation of being in charge; by contrast, in the present case the cheque was signed by T.P. Singh Kalra as director. Thus Amrit Rani's rationale did not mandate quashing here.
  3. Treatment of Sushil Singla and similar authorities: while recognizing that earlier decisions have quashed complaints against directors where there were no averments of being in charge (Sushil Singla; Smt. Sharda Aggarwal), the court interpreted Section 141 to permit proceedings against directors independent of impleading the company, relying on the statutory phrasing and supportive authority (Sawant v. K.G. & Traders cited by respondent).
  4. Factual issues vs. grounds for quashing: the court repeatedly emphasized that key disputes — whether notice was properly served on the directors, whether the notice to the company could be treated as notice to the directors, and whether the complaint contained necessary averments about being in charge and responsible — are matters of evidence and fact to be addressed at trial. The court held that alleged defects of pleading that could be cured by evidence ought not to result in quashing at this stage.
  5. On impleadment and capacity to prosecute: the court concluded that the complaint specifically alleged that the cheque was issued and signed by T.P. Singh Kalra as director, and that under Section 141 directors may be proceeded against without necessarily impleading the company. Therefore the petitioner could not successfully argue discharge solely on the ground of non-impleadment.
  6. On prematurity and notice period: the court treated whether the complaint was prematurely filed (i.e., filed before expiry of the statutory notice period) as another factual question for trial or for magistrate to consider; it did not treat the asserted prematurity as a ground to quash at this stage.
  7. Overall approach: the court declined to interfere with the Magistrate's order declining discharge because the matters relied on by the petitioner concerned evidence or factual disputes and because the complaint contained an allegation that the petitioner signed the cheque as director. The court emphasized that its decision did not express any opinion on the merits and that the magistrate would inquire into merits after trial.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED — The Criminal Miscellaneous petitions were dismissed.

Direct consequences:

  • The Magistrate's order declining to discharge T.P. Singh Kalra (Annexure P1) stands and proceedings under Section 138 shall continue against him as framed in the complaint.
  • The court did not quash complaint Annexure P2 as sought by the petitioner; trial and evidentiary proceedings are to determine the contested factual issues (adequacy of notice, whether the petitioner was in charge and responsible, and other merits).

Broader implications: The opinion does not set out to create a new binding precedent. The court treated disputed issues of notice, impleadment and allegations about being in charge as matters for trial and evidence rather than as grounds for quashing at the stage of these petitions.

Petitions dismissed.

    T.P Singh Kalra v. Star Wire India Ltd. .

    M.L Singhal, J.:— By means of this judgment Crl. Misc. No. 14294-M, 14292-Mand 14289-M, all of 1996 shall be disposed of as in these Crl. Misc. petitions the same question of law and fact is involved.

    2. Facts have been taken out from Crl. Misc. 14294-M of 1996.

    3. Through Crl. Misc. 14294-M of 1996 filed by T.P Singh Kalra, Director, M/s Orion Auto and Steel Pvt. Ltd., G-3, Gandhi Nagar, Lashkar, Gwalior, he has prayed for the quashing of complaint Annexure P2 and the order Annexure P1 passed by the Magistrate declining to discharge him in complaint Annexure P2. He has prayed for the quashing of every other proceeding taken in complaint Annexure P2.

    4. Now the facts in brief as set out by M/s Star Wire India Limited, 21/4, Mathura Road, Ballabagarh through its General Manager Shri V.K Bountra-complainant in complaint Annexure P2, filed under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 as duly amended by Act No. 66 of 1988 (hereinafter to be referred as to “the Act”).

    5. Complainant-Company is a public limited company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956. Shri V.K Bountra is its General Manager and is one of the principal officers of the company entitled to institute complaint on behalf of the company. He has been authorised to file this complaint on behalf of the complainant-company by resolution dated 18.8.89 passed by the Board of Directors of the complainant-company. Company is engaged in the business of manufacturing of iron and steel products. As per verbal order of the accused, the company supplied to the accused various quantities of bars. Accused took delivery of the goods vide bills No. 33 and 34 dated 22.4.89 and 24.4.89 for a sum of Rs. 1,12,212.54 and Rs. 1,06,923.16 respectively. In lieu of the receipt of the said bills by the accused and the bills raised by the company, the accused issued to the company cheque No. 013343 dated 14.6.89 for a sum of Rs. 2,19,135.70 drawn on Central Bank of India, Banmore (MP) in the name and favour of the complainant-company. Complainant-company deposited the said cheque with their banker namely Bank of Maharashtra, Neelam-Bata Road, Faridabad. The said cheque was sent to the banker of the accused for realisation of the amount. Cheque was returned by the banker of the accused with the remarks “Exceeds arrangement” meaning thereby there were insufficient funds to the credit of the accused to meet the said cheque. Bank of Maharasthtra, Faridabad i.e the banker of the company informed the company about the dishonour of the said cheque by the Central Bank of Maharashtra, Faridabad i.e the banker of the company informed the company about the dishonour of the said cheque by the Central Bank of India, Banmore (MP). Said cheque was signed by T.P Singh Kalra-accused as Director of the accused company. Shri Harbhajan Singh Kalra-accused is other Director of the company. Directors of the accused company have been sued as according to the relevant provisions of the Act in the event of commission of an offence by a company, every person who at the time the offence was committed was incharge of and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company as well as the company shall be deemed to be guilty of the offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly. As the said cheque had been returned by the banker of the accused unpaid on the ground that the amount standing to the credit of the account of the accused was insufficient to honour to cheque or exceeded the amount ordered to be paid from the account of the accused, accused committed offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act. Notice dated August 9, 1989 was sent by the complainant-company to the accused as required under Section 138-B of the Act but the accused failed to make payment of the said cheque within the stipulated period.

    6. After recording preliminary evidence led by the complainant Shri R.K Sharma, Judicial Magistrate First Class, Faridabad vide order dated 15.3.1990 found sufficient grounds to proceed against the accused for an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act. Vide order dated 10.6.92, a learned Single Judge of this court quashed proceedings against Harbhajan Singh Kalra-accused Director of the accused company.

    7. Application dated 2.6.95 was moved by'T.P. Singh Kalra-petitioner herein before the Magistrate for his discharge in the complaint saying that no notice had been served upon him as required under Section 138 of the Act and notice served upon the company M/s Orion Auto & Steel Industries was no substitute for notice required to have been served upon him. Service of notice is a condition precedent for the institution of the complaint. In complaint no date is mentioned as to when the cheque was dishonoured. Notice addressed to M/s Orion Auto & Steel Industries was received on 14.8.89 Complaint was filed on 29.8.89 and was thus premature. Cheque was allegedly given by T.P Singh Kalra as Director of the Company. Company was not impleaded. Impleadment of the company was a must. Further there was no mention in the complaint that he was in-charge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company. Allegation made in the complaint at best constitute civil liability as there was contract between the complainant-company and M/s Orion Auto & Steel Industries for the supply of goods and the payment of price of goods. Complainant-company had already filed civil suit against T.P Singh Kalra for the recovery of the amount of the cheque. Judicial Magistrate First Class, Faridabad declined to accept prayer of T.P Singh Kalra and discharg him in complaint Annexure P2.

    8. In support of his prayer for the quashing of the complaint Annexure P2 and the order Annexure P1 declining to quash the complaint and discharge him, T.P Singh Kalra has averred that against the order of summoning Shri Harbhajan Singh Kalra, the other accused filed petition before the High Court by way of Crl. Misc. No. 3037-M of 1990 and vide order dated 6.9.91 learned Single Judge of this court quashed complaint as well as the order of summoning qua the other accused named Harbhajan Singh Kalra. While qqashing the complaint and the order of summoning qua Harbhajan Singh Kalra learned Single Judge of this court felt impressed by the fact that notice had been served upon the company without naming the persons who were liable for issuing cheques. Through the application moved before the Magistrate, T.P Singh Kalra claimed parity with Harbhajan Singh Kalra qua whom the complaint and the order of summoning was quashed. Magistrate refused to quash the complaint qua T.P Singh Kalra arbitrarily although his case was squarely covered by the judgment of this court passed by the learned Single Judge in Crl. Misc. 3703-M/90. Learned Single Judge of this Court clearly held that notice issued to the company was no notice in the eye of law as contemplated in the Act. This was a finding given by the High Court in the case of the co-accused. Magistrate was not within his powers to give any finding which was at variance with the finding of this court. No notice was issued to the petitioner under Section 138 of the Act which is a pre-requisite for the filing of the complaint under Section 138 of the Act. Complainant company issued notice only in the name of another private limited company M/s Orion Auto & Steel Pvt. Ltd. but the said company was not arrayed or made party in the complaint. That notice which was issued in the name of the company did not specify as to which of the directors or which of the officials responsible for the affairs or business of the company had issued the cheques thereby incurring liability under the Act. It had to be specifically stated in the complaint as to who were the persons who were in-charge of the affairs of the company and who were responsible for issuing cheques etc. Two companies had mutual business dealings long back. Since long, they have stopped having mutual business dealings. Further the complaint was filed before the expiry of the statutory period of 15 days notice and, therefore, deserved dismissal on this short ground. Shri V.K Bountra, General Manager (Finance) is neither payee nor the holder in due course of the cheque. According to Section 141 of the Act, no court shall take cognizance of an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act except upon a complaint in writing made by the payee or as the case may be the holder in due course of the cheque. Further, the complaint was liable to be quashed when on the face of it, it was clear that no conviction would be possible. Complaint was filed in the year 1989. Seven years have elapsed. This inordinate delay has worked hardship to the petitioner.

    9. It has been submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that in complaint Annexure P2, there is no mention that the accused was incharge of and was responsible for the conduct of the business of the company to the company. In the absence of this allegation in the complaint, no complaint is competent against the directors of the company alone. In the complaint, should have been arrayed the company and the directors. In support of this submission, he drew my attention to Amrit Rani v. Surinder Kumar Sachdeva, 1992 (2) RCR 16 where a learned Single Judge of this court held that if in the complaint there is no allegation that the petitioner was incharge of the business of the company and responsible to it for conduct of its business, no criminal offence would be made out against the petitioner.

    10. Suffice it to say in Amrit Rani's case (supra) the facts were different. There, the accused No. 1 M/s Ambay Enterprises which consisted of Ashok Kumar accused No. 2 and Smt. Amrit Rani accused No. 3 as partners purchased from the complainant firm goods worth Rs. 3,28,401.83. When demand was raised by the complainant, the accused issued cheque dated 20.12.90 for Rs. 2 lacs drawn on Punjab and Sind Bank, Kukarmajra. On presentation, this cheque was dishonoured for want of funds. Cheques had been issued by the accused with dishonest intention knowing fully well that there was no arrangement for that amount. On receipt of intimation from the bank, notice was issued by the complainant firm to the respondent-petitioner but the amount in question had not been paid. It was found that cheque had been issued by Ashok Kumar alone. Amrit Rani did not sign the cheque. Nor there had been allegation in the complainant that she was incharge of the business of the firm and was responsible to the firm for the conduct of its business. According to Section 141 of the Act, if the person committing the offence under Section 138 is a company then every person who at the time of commission of the offence was incharge or responsible to the company for the conduct of its business becomes liable for that act along with the company itself. Complaint was quashed qua Amrit Rani as there was no allegation that she was incharge of the business of the company or she was responsible for the conduct of the business of the firm. Cheque had also not been issued by her. In this case, cheque was issued by T.P Singh Kalra and was signed by him.

    11. He drew my detention to the provisions of Section 141 of the Act. Section 141 reads as follows:—

    “141 Offence by Companies:

    If the person committing an offence under Section 138 is a company, every person who at the time the offence was committed was incharge of and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company as well as company, shall be deemed to the guilty of the offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly.”

    12. He drew my attention to Sushil Singla… v. Haripal Singh…., 1994 (1) RCR 621 where it was held that where cheque was issued by the Managing Director (MD) of a private limited company and cheque was dishonoured by the bank for want of sufficient funds, complaint was instituted under section 138 against the Managing Director and the other directors of the company. No averments that the said directors were incharge of the business of the company and were responsible to the company for the conduct of its business, complaint qua those directors could not proceed and was quashed. In Sushil Singla's case (supra), the facts were that Haripal Singh filed complaint in respect of cheque dated March 8, 1992 drawn on State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur for Rs. 1,25,000/- issued by Qimat Lal Garg, Managing Director of the M.M Leasing Limited. It was averred that petitioners Sushil Singla and Madhu Rani Garg were simply directors of the company and were neither incharge of nor responsible for the affairs of the Company. Cheque was issued by Qimat Lal Garg for and on behalf of the company who was incharge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company. Petitioners Sushil Singla and Madhu Rani Garg were impleaded as accused although no offence was disclosed against them on a bare reading of the complaint. Complaint was quashed qua Sushil Singla and Madhu Rani as there was no allegation in the complaint against them that when the offence was committed by the company, they were incharge of and were responsible to the company for the conduct of its business. Allegations in the complaint had been made against the company and its Managing Director, Qimat Lal Garg and the cheque had also been issued by the Managing Director of the company. In Sushil Singla's case, no question of law was involved whether the complaint should proceed independently against the directors of the company without the impleadment of the company. In my opinion, complaint could proceed against the directors of the company independently without the company being impleaded as is suggested by the use of the words “as well as the company” in Section 141 of the Act reproduced above. In my opinion, present petitioner T.P Singh Kalra cannot take shelter that since company Orion Auto and Steel Pvt Ltd. has not been impleaded, he too could not be impleaded. In the complaint Annexure P1, it has been clearly mentioned that cheques were issued by T.P Singh Kalra in lieu of the supplies made by the company to the accused. T.P Singh Kalra had issued the cheques being director of the company which was dishonoured is the allegation made by the complainant-company in its complaint. Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that in para 2 of the complaint, it had been clearly mentioned that the cheque was signed by the accused being the director of the company and in case of commission of offence by company, every person who at the time the offence was committed, was incharge and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company as well as company shall be deemed to be guilty of offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and there was no need to implead the company. He drew sustenance for this submission from a case reported as Sawant v. K.G & Traders, 1995 Banking Cases 346 by the Karnataka High Court.

    13. Learned counsel for the petitioner drew my attention to Smt. Sharda Aggarwal v. Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate-II, Kanpur, 1992 (3) RCR 499 in support of the submission that where cheque was issued by the Managing Director of a private limited company and the same was dishonoured, no complaint could be competent against the directors of the company without stating that they were incharge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company at the time when offence was committed. It would bear repetition that in complaint, there is averment that as per verbal order of the accused, the complainant supplied to the accused various quantities of bars. Delivery of the said goods was duly taken by the accused and the complainant-company raised its bills in lieu of the above supplies. In lieu of the receipt of the said bills by the accused and the bills raised by the complainant-company, the accused issued to the complainant-company the cheques. Cheque was signed by T.P Singh Kalra accused No. 1 as director of the accused company. Even otherwise, it will be a matter of evidence as to which of the accused was/were incharge of the business of the company and were responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company. Proof of this fact is not dependent upon the adducing of oral evidence alone. It will be dependent upon the adducing of documentary evidence also. Assuming that allegation to this effect is missing in the complaint and the complaint is defective on this account, then the same can well be supplied at the trial by adducing evidence. It is also a civil case where evidence can be led only on the pleadings and no evidence can be led which is beyond pleadings. As to whether notice issued to the accused was in conformity to the provisions of the Act is again a matter of evidence. It is also a matter of evidence whether the notice was issued to the company alone and no notice was issued to the directors thereof. It is also a matter of evidence whether notice issued to the company could be taken to be a notice to the directors of the company as company is not an abstract being. Company is only a legal entity. It is the directors composing a company to whom the issuance of notice would matter.

    14. For the reasons given above, these Criminal Misc. petitions fail and are dismissed. Nothing said above is meant to be expression of opinion so far as the merits of the case are concerned. Merits of the case shall be gone into by the Magistrate after trial.

    Petitions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T.P Singh Kalra v. Star Wire India Ltd. .
    (Jan 28, 1998)