Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for partition and possession against her brother (defendant), alleging ownership through inheritance from their deceased father, Hem Raj. The defendant relied on an alleged Will executed by the father. The plaintiff pleaded a memorandum of partition dated 4.2.1978 and, during evidence, applied to prove that memorandum by way of secondary evidence. The trial Court dismissed the application, reasoning that the plaintiff had not pleaded how the original was lost, destroyed, or came to be in the defendant's possession. The plaintiff challenged that dismissal by way of this revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant is entitled to lead secondary evidence regarding the memorandum of partition dated 4.2.1978.
  2. Whether the plaintiff had sufficiently established the loss or non-availability of the original document to justify reception of secondary evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff alleged execution of the memorandum of partition by the defendant, his father and uncle, and referenced an entry in the petition-writer's register.
  • In the application she stated there was no other person alive except the defendant who had executed and signed the document and the entry existed in the petition-writer's register.
  • She examined the petition-writer, who stated the original and its copy had been given to Hem Raj and Ram Nath.
  • She inquired of Ram Nath's children, who professed ignorance of the document's whereabouts; Hem Raj was dead and the defendant denied execution—facts relied on to show the original was lost.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant denied having executed the memorandum of partition.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the pleadings, the application for secondary evidence, and the oral evidence led on the issue framed (“whether the applicant is entitled to secondary evidence regarding the memo of partition dated 4.2.1978”). The petition-writer testified that the original and a copy were handed to Hem Raj and Ram Nath. The plaintiff's enquiries of Ram Nath's descendants produced no information; Hem Raj was deceased and the defendant denied executing the document. Applying the legal principle that secondary evidence is admissible where the original is lost or destroyed or cannot be produced for reasons not attributable to the offering party, the Court found the plaintiff had established non-availability of the original. The Court further held that a party need not prove loss in absolute terms and that the trial Court erred in treating the application in isolation of the evidence led on the framed issue. On these bases the trial Court's order dismissing the application was set aside.

Holding and Implications

REVISION PETITION ALLOWED.

Direct effects: The trial Court's order dismissing the plaintiff's application is set aside; the petitioner-plaintiff is entitled to prove the entry in the petition-writer's register regarding the memorandum of partition dated 4.2.1978; the respondent-defendant may lead rebuttal evidence. No costs were ordered. Parties were directed to appear before the trial Court on 11.10.1993. The opinion does not state any broader precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties.

    Raj Kumari v. Lal Chand .

    V.K Jhanji, J. (Oral) — This revision petition is directed against the order of the trial Court whereby application filed by the plaintiff to prove Memorandum of partition dated 4.2.1978 by way of secondary evidence, was dismissed.

    2. Plaintiff (Petitioner herein) filed a suit, against her brother, Lal Chand, for possession by way of partition of the properties as fully detailed in the body of the plaint, on the allegation that her father, Hem Raj, was the owner and on his death, she became entitled to inherit the property to the extent of half share. Defendant (respondent herein) in his written statement set up a Will alleged to have been executed by the deceased-father, in his favour. In the replication plaintiff alleged that the defendant along with his father and uncle executed memorandum of partition dated 4.2.1978 During the course of evidence, an application was filed by the plaintiff to prove memorandum of partition by way of secondary evidence. On contest, this application was dismissed by the trial Court primarily on the ground that plaintiff had no where alleged in her application that as to how the document was lost, destroyed or was in possession of the defendant. The trial Court further held that “secondary evidence can only be lead in case the original is in possession of the person, against whom the document is sought to be produced or the original has been lost or destroyed. But there is no such plea of the plaintiff in her application. This order is now being impugned by the plaintiff in the present revision petition.

    3. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, I am of the view that the revision petition deserves to succeed. Plaintiff in her pleadings made a specific mention of the memorandum of partition. In her application to prove that document by way of secondary evidence, she stated that there is no other person alive except the defendant, who executed and signed the document and the entry of the same in the petition-writer's register. In reply to this application, defendant denied having executed this document. On the application, the trial Court framed an issue “whether the applicant is entitled to secondary evidence regarding the memo of partition dated 4.2.1978” In support of this issue, plaintiff gave her statement as A.W 1 and also examined the petition-writer in whose register the entry of this document was made. Petition-writer in his statement stated that the document in original, along with its copy, was given to Hem Raj and Ram Nath, i.e father and uncle of the parties. Plaintiff in her statement stated that she made enquiries from the sons and daughters of Ram Nath, but they showed their ignorance with regard to whereabouts of the document in question. Hem Raj, father, is dead and the defendant has denied the execution of the document. Thus, the plaintiff has successfully proved on record that the original document has been lost. Secondary evidence is permissible when the original document has been destroyed or lost or when the party offering evidence of its contents, cannot for any reason, not arising from his own default or neglect, produce it is reasonable time. A party seeking permission to produce secondary evidence regarding a document, is not required to prove the loss of document in absolute terms. The trial Court while dismissing the application seems to have lost sight of the fact that once it allowed the parties to lead evidence on the issue framed on the basis of allegations made in the application, then the averments made therein have to be read in the light of evidence produced on the said issue. In the statement of the petition-writer as well as in the statement of the plaintiff, it has come on record that plaintiff was not in a position to produce the document because the persons in whose possession the document could be found, are either dead or have denied the execution of the document. In this view of the matter, the order of the trial court cannot be sustained.

    4. Consequently, the revision petition is allowed and the order of the trial Court is set aside. Petitioner-plaintiff shall be entitled to prove the entry in the register of the petition-writer in respect of memorandum of partition dated 4.2.1978 Respondent-defendant of course, shall also be entitled to lead evidence in rebuttal to the same. No costs.

    5. Parties through their counsels are directed to appear before the trial Court on the date already fixed i.e 11.10.1993

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raj Kumari v. Lal Chand .
    (Sep 28, 1993)