AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 433 read with Section 439 of the Companies Act
  • Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959.
  • Section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956.
  • Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules.
  • SECTION 434 COMPANIES ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 433 read with Section 439 of the Companies Act
  • Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959.
  • Section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956.
  • Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules.
  • SECTION 434 COMPANIES ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Mahalakshmi Sugar Mills Company Limited (hereinafter "Mahalakshmi") filed a petition under Section 433 read with Section 439 of the Companies Act seeking winding up of Straw Board Manufacturing Company Limited (hereinafter "Straw Board"). The dispute arose from a contract dated 27th January 1987, whereby Straw Board agreed to purchase 100 trucks of Bagasse from Mahalakshmi at Rs. 24 per quintal, exclusive of sales tax, and paid an advance of Rs. 20,000. Mahalakshmi supplied the agreed quantity and continued to supply additional Bagasse beyond the contract terms, which Straw Board accepted but later disputed payment for.

Mahalakshmi claimed outstanding dues of Rs. 3,95,521.36 after repeated demands and partial payments amounting to Rs. 48,852.40. Straw Board disputed the quality of the excess Bagasse supplied, alleging it was decomposed and unusable, and contended that payment for the extra supply was to be deferred for 2 to 3 years. Mahalakshmi issued a notice under Section 434 demanding payment of Rs. 3,41,627.51 with interest. Straw Board acknowledged the notice but requested account statements and failed to clear the dues, leading to the winding up petition on the ground of inability to pay debts.

Straw Board denied liability and claimed a bona fide dispute regarding the quality and payment terms. The Company Judge found Straw Board's defense to be fabricated and without good faith, holding that Rs. 3,37,167.56 was due and directed payment within one month, failing which the petition would be advertised under Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959. Straw Board appealed against this order and filed a miscellaneous application offering to pay the undisputed amount with a bank guarantee for the disputed sum.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the winding up petition under the Companies Act is maintainable when there is a bona fide dispute regarding the debt claimed by the petitioner company.
  2. Whether the appellant company’s offer to pay the undisputed amount and furnish a bank guarantee for the disputed amount precludes winding up proceedings.
  3. The evidentiary value and authenticity of the letters relied upon by the appellant to establish deferred payment terms and dispute over quality of goods.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Straw Board contended that the excess supply of Bagasse beyond 100 trucks was accepted on the condition that payment would be deferred for 2 to 3 years.
  • The material supplied in excess was allegedly decomposed and substandard, justifying non-payment or price abatement.
  • The letters attached by Straw Board to support their claim were genuine and evidenced a bona fide dispute.
  • During the appeal, Straw Board offered to pay Rs. 1,44,413.16 as the undisputed amount and proposed furnishing a bank guarantee for the disputed balance, demonstrating financial capability and willingness to pay.
  • Reliance was placed on Supreme Court precedent (Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Ltd. v. A.C.K Krishnaswami) establishing that winding up petitions cannot be used to enforce disputed debts and that bona fide disputes preclude winding up.
  • Additional reliance on case law (Hindustan Sanitary and Hardware Store v. J.C.T Electronics Ltd. and Madhusudan Gordhandas & Co. v. Madhu Woollen Industries Pvt. Ltd.) to support the proposition that bona fide disputes and payment of undisputed debts negate grounds for winding up.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Mahalakshmi argued that Straw Board disputed the entire amount before the Company Judge and made no offer to pay any undisputed portion then.
  • The defense raised by Straw Board was found to be fabricated and an afterthought, as evidenced by their earlier correspondence promising payment without raising disputes.
  • The letters relied upon by Straw Board to claim deferred payment and substandard goods were never acknowledged or received by Mahalakshmi and were denied to have been sent.
  • Mahalakshmi contended that the offer to pay the undisputed amount and furnish a bank guarantee was only made at the appellate stage, which did not justify setting aside the winding up order.
  • Reliance was placed on judgments from Calcutta, Delhi, and Bombay High Courts to support the view that fabricated defenses and absence of bona fide dispute justify winding up orders.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Ltd. v. A.C.K Krishnaswami, 1963 35 Com Cases 456 (Supreme Court) A winding up petition is not maintainable where the debt is bona fide disputed; no neglect to pay arises if dispute is genuine. The Court noted this principle but found Straw Board's dispute was not bona fide and dismissed the appeal accordingly.
Hindustan Sanitary and Hardware Store v. J.C.T Electronics Ltd., 1990 67 Com. Cases 585 Where a company is paying undisputed debts and disputes some debts, winding up is not justified. Referenced by appellant counsel; Court distinguished as Straw Board did not pay undisputed amounts before the Company Judge.
Madhusudan Gordhandas & Co. v. Madhu Woollen Industries Pvt. Ltd., 1971 3 SCC 632 Bona fide dispute over debt precludes winding up order. Appellant relied on this principle; Court rejected the bona fide nature of the dispute in the present case.
T.P Shau & Sons Pvt. Ltd., In re (Calcutta High Court) Fabricated defenses and absence of bona fide dispute justify winding up. Relied on by respondent to support that Straw Board's defense was fabricated.
Wastinghouse Saxby Farmer Ltd., In re (Calcutta High Court) Similar to above; supports dismissal of winding up petitions where defenses are false. Used by respondent to reinforce argument against appellant's defense.
Smt. Madan Debi Kundalia v. Alpine Dairy Ltd., 1983 54 C.C 41 (Delhi High Court) Supports the principle that bona fide dispute bars winding up. Relied on by respondent to show defense was not bona fide.
P.G Bhatia & Co. v. Softsule Private Ltd., 1977 47 C.C 438 (Bombay High Court) Similar principle on bona fide dispute and winding up. Respondent cited to emphasize lack of genuine dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court carefully analyzed the correspondence between the parties and the timing of disputes raised. It found that prior to the notice under Section 434, Straw Board had not disputed the correctness of the accounts or raised quality or deferred payment issues. The letters relied upon by Straw Board to claim these defenses were not acknowledged by Mahalakshmi and were denied receipt, casting doubt on their authenticity.

The Court concluded that the defense of a bona fide dispute was an afterthought, fabricated to delay payment and frustrate the winding up petition. The Court emphasized that if a genuine dispute had existed, the appellant would have raised it earlier rather than promising payment in its letters dated 29th August and 10th November 1987.

The Court also rejected the argument that the appellant’s readiness to pay the undisputed amount at the appellate stage negated the winding up order, noting that such an offer should have been made before the Company Judge. The Court found no merit in the appeal and upheld the winding up order.

Finally, the Court directed that if the appellant pays the balance amount with interest within one month, the winding up petition may not be advertised; otherwise, advertisement for winding up will proceed.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED - The appeal and the miscellaneous application were dismissed, affirming the order of the learned Company Judge directing payment of the outstanding amount.

The decision confirms that a winding up petition can be maintained where the company has failed to pay undisputed debts and that fabricated or afterthought disputes do not bar winding up. The Court’s ruling underscores the importance of raising bona fide disputes timely and substantiating them with credible evidence. No new precedent was set; the judgment applies established principles to the facts of the case. The direct effect is that Straw Board must comply with the payment order or face advertisement of the winding up petition.

    The Star Straw Board Manufacturing Company Limited, Hoshiarpur v. The Mahalakshmi Sugar Mills Company Limited Dehradun .

    R.S Mongia, J.:— This judgment of ours wilt dispose of Company Appeal No. 4 of 1989 as well as Company Misc No. 32 of 1990, which was filed by the appellant during the course of hearing of the appeal.

    2. Mahalakshmi Sugar Mills Company Limited petitioner (now respondent in the present appeal), had moved a petition under Section 433 read with Section 439 of the Companies Act for winding up the appellant Company known as Straw Board manufacturing Company Limited, on the facts which will be hereinafter mentioned. These Companies will be referred hereinafter as “Mahalakshmi” and “Straw Board“, respectively.

    3. On 27th January, 1987, the Managing Director of Straw Board confirmed the contract entered into between the Mahalakshmi and the Straw Board for the purchase of 100 trucks of Bagasse from the Mahalakshmi. The rate per quintal was fixed at Rs. 24/- exclusive of sales tax. An advance of Rs. 20,000/- by way of Bank draft was also paid by Straw Board to Mahalakshmi. The contract entered into between the parties is attached as Annexure P.1 to the Company Petition. In pursuance of the contract, the Mahalakshmi supplied 100 trucks of Bagasse to straw Board. It is the case of Mahalakshmi that even after the supply of 100 trucks Bagasse as agreed upon between the parties, it continued further supply of Bagasse beyond 100 trucks on the same terms and conditions during the whole crushing season. After the close of the season, Mahalakshmi vide its registered letter dated 23rd/14th July, 1987, sent a statement of accounts to Straw Board and requested for, immediate payment of the outstanding sum of Rs. 3,95,521.361. Again written demand for payment was repeated on 28th July, 1987 and 11th August, 1987, but no amount was paid. However, vide letter dated 29th August, 1987 (Annexure P.2), the Straw Board informed Mahalakshmi that it arranging to send payment of the bills shortly.

    4. It has been further stated by Mahalakshmi that upon repeated requests and personal visits of the representative of the Company, payments to the tune of Rs. 48,852-40 P. were made by Straw Board between the period of 9th September, 1987 to 17th November, 1987.

    5. Since the Straw Board was not making the payment of the entire amount of the outstanding bills, Mahalakshmi wrote yet another letter on 7th November, 1987 impressing upon the Straw Board to make the outstanding payment immediately. Vide letter dated 10th November, 1987. (Annexure P.3 to the petition), Straw Board replied to the letter dated 7th November, 1987 that it was arranging to send remittance. On 10th November, 1987, another letter was written by the Mahalakshmi to the Straw Board (which must have crossed the letter of even date written by Straw Board), in which again it coaxed the Straw Board that a definite schedule of the payment should be given and it was not appreciating the delay in payment on part of the Straw Board. Since the appellant-Company Straw Board failed to make the entire payment, Mahalakshmi issued a notice under Section 434 of the Companies Act through its lawyer on 8th December, 1987, calling upon Straw Board to make the payment of the amount of Rs. 3,41,627.51 P aloagwith interest at the rate of 18 per cent within three weeks from the receipt of the notice. The Straw Board acknowledged the receipt of this notice but asked for the statement of accounts from Mahalaksbmi. Mahalakshmi thereafter sent the details of the bills and the payments received so far vide its letter dated 6th January, 1988. The matter rested there and no payment was made by Straw Board to Mahalakshmi, which led to filing of the winding up petition, on the ground that the Straw Board had failed to make the payment of the principal amount as well as interest and since it was unable to pay its debts, it was liable to be wound up.

    6. The Straw Board in its reply before the learned Company Judge took up the stand that after the supply of 100 trucks of Bagasse, Mahalakshmi wanted to send more supply, which the Straw Board was finding difficult to accept. However, it agreed to accept the extra material on the understanding that the payment would be deferred for 2 to 3 years. Further the stand was that the material which was supplied over and above the agreed quantity of 100 trucks of Bagasse, was not in proper form and it was decomposed and was of no use to the respondent. According to the Straw Board the defects were duly pointed out to the supplier and it had agreed in the abatement of the price. With the reply to the petition, Straw Board had attached copies of the letters dated 27th February, 1987, nth April, 1987, 6th September, 1987, 9th July, 1987, 18th August, 1967 and 5th November, 1987 (Annexures R-1, R-3 to R-7 respectively), allegedly written by it to Mahalakshmi. It may be mentioned that in the written statement it has not been mentioned as to how these letters were despatched whether these were despatched by registered post, U.P.C or by recorded delivery. It has not been averred that these letters were duly received by Mahalakshmi.

    7. In the letter dated 27th February, 1987 (Annexure R-1) which is alleged to have been written by Straw Board to Mahalakshmi, it is mentioned that Straw Board agreed to take the supply of new and fresh Bagasse in excess of its order on the assurance that the payment of excess amount of material supplied would be made over a period of 2-3 years at the convenience of the Straw Board, the letter goes on that though the excess material was not required by it, but the same was being purchased as a good-will gesture. In letter dated 11th April, 1987 (Annexure R-3), 6th September, 1987 (Annexure R-4), 9th July, 1987 (Annexure R-5). 18th August, 1987 (Annexure R-6) and 5th November, 1987 (Annexure R-7) allegedly written by the Straw Board, it has been mentioned that the material supplied was sub standard and decomposed.

    8. In the replication filed on behalf of the Mahalakshmi, it has been specifically mentioned as under:—

    “———————I say that the alleged letter No. 260, dated 27-2-1987 is a fabrication. No such letter was ever written or received from the respondent company. This letter has been fabricated to raise a false defence/dispute. Your Lordship will notice that there is no acknowledgement by the petitioner company to this letter. Secondly after purchasing 100 trucks the respondent company made full payment of some bills as stated above. These payments show that there was no agreement for deferred payments and there is no mention thereof in in any of the payments. Thirdly at no stage in any correspondence the respondent company alleged that there was any agreement for deferred payments.

    I say that it is wrong and denied that the material supplied by the petitioner company was decomposed. Letter dated 11-4-1987 annexed as Annexure R-3 is a fabrication. Similarly letter dated 6-9-1987 annexed as Annexure R-4 (the date of which is shown in the body of the reply as 9-6-1987) is again a fabrication. Letter dated 9-7-1987 (Annexure R-5), 18-8-1987 (Annexure R-6) and 5-11-1987 (Annexure R-7) are fabrication. These letters were never sent or received by the petitioner company.”

    9. By filing the reply and taking the stand, as stated above, the Straw Board sought to urge before the learned Company Judge that there was serious dispute regarding the quality of the material supplied and further that the payments were to be made within 2 to 3 years of the supply and since there was a genuine dispute between the parties regarding their business transaction and the amount had not become payable as a period of 2 to 3 years had not lapsed there was no question of winding up the Company. It was also submitted before the Company Judge that it had been mentioned vide letter dated 18th August, 1987 (Annexure K-6) written by the Straw Board to the Mahalakshmi that in the statement of accounts sent by Mahalakshmi to Straw Board on 23/24 July. 1987, it had not credited to the account of Straw Board the cost of 250 tonnes of Bagasse, which had been intimated to them earlier, the cost of which came to Rs. 60,000/- plus sales tax of Rs. 2400/- and transportation charges of Rs. 22,500/-. It was requested that the total amount which came to Rs. 84,900/- may be credited to their account. It is evident that before the learned Company Judge the stand of the Straw Board was that since there was a serious dispute regarding the business transactions and the amount claimed by the petitioner Mahalakshmi, so case had been made out for winding up of the Company. It may be highlighted that the entire amount claimed by Mahalakshmi was disputed and no part of it was admitted to be payable.

    10. The learned Company Judge held that at no time earlier than the reply to the notice given by Mahalakshmi under Section 434 of the Act that it was stated by the Straw Board vide its reply dated 30th March, 1988 (Annexure R-8) that the material supplied was substandard. As far as the earlier letters to that effect allegedly written by the Straw Board are concerned, the same have been denied having ever been received by the Mahalakshmi. The learned Company Judge came to the conclusion that the Straw Board had at no point of time disputed the correctness of the statement of accounts submitted by the petitioner and since there was no bona fide dispute between the parties, and the defence of the Company was not in good faith, the Company Judge found that a sum of Rs. 3,37,167.56 P. was due from the Straw Board, which it had failed to pay in spite of demands. The learned Judge directed the Straw Board to pay the said amount within one month from the date of the order, i.e 10th February, 1589 failing which the Company Petition would be advertised in conformity with Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959. Dissatisfied with the judgment of the Company Judge, the Straw Board has come up in appeal.

    11. During the course of arguments in the appeal, the Straw Board moved an application being Company Misc No. 32 of 1990, in which it was prayed that the appellant may be permitted to deposit a cheque of Rs. 1,44,413-16 P as the admitted outstanding liability (over and above Rs. one lac already paid during the pendency of the appeal) alongwith a Bank guarantee for the disputed amount. Notice of this application was given to the counsel for the respondent and this application was ordered to be decided with the main case. In para 3 of the Misc application, it is mentioned as under:—

    “That the following amount admittedly is due:—

    (i) Amount due as claimed in the petition Rs. 3,37,167.56 (ii) Less paid as per High Court orders. Rs. 100,000.00 (iii) Less amount disputed. Rs. 84,900.00 Rs. 1,52,267.56 Less price of Regmal supplied and amount due. Rs. 8,254.40 Amount due Rs. 1,44,413.16”

    12. Mr. L.M Suri, Senior Advocate, learned counsel for the appellant, submitted that his client had already paid Rs. 1,00,000/- to Mahalakshmi in pursuance of the order passed by the Motion Bench while admitting the present appeal and he was ready with a cheque of of Rs. 1,44,413.16 P. and as far as the balance amount out of Rs. 3,37,167.56 P, was concerned the same was disputed, for which be was ready to give a Bank guarantee. He further submitted that he was ready to furnish Bank guarantee for the amount of interest as well. The learned counsel contended that the readiness of the appellant for payment of Rs. 1,44,413.16 P. and the furnishing of the Bank guarantee regarding the balance amount, which according to him, was a disputed amount, showed that it was not a case where the Straw Board was unable to make the payment, rather it showed that the Company was in a sound financial position. He further submitted on the basis of the averment in the Misc application that his client owned land over 30 Acres with a Factory constructed thereon and owned large number of shares in a number of Companies valuing over 20 lacs. Since, according to the learned counsel, his client was ready and willing to pay the undisputed amount and for the rest it was furnishing Bank guarantee, the question of winding up the Company did not arise.

    13. In support of the above mentioned submissions, the learned counsel relied on Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Ltd. v. A.C.K Krishnaswami . 1963 35 Com Cases 456., a judgment of the Supreme Court, wherein it was held as under:—

    “It is well-settled that a winding up petition is not a legitimate means of seeking to enforce payment of a debt which is bona fide disputed by the company. A petition presented ???sibly for a winding up order but really to exercise pressure will be dismissed, and under circumstances may be stigmatised as a scandalous abuse of the process of the court.

    If a debt is bona fide disputed there cannot be ‘neglect to pay’ within the meaning of Section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956. If there is no neglect, the deeming provision does not come into play, and the ground of winding up, namely, that the company is unable to pay its debts, is not substantiated.”

    14. On the basis of the above-said judgment, the learned counsel argued that since there was a bona fice dispute by the Company and the Company otherwise was in a position to pay the debt the only course open was to relegate the parties to Civil Court for determination of the dispute, but no order of winding up could be passed. The learned counsel further submitted that on the parity of the reasoning in Hindustan Sanitary and Hardware Store v. J.C.T Electronics Ltd. . 1990 67 Com. Cases 585., in which it was held that where the Company was paying off debt of Rs. 362 lakhs to the petitioning creditor in the course of proceedings and the Company obtaining statement of Bank's willingness to stand guarantee for the liabilities of Company, the appellant. Company being not commercially insolvent and further since the Company disputing some debts. It could net be ordered to be wound up. He also cited Madhusudan Gordhandas & Co. v. Madhu Woollen Industries Private Ltd. . 1971 3 SCC 632, to contend that since there was a bona fide dispute by the Company, the payment was rightly not made and, therefore, under the circumstances, no order of winding up of the Company could be passed.

    15. Mr. N.K Sodhi, Senior Advocate, learned counsel for the respondent-Mahalakshmi, on the other band, submitted that before the Company Judge, the entire amount was being disputed by the Straw Board and it had not made any payment or offer of payment of the undisputed amount, which offer of the Straw Board was now making in the appeal by saying that liability to the tune of Rs. 2,44,413.16 P. was undisputed. According to the learned counsel, since an order of advertisement of winding up has been passed by the Company Judge, it is now that the Straw Board has come up with the plea that it was ready and willing to pay the undisputed amount and for the balance amount of about Rs. 84,900/- plus interest, it was ready to give Bank guarantee. According to the learned counsel if there was any dispute regarding amount of Rs. 84,900/- only, the Straw Board should have at least paid or offered to pay the balance amount before the Company Judge. Since the Straw Board was ready to make the payment of the undisputed amount the appellate stage, it was no ground to set aside the order of the learned Company Judge. He further submitted that the dafence of the Straw Board before the learned Company Judge was that the entire amount was disputed and nothing was payable, which defence has been found to be false by the learned Company Judge as the letters on the basis of which the defence was based, were wholly fabricated just to raise a false defence. For this purpose, he relied on the judgments of the Calcutta High Court reported in T.P Shau & Sons Pvt. Ltd., In re4: and in Wastinghouse Saxby Farmer Ltd., In re5: and of the Delhi High Court in Smt. Madan Debi Kundalia v. Alpine Dairy Ltd. . 1983 54 C.C 41. and in Softsule Private Ltd., In re; P.G Bhatia & Co. v. Softsule Private Ltd. . 1977 47 C.C 438., a judgment of the Bombay High Court.

    16. We have considered the arguments of both the sides and find that there is no merit in this appeal. It has been rightly held by the learned Company Judge that the defence sought to be raised by the Straw Board was an after thought. In reply to the earlier correspondence of the Mahalakshmi, Straw Board had written letters on 29th August, 1987, Annexures P.2 and on 10th November, 1987, Annexure P.3 that it was arranging to send remittance of their outstanding bills and at no stage it had raised the plea that the material sent was decomposed and not according to the specifications or that the bills were payable within 2 to 3 years according to the agreement. We find that the stand taken by the Mahalakshmi is correct that if there was any dispute regarding the material or the period of payment, the Straw Board would not have written letters like Annexures P.2 and P.3, referred to above. There is nothing on the record to show as to how the letters allegedly written by the Straw Board to Mahalakshmi regarding the quality of the material or that the payments were to be made within 2 to 3 years of the supply, were despatched and whether they were at all received by the Mahalakshmi Mahalakshmi has specifically denied the receipt of any of the letters Annexure R.1 and R.3 to R.7 That being the position it is clearly established that the defence raised by the Straw Board that there was a serious dispute regarding the transactions, is thus an after thought.

    17. We are also not impressed by the arguments of the learned counsel for the appellant that since now they are making the payment of the undisputed amount and for the disputed amount the Company was giving the Bank guarantee, no order of winding up should be passed. If now the amount is undisputed, it was undisputed even before the learned Company Judge. Had the offer been made before the learned Company Judge, which is now being made by way of Company Misc. No. 32 of 1990, the position might have been different. It seems that since there is an order of the learned Company Judge regarding winding up, the Misc application has been made making an offer to pay the undisputed amount and to give a Bank guarantee regarding the rest of the amount, including interest.

    18. For the reasons recorded above, we do not find any infirmity in the judgment of the learned Company Judge, and, consequently, dismiss the appeal, as well as Company Misc No. 32 of 1990, without any order as to costs.

    19. The learned Company Judge vide his order dated 10th February, 1989, had directed that the amount of Rs. 3,37,167.56 P. be paid within one month by the Straw Board to the Mahalakshmi, failing which the Company Petition would be advertised in conformity with Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules. The admitting Bench while admitting the present appeal, vide order dated 27th November, 1989, observed that if a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- is paid to the respondent i.e Mahalakshmi then the ex parte stay order regarding the payment of money would continue, failing which the same would stand vacated. In pursuance of the stay order, the Appellant Company did pay Rs. 1,00,000/- to respondent Mahalakshmi. Under the circumstances, we direct that in case the Appellant Company pays to the respondent the balance amount (i.e Rs. 3,37,167.56 P. minus, Rs. 1,00,000/-) with 18% interest from 10th March, 1989, within one month from today, then the Company Petition may not be advertised, otherwise the Company Petition would be advertised in the Tribune, the Punjabi Tribune and in the Punjab Government Gazette, after one month of the data of the present judgment.

    Sd/- J.V Gupta, C.J

    R.M.S
    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Star Straw Board... v. The Mahalakshmi Suga...
    (Sep 11, 1990)