Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (2) of R. 10 of O. 1 of the Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (2) of R. 10 of O. 1 of the Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Ujagar Singh (respondent No. 5) executed an agreement for sale of 31 Kanals of land in favour of Kaka Singh (petitioner), Bhag Singh, and Jagga Singh. Ujagar Singh was stated to be the sole and exclusive owner of this land. Subsequently, Rohi Singh and three other minor sons of Ujagar Singh (respondents Nos. 1 to 4) filed a suit against their father for a declaration that they owned four-fifths share of the entire land measuring 58 Kanals, including the 31 Kanals in question, claiming it as coparcenary property of the joint Hindu family. They also sought a permanent injunction restraining Ujagar Singh from alienating the land without partition.

Kaka Singh (petitioner), Bhag Singh, and Jagga Singh (respondents Nos. 6 and 7) applied under Order 1, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) to be impleaded as parties in the suit, alleging they were mortgagees and had an agreement for sale. The trial court dismissed their application on the basis that the plaintiffs did not claim the one-fifth share of Ujagar Singh and that the applicants could proceed against Ujagar Singh’s share independently. Hence, it was held they were not necessary parties to the suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 should be impleaded as parties to the suit filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 4 against Ujagar Singh under Order 1, Rule 10 of the CPC.
  2. The interpretation and scope of Order 1, Rule 10(2) CPC regarding necessary parties and the questions involved in the suit.
  3. Whether the petitioner’s equitable interest in the land justifies their impleadment as parties in the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Reliance on the judgment in Krishnamachari v. Dhanalakshmi (AIR 1968 Mad 142), which held that Order 1, Rule 10(2) confers wide jurisdiction to implead parties having a direct legal or equitable interest affecting the subject-matter of the suit.
  • Contended that the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 had a legal and equitable interest in the land by virtue of the agreement for sale and mortgage, thus justifying their impleadment.
  • Expressed apprehension that if respondents Nos. 1 to 4 obtained an injunction against Ujagar Singh, it would impede enforcement of the agreement for sale or mortgage foreclosure.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Contended that the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 were neither necessary parties nor indispensable for the adjudication of the suit filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 4.
  • Relied on precedents limiting the scope of impleadment under Order 1, Rule 10 to necessary parties without extending it to avoid multiplicity of suits.
  • Maintained that the petitioner’s apprehension was misconceived since any decree in the suit would not bind or affect the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 as they were not parties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishnamachari v. Dhanalakshmi, AIR 1968 Mad 142 Wide jurisdiction under Order 1, Rule 10(2) CPC to implead parties having direct legal or equitable interest affecting the subject-matter of the suit. Recognized as favoring the petitioner’s case but noted as inconsistent with other authoritative views of this Court.
Banarsi Dass v. Panna Lal, AIR 1969 Punj and Har 57 Order 1, Rule 10(2) CPC is confined to necessary parties without which the suit cannot be completely decided; no jurisdiction to implead parties merely to avoid separate suits. Followed by the Court to hold that the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 are not necessary parties and cannot claim impleadment as a matter of right.
Manmohan Singh v. Satnarain, AIR 1971 Punj 400 Impleadment under Order 1, Rule 10 requires that the party’s presence is essential for complete and effective disposal of the suit. Applied by the Court to reject impleadment since absence of petitioner would not prevent effective disposal.
B. Somaiah v. Smt. Amina Begum, AIR 1976 Andh Pra 182 Order 1, Rule 10 does not require impleading all persons with any right or interest in the subject-matter; questions involved refer only between parties to the suit. Used by the Court to support the narrower interpretation of Order 1, Rule 10 consistent with other benches of this Court.
Narayan Chandra v. Matri Bhandar Pvt. Ltd., MR 1974 Cal 358 Similar restrictive approach to impleadment under Order 1, Rule 10 CPC. Reinforced the Court’s stance against broad impleadment in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the scope of Order 1, Rule 10(2) CPC concerning impleadment of parties. It acknowledged the petitioner’s reliance on the Madras High Court’s wider interpretation in Krishnamachari v. Dhanalakshmi, which permits impleadment of parties with any legal or equitable interest in the subject matter. However, the Court emphasized binding precedents from different Benches of this Court, notably Banarsi Dass v. Panna Lal, which restricts impleadment to necessary parties without whom the suit cannot be effectively decided.

The Court further noted that the petitioner and co-applicants were neither necessary parties nor indispensable for adjudicating the suit filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 4. The absence of the petitioner would not prevent complete and effective disposal of the suit. The Court rejected the argument that impleadment should be allowed to avoid multiplicity of suits or to protect equitable interests that do not affect the questions between the parties to the suit.

Moreover, the Court found the petitioner’s apprehension that an injunction against Ujagar Singh would affect their rights to be misconceived, as any decree in the suit would not bind non-parties. The petitioner and co-applicants remain free to pursue their rights, including filing a suit for specific performance, where they may choose to implead respondents Nos. 1 to 4 as co-defendants.

Ultimately, the Court upheld the trial court’s order dismissing the application for impleadment as legally correct and not subject to interference.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The Court’s decision directly upholds the trial court’s rejection of the petitioner’s and co-applicants’ application to be impleaded as parties to the suit filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 4. The ruling confirms that impleadment under Order 1, Rule 10(2) CPC is confined to necessary parties essential for complete adjudication of the suit and does not extend to persons with mere equitable interests or to avoid multiplicity of suits. No new precedent is established; the decision reaffirms existing legal principles and leaves the parties to bear their own costs.

    Kaka Singh v. Rohi Singh And Others

    1. Ujagar Singh respondent No. 5 executed an agreement for sale of 31 Kanals of land in favour of Kaka Singh petitioner, Bhag Singh and Jagga Singh. Ujagar Singh is stated to be the sole and exclusive owner of the said land. Rohi Singh and three other minor sons of Ujagar Singh aforesaid (respondents Nos. 1 to 4) subsequently filed a suit against their father Ujagar Singh (without impleading either the petitioner or Bhag Singh respondent No. 6 or Jagga Singh respondent No. 7 as parties to the suit) for a declaration to the effect that they are owners of four-fifths share of the entire land measuring 58 kanals including 31 kanals of land in question in their capacity as members of the joint Hindu family on the allegation that the whole of the said land is coparcenary property. Respondents Nos. 1 to 4 (plaintiffs in the suit) further prayed for the grant of a permanent injunction to restrain their father Ujagar Singh from alienation the land without getting it partitioned and alienating anything more than his share therein. Kaka Singh petitioner and Bhag Singh and Jagga Singh respondents Nos. 6 and 7 made an application under O. 1, R. 10 of the CPC to the trial Court for being impleaded as parties (co-defendants) in the suit of the minors against their father on the allegation that they were mortgagees of part of the land and had also got the agreement for sale in their favour. By its order dated May 19, 1976, the Court of Shri N.S Saini, Sub-Judge, First Class, Mansa, has dismissed the said application of the petitioner and of the said respondents on the ground that the plaintiffs in the suit have not laid any claim to the one-fifth share of the defendant in the coparcenary property and the applicants (the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7) can, therefore, proceed against Ujagar Singh and his share of the property to enforce the alleged agreement to sell. On that basis it has been held that they are not necessary parties to the present suit.

    2. Mr. Gur Rattan Pal Singh, the learned counsel for the petitioner, has invited my attention to the judgment of a learned single Judge of the Madras High Court in Krishnamachari v. Dhanalakshmi, AIR 1968 Mad 142, wherein it has been held that O. 1, R. 10(2) of the Code confers upon the Court a very wide Jurisdiction and the Court should not be disposed to a curtailment of the powers more than what to expressly decided by judicial decisions binding on it. It has been observed by the learned Judge that the Madras High Court has consistently adopted a wider interpretation of the scope of O. 1, R. 10 and in the state of authorities the contention that the expression “the questions involved in the suit” in the said provision should receive narrow view, namely, that only, questions as between the parties to the litigation and not questions between any of the parties to the suit and a third party even though touching the property which to the subject-matter of the suit, cannot be accepted. It was held by the learned Judge that in applying O. 1, R. 10(2) the only question is whether an applicant who applies for being impleaded as a party to the suit has got a direct interest in the subject-matter in dispute which would be affected by the result of the litigation. The Madras High Court has in that case gone to the extent of holding that “the interest” that is necessary to make a person party is legal interest including equitable interest, that is, an interest which the law would recognise and uphold. The facts of that case were that in a suit for partition the plaintiffs were claiming the property to be joint family property. An application was made by a third person for impleading himself as a supplemental defendant on the ground that the defendant in the partition suit had entered into an agreement of sale with him whereby he had agreed to convey a part of the property to the applicant. On those facts it was held that the applicant should have been impleaded as a supplemental defendant by the Court in the exercise of its powers under O. 1, R. 10(2) of the Code, The judgment of the Madras High Court no doubt favours the petitioner's case but is not consistent with the view taken on this subject by different Benches of this Court. In Banarsi Dass v. Panna Lal, AIR 1969 Punj and Har 57, Sarkaria, J. (now an Hon'ble Judge of the Supreme Court) took the view that the powers given to the High Court under sub-rule (2) of R. 10 of O. 1 of the Code are confined only to two cases, namely, when a party ought to have been joined but has not been joined as a party, that is, when he is a necessary party and (2) when without the presence of the applicant the questions in the suit cannot be completely decided. The learned Judge went to the length of holding that there is no jurisdiction to add a party in any other case merely because that would save a third person the expense and botheration of a separate suit for seeking adjudication of a collateral matter. There is no doubt that in the suit filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 4 against respondent No. 5 the plaintiff was neither a necessary party nor a person without whom the said suit cannot be decided. According to the rule laid down in Banarsi Dass Durga Prashad's case, the applicant cannot therefore, claim to be impleaded as a party to the suit filed by respondents Nos. 1 to 4 as a matter of right.

    3. Sodhi, J., as he then was, took a similar view in Manmohan Singh v. Satnarain, (1971) 73 Pun LR 525 : (AIR 1971 Funj 400). The learned Judge held that what has to be seen in allowing or disallowing an application under O. 1, R. 10 of the Code is whether the addition of a new party would be consistent with the scope of the “inquiry as necessitated in the pending suit and that in the absence of such a party it would not be possible to completely and effectively dispose of the controversy in the pending suit and not that some other suit may be avoided. Similarly, a learned single Judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court has held in B. Somaiah v. Smt. Amina Begum, 1975 (2) Andh WR 243 : (AIR 1976 Andh Pra 182), that where a person applies to be made a party what the Court ought to see is whether there is anything in the suit which cannot be determined owing to his absence or whether there would be prejudice by his not being added as a party. It was observed that O. 1, R. 10 cannot be read as requiring that all persons who are likely to have any sort of right, title or interest in respect of the subject-matter of a suit should be made parties thereto. The learned Judge took the same view as the different Benches of our Court but contrary to the view of Madras High Court in holding that “the questions involved in the suit” refer “only to the questions between the parties to the suit. Similar view has also been taken in Narayan Chandra v. Matri Bhandar Pvt. Ltd., MR 1974 Cal 358.

    4. Howsoever much equitable the claim of the petitioner may be, it appears that, in view of the binding judgments of different Benches of this Court it is not possible to allow the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 to be impleaded as parties to the suit. Counsel says that the apprehension of the petitioner is that if respondents Nos. 1 to 4 are able to obtain an injunction against their father (respondent No. 5) restraining him from alienating any part of his land it may become impossible for the applicants to enforce their agreement to sell or even to foreclose the mortgage against Ujagar Singh. This apprehension appears to me to be misconceived. The petition and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 are not parties to the suit and any decision, judgment or decree given or passed therein would neither bind the petitioner and Respondents Nos. 6 and 7 nor affect their interests in any manner. This is particularly so in the present case where the application of the petitioner and respondents Nos. 6 and 7 to be impleaded as parties to the suit of respondents Nos. 1 to 4 has been successfully resisted by the plaintiff-respondents. It would not lie in their mouth to urge that the interest of the petitioner and his co-applicants can be affected by a decree passed in a suit to which they did not allow them to become a party. Even the learned trial Judge has held that it would be open to the petitioner and his co-applicants to pursue their agreement of sale of Ujagar Singh's property.

    5. It would be for the petitioner and his co-applicants to decide at the time of filing the suit for specific performance against respondent No. 5, if and when such a suit is filed, whether they would like to implead respondents Nos. 1 to 4 also as co-defendants with respondent No. 5 in that suit. That is not a matter on which any view can be expressed by this Court in the present proceedings. From whichever angle the matter is looked at, it appears that the order of the learned Subordinate Judge is legally correct and cannot be interfered with.

    6. For the foregoing reasons and subject to the observations made above, this petition is dismissed leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

    7. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kaka Singh v. Rohi Singh And Others
    (Mar 24, 1977)