Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, the Act) and Notification No. LAC(P) NTLA-88/2785,
  • denied.7. Rules 3, 4 and 5 of Order 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act Annexure P-1 and P-5
  • HARYANA URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ACT 1977
  • Development) Act, 1963 and Urban Area Act, 1988,
  • SECTION 6 LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • Section 6(Annexure P-5).10.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, the Act) and Notification No. LAC(P) NTLA-88/2785,
  • denied.7. Rules 3, 4 and 5 of Order 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act Annexure P-1 and P-5
  • HARYANA URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ACT 1977
  • Development) Act, 1963 and Urban Area Act, 1988,
  • SECTION 6 LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • Section 6(Annexure P-5).10.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — G.R. Majithia, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes of C.W.P. No. 3269 of 1990 and twenty-one connected writ petitions (listed in the opinion) filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. The petitions challenge Notification No. LAC(P)NTLA-87/1914 dated April 21, 1987 issued under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (the Act), and Notification No. LAC(P)NTLA-88/2785 dated April 20, 1988 issued under Section 6(2) of the Act by the Haryana Government, Urban Estate Department.

The land had been earmarked for acquisition at the request of the Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA) for "development and utilization of land as residential area" under the Haryana Urban Development Authority Act, 1977. Some landowners (petitioners) filed written objections under Section 5-A of the Act claiming that their lands were already developed (houses, factories, saw mills, hospital nearby etc.), that similar or nearby plots had been released from acquisition while their plots were not, and that the government adopted a policy of selective release ("pick and choose") including releases both before and after the Section 6 declaration.

The State filed a written statement raising preliminary objections that certain petitioners did not file objections under Section 5-A and denying the substance of several allegations. The State maintained the acquisition aimed to prevent unregulated development and that objections were considered by Government authorities (including hearings on February 10, 1983). The record of acquisition and internal notes were summoned and examined by the Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notifications issued under Section 4(1) and Section 6(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 are legal and valid.
  2. Whether compliance with the condition precedent in Section 6 — namely the Government's satisfaction after considering the report, if any, under Section 5-A(2) — was observed in the present case, and whether a declaration under Section 6 is vitiated if the report under Section 5-A(2) was not considered prior to recording satisfaction and publishing the declaration.
  3. Whether selective release of portions of land from acquisition (including releases after publication of the Section 6 declaration) constituted arbitrary, mala fide or discriminatory action by the State, in violation of Article 14 (and as alleged, Article 31) of the Constitution of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The land in question was already developed or populated (houses, hospitals, schools, factories, saw mills), and acquisition for residential redevelopment served no useful purpose for those already possessing constructed properties.
  • Some vacant plots and partially constructed properties were released from acquisition (both before and after the Section 6 declaration), whereas the petitioners' already developed houses and factories were not released, indicating discriminatory treatment and mala fide "pick and choose" policy.
  • The Section 6 notification dated April 20, 1988 covered less area (247.34 acres) than the Section 4 notification (250.45 acres), and the petitioners contended that some land was released even after the Section 6 declaration had been published.
  • The acquisition is violative of Articles 14 and 31 of the Constitution and is illegal, inequitable and unconstitutional because similar situated persons were treated differently.

State's Arguments (Respondent)

  • A preliminary objection that some petitioners did not file objections under Section 5-A within the statutory period.
  • The constructed areas of certain petitioners were released after consideration of their objections under Section 5-A; some petitioners' land was vacant at the time of Section 4 notification and the area was not a developed area in the planning sense.
  • The purpose of acquisition was to check unregulated development and to ensure provision of public amenities (roads, sewerage, drinking water, schools, hospitals, parks etc.) through HUDA as implementing agency; purchase of plots by petitioners may have been in violation of other statutory controls (Punjab Controlled Area Act, 1963 and Urban Area Act, 1988).
  • All objections under Section 5-A were considered (including personal hearing on February 10, 1983), and notices under Section 9 of the Act were issued to landowners based on revenue records; awards for certain portions had been announced earlier on April 17, 1990.
  • Generally denied other allegations of mala fides and discrimination, asserting releases were made on individual merits after statutory consideration where applicable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Badat and Co., Bombay v. India Trading Co., AIR 1964 SC 538 Principle under Order VIII, Rules 3–5 CPC: evasive or non-specific denials in the written statement are deemed admissions; respondent must specifically traverse allegations or they stand admitted. The Court applied this principle to hold that the respondent's evasive denials amounted to admissions of the petitioners' factual pleas (notably that some lands similarly situated had been released after Section 6 declaration).
Ganga Bishnu Swaika v. Calcutta Pinjrapole Society, AIR 1968 SC 615 Interpretation of Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act: satisfaction by the Government after consideration of the report, if any, under Section 5-A is a condition precedent to a valid declaration; the declaration itself need not state the Government's satisfaction but satisfaction must follow consideration of the report. The Court held that in the present case the Government's satisfaction was recorded before the complete report under Section 5-A(2) was received/considered; relying on this precedent, the Court concluded the Section 6 declaration was vitiated.
Maganbhai Vanarshibhai Patel v. State of Gujarat, AIR 1976 Gujarat 84 Principle on discrimination/arbitrariness in State action: State must not adopt arbitrary, pick-and-choose policies; discriminatory treatment by the State is contrary to Article 14. The Court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that the alleged selective release of land parcels illustrated arbitrary and discriminatory State action violative of Article 14.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by summarizing the statutory scheme for compulsory acquisition under the Land Acquisition Act: issuance of Section 4 notification as public notice and authorization to departmental officers, the statutory right of interested persons to file objections under Section 5-A within 30 days, and the requirement that a Section 6 declaration be issued only after the appropriate Government is satisfied, having considered the report, if any, under Section 5-A(2).

The Court examined the pleadings (primarily C.W.P. No. 3269 of 1990) and noted that several factual averments by petitioners — including that some plots and developed structures were released from acquisition even after publication of the Section 6 declaration, and that petitioners' developed properties were not released while others similarly situated were — were not specifically denied by the State in a non-evasive manner. Applying the principles in Badat and Co. (Order VIII rules), the Court treated such non-specific/evasive denials as admissions.

The Court summoned and reviewed the acquisition record from the concerned Department, which corroborated the petitioners' averments. The Court also relied on an internal note dated January 20, 1989 by the Additional Director, Urban Estates, which indicated that objections under Section 5-A had been arbitrarily dealt with in some cases and that releases were inconsistent (sometimes whole pieces, other times only constructed portions). The note also recorded that some releases were ordered by the Chief Minister on specific dates.

Critically, the Court found that the Haryana Government's satisfaction under Section 6 had been recorded before the complete report under Section 5-A(2) was received and considered. Relying on the authoritative exposition in Ganga Bishnu Swaika, the Court held that consideration of the report under Section 5-A(2), if any, is a condition precedent to a valid Section 6 declaration. Because in this case the report had not been received/considered prior to the Government recording satisfaction and publishing the Section 6 declaration, the declaration was vitiated.

Separately and cumulatively, the Court concluded that the pattern of selective releases (including releases after the Section 6 notification and differential treatment of neighboring plots and structures) demonstrated arbitrary, mala fide "pick and choose" state conduct. Such conduct, the Court held, amounted to discrimination and arbitrariness contrary to Article 14 of the Constitution, a conclusion reinforced by the cited Gujarat precedent.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: For the reasons stated, the writ petitions succeed and the declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 is quashed.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The Section 6 declaration dated April 20, 1988 (and thus the consequent acquisition insofar as it rests on that declaration) cannot be sustained on the factual and legal grounds found by the Court.
  • The Court found procedural invalidity in recording Government satisfaction prior to consideration of the Section 5-A(2) report, and substantive invalidity arising from arbitrary/selective releases constituting discrimination violative of Article 14.
  • The Court ordered that the parties bear their own costs.

The opinion does not indicate that a new legal precedent was created; rather it applied existing authorities to the facts before the Court.

    Sukhdev Sharma v. State Of Haryana .

    G.R Majithia, J. — This judgment disposes of C.W.P No. 3269 of 1990 and 21 other connected writ petitions, i.e C.W.P Nos. 3270, 3271, 3654, 4668, 4670, 4716, 4743, 4744, 4758, 4865, 4862, 4954, 4972, 5056, 5160, 5041, 5241, 5173, 6591, 12016 of 1990 and 4810 of 1991. In these petitions under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India, serious challenge has been made to Notification No. LAC(P)NTLA-87/1914, dated April 21, 1987 issued under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, the Act) and Notification No. LAC(P) NTLA-88/2785, dated April 20, 1988, issued by the Haryana Government, Urban Estate Department, under Section 6(2) of the Act

    2. Reference to relevant facts has been made from the pleadings in C.W.P No. 3269 of 1990 except where it is otherwise necessary to refer to a particular fact in a particular writ petition it has been so made from the pleadings of that writ petition.

    3. The process of compulsory acquisition starts with the issuance of a notification under Section 4 of the Act The object of issuing a notification under Section 4 of the Act is two-fold. First, it is a public announcement by the government and a public notice by the Collector to the effect that the land, as specified therein, is needed or is likely to be needed by the government for the “public purpose” mentioned therein; and secondly it authorises the departmental officers or officers of the local authority as the case may be, to do all such acts as are mentioned in Section 4(2) of the Act. The notification has to be published in the locality and particularly persons likely to be affected by the proposal have to be on notice that such activity is afoot Sub-section (1) of Section 5-A of the Act enables any person interested in any land which has been notified under Section 4(1) of the Act, within thirty days from the date of publication of the notification to file objection to the acquisition of the land or of any land in the locality, as the case may be. Every such objection must be made to the Land Acquisition Collector in writing. Under Section 6 of the Act, a declaration can be issued only after the appropriate Government is satisfied, after considering the report, if any, made under Section 5-A(2) that any particular land is needed for a public purpose or for a Company. Consideration of the report under Section 5-A(2) will be a condition precedent to a valid declaration under Section 6 of the Act.

    4. In the instant case, the land was acquired by the Haryana Government on a request made by the Haryana Urban Development Authority (for short, the HUDA). The public purpose specified in the notification under Section 4(1) of the Act, is, “for the development and utilization of land as residential area under the Haryana Urban Development Authority Act, 1977.” The notification also provided that “any person interested who has any objection to the acquisition of land in the locality, may within a period of 30 days of publication of this notification, file objections in writing before the land Acquisition Collector.” Some of the petitioners filed objections saying that their land was situated in already developed congested area; that the land was purchased for residential and factory purposes; that they did not own any other residential plot except the ones sought to be acquired that the acquired land was already developed and populated and the site plan annexed with the petition would show that a big Hospital, Schools, factories, saw wills and many pucca houses were already there in the acquired land; that they had set up a saw mill in the said land after getting permission from the Municipality, Jagadhari and also paid House-tax; that they also got the licence from the Chief Inspector of Factories for running the saw mill vide Registered No. AMB-S-269/6305 on December 31, 1985 and that their unit is also registered with the Industries Department as a S.S.I Unit; that they have also built up pucca rooms and shed in the factory and made part construction on the rest of the land for their houses. It is further averred in the petition that some vacant plots, plots built upto plinth level, some houses and saw mills have been exempted from acquisition, whereas the house and factory of the petitioners have been acquired. The site plan, Annexure P-2 to the writ petition, would show that vacant plots situated in khasra No. 487 and Khasra No. 60 and so many other partly constructed houses and Saw Mills have been released from acquisition even after the publication of the notification under Section 6 of the Act. The properties released after the publication of notification under Section 6 of the Act are shown in brown lines in Annexure P-2. It is averred that the authorities have adopted the policy of pick and choose in releasing some of the land from acquisition and have acted in a mala fide manner. Even the vacant plots which are in the middle of the acquired land have been released from acquisition, whereas the petitioners' property which is already developed as a house and a factory and which is adjacent to ESI Hospital and a few yards away from the shopping and Commercial Complex has been acquired; land notified under Section 4(1) of the Act measures 250.45 acres, whereas the land notified under Section 6 of the Act measures 247.34 acres. The land released from the acquisition before the publication of the notification under Section 6 is shown with the help of blue lines in the site plan, Annexure P-2 to the writ petition, and the land released from acquisition after the publication of notification under Section 6 is shown with the help of brown lines in the said site plan.

    5. In the written statement filed on behalf of the State by Shri K.K Sharma, Land Acquisition Collector, Urban Estate; Panchkula, a preliminary objection was taken that petitioners No. 1 to 3, 6 and 9 did not file objections under Section 5-A of the Act. On merits, it was stated that the constructed area of petitioners No. 4 and 8 was released by the Government after considering the objections under Section 5-A of the Act filed by them. Land of rest of the petitioners was lying vacant at the time of publication of the notification under Section 4 of the Act and that the area under which the land of the petitioners falls is not developed one. The purpose of acquisition is not so much to provide residential plots to the persons who do not own any residential plot in the State; the main aim of the respondent is rather to restrict unregulated development which leads to creation of slumps. For this purpose, HUDA is an implementing agency for the planning made by the Planning Department. A developed area should have roads, sewerage, drinking water, street lights, schools, hospitals, parks, market and public utility buildings. The land under acquisition does not have the aforesaid facilities. Further, as per the Punjab Controlled Area (Restriction of Unregulated Development) Act, 1963 and Urban Area Act, 1988, no person can make sale, purchase of plots without the permission of the competent authority and without getting permission in land case from the District Town Country Planner. The purchase of the plot by the petitioners is in violation of the provisions of the aforesaid two Acts. It was further averred in the written statement that all the objections received under Section 5-A of the Act were duly considered vide personal hearing on the plot on February 10, 1983. Notices under Section 9 of the Act were issued to all the landowners at the addresses available in the revenue record. Award of Khasra numbers 688, 689, 696 and 695 had not been announced as the same khasra numbers were included in the separate writ petition No. 5144 of 1990 in which this Court had stayed acquisition proceedings vide order dated October 10, 1990. Award with respect to the land measuring 173.34 had already been announced on April 17, 1990. The other allegations made in the writ petitions were generally denied.

    6. It will be relevant to reproduce some of the averments made in the writ petition and the corresponding reply to those averments in the written statement:—

    “AVERMENTS IN THE WRIT PETITION:

    “7. That respondent issued another notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act which was published in the official Gazette dt. 20.4.1988 A copy of the notification dt. 20.4.1988 is attached as Annexure P-5 with the writ petition. A perusal of this notification would show that land measuring 247.34 acres was acquired vide this notification whereas under Section 4 notification (Annexure P-1) land measuring 250.45 acres was notified for acquisition. The land released under Section 6 notification has been shown with the help of Blue lines in the site plan P-2. It is pertinent to mention here that respondent released land shown in Brown colour lines in Annexure P-2 after the notification issued under Section 6(Annexure P-5).

    10. That notifications issued by the respondent under Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act Annexure P-1 and P-5 respectively are illegal and are liable to be quashed on the following grounds inter alia:—

    (iv) that the acquired land of the petitioners is situated in a thickly populated area behind the ESI Hospital. A perusal of Annexure P-2 and P-3 would show that the area is already developed fully. There is no justification to acquire the same under the notification to construct the house for the development and utilisation of the land as residential area by the Haryana Urban Development Authority. There is no idea to demolish the good and newly built houses and build another house on that land. So no useful purpose will be served by acquiring the land.

    v) That the notification issued by the Govt. is illegal and against the provisions of law, equity, good conscious and unconstitutional because some vacant plots, plot built upto plinth level and some houses and Saw Mills built in the locality has been exempted from the acquisition whereas the house and factory of the petitioner have been acquired. Thus a great discrimination has been done to the petitioner by the respondent Authorities. A perusal of Annexure P-2 would show that vacant plots situated in Khasra No. 487 and Khasra No. 60 and so many other partly constructed houses and Saw Mills have been released from acquisition even after the publication of notification under Section 6 of the Act. The properties released after publication of notification under Section 6 of the Act and shown in Brown lines in Annexure P.2 Thus the acquisition is violative of Articles 14 and 31 of the Constitution of India.

    vi) That respondent-authorities have exercised the power in a colourable manner which has vitiated the whole acquisition proceedings thus warranting the quashing of the same. A perusal of Annexure P-2 would show that the respondent authorities have acted in a mala fide and pick and choose manner while acquiring the land. The land of similarly situated persons have been released after notification under Section 6 of the Act Even the vacant plots which are in the middle of the acquired land have been left from the acquisition whereas petitioners property which is already developed as a house and factory and which is adjacent to ESI Hospital and a few yards away from the shopping and commercial complex has been acquired.”

    CORRESPONDING REPLY OF AFORESAID PARAS:

    “7. That contents of para 7 of the writ petition are not disputed.

    10. That in reply to para 10 of the writ petition, it is submitted that notification issued under Sections 4 and 6 of the Act are legal and valid and constitutional. Grounds are replied as under:—

    (iv) that reply of para 5 of the writ petition may please be read as reply of this sub-para.

    (v) that contents of sub-para (v) of the writ petition are wrong, hence denied. Construction/houses were released on the basis of objections filed by the petitioners under section 5-A of the Act and on the basis of individual merits of each case by the Govt.

    (vi) that contents of sub-para (vi) are wrong hence denied. Reply of sub para (iv) is reiterated.”

    Thus, the plea of the petitioners that some of the land was released from acquisition even after the publication of the declaration under Section 6 of the Act has not been denied. Furthermore, in some cases, vacant plots, plots built upto the plinth level and houses and saw mill in the locality have been excluded from the acquisition, whereas the petitioners' house and factory have been acquired. The plea of the petitioners that vacant plots situated in Khasra Nos. 487 and 60 and so many other partly constructed houses and Saw Mills have been released from acquisition even after the publication of the notification under Section 6 of the Act has not been denied.

    7. Rules 3, 4 and 5 of Order 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure form an integrated code dealing with the manner in which allegations of fact in the petition should be traversed and legal consequences flowing from its non- compliance. The written statement must deal specifically that each allegation of fact in the petition and when a respondent denied any such fact, he must not do so evasively but answer the point of substance. If his denial of a fact is not specific but evasive, the said fact shall be taken to be admitted. In such an event, the admission itself being proof, no other proof is necessary. (See in this connection Badat and Co., Bombay v. India Trading Co., AIR 1964 SC 538). The facts stated in the writ petitions which have not been specifically denied will be deemed to be admitted. The respondent could not controvert the plea of the petitioners that in the case of the persons who were similarly situated as the petitioners, their plots were released from acquisition even after the publication of the declaration under Section 6 of the Act.

    8. I summoned the record of acquisition from the concerned Department and it testifies the averments made in the writ petitions. The extracts of the orders under which the land was released from acquisition after the publication of notification under Section 6 of the Act are appended as Appendices I and II to the judgment

    9. In the note dated January 20, 1989 written by the Additional Director, Urban Estates, it is pertinently mentioned although not in specific language that the objections under Section 5-A of the Act for releasing the land from acquisition were arbitrarily dealt with. While in some cases the whole pieces of land - constructed portion as well as adjacent open area were released, in others only the constructed portion had been released. Release of proportionate open area (along with the constructed area) is an accepted practice and necessity, but in some cases it was not adhered to. Some land was released from acquisition under the orders of the Chief Minister, Haryana dated August 8, 1988 and June 24, 1989.

    10. Declaration under Section 6 of the Act was published on April 20, 1988. Declaration under Section 6 is issued by the appropriate Government only when it is satisfied, after considering the report, if any, made under Section 5-A(2) of the Act, that any particular land is needed for a public purpose or for a Company. In the instant case, satisfaction of the Haryana Government under Section 6 was recorded first and report under 5-A(2) was made thereafter. The declaration under Section 6 of the Act itself stands vitiated. It will be relevant to reproduce the following observations of the apex Court in Ganga Bishnu Swaika v. Calcutta Pinjrapole Society, AIR 1968 SC 615 (at pp. 618 and 619):—

    “Sub-section (1) provides that when the Government is satisfied that a particular land is needed for a public purpose or for a Company, a declaration shall be made ‘to that effect’. Satisfaction of the Government after consideration of the report, if any, made under Section 5-A is undoubtedly a condition precedent to a valid declaration, for, there can be no valid acquisition under the Act unless the Government is satisfied that the land to be acquired is needed for a public purpose or for a Company. But there is nothing in sub-section (1) which requires that such satisfaction need be stated in the declaration. The only declaration as required by sub-section (1) is that the land to be acquired is needed for a public purpose or for a Company. Sub-section (2) makes it clear, for it clearly provides that the declaration ‘shall state’ where such land is situate, ‘the purpose for which it is needed’, its approximate area and the place where its plan, if made, can be inspected. It is such a declaration made under sub-section (1) and published under sub-section (2) which becomes conclusive evidence that the particular land is needed for a public purpose or for a Company, as the case may be. The contention, therefore, that it is imperative that the satisfaction must be expressed in the declaration of that otherwise the notification would not be is accord with Section 6 is not correct.”

    In that case, the question had arisen whether the satisfaction of the appropriate Government that the land is needed for a public purpose must be mentioned in the notification under Section 6 of the Act itself, and the notification under Section 6 in that case used the words “whereas it appears to the Governor that the land is required” for a public purposes. The declaration did not show such satisfaction and the High Court had held the notification under Section 6 not to be in proper form. On appeal, construing the language of the Section 6 of the Act, the apex Court observed as reproduced supra. Thus, the satisfaction of the Governor has to be recorded only after consideration of the report, if any, made under Section S-A of the Act Consideration of the report, it any, made under Section 5-A is a condition precedent to a valid declaration under Section 6. In the instant case, declaration under Section 6 itself is vitiated, because on the date when the declaration was published, complete report under Section 5-A(2) of the Act had not been received by the Governor. Some of the notified land bad been released from acquisition even after the publication of the declaration under Section 6 of the Act

    11. The plea of the petitioners, detailed and discussed supra, suggests that land of some of the landowners similarly situated as the petitioners was released from acquisition while that of the petitioners was not released. The ground of exclusion adopted in the case of the petitioner indicates that discrimination is transparent It is elementary that in all State actions discrimination and arbitrariness has to be ruled out. But in the instant case, it is writ large. The action of the State cannot be upheld. The policy of the Government has to be uniform and it cannot be allowed to adopt the policy of pick and choose. Such action of the State to pick and choose is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution and has to be struck down being contrary to the constitutional provisions.

    (See in this connection Maganbhai Vanarshibhai Patel v. State of Gujarat, AIR 1976 Gujarat 84).

    For the reasons stated above, these petitions succeed and the declaration under Section 6 of the Act cannot be sustained and is quashed. However, I leave the parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sukhdev Sharma v. State Of Haryana .
    (Sep 29, 1992)