impugned Judgment and Decree dated 20.12.1979 passed by Sri Birendra
Kumar Sinha, the learned 5th Addl. Subordinate Judge, Siwan in title suit
No.153 of 1970 dismissing in part the plaintiff's suit for partition.
2. The plaintiff-appellant filed the aforesaid title suit No.153 of 1970
claiming partition of properties mentioned in Schedule I, II and III to the
extent of his 1/4th share.
3. The plaintiff claimed his share on the facts inter alia that Devi
Sharma had two sons, namely, Shyama Sharma and Raghubir Sharma. The
plaintiff and defendant No.1 2 and 3 are sons of Raghubir Sharma and
defendant Nos. 4 to 10 are sons and daughters and wife of Shyama Sharma.
Both the brothers, namely, Shyama Sharma and Raghubur Sharma had
separated in 1945. The properties were also partitioned except ancestral
house which remained joint. Shayama Sharma died in the year 1958.
Raghubir Sharma died in the year 1961 in jointness with the plaintiff and
defendant No.1 to 3. After some time of the death of Raghubir Sharma, the
plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3 separated in family business but there was
no partition of the properties of Raghubir Sharma. However, the parties were
cultivating the lands according to their convenience. The joint house at
Lucknow was occupied by tenants and the defendant No.1 was collecting the
rent on behalf of all the defendants and plaintiffs. The defendant No.1 was
residing at Lucknow as he was in railway service. For some time past, the
intention of the defendant No.1 has become bad and refuse to give true
account of collection of rent of Lucknow house, therefore, the plaintiff filed the
suit for partition. It may be mentioned here that the facts which are relevant
has only been mentioned here and the prior to history of genealogy is not
given.
4. The further case of the plaintiff is that the house built over plot
No.1037 and the land is also joint family property which was acquired and the
house was built with joint family fund. The name of wife of defendant No.1 is
simply benamidar.
5. On being noticed, the defendant No.1 filed a separate contesting
written statement. His case in short is that he entered into railway service in
the year 1942 and posted at Lucknow. Out of his own earning, he purchased
two blocks of land with houses i.e., plot No.121 and 122 mentioned in
Schedule II of the plaint for consideration of Rs.2,000/- in the name of his
father, Raghubir Sharma because he was in Central Government service.
After purchase, he is living in the house and has also inducted tenants in
portion of the house. When he fell in need of money, he borrowed Rs.5,000/-
from Pancham Sahu and Makfula deed was executed by his father at his
instance. After that the loan was paid back by the defendant and got back the
deed. Accordingly, the land and house at Lucknow on plot No.121 and 122
are the self acquired property of this defendant No.1. Neither Raghubir
Sharma nor the plaintiff nor the defendant No.2 and 3 have got any right in
the said property. The house at Lucknow on plot No.106 is the joint family
property which stands in the name of 4 brothers, i.e., the sons of Raghubir
Sharma. So far house and land on plot No.1037 at village Kherai is
concerned, it is the self acquired property of his wife out of her kosila money
and, therefore, the same is her self acquired property. All other matters have
been admitted by this defendant.
6. On the basis of these pleadings of the parties, the learned Court
below framed the following issues :
7. After trial, the learned Court below recorded finding at paragraph 26
that the plaintiff has totally failed in proving that the properties i.e., the house
and land of plot No.121 & 122 at Lucknow was acquired by joint family fund
and the land pertaining to village Kherai of plot NO.1037 was also acquired by
joint family fund whereas the defendant No.1 has successfully established that
the said property at Lucknow was acquired by defendant No.1 out of his own
earning and that the property of village Kherai was acquired by his wife
Lalmuni Devi out of her own kosila money and the structure thereon was
constructed out of her stridhan. Accordingly, the suit has been dismissed with
respect to those properties and so far rest is concerned, the suit has been
decreed in part.
8. The learned senior counsel, Mr. Dwivedi appearing on behalf of the
appellant submitted that the learned Court below has not appreciated the law
in proper way and has applied the law in wrong way. According to the learned
counsel, the Court below has not considered the fact that the property at
Lucknow on plot No.121 and 122 is standing in the name of Raghubir Sharma
father of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3. Therefore, the presumption is
that Raghubir Sharma was the owner of the property. After his death, the
property devolved on his 4 sons equally. The learned Court below wrongly
placed onus on the appellant to prove the fact that the property was acquired
out of joint family fund. The onus was on the defendant to prove that in fact
he has acquired property in the name of father out of his own earning. It is
not the case of the plaintiff that the property of Raghubir Sharma was
acquired out of joint family fund. So far the property at village Kherai is
concerned, admittedly, it is standing in the name of wife of defendant No.1.
The sale deed has been produced by the plaintiff and in fact the consideration
5 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
5 / 18
amount was paid out of joint family fund. To prove the income of the joint
family, the parties have adduced evidence but the learned Court below did not
consider the evidences on right prospective. The learned Court below rejected
the evidences only saying that all these documents do not prove the joint
family fund and, therefore held that the properties of Lucknow on plot No.121
& 122 and the property at village Kherai are not joint family property. On
these grounds, the learned counsel submitted that the impugned Judgment
and Decree are liable to be set aside.
9. On the contrary, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent submitted that the defendant No.1 is in Government service since
1942 and was posted at Lucknow, therefore, he has purchased the property
on plot No.121 and 122 in the name of his father out of his own earning. His
father is benamidar and had no money to purchase the said property. Since
the plaintiff is claiming partition claiming the property to be joint family
property, the learned Court below has rightly placed the onus on him to prove
that the property is joint family property and unless he proves this fact that
the property is joint family property, it cannot be partitioned. So far property
at village Kherai i.e., plot No.1037 is concerned, admittedly, it is standing in
the name of wife of defendant No.1 and, therefore unless the declaration is
sought for that the property is the joint family property, the same cannot be
partitioned. The learned counsel further submitted that the learned trial Court
considered all aspects of the matter and then has recorded a finding. In such
view of the matter, the First Appeal is liable to be dismissed with cost.
10. In view of the above contentions of the parties, the points arises for
consideration in this appeal are :
(i) Whether there is unity of title and possession on the property at
Lucknow on plot No.121 & 122 between the parties or whether it
6 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
6 / 18
is self-acquired property of defendant No.1 in the name of his
father, Raghubir Sharma.
(ii) Whether the property, i.e., plot No.1037 of village Kherai
standing in the name of Lalmuni Devi is her self-acquired
property or is joint family property and liable for partition.
11. Point No. (i) :- It is admitted fact that the properties on plot
No.121 and 122 is in the name of Raghubir Sharma, i.e., the father of the
plaintiff and defendant No.2 and 3. Raghubir Sharma died in 1961. The suit
has been filed in the year 1970 claiming 1/4th share in the said property by the
plaintiff. Since the property was purchased in the name of Raghubir Sharma
on his death, it will devolve equally on 4 sons according to Hindu Succession
Act irrespective of the fact that whether it was purchased out of joint family
property or it was purchased by Raghubir Sharma out of his self income. The
defendant No.1 is claiming that he has purchased the property out of his own
earning. In such circumstances, the burden is on defendant No.1 to prove
that in fact his father was benamidar.
12. From perusal of the impugned Judgment, it appears that the learned
Court below proceeded to decide this issue quoting the Hindu law to the effect
the burden is on the person who is claiming a share to prove that the property
was purchased out of joint family fund. In the entire Judgment, the Court
below has considered this aspect as to whether the family possess some
nucleous to show that the house at Lucknow and Kherai have been acquired
out of the joint family fund. In my opinion, this approach of the learned trial
Court is entirely wrong approach. The joint family fund or nucleous is relevant
for the purpose of consideration regarding the purchase of property at village
kherai, i.e., plot No.1037 because it is admittedly purchased in the name of
wife of defendant No.1. Therefore, the joint family fund or nucleous is
7 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
7 / 18
relevant for this property only. So far property at Lucknow on plot No.121 &
122 is concerned, the plaintiff is not required to prove that it was purchased
out of joint family fund. As has been stated above, it is admittedly recorded in
the name of father of the parties. Since, natural succession is being
challenged by defendant No.1 alleging that his father was benamidar and it is
his self-acquired property, it is for him to prove this fact that in fact out of his
own earning, the property on plot No.121 and 122 were purchased by him.
Therefore, the burden is on defendant No.1 to plead about his income, about
his saving and to prove that out of this saving, he gave the consideration
amount of Rs.2,000/-.
13. Now let us consider the evidences adduced on behalf of the parties
in relation to the property at Lucknow on plot No.121 and 122. P.W.2 & 3
have stated that Raghubir Sharma was the karta and till date there has been
no partition of his property. P.W.5 has stated that Raghubir Sharma was the
karta. P.W.11 who was tenant in the house at Lucknow has stated that
parties have two house at Lucknow. He claimed that Raghubir was his Phufa.
At paragraph 14, he had stated that his father was tenant for last 30 years.
P.W.12 also claimed that he was tenant in the house of Lucknow which is in
dispute. P.W.15 is the plaintiff himself. He has fully supported his case that
till his father was alive, he was karta. All the properties are joint. All the
properties which were acquired were acquired in jointness and all the brothers
have got equal share in the property of father. He has stated that the
property was purchased in the name of his father by ext.6/A and the
consideration amount was given by his father in presence of this witnesses
vide paragraph 6. After death of father, the defendant No.1 was managing
the family as he was elder brother. At paragraph 16, he has stated that there
was 20 biggha ancestral land which was partitioned between Shayama Sharma
8 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
8 / 18
and his brother, Raghubir Sharma in the year 1945. In that partition, 10
bigghas land was allotted to Raghubir Sharma. This sale deed has been
executed in favour of his father on 20th February, 1946 by Ram Khelawan. At
the time of registration, this witness had also accompanied to registry office at
Lucknow. The sale deed has been proved, ext.6/A. Admittedly, it is in the
name of father Raghubir Sharma. The only dispute is that the defendant No.1
is claiming that he has purchased this property out of his own earning in the
name of his father. Therefore, the burden as started above is on him to
prove. The case of the plaintiff is admitted and according to law on the death
of Raghubir Sharma, the property will devolve on 4 brothers equally, if
defendant No.1 failed to prove his case. In the written statement at
paragraph 9, he has pleaded that he was employed in the year 1942 in railway
and out of his earning, he purchased the land and house on plot no.121 and
122 at Lucknow for Rs.2,000/-. He was in service, therefore, he got the sale
deed executed in the name of his father. This is only pleading regarding this
property.
14. D.W.18 is the defendant No.1. In his evidence, he has stated that
at Lucknow, he is employed since 1942. Out of his own earning, he purchased
the Lucknow property in 1946 the plot no. is 121 & 122. He claimed that he
has paid the money and got the sale deed executed in the name of his father
because he was in Government service and there was difficulty in obtaining
the sale deed in his name. He denied that the property was purchased out of
joint family property. He stated that his father has no saving out of cultivation
of joint family land. The sale deed has been produced from the custody of this
defendant. From perusal of rest of evidence, it appears that he has only
stated about the possession and collection on rent etc. In the examination-in-
chief nowhere he has stated about his income, i.e., monthly salary and also
9 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
9 / 18
the expenditure thereof and monthly saving. Since the onus is on him to
prove wherefrom he got this Rs.2,000/-, i.e. to consideration money, he is not
required to prove that his father had no income or that there was no joint
family income or nucleous nor the plaintiff is required to prove that the joint
family had nucleous. The burden is on the defendant No.1. In the pleading as
stated above and in the evidence discussed above except this statement that
he was employed in railway in 1942, there is nothing about his income or
salary and likewise there is nothing that how much he was saving per month.
Admittedly, the property has been purchased in February, 1945. In the cross-
examination at paragraph 38, he has admitted that he was employed as
Apprentice and his monthly salary initially was Rs.10/- till July, 1943. The
salary was increased from September 1943 to Rs.33 till April, 1945. D.W.4
has also admitted that Ramraj joined as Apprentice of salary of Rs.10/- per
month. This D.W. 18 has also stated that his name has been mutated at
Lucknow municipality.
15. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that in November,
1942, the defendant No.1 joined as Apprentice in railway and according to the
calculation as stated by D.W.18 in paragraph 38, the total income of the
defendant No.1 comes to Rs.2,178/- A written argument has also been filed
on behalf of the defendant-respondent. The learned counsel submitted that
out of the said income, the consideration amount of Rs.2,000/- has been paid.
So far this submission is concerned, I will later on deal after perusing the
other evidences of the witnesses. D.W.3 at paragraph 2 has stated that
Ramraj had purchased property from Ram Khelawan. D.W.4 has stated that
only Ramraj was in possession of property in question. D.W.5 claiming
himself to be a tenant had stated that he used to pay the rent to Ramraj. The
evidences of D.W.6 is also in the same line as that of D.W.5. D.W.10 has
10 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
10 / 18
stated that Rs.1000/- is given to vendor and at that time, Raghubir was not
present. D.W.11 and 12 are tenant in the house at Lucknow who have stated
that Ramraj was collecting the rent. D.W.13 is cousin brother. At paragraph
2 and 3, he has stated that Ramraj had purchased the property of plot
No.1218122. His other brothers have no concern with the property and
Raghubir had no fund. This witness at paragraph 12 has admitted that the
second marriage of defendant No.1 was held in the year 1950. The other
witnesses are on the acquisition of property of plot No.1037 of village Kherai.
These are the evidences on the point of acquisition of the property on plot
No.121 and 122. No documentary evidence has been produced by the
defendant-respondent in support of his income and saving per month. There
is no pleading regarding monthly income and expense and saving. The
witnesses have stated only that he was employed in railway as Apprentice on
monthly salary of Rs.10/- What was his monthly expense is not clear.
Admittedly, the family had no residential accommodation at Lucknow.
Therefore, the defendant No.1 was expected to have spent towards his
accommodation fooding, lodging transportation and clothing. Nothing has
been explained by the defendant No.1 that how much he was spending on
these accounts and what was his saving per month. In view of this fact, the
submission of the learned counsel that on calculation of total income till the
date of purchase of the property comes to Rs.2,178/- is not acceptable for the
reasons that no account has been given regarding expenditure. It is not his
case that he got money from any other person.
16. In view of the above fact only on saying that he had purchased the
property in the name of his father or that he paid the consideration amount, it
will not be reliable. The evidence must be reliable evidence. Mere saying will
not do. The evidence must be acceptable.
17. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the property
has been mutated in the municipality. So far this submission is concerned, it
may be mentioned here that how the name of the defendant No.1 has been
mutated has not been brought on record. Admittedly, the property is in the
name of Raghubir Sharma. On his death, the property will devolve on his 4
brothers. In such circumstances, there must be some basis or any order
passed by competent authority showing in what circumstances or on what
basis the name of defendant No.1 has been mutated in the municipality. Mere
mutation will not do. In other words, only because in the municipality, the
name of defendant No.1 has mutated, he will not be declared as the owner of
the property exclusively.
18. The learned counsel for the defendant-respondent submitted that
the defendant No.1 is in exclusive possession of the property. So far this
submission is concerned, admittedly defendant No.1 is employed at Lucknow.
It is admitted fact that family is joint. Therefore, possession of one brother
does not mean that other brothers were ousted. Since, he was only employed
at Lucknow, it is quite natural that he was residing there. But it does not
mean that he became the absolute owner.
19. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the sale deed
was in custody of the defendant No.1-respodnent and he has produced the
same in the Court. No doubt while considering the case of benami, the Court
has to consider the ingredients like the possession of the property, the party
dealing the property and the custody of the title document. But here in the
present facts and circumstances of the case, it is admitted case that the title
deed is in the name of father, Raghubir Sharma. On the death of father, if the
title deed came to be possessed by one of the son, he cannot be allowed to
say that because he is possessing the sale deed he is real owner of the
12 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
12 / 18
property. Admittedly, the property is situated at Lucknow. The sale deed was
registered at Lucknow. The defendant No.1 is employed at Lucknow and is
residing in the house and, therefore, it is expected that he should be in
possession of the title deed also. Admittedly the other brothers including the
plaintiffs resides in Bihar but on these facts alone, there can be no
presumption that because defendant No.1 is residing at Lucknow and is in
possession of title deed, the property has been purchased by him out of his
own earning, particularly, when he is not disclosing as to how he managed to
pay Rs.2,000/- on the date of purchase of the property in the year 1946. The
main ingredients for considering the benami nature of transaction is passing of
consideration is to be proved by the person strictly who claimed to be real
owner. If he fails to prove the payment of consideration by him, merely on
the basis of possession of property or title deed, no finding can be recorded
that he is the real owner of the property or that he has paid the consideration
amount.
20. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the
defendant No.1 was residing with his uncle at Lucknow and, therefore, he was
not incurring any expenses vide paragraph 38 of D.W.15. It is admitted fact
that the defendant No.1 was employed in October, 1942 and the property had
been purchased in February, 1946. In such circumstances, particularly when
the defendant was employed the submission of the learned counsel for the
defendant is not acceptable that defendant No.1 was not incurring any
expenses or that he was not spending a farthing. This one line explanation
cannot be accepted and it appears that merely because one witness is saying
an absurdity the Court cannot accept it as reasonable explanation. This
explanation has been given only to patch up the matter that he saved entire
13 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
13 / 18
income during this long more than 3 years. I, therefore, find no force in the
submission of the learned counsel for the respondent.
21. The documentary evidences produced by the defendant relates to
the possession of the property which is admitted by the plaintiff. The
municipal receipts have been marked as ext. 'C' series. Ext.C/6, ext.C/14,
ext.C/8 are municipal receipts standing in the name of Ram Khelawan. The
learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the tax have been paid by
the defendant No.1. Since the defendant No.1 was residing there, it is quite
natural that he was paying the tax and was obtaining the municipal receipts.
Likewise the ext. 'D' series are the water tax receipts. These documents only
proved that in the name of Ram Khelawan, the vendor of Raghubir Sharma,
the municipal tax or water tax were being paid by defendant No.1. Ext. 'R'
series are the counter foil of rent receipts. This also only proves that Ramraj
was collecting and granting receipts to the tenants. As stated above these
documents also only prove that Ramraj was residing at Lucknow, therefore, he
was doing the management of the house and was inducting tenants. On these
basis, it cannot be said that he became real owner of the property as
admittedly neither the father nor the brothers of the defendant No.1 were
residing at Lucknow. On the basis of these documents, it cannot be said that
the title has been created in favour of the defendant No.1. Ext. 'I' series are
the correspondence between Ramraj and Municipal Board, Lucknow. As stated
above, these documents do not prove the benami nature of the transaction.
At best it can very well be said that the defendant No.1 was residing in
Lucknow. It may be mentioned here that it is the specific case of the plaintiff
that since defendant No.1 was residing at Lucknow, he was managing as he
was elder brother.
22. Regarding the mutation of defendant No.1 in the municipality is
concerned, the defendant has produced ext. 'M' series. It is admitted fact that
the property was in the name of Raghubir Sharma and all these ext. 'M' series
excluding some of them are after the institution of the suit. Some of these
exhibits are prior to institution of the suit wherein name of Raghubir Sharma
has been mentioned and the payment of tax has been mentioned. As stated
above on the basis of these ext. 'M' series, which shows the payment of taxes
ect., it cannot be said that a title has been created on defendant No.1 or that
it can be recorded that he is the real owner of the property. At the cost of
repetition, I may mention here that the defendant No.1 must prove that he
has paid the consideration amount which he has failed to prove as discussed
above.
23. On the contrary, the plaintiff has also produced the rent receipt
ext.4 series which are in the name of Raghubir Sharma. It appears that the
learned Court below discarded these exhibits on the ground that holding
number and plot number has not been mentioned. It may be mentioned here
that it is not the case of the defendant that these exhibit 4 series do not relate
to the suit property. The plaintiff has also produced the inland letters written
by defendant No.1 either to his father or to the plaintiff. These inland letters
and post cards have been marked as ext.6 series. From perusal of some of
the letters, it appears that accounts was asked for about the rent of Lucknow
house and in connection with that there was strain relation. Ext.4/K has been
produced by the plaintiff to show that in fact the defendant No.1 was giving
account.
24. In view of the above discussion of the documentary evidences
produced by the plaintiff, it is clear that the defendant No.1 was giving
account about the rent collected by him.
25. From perusal of the impugned Judgment, the learned Court below
did not discuss at all these documentary evidences on the ground that these
documentary evidences do not prove joint family nucleous.
26. It is the case of the defendant that Makfula deed was executed by
his father at his instance regarding the property at Lucknow on plot No.121
and 122 when he was in need of money of Rs.5,000/-. The defendant No.1
repaid the said amount and got the Makfula deed. Therefore, it is admitted by
defendant No.1 that he was in need of money and his father executed Makfula
deed and, therefore, merely because he repaid the amount, it cannot be said
that he is the real owner. Admittedly till 1949, the first wife of this defendant
No.1 alive. No reason has been assigned as to why instead of purchasing the
property in the name of his wife, he claimed to have purchased the property in
the name of his father. Nothing has been brought on record to show that
there was any bar in purchasing the property by government employee.
27. In view of my above discussion, I find that the defendant No.1 has
failed to prove his case that he purchased the property on plot No.121 & 122
at Lucknow in the benami name of his father, Raghubir Sharma. Therefore,
the finding of the learned trial Court on this question is hereby reversed. It is
held that the plaintiff is entitled for his share to the extent of 1/4th on the
house and land on plot No.121 & 122 at Lucknow, i.e., schedule II property.
This point is accordingly answered in favour of the appellant.
28. Point No.(ii) :- Admittedly, the sale deed in the name of wife of
defendant No.1 is of the year 1954. It is admitted fact that the defendant
No.3(d) Lalmuni Devi was married with the defendant No.1 in the year 1950.
The consideration amount is Rs.250/- only. To prove the fact that the
property has been purchased by the joint family, the appellant have produced
witnesses and likewise the defendants have also produced witnesses to show
16 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
16 / 18
that in fact the property was purchased by Lalumni Devi out of her own
money.
29. It may be mentioned here that during the life time of defendant
No.1 the wife of defendant No.1 has got no share in the joint family property.
Therefore, the plaintiff is claiming that Raghubir Sharma and his 4 brothers
who have only the title and interest over the joint family property purchased
the property in the name of a family members who has not title or interest. In
such circumstances, the plaintiff must first pray for declaration that the
property which is standing in the name of female member is benamidar of the
co-owner or the coparcener or joint family. No doubt, it is settled law that the
property can be purchased by the karta in the name of any of the joint family
member or in his own name but since in the present case, the property is
standing in the name of a lady who has no interest at all in the joint family
property or nucleous thereof during lifetime of her husband, the benami
nature has to be proved by the co-owners.
30. In the plaint, nothing has been pleaded as to why the property was
not purchased either in the name of karta or in the name of 4 male members
who were the coparcener or co-owner. Even if there was sufficient income in
the joint family and there was sufficient saving then also the father and his 4
sons were the exclusive owner thereof. In such circumstances, the joint
family has to prove firstly that the joint family purchased the property in the
benami name of Lalmuni Devi. The other aspect of the matter is that even if
the property has been purchased by the joint family then also the presumption
will be that the said property was purchased for the benefit of the defendant
No.3(d). Unless the joint family proved the fact that it was not purchased for
the benefit of wife of defendant NO.1, i.e., defendant No.3(d), the property
cannot be presumed to be joint family property.
31. In the present case, the defendant has examined the witnesses to
prove the fact that defendant No.3(d) had purchased the property out of her
own money. D.W.8 Sukha Bhobi claiming himself to be labourer has stated
that he had worked in construction work of the house on plot No.1037 and the
payment was given by wife of Ramraj. D.W.10 at paragraph 3 has also stated
that the property is measuring 6 dhur belong to wife of Ramraj. D.W.14 is
own brother of defendant No.3(d). He has stated that his father was jeweler
and the defendant No.3(d) got gift at the time of marriage. She got Rs.500/-
in mukhdekhi. She also got khoicha money and out of the said money, she
purchased the property in question from Jamadar Singh and constructed
house. This witness was there to manage the construction. In the cross-
examination, he has stated that at the time of Bidaigiri, Rs.1500/- was given
to his sister. His sister is not pardanasin. D.W.15 is Lalmuni Devi herself.
She has also supported the case that at the time of marriage, she got
Rs.1400/- - Rs.1500/- money in khoicha. In sasural also she got 400-500/- in
mukhdekhi. She has further stated that she spent Rs.1400-1500/- in
construction. Her father has jewellery and grossery shop. D.W.18 has also at
paragraph 9 stated that his wife had purchased 6 dhurs land for Rs.250/-. At
paragraph 10, he has stated that his wife constructed the room over the said
land. At paragraph 11, he has stated that his father-in-law is rich and dealt
with in jewellery and grossery as well as agriculture and his wife got money in
mukhdekhi.
32. So far the evidences of the plaintiffs are concerned, they have only
tried to show that the joint family property had sufficient income. P.W.3 has
stated that the lands are fertile lands. Such is the evidence of P.W.4. P.W.10
has stated that he sold property to Raghubir Sharma for Rs.1500/-. Now,
therefore, even if the family had sufficient income or that Raghubir Sharma
18 Patna High Court FA No.200 of 1980 dt.09-05-2012
18 / 18
had sufficient income, there can be no presumption that the property
purchased in the name of a female member has been purchased out of the
joint family property. There is no pleading in the plaint regarding the income
of the joint family and also the savings of the joint family. However, some of
the witnesses have stated that in partition, Raghubir Sharma got 10 bigghas
land whereas some of the witnesses stated that he got 5 bigghas land. On the
basis of this evidence, there can be no presumption as stated above. The
plaintiff has also not prayed for any declaration that the property is held by
defendant No.3(d) as benamidar of the joint family. On the other hand, the
defendants have adduced reliable evidence to prove that defendant No.3(d)
had sufficient money with her and out of the said money, she purchased the
property in question and house was constructed thereof by her.
33. In view of my above discussion, I find that the defendants have
been able to prove that the 6 dhurs land of plot No.1037 of village kherai is
the self acquired property of Lalmuni Devi, the wife of defendant No.1. The
finding of the learned trial Court on this point is, therefore, confirmed.
34. In the result, this appeal is allowed in part. The impugned
Judgment and Decree are accordingly modified to the extent that the
property on plot No.121 & 122 at Lucknow is joint family property and
plaintiff is entitled for his share to the extent claimed. So far property
over plot No.1037 of village kheria is concerned, the plaintiff has no
right to claim for partition. In the facts and circumstances of the case,
the parties shall bear their own costs.
(Mungeshwar Sahoo, J.)
Patna High Court, Patna
The 9thMay, 2012
Sanjeev/A.F.R.